Bush NSA spies on Americans

And that exchange with my final comment "You do understand that in our hair-trigger world that is the fact? Nah, probably not." is much broader in scope than this current tempest-in-a-peapot and covers POTUS responsibility that has been de-facto since the beginning of the Cold War.

Nor does it cover personal/political wrongdoing by POTUS.
Please explain the scope then, because it was posted in response to my direct comment that you seemed to advocate no accountability for the president on national security matters. Do you feel that it should be so or not?

If the answer is no, it will take more explanation from you to make your opinion distinct from that. If the answer is yes, then personal/political wrongdoing is moot without accountability.
 
Please explain the scope then, because it was posted in response to my direct comment that you seemed to advocate no accountability for the president on national security matters. Do you feel that it should be so or not?
That is a good question. If only conventional weapons are the threat, I prefer higher accountability. In the current world -- one zealot, or maniac -- equals megadeaths, I prefer action to inaction and I see a POTUS hamstrung if accountability is his foremost thought. After-the-fact accountability is hard to dodge for POTUS as for all of us.

If the answer is no, it will take more explanation from you to make your opinion distinct from that. If the answer is yes, then personal/political wrongdoing is moot without accountability.
Huh?
 
That is a good question. If only conventional weapons are the threat, I prefer higher accountability. In the current world -- one zealot, or maniac -- equals megadeaths, I prefer action to inaction and I see a POTUS hamstrung if accountability is his foremost thought. After-the-fact accountability is hard to dodge for POTUS as for all of us.

This is something approaching rational as at least you acknowlede a spectrum of levels of accountability. Today it's a fact that we're faced with possibly single maniacs with the power of megadeath in their hands. So, right now, you prefer no safeguards against the abuse of power? Or some? More interesting would be a discussion of which safeguards you find acceptable and which ones you don't. The ones discussed in this thread, for example.


My point is, if you remove accountability, it doesn't matter if the president is bucking the law for national security or for personal reasons--he's unaccountable.
 
rikzilla said:
Bullsh!t. The JOB of the press is to report the news; not make the news. By pushing this story to influence the vote on the PA the NYT editor is attempting to influence law. It's not their JOB...it's chutzpah, hubris, meddling.
Actually, it is the press's job to serve as a government watchdog. That's why we have a First Amendment.
Correct.

Incidentally Luke, I admire your thoughtful posts in this thread.
 
Seen this report? http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20051216/ap_on_go_pr_wh/bush_nsa



Why not go thru the legal process with warrants? Why do it illegally?

Lurker
It's a reasonable question, but not hard to imagine situations where you don't have time. An obvious one would be an internationally intercepted call to the US or a call from the US to an international location (not sure if that means they should stop listening without a warrant), but then the conversation is heard to involve calling someone else in the US to pass an urgent message and so on.

Not unlikely I think, and this is in real time; impossible to track if warrants are needed.

HOWEVER, I believe there are provisions for warrants to be obtained AFTER the fact, and I'm not sure why that has not been discussed more.

Edited to ask: Why the administration hasn't done this, or if they have why they haven't said so.
 
Last edited:
Here's what I wonder about a retroactive warrant. Is the information that is gained from a wiretap used as evidence to support the warrant?

In other words, let's say the cops search your house without a warrant and they find a pound of cocaine. Then they go to the judge and ask for a retroactive warrant. And the judge wants to know why he should grant it. "Well, we found a pound a cocaine."

You see what I mean? That's plainly an unlawful search and seizure.

(I'm not reading all posts first, obviously, as I have already mentioned this)

They would need to show cause to have searched, before finding anything, just like in a normal situation.
 
I think a return of the of media to a role as The Fourth Estate would be welcome. They have a long way to go to earn that title of honor back.

The New York Times is usually thought of as being more liberal than not isn't it? Hard to tell these days. It would be sadly telling, but not unexpected if they held the story back in order to obtain more favorable access to newsmakers. Idle speculation.

Bush is not really worth hating. Corruption, arrogance, and
"legal-is-defined-as-what-we-want" are worth hating, but hardly limited to one individual. If we willingly tolerate these things due to our irrational fears and let them go unchallenged we deserve the crappy kind of government we'll get.

If we die of a suitcase nuke because we didn't let these guys do whatever they want, at least we'd die free and with honor and not in paranoid fright of preintelligent retro religious fanatics.

Borders are porous, containers on ships still go uninspected, chartered & corporate flights are still easy air targets. Various public service groups still could not communicate in a disaster. This is the same administration that got "F"'s just a couple weeks ago by the 911 commission. I doubt that being able to spy on Americans is way up there on the to-do list and gonna make a big difference.

The tone of the Newsweek editorial is an ominous sign of what may come, and sad for anyone of any political party.
 
Coming in late...

