International Pedantry Month still around
Click on the boxed arrow above to see Bodhi's post, I will just react here to some lines from his message.
Dear Bodhi, first, let's have a good laugh, ala Fat Laughing Buddha, Hotei, I think as Ryokan informed me that's his name; and Merentha tells us the Fat Laughing Buddha is the next Maitreya to come, another Buddha reincarnate, and I read that he is the final one, to inaugurate the era of true Dharma and rule the world in peace and in prosperity -- shade of the rapture.
Hahahaha, hohohoho, hahahaha, hohohoho! And recall that Hotei, the Fat Laughing Buddha, he was a Zen monk himself. Now, if all you Zen guys get to be Fat Laughing Buddhas, mankind would have more mirth and fun.
-------------------
I seem to be in some deja vu here, reminiscent of Username and specially D David, who just got to put in their last word.
Allow me to invite you, good Bodhi, to be my teacher then, for this episode of the present thread. Let me seek instructions from you.
-------------------
Originally Posted by yrreg :
I used to like photography but as a kid and motorcycles also as a kid. Nowadays, I seem to be through with all such contrivances. You know photography? Okay, tell me in fifty (50) words or less the meaning of f22 in photography.
Bodhi:
With Google around those kind of questions are even boring. Don't you think?
I just want to see you explaining
f22 in fifty (50) or less words, so that I can use your draft as a model for KISS writing: Keep It Simple and Short. So, dear teacher, don't disappoint me, have a some compassion, or exercise a compassionate heart toward a student, a learner.
Originally Posted by yrreg :
Speech is difficult enough as it is, but Zen monks have to make speech even more difficult just to give the impression that they are saying something so dazzling. See if they can make a better mouse trap with their subtle dazzle of a speech habit.
Bodhi:
"just to give the impression", obviously, from your point of view. From mine, its a way to transcend words and see the meaning behind them. You have not read Wittgenstein, have you? He understood so well that the meaning of words is not as clear as you believe when you demand that Buddhists should be clear. Clear about what? Your personal preferences about what is ok and what is not?
Dear teacher Bodhi, please give me again in fifty (50) words or less, what Wittgenstein said about his having "understood so well that the meaning of words is not as clear as you believe..." Just tell me if Wittgenstein means that people can never be clear with their words as they think they are clear?
I am always very unhappy with people who bring in names of supposedly authorities, like Buddha and Wittgenstein, as though they themselves don't or they can't see at all the sense in anything, unless some authorities say it; and others are like them, who cannot see any sense unless some authorities are cited in support.
If Buddha says anything that makes sense to you and you are of average intelligence like Yrreg, then you can just tell it to me in your own words, and rest assured that I can accept it also because I can see the sense in it; so also with Wittgenstein. At most you can just give the credit to Buddha and to Wittgenstein for seeing the sense in something which you yourself can also see the sense thereof, once you do apply your at least average intelligence to the matter.
Anyway, tell me in your own words fifty (50) or less what Wittgenstein said in the present connection about the clearness or more correctly unclearness of words, from the standpoint of the speaker and from the standpoint of the listener. Is he trying to convince people that speaker and listener can never be clear about the words, their own, passing between them? That so? Why then does he even bother to talk to us? No, I am not being cryptic but really asking you, That so?
Please, for the love of Buddha or more appropriately, Hotei, the Fat Laughing Buddha, and also Wittgenstein, just because one Gautama and one Wittgenstein spoke, so we are supposed to be dumb and dumber and more dumb.
That is why I am prone to depression, aside from my genes, I see people moving around after having read Buddhist sutras and Zen-nic koans, behaving or appearing dumb and dumber and more dumb and expecting everyone to be and do likewise; otherwise they won't get to the ultimate reality of life and the universe in the case of Buddha's expectation, or Wittgenstein's expectation of clarity or its absence in words.
Originally Posted by yrreg :
I suggest they take up farming, that should bring them down to earth and really get them to impact on reality.
Bodhi:
Oh they do.
I will do some searching around on farming among Buddhist and Zen monks, and get back to you.
Yrreg
PS Please see next post.