Budhism Is Not A Religion

There are good reasons why Buddhism is usually treated lightly. Unlike some other religions, it does not require its followers to knock on your door every other weekend to proselytize, and it does not curse unbelievers to eternal damnation.

Neither does Judaism, but I don't see much evidence that Judaism gets a light touch.

Word game or not, there is a misunderstanding about Buddhism's explanation of the nonexistent "eternal soul". Some Buddhists on this board understand it as:
Buddhism believes there is no soul -> Buddhism does not believe in rebirth.​
Instead, Buddhism teaches:
Unenlightened beings hold on to the illusion of the soul -> unenlightened beings continue to be reborn.
Enlightened being understands there is no soul -> enlightened being escapes rebirth.​

We need at least an approximate definition of "rebirth" here.
 
read my signature

Again, one thing is to think about it. Think its easy (the interesting part is that we think this from the very I that is doubted).

But another very different (inconceivable different) is to actually let the world to see "itself", in other words, let the ego disolve and let "you" become part of the noumena, forgetting phenomena.

but I dont see the point on discussing Buddhism if you are not going to submerge yourself in it. All you will be doing is discussing words, like we have seen in these threads regarding Buddhism).

ui think you would be one of the few people here who would understand why i blab on... ^^
 
Biologist not exactly like Buddhist

Originally Posted by yrreg :
... you cannot study Buddhism without examining Buddhists ...​
Yes you can. In exactly the same way that you can study biology without examining biologists.

First, it is easy right away to know that a Buddhist is not in the same basket as a biologist; the Buddhist is dealing with thoughts or notions and feelings in his own heart and mind, while the biologist is dealing with body organs and physiological processes, in general with life and life systems, the organic kind which is as far as I know the only kind.

There are therefore here two very different kinds of dealerships.

Now as regards Buddhism and biology, actually, when you study Buddhism you are studying certain kinds of thoughts or notions in the mind of a man or some men, which are not present in the mind of everyman, and these thoughts together make up Buddhism.

But when you study biology you are not studying certain kinds of thoughts or notions in the mind of a man or some men which together make up biology, which thoughts or notions are not present in the mind of everyman. In biology you are studying organic life, that of man, and insects and plants and bacteria and any and every life form.

Back to Buddhist and biologist, they are both teachers in a way; but the Buddhist is a teacher only when he teaches others about his thoughts and feelings and actions by which he is known as a Buddhist or a believer in Buddhism, not so the biologist.

The biologist is a teacher not of his thoughts and feelings and actions by which he is known as a biologist, but he dispenses information about organic life and living systems of life forms.

That is why you cannot study Buddhism without studying Buddhists, because Buddhism is in the mind as in a laboratory: the mind in regard to Buddhism is Buddhism's lab, and that mind is that of Buddha and also that of Nosho; but you can study biology without probing the mind of the biologist, however if you prefer, his body, yes; but then any other man's body is just as good for studying biology, that of man that is, yet for that matter not necessarily a man's body, it can be a cockroach's body.

You don't have to go to the mind of the biologist as to the laboratory to study biology, but you definitely and indispensably have to go to the minds of Buddhists, starting with the Buddha and then everyone who professes to follow him, again as to the laboratory, to study Buddhism.

Summing up, while in Buddhism you study the professor himself, the Buddhist professor who professes Buddhism; in biology you don't study the biologist professor himself, but the materials he has information about, which materials are not in his mind as in their natural habitat, but outside and away from his mind.

That is why Buddhists who don't study themselves and study the Buddha himself, the what and the why and how and the wherefore of the thoughts and practices making up Buddhism and very important their kind of, namely, their personal take on Buddhism, do not know Buddhism, not the kind that is in their heart and mind.


Lesson to be learned here:

If we take as an imperative verity that the unexamined life is not worth living, then it is incumbent upon every Buddhist to look into his own personal psychology of his adherence to Buddhism, to examine psychologically the what, and the why, and the how, and the wherefore of his embrace and practice of Buddhism.


Yrreg
 
First, it is easy right away to know that a Buddhist is not in the same basket as a biologist; the Buddhist is dealing with thoughts or notions and feelings in his own heart and mind, while the biologist is dealing with body organs and physiological processes, in general with life and life systems, the organic kind which is as far as I know the only kind.

There are therefore here two very different kinds of dealerships.

Quite.

The claims of Buddhism consist of claims that Buddhism will cause changes in the user, i.e. the Buddhist. So it is appropriate to study Buddhists.
 
Bodhidharma, who brought Buddhism to China, was very clear that people who worship statues and shave their heads were fools and fanatics. In other words, they didn't understand the purpose of Buddhism.
 
"佛" (fo2) in Chinese popular usage

I think your colleague is very much mistaken. The character "佛" (fo2) is a contraction of "佛陀" (fo2 tuo2), which is the Chinese phonetic translation for "Buddha". I am not familiar with ancient Chinese dialects, but it is plausible that the prevalent dialect at the time when Buddhism first arrived in China would have a closer pronunciation for "Buddha" from those two characters.

The confusion with idolatory was probably a result of the Cultural Revolution in Maoist China when Buddhism, Chinese traditional faiths (often confused as Taoism, even by the Chinese) and Chinese ancestral worship were persecuted and denigrated for promoting superstition.

In terms of word meaning, an idol or image would be "像" (xiang4). Hence, an idol or image of the Buddha would be "佛像" (fo2 xiang4), just like a generic term for sculpture would be "雕像" (diao1 xiang4) or "carved image".
I appraoched the nice Chinese lady in office again.

She told me that "佛" (fo2) is indeed the name for Buddha, but also it means commonly or popularly a religious statue Chinese pray before and pray to for favors, even though not representing Buddha but some original Chinese deity, what we call idol in English or graven image in a Biblical or Judeo-Christian context.

I think she is not possessed of academic finesse in matters of Chinese religious concepts and terms.

But tell me, that sound represented by the character, "佛" (fo2), is it just a sound without any meaning, but conventionally referred to the Buddha owing to sound affinity? Or does it have an intrinsic meaning in the Chinese language even before its application to Buddha? And if that original meaning has some connection with worship of religious statues?


Thanks for your informative inputs to my education.


Yrreg
 
It's not science, it's not religion; what is Buddhism?

Now that we hear at least from some Buddhists here that Buddhism is not science nor scientific and it is not religion.

That leaves philosophy and art.

There is a lot of artistic outputs in stone, and in canvas and paper, with ink and paint, occasioned by Buddhism; but I don't think we can say that Buddhism is an art form, like say tea ceremony in Japan is an art form -- with influence from Zen(?)

That leaves philosophy. But what kind of a philosophy is this where its fans engage their mind in order to alter its mind-state into a mode of mental condition they call Nirvana; or even for those Buddhists who believe in post mortem existence in any kind of tortured explanation, some not susceptible to word representation, dimension of being, or even paradoxically non-being, they also call Nirvana.

Now, very important in the concept of Nirvana, it is the liberation of man from suffering; what suffering?

All kinds that Buddhists can imagine; but according to their more profound thinkers it is what I would understand a guy in the Bible complains about: all life, human existence, everything being vanity and tiredness of spirit, that kind of a boredom and distaste even for existence and recurring existence (which only Buddhists can believe in), also said to possess the character of abysmal transcendence [hahaha softly].

No, I don't think for that kind of a mind cultivation, I can call Buddhism a philosophy, unless they the Buddhists just talk Nirvana, but don't do nothing with their mind to bring about any kind of mind state altering or channeling if that word be appropriate. For philosophy to my understanding is into thinking and talking, not so much into doing except when the talkers want to rule fellow men to change them to their own thinking.


What about calling Buddhism a system of mental magic, a magic that the Buddhist's mind works on his own mind to experience, yes, Nirvana.

According to my favorite opinion maker, Res Oir Amsus, there is a very thin line between religion and magic, that line consists in the distinction between a personalistic power in religion and a non-personalisitc power, a blind force of nature in magic.

You see, in religion you bargain with the personalistic though unknown power, but in magic you deal with the non-personalistic power as with a machine, pressing a button or pulling a lever, only in the case of the magic of Buddhism you use -- no, not formulaic words and bodily gestures and/or postures, but with your mind -- no, not by thinking, but more properly by non-thinking, what they call Buddhist meditation.

Just that you still need your mind to do that kind of a mental magic, and of course a brain is absolutely indispensable, even the most non-self Buddhists will grant you that, unless they want to meditate brainless -- which might actually works better for Buddhists are tireless in insisting on not using your brain, it's an obstacle toward Nirvana.


Yrreg
 
She told me that "佛" (fo2) is indeed the name for Buddha, but also it means commonly or popularly a religious statue Chinese pray before and pray to for favors, even though not representing Buddha but some original Chinese deity, what we call idol in English or graven image in a Biblical or Judeo-Christian context.

While the generic term for the activity of praying to a deity is called "拜神" (bai4 shen2), it is often used interchangeably with "拜佛" (bai4 fo2) even by non-Buddhists. For a long time, Chinese Buddhism has been mixed with Taoism and traditional Chinese folk beliefs. It was one big mess before modern efforts to reform the religion and return to the source.

But tell me, that sound represented by the character, "佛" (fo2), is it just a sound without any meaning, but conventionally referred to the Buddha owing to sound affinity? Or does it have an intrinsic meaning in the Chinese language even before its application to Buddha? And if that original meaning has some connection with worship of religious statues?

The character has only one meaning, and that is the "Buddha". If there was one before the introduction of Buddhism to China, then I'm not aware of it. However, I'm not a scholar on the history of the Chinese language.
 
Last edited:
"佛" (fo2) = man as if

While the generic term for the activity of praying to a deity is called "拜神" (bai4 shen2), it is often used interchangeably with "拜佛" (bai4 fo2) even by non-Buddhists. For a long time, Chinese Buddhism has been mixed with Taoism and traditional Chinese folk beliefs. It was one big mess before modern efforts to reform the religion and return to the source.

The character has only one meaning, and that is the "Buddha". If there was one before the introduction of Buddhism to China, then I'm not aware of it. However, I'm not a scholar on the history of the Chinese language.

Sorry to disturb you again, Merentha.

I asked the lady again. She told me that she is no linguist either in Chinese language. However, from the composite characters in a Chinese word one can often get to the meaning of a word.

In the case of the word and sound "佛" (fo2), from left to right, the first character consisting of two strokes, the upper one slanting downward from top right to bottom left, balancing on the vertical segment. the figure means according to her, man; while the right character, looking like a dollar sign but with the S drawn like an abstract symbol of a seahorse, according to her means the English phrase "as if."

This is getting more and more interesting. If you read the two characters "man" and "as if" from left to right, as in English, "佛" (fo2) stands for "man as if."

The nice Chinese lady however told me -- and this is the most beautiful part for me, that Chinese writing is written and read from right to left unlike English; in which case "佛" (fo2) stands for "as if man."

I was saying that maybe the Chinese in their naughty wisdom assigned that word "佛" (fo2) to Buddha, to play a joke on Buddha, calling him closely by sound but choosing a word which compositely means something looking "as if man," making fun also thereby of his followers as worshipers of something looking "as if man."

This Chinese lady also gave me something more to enjoy as humorous and also quite insightful; she shared with me a parody on the worship of Buddha, using the Sinicized version of the Buddha, one Amitabha. Below are two lines she recites, the first means "Amitabha sincerely worship," but the second almost sounding like the first means "Amitabha crazily worship:"

O mi to hut sieng sim pai put
(Amitabha sincerely worship, or
Worship sincerely Amitabha)

O mi to hut sieng kieng pai put
(Amitabha crazily worship, or
Worship crazily Amitabha)
​

If you should have access to those learned men in the local campus on Chinese words, please ask them about the history of that Chinese word "佛" (fo2), for a name assigned by the Chinese word craftmen to Buddha.


This is rich. Wait till some enterprising Yankee writes a Da Vinci Code on Buddha and Amitabha and all their reincarnates from Nepal through China to Afghanistan.

That will take away the fad from Buddhism among Western Buddhists who know more and more authentically than the benighted Buddhists of the Far East.


[Hahahaha softly. I prefer the Fat Laughing Buddha.]


Yrreg
 
Sorry to disturb you again, Merentha.

I asked the lady again. She told me that she is no linguist either in Chinese language. However, from the composite characters in a Chinese word one can often get to the meaning of a word.

In the case of the word and sound "佛" (fo2), from left to right, the first character consisting of two strokes, the upper one slanting downward from top right to bottom left, balancing on the vertical segment. the figure means according to her, man; while the right character, looking like a dollar sign but with the S drawn like an abstract symbol of a seahorse, according to her means the English phrase "as if."

This is getting more and more interesting. If you read the two characters "man" and "as if" from left to right, as in English, "佛" (fo2) stands for "man as if."

I disagree with the Chinese lady, and I have serious suspicions about her knowledge of the Chinese language.

First, each Chinese character is read as a whole. Many characters are formed by two or small simpler characters, but the meaning is not necessarily dependent on the component characters. There is also no such thing as reading left-to-right or right-to-left within a character. Wikipedia has a good explanation about Chinese characters.

Second, the character "弗" (fu2) does not mean "as if". It is a character rarely found in modern usage but more common in ancient scholarly texts. Its general meaning, depending on context, is "not/negate/prohibit". However, it is used in the character for "Buddha" as a phonetic component (refer to wikipedia link above). The character on the left-hand is a modified representation of man "人" (ren2) and represents the context of the character's usage.

Third, the actual word for "as if" is "仿佛" (fang3 fu2), though it is more commonly written nowadays as "彷彿". Though the character for the "Buddha" is used, its pronunciation is different, which renders its meaning different. Perhaps the word was used differently in ancient times. Anyhow, if we were to split up this word as two characters and pronounce the second character as "fo2", then its meaning could read as "to imitate the Buddha"/"to be like the Buddha".

This Chinese lady also gave me something more to enjoy as humorous and also quite insightful; she shared with me a parody on the worship of Buddha, using the Sinicized version of the Buddha, one Amitabha. Below are two lines she recites, the first means "Amitabha sincerely worship," but the second almost sounding like the first means "Amitabha crazily worship:"

Based on your romanization of the rhyme, the Chinese lady sounds like she might be Taiwanese since the rhyme is in Hokkien. Anyhow, the rhyme sounds like immature word play, such as a children's playground chant to make fun of the odd kid who happens to be Buddhist.

If you should have access to those learned men in the local campus on Chinese words, please ask them about the history of that Chinese word "佛" (fo2), for a name assigned by the Chinese word craftmen to Buddha.

This is rich. Wait till some enterprising Yankee writes a Da Vinci Code on Buddha and Amitabha and all their reincarnates from Nepal through China to Afghanistan.

That will take away the fad from Buddhism among Western Buddhists who know more and more authentically than the benighted Buddhists of the Far East.


[Hahahaha softly. I prefer the Fat Laughing Buddha.]


Yrreg

I'm a working girl, so there isn't any Chinese Prof I could seek advice. For your info, the term "Buddha" usually refers to Sakyamuni Buddha, who is different from Amitabha Buddha. The "Fat Laughing Buddha" is the Chinese representation of the next Buddha (as foretold by Sakyamuni Buddha), also known as Maitreya Buddha. Theravadan Buddhist art tend to represent him slim and serious as opposed to fat and laughing. The existence of previous Buddhas like Amitabha will likely spark off another debate of more Buddhist woo since it might imply that either the Buddhist history of man is longer than evolutionary history suggests, or that there are intelligent alien worlds out there not unlike Earth.

I don't think Buddhists need to "worry" about any Da Vinci code. There isn't any Holy Grail-like tradition, no secret councils, the Buddha didn't claim to be God or God's son, and he didn't resurrect. In fact, his official life story already has a wife and son included!
 
Thanks, Merentha.

I disagree with the Chinese lady, and I have serious suspicions about her knowledge of the Chinese language.

First, each Chinese character is read as a whole. Many characters are formed by two or small simpler characters, but the meaning is not necessarily dependent on the component characters. There is also no such thing as reading left-to-right or right-to-left within a character. Wikipedia has a good explanation about Chinese characters.

Second, the character "弗" (fu2) does not mean "as if". It is a character rarely found in modern usage but more common in ancient scholarly texts. Its general meaning, depending on context, is "not/negate/prohibit". However, it is used in the character for "Buddha" as a phonetic component (refer to wikipedia link above). The character on the left-hand is a modified representation of man "人" (ren2) and represents the context of the character's usage.

Third, the actual word for "as if" is "仿佛" (fang3 fu2), though it is more commonly written nowadays as "彷彿". Though the character for the "Buddha" is used, its pronunciation is different, which renders its meaning different. Perhaps the word was used differently in ancient times. Anyhow, if we were to split up this word as two characters and pronounce the second character as "fo2", then its meaning could read as "to imitate the Buddha"/"to be like the Buddha".

Based on your romanization of the rhyme, the Chinese lady sounds like she might be Taiwanese since the rhyme is in Hokkien. Anyhow, the rhyme sounds like immature word play, such as a children's playground chant to make fun of the odd kid who happens to be Buddhist.

I'm a working girl, so there isn't any Chinese Prof I could seek advice. For your info, the term "Buddha" usually refers to Sakyamuni Buddha, who is different from Amitabha Buddha. The "Fat Laughing Buddha" is the Chinese representation of the next Buddha (as foretold by Sakyamuni Buddha), also known as Maitreya Buddha. Theravadan Buddhist art tend to represent him slim and serious as opposed to fat and laughing. The existence of previous Buddhas like Amitabha will likely spark off another debate of more Buddhist woo since it might imply that either the Buddhist history of man is longer than evolutionary history suggests, or that there are intelligent alien worlds out there not unlike Earth.

I don't think Buddhists need to "worry" about any Da Vinci code. There isn't any Holy Grail-like tradition, no secret councils, the Buddha didn't claim to be God or God's son, and he didn't resurrect. In fact, his official life story already has a wife and son included!

Thanks, Merentha, for your inputs to my education.

I won't trouble the Chinese lady in the office any further. As I said she is not in the academe.

But that part about knowing the meaning of a Chinese word from its component characters, I have heard that pitch before, for example Chinese tell us that the Chinese word for crisis has two component characters, something like trouble and opportunity, and good is woman and child together.

But here is something more challenging, mother is composed of woman and horse. Hahaha. I guess this is one instance where the Chinese used the sound for horse and affix it to woman, indicating that this sound for horse, ma which is a universal first sound made by babies, calling the attention of their mother, should be understood as referred to woman with child.

I once had a pocket book on how to write concretely and briefly by thinking Chinese as Chinese write their characters; don't know where I can find it in the house now. The author is an American columnist on how to write good, simple, and intelligible English, even on deep issues.

I can't forget what he said in his introduction, that unlike European languages with conjugations and declensions making language learning so difficult, Chinese language did away with all that; but it must not be thought that Chinese is a primitive language, because before the Chinese got to their simplistic shorthand type of writing and speaking, they also used conjugations for verbs and declensions for nouns and adjectives.

------------

Coming to Buddhism as a religion or not, what do you have for a religion now? since you have given up on Buddhism for being not up to your rational skeptical mind now. You are giving up Buddhism whereas the Westerners are lapping it up, thinking that Buddha was way ahead of his times: nothing superstitious, everything with him so ultra rational. And like their newly discovered idealized master from the Far East, they have gone into meditation as a way to attain genuine what? wisdom of course, starting with the meaning of life.

And what is that meaning of life now for them as Buddhists? life has only one eternal meaning, namely, to get to Nirvana -- whatever that Nirvana is supposed to be, if anything at all it is still murky to me -- because I am not enlightened, hahaha. Or I don't have their faith, in Buddha.


Yrreg
 
But that part about knowing the meaning of a Chinese word from its component characters, I have heard that pitch before, for example Chinese tell us that the Chinese word for crisis has two component characters, something like trouble and opportunity, and good is woman and child together.

But here is something more challenging, mother is composed of woman and horse. Hahaha. I guess this is one instance where the Chinese used the sound for horse and affix it to woman, indicating that this sound for horse, ma which is a universal first sound made by babies, calling the attention of their mother, should be understood as referred to woman with child.

Most Chinese characters of two or more component characters are formed the second way. Hence, my Chinese teachers always say that even if we've never seen a character, we can usually make a good guess of its pronunciation from the phonetic component.

I once had a pocket book on how to write concretely and briefly by thinking Chinese as Chinese write their characters; don't know where I can find it in the house now. The author is an American columnist on how to write good, simple, and intelligible English, even on deep issues.

Over here in Singapore where many people are bilingual and where Mandarin is usually the spoken language for the Chinese, this is actually a problem when learning English. The "Singlish" as spoken by many Chinese Singaporeans is an awful mismash of Chinese and English sentence structures.

I can't forget what he said in his introduction, that unlike European languages with conjugations and declensions making language learning so difficult, Chinese language did away with all that; but it must not be thought that Chinese is a primitive language, because before the Chinese got to their simplistic shorthand type of writing and speaking, they also used conjugations for verbs and declensions for nouns and adjectives.

I don't know how accurate is that statement, but my experience with ancient Chinese texts is that they are difficult to understand despite their apparent simplicity. They are simple in the sense that a sentence could comprise of just a few characters. Yet, to transcribe those few characters to modern Chinese could easily use up twice as many characters.

Coming to Buddhism as a religion or not, what do you have for a religion now? since you have given up on Buddhism for being not up to your rational skeptical mind now. You are giving up Buddhism whereas the Westerners are lapping it up, thinking that Buddha was way ahead of his times: nothing superstitious, everything with him so ultra rational. And like their newly discovered idealized master from the Far East, they have gone into meditation as a way to attain genuine what? wisdom of course, starting with the meaning of life.

And what is that meaning of life now for them as Buddhists? life has only one eternal meaning, namely, to get to Nirvana -- whatever that Nirvana is supposed to be, if anything at all it is still murky to me -- because I am not enlightened, hahaha. Or I don't have their faith, in Buddha.


Yrreg

I do not profess any particular faith. I was brought up a Buddhist, have explored Christianity, like to read up on other religions and mythologies, and have even dabbled in woo stuffs like tarot cards. But at every point, something always rankled at the back of my mind. Do any of these stuff make any sense? Do I even believe it?

I made up interpretations for my card readings and my more credulous friends could swear I was psychic. :D

I was bothered that an all-powerful God should care about the petty problems of a few people living in peaceful Singapore, when He has failed to bring peace to his supposed Holy Land for centuries. Why should a God who was so eager to interfere in affairs in the past as described in the bible become so silent now? I decided that he was mythological, just like the Greek and Norse Gods.

As for Buddhism, I did not care for the supernatural stuff. I reasoned that karma was used to instruct the poor and downtrodden to be content with their lot because they're paying for their "sins" committed in a past life. In any case, assuming that Buddhism is 100% true, I figured that if I didn't consider life to be suffering and don't mind being caught in samsara, why should I be bothered about missing out on Nirvana? Life is too short and too interesting to spend on meditating for a goal that may not exist.

However, I do not begrudge the decisions of others to be spiritual. If the West can export Christianity to Asia, I don't see why Asia can't export Buddhism to the West. If people find meaning in a religion, do not impose it on others, do not demand the deaths of unbelievers, do not destroy families to gain converts, and are generally harmless, I am willing to give them some measure of respect.
 
my version of budhism

There are numerous forms of Buddhism, and some do pray directly to Lord Buddha as they are taught. Other forms have ceremonies which have all the aspects of relgious ritual.

I surmise you lean toward the Ch'an or Zen form of Buddhism which certainly is non-religious in practice and does not deify Sakyamuni, the historical Buddha. But please do not make the mistake of thinking your version is the only correct version. That simply is not the case. http://en.wikipedia.org./wiki/Buddhism

i appolozise if i seemedto have mis led you and some others here.

i do not have a particular version.
the words i stated are not versions.

I merely attept to guide a 'path'
all the writings you read of budhas teachings are Not definitions...
they are just 'path'

some may seem to be right for you.
some may seem completely wrong.

it doesnt really matter.
you just have you own road.

you dont have to 'be' budhist or anything.

nothing is really defind as we might think they are.
our minds are traped in a cycle of meanings and definition created by our selves. which was mostly done in order to understand the world and communicate to each other(to put it simply ^^)

Remember!

budha did not call him self 'the budha'
other people did.
 
I was bothered that an all-powerful God should care about the petty problems of a few people living in peaceful Singapore, when He has failed to bring peace to his supposed Holy Land for centuries. Why should a God who was so eager to interfere in affairs in the past as described in the bible become so silent now? I decided that he was mythological, just like the Greek and Norse Gods.

As for Buddhism, I did not care for the supernatural stuff. I reasoned that karma was used to instruct the poor and downtrodden to be content with their lot because they're paying for their "sins" committed in a past life. In any case, assuming that Buddhism is 100% true, I figured that if I didn't consider life to be suffering and don't mind being caught in samsara, why should I be bothered about missing out on Nirvana? Life is too short and too interesting to spend on meditating for a goal that may not exist.

So much truth in so few words. Nicely done.
 
I was bothered that an all-powerful God should care about the petty problems of a few people living in peaceful Singapore, when He has failed to bring peace to his supposed Holy Land for centuries. Why should a God who was so eager to interfere in affairs in the past as described in the bible become so silent now? I decided that he was mythological, just like the Greek and Norse Gods.

As for Buddhism, I did not care for the supernatural stuff. I reasoned that karma was used to instruct the poor and downtrodden to be content with their lot because they're paying for their "sins" committed in a past life. In any case, assuming that Buddhism is 100% true, I figured that if I didn't consider life to be suffering and don't mind being caught in samsara, why should I be bothered about missing out on Nirvana? Life is too short and too interesting to spend on meditating for a goal that may not exist.

However, I do not begrudge the decisions of others to be spiritual. If the West can export Christianity to Asia, I don't see why Asia can't export Buddhism to the West. If people find meaning in a religion, do not impose it on others, do not demand the deaths of unbelievers, do not destroy families to gain converts, and are generally harmless, I am willing to give them some measure of respect.


should try though,meditation i mean.
Maybe you will learn to enjoy life much more then you knew. ^^
but if it seems like just sitting down doing nothing.. then it is ok. try yoga, or fishing, taichi is good also.
you have a great perspective on life. the thing about a 'god' seemed a little negative. but i lean towards agreeing with you.
you writings are your own thoughts, i appreciate them.
 
Quite.

The claims of Buddhism consist of claims that Buddhism will cause changes in the user, i.e. the Buddhist. So it is appropriate to study Buddhists.
There might be reasons why it is appropriate to study Buddhists, but that doesn't mean you can't study Buddhism without studying Buddhists. Of course you can.

For example, one could read a book by Thich Nhat Hanh on Buddhism. In order to read and study this book, it is not necessary to study Thich Nhat Hanh. You don't have to know he's from Vietnam, or that Martin Luther King Jr. nominated him for the Nobel Peace Prize. You don't have to know if he believes in a god. You don't have to know if he personally has benefited from meditation. It's not necessary to study Thich Nhat Hanh as a person in order to study his teachings on Buddhism (although it might be interesting).

Just as it is possible to read about and study biology without analyzing the lives of biologists, it is possible to read about and study Buddhism without analyzing the lives of Buddhists.

This doesn't mean Buddhism is the same as biology. It also doesn't mean there's no value in studying Buddhists (or biologists, for that matter).

But to say that it is impossible to critically analyze Buddhism without critically analyzing Buddhists is just not true. In order to understand Buddhism, I don't have to pick apart the thoughts and feelings of anyone (except maybe myself).

In fact, picking apart the thoughts and feelings of some other person probably is just going to be a distraction from the real task. It can become just an excuse for not looking closely at the very thing we're trying to study.
 
There might be reasons why it is appropriate to study Buddhists, but that doesn't mean you can't study Buddhism without studying Buddhists. Of course you can.

It seems that International Pedantry Month has rolled around again.

It's completely obvious that when yyreg or I use the phrase "study Buddhism," we mean subjecting the claims of Buddhist that are attributed to Buddhism to skeptical study, and that cannot be done to any significant degree without studying Buddhists.

Just as it is possible to read about and study biology without analyzing the lives of biologists, it is possible to read about and study Buddhism without analyzing the lives of Buddhists.

Bad analogy. The claims of biologists are about living creatures. It is, indeed, impossible to study those claims without studying living creatures. If someone claims, for example, that there is a jewel in the head of a toad, one can examine that claim by finding a dead toad and opening it up. (I don't have the heart to kill a toad.) The claims of Buddhists are about Buddhists. It is not possible to study those claims without studying Buddhists.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom