Budhism Is Not A Religion

Honestly again, No, I haven't read one honest sentence from the Buddhists interacting with me in this JREF forum, it's all rote talking from their masters and from their readings, but never any genuine penetration into what the Buddha is all about if ever he was into anything serious, aside from groaning about the sufferings of life and existence which even the ants and the bees have to bear with but they continue on and on with their life and work, to keep alive and to raise kids to be alive and surviving and continuing their existence in their turns, and improving their survival rating.

LOL! I knew it! yrreg have me on ignore!, its funny, yet sad to see how many emotions he have regarding this subject.

If only he could read... I would say to him "come on, life is simplier than you think. True, sometimes hurt, but hey, maybe you will find yourself smiling again when all your bitterness is gone".

To bad he cant read me! I can sing and I can shout and I will still be invisible! Yahoo!
 
I read you load and clear.

LOL! I knew it! yrreg have me on ignore!, its funny, yet sad to see how many emotions he have regarding this subject.

If only he could read... I would say to him "come on, life is simplier than you think. True, sometimes hurt, but hey, maybe you will find yourself smiling again when all your bitterness is gone".

To bad he cant read me! I can sing and I can shout and I will still be invisible! Yahoo!

I read you loud and clear, good Bodhi Dharma Zen. But if you have any particular questions to raise up with me or any insights you like to share with me from your compassion yet Zen mind, I will welcome them with open arms and exercise my skeptical critical analysis on them.

You know? I am reading up on Zen. But I have come to the realization that as I said many times in these forums here, I am searching for the big picture and the short statement from some genius, who can only portray the big picture in a short statement because he knows the real story.

Right now I will tell you that I find Zen to be up to my mind and heart, but no need to invest so much material and moral resources into its cultivation. That's why I think you folks into Zen are making Zen into a cult, exactly. You people are into Zen as a cult. Think about that.

Pure dyed in the wool skeptics are better and clearer and more solid and quintessential Zen-ic than you folks, and without devoting years and years into meditation, missing home, and wife, and kids in the process which is what life is all about.

Ask that from your Zen masters.

That's the tragedy with Buddhists here, they miss the big picture and the short statement, which only can be seen and clearly made out of in contours, when they finally come to their senses to get out of it, and look at it as from a satellite and see where and what it is from that distant vantage point.

I am getting emotional again, you are right. Thanks for the reminder; but I try to keep to acceptable language in view of civil conduct as in the church or temple or halls of justice or in the floor of congress.


Yrreg
 
But isn't that exactly what every culture that embraced Buddhism has done? Namely, reinterpret Buddhism into something new. Over the centuries, this is how "Buddhism" came to be such a big tent, with so many different interpretations and traditions.

I don't know if I would call that intellectual dishonesty, although maybe in some cases it is. But I get the sense that the folks who post here are being very intellectually honest, in that they are providing their own interpretations of Buddhism.

I don't see how a person can intellectually reach for Buddhism and explore it without interpreting it (or reinterpreting it) for oneself.

Of course, when one looks at the whole category of "Buddhism" that's out there in the world, it's going to includes lots and lots of seemingly contradictory things. This is a western, skeptical forum, so it's natural that some people will try to offer for discussion an interpretation of Buddhism that seems more relevant within this forum. There clearly are other forms of Buddhism as well.

Certainly Buddhism has undergone many cultural reinterpretations. The fact that there are so many schools of thought (e.g. Mahayanism and Theravadism) is evidence of this. Nevertheless, the difference between the major schools lie in their chosen interpretation of how to break out of the cycle of samsara and attain Nirvana. Before coming to this board, I have never encountered any disputes about the supernatural nature of rebirth, karma and nirvana. These ideas are accepted as they are.

For some believers here to claim that the majority of Buddhists in the world, like them, deny the supernatural implications of rebirth and nirvana is total rubbish and intellectually dishonest. Especially so when their new interpretation is at odds, not just with Buddhist tradition, but also with the teachings in the Pali texts.

While Buddhism encourages its followers to investigate its teachings before accepting them, some of its tenets like samsara, karma and nirvana are all unfalsifiables. It believes in the existence of other realms of gods, hungry ghosts and hell. These cannot be tested using the scientific method. The Buddha has said that nirvana cannot be described by words as it is a state beyond our mundane experience. He likened the explanation of nirvana to us who are still trapped within the cycle of samsara as trying to describe light to a blind man.
 
First, Merentha, welcome to this forum.

I am new myself. I thought I would do something different by taking up skeptical criticism of Buddhism, since everyone in the Net is praising Buddhism to the sky. Try this experiment, enter Buddhism in Google search box, and you will find nothing but encomium on Buddhism; it's the hottest kid in the internet block on religion today.

And horror of horrors, when you get to the skeptics' sites, they also have such a most loud silence on criticizing Buddhism, which is worth another most skeptical criticism on skeptics holding Buddhism with kids gloves.

Please understand that I am not criticising Buddhism here, but merely correcting those who have misinterpreted Buddhism in order to make it more palatable to sceptics.

There are good reasons why Buddhism is usually treated lightly. Unlike some other religions, it does not require its followers to knock on your door every other weekend to proselytize, and it does not curse unbelievers to eternal damnation. You may liken it to the harmless old aunt who believes her cat talks to her, but she doesn't impose on you to talk to her cat. Still, you enjoy visiting her because she tells interesting stories and she makes delicious cookies (in the case of Buddhism in Asia, most temples provide delicious free vegetarian meals on festive days). :p

As regards how to indicate in your writing here internet reference what they call urls, I am a new hand myself and learned the trade by self-instructions with plenty f trials and errors and darings -- no, don't fear, nothing will happen bad to you or your computer for being experimental with how to do things in writing posts here.

Thanks for the help, but I can't post URLs yet because I haven't reached my minimum post quota yet. Its function is disabled for n00bs like me.

------------------

It is true that Buddhism does not believe in an eternal soul. However, it teaches that the "eternal soul" is an illusion, and it is our attachment to the illusion of the "eternal soul" that condemns us to be forever trapped in the cycle of samsara (death and rebirth).​
​

This is to me a word game, because an illusion implies something that the illuded person is illuded about. Not that I am a believer in the soul, but the use of the word illusion is more into a protestation of non-attachment or giving it no importance, than that the person supposedly illuded does not accept any kind of existence that continues after the death of a person.

So also with all these endless explanations by Buddhists of their concept and insistence on the non-self.

Word game or not, there is a misunderstanding about Buddhism's explanation of the nonexistent "eternal soul". Some Buddhists on this board understand it as:
Buddhism believes there is no soul -> Buddhism does not believe in rebirth.​
Instead, Buddhism teaches:
Unenlightened beings hold on to the illusion of the soul -> unenlightened beings continue to be reborn.
Enlightened being understands there is no soul -> enlightened being escapes rebirth.​

But I want to ask you for some time now but always forgot, quickly: What is the Chinese term for Buddhism in the Chinese you use at home and also the more academic terms; are they purely phonetic, meaning as with many English words trans-phonetized into Chinese vocalization, or what. I guess you know what I mean; because I tend to think that Buddhism is a misnomer like Mohammedanism was a misnomer; now the term used is Islam, as the Muslims had been insisting since way back.

The religion of Buddhism is called "佛教" (fo2 jiao4), which is made up of the characters for "Buddha" and "Religion". The study of Buddhism is called "佛学" (fo2 xue2) with the characters for "Buddha" and "Study". The object of study, aka the Dharma, is called "佛法" (fo2 fa3) where the second character can be translated as either "laws" or "ways". Those who practises Buddhism as said to "修佛" (xiu1 fo2) or "practise Buddha", but the character for "Buddha" here is usually understood to be a contraction for "佛法".

Buddhism isn't a misnomer like Mohammedanism/Islam since the teachings originated from the Buddha himself. Muslims object to Mohammedanism because they believe that Mohammed's revelations came directly from God, not Mohammed.
 
I read you loud and clear, good Bodhi Dharma Zen.

Good!

You know? I am reading up on Zen. But I have come to the realization that as I said many times in these forums here, I am searching for the big picture and the short statement from some genius, who can only portray the big picture in a short statement because he knows the real story.

Huh? I have been shouting and shouting.

HEEELOOOOOOO YRREEGGG!!!!!!!! THE ANSWER IS HEEREE! what do you see? pixels in your monitor? look stronger, deeper, see my friend!

Huh, maybe no.

Whats good about what you are looking for if you are unable to see it? Of course, the answer might be so simple that you might look over it looking for "the real thing" ;-) Dont worry, thats perfectly normal!!

Right now I will tell you that I find Zen to be up to my mind and heart, but no need to invest so much material and moral resources into its cultivation. That's why I think you folks into Zen are making Zen into a cult, exactly. You people are into Zen as a cult. Think about that.

Done. What were you saying?

Pure dyed in the wool skeptics are better and clearer and more solid and quintessential Zen-ic than you folks, and without devoting years and years into meditation, missing home, and wife, and kids in the process which is what life is all about.

Ask that from your Zen masters.

Ok I will. Oh wait, Im my own master! Now, the fact that some Zen teachers and students "abandon" (more like discard) what you call the "normal life" does not mean that every person who likes Zen has to do that in order to like Zen.

Sorry to dissapoint you!! But I live a pretty "normal" life, I have a beautiful wife and a precious little girl, I do not have "a job", I made good money doing what I want and mostly when I want. I do not practice Zen (this is, I do not sit at a regular schedule), I used to sit and still love the idea of spending some time at a monastery from time to time.

But really, since I found the Kensho! I dont see a point in going around still looking for it.

Oh, yes, and I have to tell you. There is no "normal" life, there is no "superior" life and you dont have the right to disqualify those who do not share your beliefs or your way of life!

That's the tragedy with Buddhists here, they miss the big picture and the short statement, which only can be seen and clearly made out of in contours, when they finally come to their senses to get out of it, and look at it as from a satellite and see where and what it is from that distant vantage point.

Which picture? yours? what about mine? or Helen's, Robin's, or Robert's? Who has the "real picture"? an athlete? a Zen teacher? a president?

I am getting emotional again, you are right. Thanks for the reminder; but I try to keep to acceptable language in view of civil conduct as in the church or temple or halls of justice or in the floor of congress.

Yes, you are civil, but I believe you are also sad, thats the emotional part I was referring to.

Enjoy my friend, enjoy, because we dont know anything and we have so little time to waste. Get out of your computer and kiss somebody, or have a nice glass of wine and taste it.

Of course, you can use it the way you like, its your time! But this is a humble proposal.

(in fact, its for everyone who cares to read, not just you ;-) )
 
Last edited:
Yeah, well at least he's honest about it.
(I hate Scrabble. To me, its more like what words you can't spell with 7 letters than what you can spell with 7 letters!)

My favorite word is quazar, which is the british spelling. Due to dysphonia I prefer 'imaginary' scrabble.
 
I have been thinking seriously how to grab the horns of this bull called Buddhism. And I have come to the idea that the best way to do it is to delve into the cibus, potus, coitus, and alimentary refuse of this bull.

So, if soon you come to a thread on Coitus and Buddha, then you will know that I have gathered some enlightening materials on coitus and Buddha from that most convenient research source present to mankind today, the Internet.
I suggest you try google on 'tantra, esoteric, buddhism'.
Paging D Daving: Please redraft your definition of Nirvana to emulate the definition of religion by Pes Oir Amsus, above; so that people can easily discern who is possessed of Nirvana when they see one such person.


Yrreg


When I feel that it will be beneficial:
I shall try this parse :
1. A state of mind achieved through practice
2. In this state the indivdual acts freely
3. Without preconception or predjudice
4. And mindfully aware of thier role in thier world.
5. While riding a pogo stick.
 
For some believers here to claim that the majority of Buddhists in the world, like them, deny the supernatural implications of rebirth and nirvana is total rubbish and intellectually dishonest. Especially so when their new interpretation is at odds, not just with Buddhist tradition, but also with the teachings in the Pali texts.
If that claim has been made here (I probably missed it), then you are right in questioning the claim.

Another way of looking at this: I think a lot of Western Buddhists who were born and raised in America probably do adhere to a more simplified interpretation of Buddhism, with less of the so-called "supernatural" furnishings. I understand that in some Buddhist temples, there are essentially two sanghas: local Americans who grew up with different faiths, and immigrants who grew up with traditional Buddhism. I've heard (though I don't have direct experience with this) that these two groups coexist but sometimes do not mix very comfortably.

The modern Western/American interpretation of Buddhism in some circles (clearly not all) is quite a different interpretation than that of many traditional schools. Which might explain the perspective of some posters here.
 
Still not a good definition for picking out Nirvanists

When I feel that it will be beneficial:
I shall try this parse :
1. A state of mind achieved through practice
2. In this state the indivdual acts freely
3. Without preconception or predjudice
4. And mindfully aware of thier role in thier world.
5. While riding a pogo stick.

I am sorry to inform you that your definition of Nirvana if a definition it is that you are attempting is not yet good enough to spot a human with Nirvana from others without.

A definition is precisely for the purpose of mapping out limits by which things can be separated from other things.

If your purpose is to be figurative; please, a useful definition tries not to be figurative. So please, no pogo stick for then your definition is too restrictive as to exclude from Nirvana anyone and everyone not riding a pogo stick.

Otherwise your definition is too overly broad for being inclusive of everyone even the as Epepke puts it, sociopaths.

Read this definition again of religion by my favorite opinion maker:

Religion is a human behavior founded upon a belief in an unknown power resulting in affections and actions intended by the believer to influence the unknown power to react favorably to the believer. -- Pes Oir Amsus​
​

And try to draft a definition of Nirvana following the template that you should be able to see in it.

------------------

I am going over to the threads on Buddhism is not scientific! (from you), and Evidence in Buddhism (from Ryokan), to see whether there are new developments there to satisfy people asking pertinent questions of their authors.

I will be back.


Yrreg


Yrreg
 
You can add "boring" to my report. A P-zombie (just to borrow a term from another thread) with no mmmph, no nothing. Letters following other letters, definitions tackling other definitions.

What is a meaning except a collection of words, what is a definition but words that sound good together.

There! can you spot the great universe when words are seen as words?

Maybe some day, maybe.
 
No evidence for Buddhism so far... why be Buddhists then?

Well, I am back from the thread on Evidence of Buddhism by Ryokan and Buddhism is not scientific by D David.

Ryokan so far to date has not produced any evidence worthy of peer reviews by scientists; and D David has not answered the query of Splossy, why if Buddhism is not scientific why namely folks here are into Buddhism and altering their lives because of Buddhism.

Suggestion to Ryokan: send not just one or two emails to a scientist with credentials asking him for studies on Buddhist meditation that can stand the peer review from fellow scientists in academic scientific journals, but also send emails to their colleagues and assistants who are into helping the scientist with his work and specially his publications, asking them for the scientist's studies in re Buddhist meditation propagated in genuinely reputable academic ephemerides.

We know that scientists are also in the habit of lending their names to popular mass consumption papers, and ending there.


As to D David, maybe you should take back your statement that Buddhism is not scientific, since your revered master here, Ryokan, is in the task of gathering evidence to prop up Buddhism in particular Buddhist meditation -- not that I am of the opinion that Buddhism is scientific but that Buddhism can be studied scientifically.


Yrreg


Annex

Evidence of Buddhism by Ryokan Resident Buddhist
12th January 2006, 12:26 AM


Ryokan to Yrreg
22nd January 2006, 01:34 AM

Paging Ryokan, paging Ryokan: Please report to your thread on Evidence in Buddhism.

I wasn't going to bump the thread until I had a definite answer for what epepke is asking for. I've e-mailed some of the scientist involved in the project, but so far no answer.

Buddhism is not scientific!

Upon consideration I have concluded that budddhism is not scietific. It may promote the methods of scepticism, in that it encourages a person to judge the merits of dharma on one's own.

But I believe that Epepke's arguments in other threads are very valid, this is not the sole threshold for scepticism nor is it 'science', so while buddhism may not contradict science, it is not scientific.

Lets go!

Splossy: Why do buddhists take it seriously and alter the way they lead their lives when it isn't "scientific"? -- Splossy #12
 
A man prone to depresssion

Yes, you are civil, but I believe you are also sad, thats the emotional part I was referring to.

Enjoy my friend, enjoy, because we dont know anything and we have so little time to waste. Get out of your computer and kiss somebody, or have a nice glass of wine and taste it.

Of course, you can use it the way you like, its your time! But this is a humble proposal.

(in fact, its for everyone who cares to read, not just you ;-) )

Thanks, Bodhi Dharma Zen.

That label Bodhi, that's the name of a fastfood outlet chain popular in my part of the world, where they serve vegetables and everything also, processed from soya beans, which Buddhists are not supposed to eat, but dressed up and spiced up to look and taste even better than genuine pork, beef, chicken, and fish.

Sad, you say; you have struck a right chord. I am resigned to be what I know from honest self-knowledge to be prone to depression, even my blood pressure is lower than the middle of the average range considered good by medical researchers.

But not to worry, I take pride for being in the company of men who are intelligently insightful and thereby from logic emotionally depresssed. Hahahaha softly, but I can take care of myself very well, thank you. And I still can't accept why people here have got to get their fix from Buddhism and even the Zen kind.


Yrreg
 
Worshippers of idol(s)

Word game or not, there is a misunderstanding about Buddhism's explanation of the nonexistent "eternal soul". Some Buddhists on this board understand it as:
Buddhism believes there is no soul -> Buddhism does not believe in rebirth.​
Instead, Buddhism teaches:
Unenlightened beings hold on to the illusion of the soul -> unenlightened beings continue to be reborn.
Enlightened being understands there is no soul -> enlightened being escapes rebirth.​

The religion of Buddhism is called "佛教" (fo2 jiao4), which is made up of the characters for "Buddha" and "Religion". The study of Buddhism is called "佛学" (fo2 xue2) with the characters for "Buddha" and "Study". The object of study, aka the Dharma, is called "佛法" (fo2 fa3) where the second character can be translated as either "laws" or "ways". Those who practises Buddhism as said to "修佛" (xiu1 fo2) or "practise Buddha", but the character for "Buddha" here is usually understood to be a contraction for "佛法".

Buddhism isn't a misnomer like Mohammedanism/Islam since the teachings originated from the Buddha himself. Muslims object to Mohammedanism because they believe that Mohammed's revelations came directly from God, not Mohammed.

The religion of Buddhism is called "佛教" (fo2 jiao4), which is made up of the characters for "Buddha" and "Religion".


A Chinese lady in the office told me that the first character from the left stands for idol. I asked her whether when Buddhism came to China the Chinese in their genius owing to the big statues of Buddha already extant by that time outside China, right away gave the religion the name of the word for idol.

So, Buddhism in Chinese is called the idol religion, and Buddha is given the name idol.

That is some joke on the Buddhists here who take pride in calling themselves Buddhists.

Anyway, it is good to have someone well versed in Chinese and in English, and of good learning in religious history i.e., of Buddhism.

Tell me something about the use of the name "佛教" by the Chinese people when Buddhism came to China. Were they really into some naughty nuances in their choice of the term or confection of the term? Or did it just happen that the Pali word for Buddha happens to be equivalent to the sound of idol in Chinese.

Yes, tell me about the rationale behind that terminological choice.


Thanks for your enlightenment; now the Buddhists of the West will guard themselves on feeling so sure about invoking the name of Buddha, identifying themselves as Buddhists.

Yrreg
 
And I still can't accept why people here have got to get their fix from Buddhism and even the Zen kind.

Do you like photography? I do, it was one of those things that I wanted to do, but had little time to attempt it. Now I just bought a nice camera, Lumix FZ30, I like it VERY much hanging around with my camera and taking lots of pictures (so far, about 5,000). Of course, only a few of them are really beautiful, but heck, Im having lots of fun.

Some others like to dance, though.
 
If that claim has been made here (I probably missed it), then you are right in questioning the claim.

Here's some:

the majority of Buddhist sects do not belive in reincarntion. So whilst your understanding may be true for some sects, it is by no means universaly accurate.Karma is basicly a way of saying "your actions will have consequences".

There is no reincarnation in Buddhism, except for some small fringe denominations.

There are somewhere around 1.32 zillion buddhists who do not subscribe to reincarnation, past lives or any form of afterlife. The remainder are largely Hindu or Christian majors with a minor in Buddhism.

-----

Another way of looking at this: I think a lot of Western Buddhists who were born and raised in America probably do adhere to a more simplified interpretation of Buddhism, with less of the so-called "supernatural" furnishings. I understand that in some Buddhist temples, there are essentially two sanghas: local Americans who grew up with different faiths, and immigrants who grew up with traditional Buddhism. I've heard (though I don't have direct experience with this) that these two groups coexist but sometimes do not mix very comfortably.

This would probably account for the dichotomy. I can understand the decision of these Buddhist temples to make Buddhism more attractive to the west, but I can't say I agree with them. On some levels, it's a little like Scientology - a member doesn't get to hear about Xenu until OTIII and by then it may be too late to get out. :eye-poppi
 
The religion of Buddhism is called "佛教" (fo2 jiao4), which is made up of the characters for "Buddha" and "Religion".


A Chinese lady in the office told me that the first character from the left stands for idol. I asked her whether when Buddhism came to China the Chinese in their genius owing to the big statues of Buddha already extant by that time outside China, right away gave the religion the name of the word for idol.

So, Buddhism in Chinese is called the idol religion, and Buddha is given the name idol.

That is some joke on the Buddhists here who take pride in calling themselves Buddhists.

Anyway, it is good to have someone well versed in Chinese and in English, and of good learning in religious history i.e., of Buddhism.

Tell me something about the use of the name "佛教" by the Chinese people when Buddhism came to China. Were they really into some naughty nuances in their choice of the term or confection of the term? Or did it just happen that the Pali word for Buddha happens to be equivalent to the sound of idol in Chinese.

Yes, tell me about the rationale behind that terminological choice.


Thanks for your enlightenment; now the Buddhists of the West will guard themselves on feeling so sure about invoking the name of Buddha, identifying themselves as Buddhists.

Yrreg

I think your colleague is very much mistaken. The character "佛" (fo2) is a contraction of "佛陀" (fo2 tuo2), which is the Chinese phonetic translation for "Buddha". I am not familiar with ancient Chinese dialects, but it is plausible that the prevalent dialect at the time when Buddhism first arrived in China would have a closer pronunciation for "Buddha" from those two characters.

The confusion with idolatory was probably a result of the Cultural Revolution in Maoist China when Buddhism, Chinese traditional faiths (often confused as Taoism, even by the Chinese) and Chinese ancestral worship were persecuted and denigrated for promoting superstition.

In terms of word meaning, an idol or image would be "像" (xiang4). Hence, an idol or image of the Buddha would be "佛像" (fo2 xiang4), just like a generic term for sculpture would be "雕像" (diao1 xiang4) or "carved image".
 
Hi Yrreg,

I think your message is on target when you caution against taking pride in calling oneself a "Buddhist." While I often find your posts to be grating, I have to admit that underneath it all, you make an unflinching demand that I can't dismiss, namely, to examine oneself and avoid delusion.

I think it's appropriate that you identify yourself as "Resident Buddhist Critic" rather than "Resident Buddhism Critic."

On some levels, it's a little like Scientology - a member doesn't get to hear about Xenu until OTIII and by then it may be too late to get out.
It's never too late to get out.
 
I am sorry to inform you that your definition of Nirvana if a definition it is that you are attempting is not yet good enough to spot a human with Nirvana from others without.

A definition is precisely for the purpose of mapping out limits by which things can be separated from other things.

If your purpose is to be figurative; please, a useful definition tries not to be figurative. So please, no pogo stick for then your definition is too restrictive as to exclude from Nirvana anyone and everyone not riding a pogo stick.

Otherwise your definition is too overly broad for being inclusive of everyone even the as Epepke puts it, sociopaths.

Read this definition again of religion by my favorite opinion maker:

Religion is a human behavior founded upon a belief in an unknown power resulting in affections and actions intended by the believer to influence the unknown power to react favorably to the believer. -- Pes Oir Amsus​
​

And try to draft a definition of Nirvana following the template that you should be able to see in it.

------------------

I am going over to the threads on Buddhism is not scientific! (from you), and Evidence in Buddhism (from Ryokan), to see whether there are new developments there to satisfy people asking pertinent questions of their authors.

I will be back.


Yrreg


Yrreg

I am not sure what the point would be of redefining it, the definition of internal states through direct observation is difficult. The only means to access the interior state of an individual is through interview and survey. So coming up with a directly observable state would be difficult, especialy because of the motion of the pogo stick.

Otherwise your definition is too overly broad for being inclusive of everyone even the as Epepke puts it, sociopaths

That may be , but for clarity, which is what you asked for, I tried to not add any qualifiers. The definition of narmative area is very complicated. But from working with sociopaths, quite frequently, sociopaths do not act freely and they are often subject to the vauge terms of preconception and prejudice. So they would be excluded from the definition. Most sociopaths are very attached to thier acts, as demonstrated by thier repetitive explanations for why it is everybidy elses fault that they do what they do.

And while the defintion of religion that use is the one you like, I would counter that in some forms of buddhism there is no resources to unknown powers, there are the practices of the eightfold path and the virtues. They do not rely upon unknown forces, it is the practice itself that leads to the desired effect.
 
Critical both of Buddhism and Buddhists

Hi Yrreg,

I think your message is on target when you caution against taking pride in calling oneself a "Buddhist." While I often find your posts to be grating, I have to admit that underneath it all, you make an unflinching demand that I can't dismiss, namely, to examine oneself and avoid delusion.

I think it's appropriate that you identify yourself as "Resident Buddhist Critic" rather than "Resident Buddhism Critic."

I call myself Resident Buddhist Critic as some kind of flippant riposte to Ryokan's calling himself Resident Buddhist; of course neither he nor I are resident in the sense of designated by the JREF management.

About your distinction between being a Buddhist critic and a Buddhism critic, I am critical of both: Buddhism and Buddhists. I use the word Buddhist as an adjective referring to both Buddhism and adherents of Buddhism, i.e. Buddhists.

There is something very peculiarly different between Buddhism which is a worldview and say biology which is a science, namely: you cannot study Buddhism without examining Buddhists, but you can study biology without examining biologists.

I don't think anyone can be critical of Buddhists without being critical of Buddhism, or critical of Buddhism without being critical or exercising criticism on Buddhists.


Yrreg
 
My definition of Nirvana is a few vodkas under my belt and reading the intellectual loop-de-loops of my peers right here, on channel JREF.

M.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom