Biologist not exactly like Buddhist
Originally Posted by yrreg :
... you cannot study Buddhism without examining Buddhists ...
Yes you can. In exactly the same way that you can study biology without examining biologists.
First, it is easy right away to know that a Buddhist is not in the same basket as a biologist; the Buddhist is dealing with thoughts or notions and feelings in his own heart and mind, while the biologist is dealing with body organs and physiological processes, in general with life and life systems, the organic kind which is as far as I know the only kind.
There are therefore here two very different kinds of dealerships.
Now as regards Buddhism and biology, actually, when you study Buddhism you are studying certain kinds of thoughts or notions in the mind of a man or some men, which are not present in the mind of everyman, and these thoughts together make up Buddhism.
But when you study biology you are not studying certain kinds of thoughts or notions in the mind of a man or some men which together make up biology, which thoughts or notions are not present in the mind of everyman. In biology you are studying organic life, that of man, and insects and plants and bacteria and any and every life form.
Back to Buddhist and biologist, they are both teachers in a way; but the Buddhist is a teacher only when he teaches others about his thoughts and feelings and actions by which he is known as a Buddhist or a believer in Buddhism, not so the biologist.
The biologist is a teacher not of his thoughts and feelings and actions by which he is known as a biologist, but he dispenses information about organic life and living systems of life forms.
That is why you cannot study Buddhism without studying Buddhists, because Buddhism is in the mind as in a laboratory: the mind in regard to Buddhism is Buddhism's lab, and that mind is that of Buddha and also that of Nosho; but you can study biology without probing the mind of the biologist, however if you prefer, his body, yes; but then any other man's body is just as good for studying biology, that of man that is, yet for that matter not necessarily a man's body, it can be a cockroach's body.
You don't have to go to the mind of the biologist as to the laboratory to study biology, but you definitely and indispensably have to go to the minds of Buddhists, starting with the Buddha and then everyone who professes to follow him, again as to the laboratory, to study Buddhism.
Summing up, while in Buddhism you study the professor himself, the Buddhist professor who professes Buddhism; in biology you don't study the biologist professor himself, but the materials he has information about, which materials are not in his mind as in their natural habitat, but outside and away from his mind.
That is why Buddhists who don't study themselves and study the Buddha himself, the what and the why and how and the wherefore of the thoughts and practices making up Buddhism and very important their kind of, namely, their personal take on Buddhism, do not know Buddhism, not the kind that is in their heart and mind.
Lesson to be learned here:
If we take as an imperative verity that the unexamined life is not worth living, then it is incumbent upon every Buddhist to look into his own personal psychology of his adherence to Buddhism, to examine psychologically the what, and the why, and the how, and the wherefore of his embrace and practice of Buddhism.
Yrreg