If FISA was in place, and workable, (I'm hearing Bush claim that the whole thing was and is unwieldly), it would tend to indicate that wiretaps without warrants was pointless, and it would suggest another political blunder on the part of Bush.

For me, this is a deal-breaker. Had I known about it, I'd have written in Lieberman.
 
I seem to recall the NSA was doing this anyway through ECHELON.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECHELON


ECHELON, NSA spooks face Congress scrutiny
The wages of sin: legislative oversight
Published Saturday 27th November 1999 09:11 GMT


Conspiracy paranoiacs rejoice: the controversial spy operation known as ECHELON, reportedly run by the US National Security Agency (NSA), is going under the microscope when Congress returns from the holidays.

In a double blow to the spook agency's sense of immunity, Congress has drafted a bill requiring it to account for itself, while the House Government Reform Committee has decided to grill NSA officials in hearings early next year.

The struggle warmed up earlier this year as the House Select Committee on Intelligence requested documents from the NSA explaining its operating standards. NSA officials refused to deliver the information, invoking attorney/client privilege, a sadly thin defence.

Public relations has never been the NSA's strong suit, though its aloof character does have its uses in terms of 'deniability.' But snubbing Congress was a foolish move, as legislators will now, on principle, demand a good deal more information than they had originally sought, and probably vote themselves some form of oversight power.

Oversight is a bit tricky, as Congress is not empowered to supervise military operations per se, though it has the power of the purse and can, when aroused, limit funds for operations of which it disapproves. In one famous example, former President Richard Nixon learned of this power the hard way when a disgusted Congress cut off financing for the Vietnam War, effectively shutting it down.

http://www.theregister.co.uk/1999/11/27/echelon_nsa_spooks_face_congress/
 
If FISA is so unworkable, why didn't it get reformed? After all, so much attention and time and energy was spent overhauling things after 9/11. If the administration had a problem with FISA, why didn't they try to reform it, instead of bypassing it and breaking the law?
 
If FISA is so unworkable, why didn't it get reformed? After all, so much attention and time and energy was spent overhauling things after 9/11. If the administration had a problem with FISA, why didn't they try to reform it, instead of bypassing it and breaking the law?

A speculation, not an assertion: by reforming the law, they would acknowledge that sensible laws can restrain them and still preserve national security. They would rather argue that the laws are NOT sensible and the only alternative is to remove all restraints.
 
If FISA is so unworkable, why didn't it get reformed? After all, so much attention and time and energy was spent overhauling things after 9/11. If the administration had a problem with FISA, why didn't they try to reform it, instead of bypassing it and breaking the law?

GWB has told me that even asking those questions is shameful.

really.
 
For a pretty good FAQ on FISA, go here:

http://www.eff.org/Censorship/Terrorism_militias/fisa_faq.html

It appears to be objective but also slightly anti-FISA, in the sense it thinks it grants too much power, not too little.

Key points:

1. FISA treats US citizens and non-US citizens differently.


2. It’s primary purpose is the collection of Foreign Intelligence Information, not criminal information; however, criminal information collected incidental to the collection of FII is admissible in criminal court.

3. The FISC (Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court), comprises 7 judges who meet two days per month. In addition, 2 of the 7 judges are on call at all times.

4. FISC does not actually issue warrants in the sense normally meant. Legal experts on this forum can explain this better than I.

5. Defendants facing charges based upon information collected under FISA do have the right to challenge its legality and to have it suppressed. However, the deck is stacked against them because the government can claim national security reasons to avoid revealing the collected information.

6. I’ll quote the entire #16 answer (How Does FISA Work?). It’s informative:

From the website said:
Under FISA, requests for counterintelligence warrants are funneled through the Justice Department, which reviews applications by the CIA as well as other agencies before submitting them to the FISA court. 50 U.S.C. §§ 1804(a), 1822(a)(1) (1994). Each application to the FISA court must first be personally approved by the Attorney General. See 50 U.S.C. § 1804(a).
From the website said:
The application must contain, among other things,

a statement of reasons to believe that the target of the surveillance is a foreign power or agent of a foreign power, specified information on the implementation of the surveillance, and a "certification" from a high-ranking executive branch official stating that the official "deems the information sought to be foreign intelligence information" and that the information sought "cannot reasonably be obtained by normal investigative techniques."
See generally 50 U.S.C. §§ 1804(a)(7), 1805(a) (setting forth the findings necessary to support the issuance of an order authorizing surveillance).

Particular facts or representations required include: statements regarding all previous applications involving the target; "detailed description of the nature of the information sought and of the type of communication or activities to be subject to the surveillance," § 1804(a)(6); the length of time surveillance is required, § 1804(a)(10); whether physical entry into a premises is necessary, and proposed procedures to minimize the acquisition, use, and retention of information concerning nonconsenting U.S. persons. § 1804(b).

On the basis of the application, a FISC judge must find probable cause that the target is a foreign power or agent of a foreign power, and that the facilities where the surveillance is directed are or will be used by the target.

For U.S. persons, the FISC judge must find probable cause that one of four conditions has been met: (1) the target knowingly engages in clandestine intelligence activities on behalf of a foreign power which "may involve" a criminal law violation; (2) the target knowingly engages in other secret intelligence activities on behalf of a foreign power pursuant to the direction of an intelligence network and his activities involve or are about to involve criminal violations; (3) the target knowingly engages in sabotage or international terrorism or is preparing for such activities; or (4) the target knowingly aids or abets another who acts in one of the above ways.

Courts have attached conditions to the executive's use of warrantless surveillance, including the requirement that the President or Attorney General authorize the search, the search targets a foreign power or its agents, and the primary purpose of the search is to gather foreign intelligence information. See Exec. Order No. 12,333, § 2.5, 3 C.F.R. 200 (1982), reprinted in 50 U.S.C. § 401 note (1994) (requiring approval of attorney general for warrantless searches).

An order of the FISC may approve electronic surveillance of an agent of a foreign power for ninety days and of a foreign power for a year. Extensions may be granted on the same terms, except that targets who are foreign powers may be subject to surveillance for an additional year if there is probable cause to believe that no communication of any U.S. person will be acquired.


The entire page is an interesting and fairly easy read, so I recommend it.

It belies the arguments put forth suggesting that FISA is unwieldy or untimely.

My egotistical opinion: If Bush and/or his representatives authorized surveillance/searches of US citizens (and possibly non-US citizens) without going through FISA, they were wrong wrong wrong and must be held accountable. Notifying members of Congress does not change this; instead, it brings those members of Congress into the fold of the culpable.

Edited for spacing
 
Coming in late...

If FISA was in place, and workable, (I'm hearing Bush claim that the whole thing was and is unwieldly), it would tend to indicate that wiretaps without warrants was pointless, and it would suggest another political blunder on the part of Bush.

For me, this is a deal-breaker. Had I known about it, I'd have written in Lieberman.

...and your vote would have been wasted on an ineffective protest. (I did that in 2000 with my Nader vote)

But this points up the larger problem of allowing the loony moonbat left to hijack the Democratic Party. There was no viable choice offered by the Dems. Kerry is no Lieberman. Bush was the only possible choice left for an American voter who cared about winning the WOT.

-z
 
My egotistical opinion: If Bush and/or his representatives authorized surveillance/searches of US citizens (and possibly non-US citizens) without going through FISA, they were wrong wrong wrong and must be held accountable. Notifying members of Congress does not change this; instead, it brings those members of Congress into the fold of the culpable.

Edited for spacing
I’m not sure that it would make members of congress culpable. What we seem to hearing from some of those congressmen that knew about it is that they did not approve of it, and were then prohibited from discussing it with anybody due to secrecy issues. If the president tells you, “I’m doing something illegal, but if you tell anybody you will be tried for treason” what sort of responsibilities do you hold?
 
I don't know. Why don't you pose your question to the editor of the NYT. It is obvious that the release was timed since the story was held. The timing was entirely up to the NYT editor...perhaps it was aimed at the PA debate instead?


-z

Correct! And if the NY Times had reported the news rather than made the news, let’s see what would have happened;

Just prior to the election;

1) If it weren’t for a certain reporter "standing up for freedom of the press", the American public would have known at least two members of the Whitehouse were being investigated or would have been indicted. (Fitzgerald said he wanted to have it tied up in 2004, when indicting Libby).
2) Because of this they would have know the stories printed by said reporter were bogus, and the reasons for going to war were bogus.
3) That the NSA was being spied on.

All this was in the hands of the NY Times. Liberal paper it may be, but the owner certainly is not. That’s an amazing effort to keep facts from the people prior to an election, reporting the news not making it.. when will the NY Time actually start doing that? How many more stories are they hiding?

It's amazing the small band of Bush apologists (and the large section of values/evangelical voters) that are left continue to defend him. The economic conservative left, the independent left and now we have a few people who still trust him. You guys are beginning to sound a little silly right now.

I wonder if there were a group of people who supported Nixon to the end as well? I know many Germans supported Hitler to the end. So is this a "backed in to a corner" reaction or is it something else? Defending you World view to the end is great though. I want you guys to keep justifying torcher, and breaking the constitution. The conservative dogma RIP for many, many years.

The country is now back in our control, get used to it. Here is to a decade of liberal progress. We will pick up the pieces, don't you worry.

When Rove is gone (this week) what are you left with? Bush calling the shots? We saw what happened when he calls the shots with Myers. Its going to be fun watching him go down in flames, what remains to be seen is how long the vocal minority on the right continue to parrot talking points.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom