Budhism Is Not A Religion

Bad analogy. The claims of biologists are about living creatures. It is, indeed, impossible to study those claims without studying living creatures. If someone claims, for example, that there is a jewel in the head of a toad, one can examine that claim by finding a dead toad and opening it up. (I don't have the heart to kill a toad.) The claims of Buddhists are about Buddhists. It is not possible to study those claims without studying Buddhists.

All good points. I have to agree with you.

ETA : In the sense that if you want to study the truths of Buddhism, you have to study Buddhists. You can, of course, study the subject of Buddhism without examening a single Buddhist.
 
Buddhism without Buddhists?

Yrreg:

First, it is easy right away to know that a Buddhist is not in the same basket as a biologist; the Buddhist is dealing with thoughts or notions and feelings in his own heart and mind, while the biologist is dealing with body organs and physiological processes, in general with life and life systems, the organic kind which is as far as I know the only kind.

There are therefore here two very different kinds of dealerships.
Epepke:

Quite.

The claims of Buddhism consist of claims that Buddhism will cause changes in the user, i.e. the Buddhist. So it is appropriate to study Buddhists.
Nosho:

There might be reasons why it is appropriate to study Buddhists, but that doesn't mean you can't study Buddhism without studying Buddhists. Of course you can.

Etc. etc. etc.

There might be reasons why it is appropriate to study Buddhists, but that doesn't mean you can't study Buddhism without studying Buddhists. Of course you can. -- Nosho​

You can try to read Buddhist texts without any efforts at all to know the mind and heart of their author(s) in regard to the meanings expounded by them in their texts, but then you would not be able to derive an understanding of those texts as intended by their authors.

It would be like reading the last will and testament of a deceased person without reference to his mind and heart, his life in all its history and circumstances.

We can study Buddhism as intended by Buddha some 2,500 years ago when he taught his worldview which we now call after his name, Buddhism. And we can study the Buddhism as understood and practiced by Buddhists.

In both instances we have to study the person of Buddha in the first instance, and we have to study the persons of Buddhists in the second instance: how they understand Buddhism and implement Buddhism in their lives. Otherwise we would not come to a complete understanding of Buddhism.

Using the analogy of a last will and testament left by a deceased person, we can say very correctly that Buddhism is the last will and testament left by the Buddha. People today newly introduced to Buddhism, who want to follow faithfully the last will and testament of Buddha definitely have to study the heart and mind of Buddha, the person.

Do they have to study Buddhists who claim to have been observing the last will and testament of Buddha before them and presently already and traditionally practicing Buddhism? Certainly, at least to know how they are doing in case they are doing Buddhism more faithfully and thereby presumably more efficaciously than newcomers to Buddhism.

Now, as regards people outside Buddhism who are not into embracing Buddhism, but just for scholarly interest, they have to study both the last will and testament of Buddha to know Buddhism as intended by Buddha himself, and very important Buddhists also in regard to how they understand and practice Buddhism, the last will and testament of Buddha, on the very sound basis that Buddhists must know Buddhism better than anyone else non-Buddhist.

After studying both Buddhism as intended by Buddha which is presumed to be expounded in the ancient texts on Buddhism, and Buddhists down the centuries of Buddhism's and Buddhists' history, then the non-Buddhist student can know about Buddhism as intended in the ancient texts and Buddhism as practiced by Buddhists past and present, and be able to tell us how faithful Buddhists have been to Buddha down the centuries and in various lands, and also very interesting whether they have departed from Buddha, how and why.


Now as regards biology, one can study biology by examining life forms like oneself, a living specimen, and, as I said, cockroach, and all other animals and plants and bacteria and viruses, without ever reading a text on biology written by a researcher-writer-teacher called a biologist.

---------------

Buddhism is a purely man-made notion, the product of a man's heart and mind, and taken by other men into their hearts and minds and observed in their life conduct; you cannot therefore study that man-made notion of a Buddhism without examining the minds and hearts and life conducts of Buddhism's founder and practitioners of Buddhism, i.e., studying also Buddhists, starting with the original Buddhist, the Buddha himself, and then every John Doe and Jane Doe proclaiming themselves to be followers of Buddha.

That is the big and essential difference between studying Buddhism and studying biology, between Buddhist and biologist: whether the object of study is purely a product of man's mind and heart which man can do without and even better without, or the object of study is independent of man's mind and heart.


Yrreg
 
That is the big and essential difference between studying Buddhism and studying biology, between Buddhist and biologist: whether the object of study is purely a product of man's mind and heart which man can do without and even better without, or the object of study is independent of man's mind and heart.

Big assumption. You see, as long as you are discussing words you will not reach that much. Its your choice, but if you really think you are understanding I have to say that you are not.

Both Buddhism and biology are entirely products of man's mind, and both can only study human's affairs. I could enter a discussion regarding what is and what is not independent of human's minds. But it wont be a productive chat.

So, I choose to let you know that you are wrong, and that if you really wanted to study the subject and not criticizing, then you would be able to understand. You are like someone who don't know anything about photography and yet believes he is a good critic.

But what really happens here is that you simply dont like photography. I do. Do you have an issue regarding it? ;)
 
Last edited:
Truths and facts and claims

Epepke:

Bad analogy. The claims of biologists are about living creatures. It is, indeed, impossible to study those claims without studying living creatures. If someone claims, for example, that there is a jewel in the head of a toad, one can examine that claim by finding a dead toad and opening it up. (I don't have the heart to kill a toad.) The claims of Buddhists are about Buddhists. It is not possible to study those claims without studying Buddhists.
Ryokan:

All good points. I have to agree with you.

ETA : In the sense that if you want to study the truths of Buddhism, you have to study Buddhists. You can, of course, study the subject of Buddhism without examening a single Buddhist.

Gentlemen, I invite everyone to consider seriously these three terms: truths, facts, claims.

1. Truths -- There are two kinds of truths, the ones that are facts and everything else that parades as truths but are not facts; examples of the first are this sentence, one plus one equals two, and sunrise in the morning; examples of the second: karma, rebirth, and Nirvana taught as truths in Buddhism.

2. Facts -- Facts are events that can be perceived by our senses and verified in the science laboratories; examples of facts, the existing self, existence itself, frogs, Ryokan, Yrreg, Epepke, US occupation of Iraq.

3. Claims -- These are assertions to facts and truths.

---------------------

In the sense that if you want to study the truths of Buddhism, you have to study Buddhists. You can, of course, study the subject of Buddhism without examening a single Buddhist. -- Ryokan​
​

When you study the subject of Buddhism, you are studying a man-made notion, product of his mind and heart; so you have to study the man and his followers, their minds and hearts, to find out from their minds and hearts what are the facts-truths in that man-made notion called Buddhism, after the author, Buddha.

So, it is obvious that you can't study Buddhism without studying Buddhists, starting with the first and originator of Buddhism himself, the Buddha, and absolutely indispensable, his followers who call themselves Buddhists, claiming to know his mind and heart about his man-made notion of a worldview, now called Buddhism, after his name.

What about studying Buddhists, what are you studying in studying Buddhists? What else but Buddhists qua Buddhists, namely, in terms of their embrace and practice of Buddhism, starting first of course with the examination of whether they are into Buddhism at all, that claim -- for there are all kinds of Buddhists in all kinds of Buddhism. And this is where you are into studying Buddhism, unavoidably for studying Buddhists.

Conclusion: You can't study Buddhism without studying Buddhists.

Scholion: But you can study the frog without studying the ranalogist i.e., the expert in frogs.


Yrreg
 
Buddhism is a purely man-made notion, the product of a man's heart and mind, and taken by other men into their hearts and minds and observed in their life conduct; you cannot therefore study that man-made notion of a Buddhism without examining the minds and hearts and life conducts of Buddhism's founder and practitioners of Buddhism, i.e., studying also Buddhists, starting with the original Buddhist, the Buddha himself, and then every John Doe and Jane Doe proclaiming themselves to be followers of Buddha.
Very true, no disagreement here. And in doing so you will find that 90% of buddhism in practice is religous in nature, whatever the intent of the founder may have been. I don't think the buddha would object to the trappings, except where they create barriers to enlightenment. But given that what knowledge we have of the buddha is rather distant that is only a guess.
That is the big and essential difference between studying Buddhism and studying biology, between Buddhist and biologist: whether the object of study is purely a product of man's mind and heart which man can do without and even better without, or the object of study is independent of man's mind and heart.


Yrreg

And that can actualy be studied , although most people don't like to have rigour in thier social science. Wether or not a human needs solace found in religion, spriituality and mysticism, would be another thread. There have been secular discussions on the origins and human need for the religous. But most people get very hung up on the words. Like prayer, I believe that prayer can be beneficial, not because of divine intervention but because of the internal process. But saying there is benefit to prayer usualy draws fire on the JREF forum.
 
Gentlemen, I invite everyone to consider seriously these three terms: truths, facts, claims.

1. Truths -- There are two kinds of truths, the ones that are facts and everything else that parades as truths but are not facts; examples of the first are this sentence, one plus one equals two, and sunrise in the morning; examples of the second: karma, rebirth, and Nirvana taught as truths in Buddhism.
There is some latitude of self referencing communication sets in mathematics. 1+1=2 only because we define it that way, so it is not a fact but a definition.
The law of gravity describes the observed behavior of objects, that does not mean that the law of gravity exists, it means there is a human description for the observations.
So there are things that we believe to be true through defintion or description.
2. Facts -- Facts are events that can be perceived by our senses and verified in the science laboratories; examples of facts, the existing self, existence itself, frogs, Ryokan, Yrreg, Epepke, US occupation of Iraq.
You are using some defintions there, there are things that can be observed, and there are conventions in the languaga used to describe the observations. Science is not a process of aquire facts but describing the behavior of observations.
 
There are words and there are words.

Yrreg:

That is the big and essential difference between studying Buddhism and studying biology, between Buddhist and biologist: whether the object of study is purely a product of man's mind and heart which man can do without and even better without, or the object of study is independent of man's mind and heart.
Bodhi Dharma Zen:

Big assumption. You see, as long as you are discussing words you will not reach that much. Its your choice, but if you really think you are understanding I have to say that you are not.

Both Buddhism and biology are entirely products of man's mind, and both can only study human's affairs. I could enter a discussion regarding what is and what is not independent of human's minds. But it wont be a productive chat.

So, I choose to let you know that you are wrong, and that if you really wanted to study the subject and not criticizing, then you would be able to understand. You are like someone who don't know anything about photography and yet believes he is a good critic.

But what really happens here is that you simply dont like photography. I do. Do you have an issue regarding it? ;)


But what really happens here is that you simply dont like photography. I do. Do you have an issue regarding it? ;) -- Bodhi Dharma Zen ​

I used to like photography but as a kid and also motorcycles also as a kid. Nowadays, I seem to be through with all such contrivances. You know photography? Okay, tell me in fifty (50) words or less the meaning of f22.

I was so absorbed with photography but on a string budget that to save on films I devised a way to first expose one half of a frame for one shot and then the other half for another shot of a different object. If you want to know how I did that, ask me and I will tell you how, but with the old simple celluloid film camera.

I don't have any issue against photography. Sometimes I don't know what you are driving at with your to me cryptic or 'koan-ic' one liners.

Speech is difficult enough as it is, but Zen monks have to make speech even more difficult just to give the impression that they are saying something so dazzling. See if they can make a better mouse trap with their subtle dazzle of a speech habit.

And people can think properly and make sense to each other even on the most complex and complicated questions in simple, clear, common speech, without bringing in all kinds of supposedly contradictory nuances -- what for? except to appear smart to people who are busy enough without wondering whether there is something really momentous in absurd 'koan-ic' utterances.

But they don't know what life and the universe is all about...

Yes, tell that to the patient peasant working on his fields to produce from the earth whatever is needed to feed mankind. Now, I am really curious what monks, specially Zen monks, do for a living, when they are not into meditation on what is the sound of one hand clapping.

I suggest they take up farming, that should bring them down to earth and really get them to impact on reality. If I were a cynic I would say that Buddhism was invented by the Buddha to dispense himself and his followers from making an honest living with real work using their hands and shoulders, and of course their brains on the brain's original and natural assets.

What do Buddhist monks and Zen monks do for a living? Begging, out of humility and for being too busy to work for a living, busy with their absorption over suffering and man's purpose or meaning in the universe, ah yes, ultimate reality.

-------------------
Both Buddhism and biology are entirely products of man's mind, and both can only study human's affairs. I could enter a discussion regarding what is and what is not independent of human's minds. But it wont be a productive chat.​

Both Buddhism and biology are entirely products of man's mind... Entirely?

"It seems that International Pedantry Month has rolled around again." -- Ryokan #180 above.


Anyway, hahahaha softly.


Yrreg
 
Definitions are not arbitrary unless...

There is some latitude of self referencing communication sets in mathematics. 1+1=2 only because we define it that way, so it is not a fact but a definition.
The law of gravity describes the observed behavior of objects, that does not mean that the law of gravity exists, it means there is a human description for the observations.
So there are things that we believe to be true through defintion or description.

You are using some defintions there, there are things that can be observed, and there are conventions in the languaga used to describe the observations. Science is not a process of aquire facts but describing the behavior of observations.

Definitions are not arbitrary unless you live inside the mind of a Buddhist in Nirvana, or with Alice in Wonderland.

See if you can get anywhere protesting that one plus one equals two is just a definition, in the bank and in the supermarket.

See if you can survive in the turnpikes with your protestation that the formulations of physical laws are only definitions to describe the physical world according to man's perception. They should take away your driver's licence and keep you in a safe house, for your own preservation and to save others from you.


Yrreg
 
I used to like photography but as a kid and also motorcycles also as a kid. Nowadays, I seem to be through with all such contrivances. You know photography? Okay, tell me in fifty (50) words or less the meaning of f22.

With Google around those kind of questions are even boring. Don't you think?

I don't have any issue against photography. Sometimes I don't know what you are driving at with your to me cryptic or 'koan-ic' one liners.

Nothing like that, you are seeing your own predjuices. Im talking about things that you like and things you dont like, and saying that Buddhism is like that. You dont like it, some of us do. And you are the only one who has a problem with that! Maybe its time to get over it? ;)

Speech is difficult enough as it is, but Zen monks have to make speech even more difficult just to give the impression that they are saying something so dazzling. See if they can make a better mouse trap with their subtle dazzle of a speech habit.

"just to give the impression", obviously, from your point of view. From mine, its a way to transcend words and see the meaning behind them. You have not read Wittgenstein, have you? He understood so well that the meaning of words is not as clear as you believe when you demand that Buddhists should be clear. Clear about what? Your personal preferences about what is ok and what is not?

except to appear smart to people who are busy enough without wondering whether there is something really momentous in absurd 'koan-ic' utterances.

I sense anger.

Yes, tell that to the patient peasant working on his fields to produce from the earth whatever is needed to feed mankind. Now, I am really curious what monks, specially Zen monks, do for a living, when they are not into meditation on what is the sound of one hand clapping.

Usually the work in Zen monasteries is hard. Whats your point?

I suggest they take up farming, that should bring them down to earth and really get them to impact on reality.

Oh they do. Besides, and this is much more important... Whos reality? I already covered this several posts ago. You didnt read, or maybe you could not understand. My bad for assuming you could read more than what is written.

... busy with their absorption over suffering and man's purpose or meaning in the universe, ah yes, ultimate reality.

So, the ultimate reality is yours and only yours?

Both Buddhism and biology are entirely products of man's mind... Entirely?

So who is the cryptic here? LOL
 
ETA : In the sense that if you want to study the truths of Buddhism, you have to study Buddhists. You can, of course, study the subject of Buddhism without examening a single Buddhist.

Quite true, but I think it's a different point.
 
budhism, IS NOT A RELIGION!!!!

OVER THE YEARS IT TOOK THE CHARACTERISTIC OF A RELIGION.
HOWEVER, IF YOU BECAME A MONK YOU WILL KNOW THAT.

IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH

* GOING TO A BETTER PLACE.
* LIVING A 'BETTER' LIFE.
* SOME SUPER BEINGS OR GODS.

BUDHISM IS ABOUT.. TO PUT IT SHORTLY

* SEEING/KNOWING/REALISING THE REALITY AS THEY ARE
* HAVING/ACHIEVING/LEARNING THE RIGHT UNDERSTANDING
* BEING MINDFUL OF THE EXISTANCE. PRESENCE/PRESENT(NOW)/PERPETUITY



snip

So, if I change a few words here and there, how is this fundamentaly different from Scientology?
 
Profuse apologies for the mistake.

The following text came from me and appears in the post from me reproduced in the quote box below, ANNEX, in the second to the last line.

There is an honest mistake in that excerpt, the attribution should be to Epepke, not Ryokan.

Wrong attribution:
"It seems that International Pedantry Month has rolled around again." -- Ryokan #180 above.

Correct attribution:
"It seems that International Pedantry Month has rolled around again." -- Epepke #180 above.


Sincere regrets to Ryokan and to Epepke.


Yrreg

ANNEX:

But what really happens here is that you simply dont like photography. I do. Do you have an issue regarding it? ;) -- Bodhi Dharma Zen ​

I used to like photography but as a kid and also motorcycles also as a kid. Nowadays, I seem to be through with all such contrivances. You know photography? Okay, tell me in fifty (50) words or less the meaning of f22.

I was so absorbed with photography but on a string budget that to save on films I devised a way to first expose one half of a frame for one shot and then the other half for another shot of a different object. If you want to know how I did that, ask me and I will tell you how, but with the old simple celluloid film camera.

I don't have any issue against photography. Sometimes I don't know what you are driving at with your to me cryptic or 'koan-ic' one liners.

Speech is difficult enough as it is, but Zen monks have to make speech even more difficult just to give the impression that they are saying something so dazzling. See if they can make a better mouse trap with their subtle dazzle of a speech habit.

And people can think properly and make sense to each other even on the most complex and complicated questions in simple, clear, common speech, without bringing in all kinds of supposedly contradictory nuances -- what for? except to appear smart to people who are busy enough without wondering whether there is something really momentous in absurd 'koan-ic' utterances.

But they don't know what life and the universe is all about...

Yes, tell that to the patient peasant working on his fields to produce from the earth whatever is needed to feed mankind. Now, I am really curious what monks, specially Zen monks, do for a living, when they are not into meditation on what is the sound of one hand clapping.

I suggest they take up farming, that should bring them down to earth and really get them to impact on reality. If I were a cynic I would say that Buddhism was invented by the Buddha to dispense himself and his followers from making an honest living with real work using their hands and shoulders, and of course their brains on the brain's original and natural assets.

What do Buddhist monks and Zen monks do for a living? Begging, out of humility and for being too busy to work for a living, busy with their absorption over suffering and man's purpose or meaning in the universe, ah yes, ultimate reality.

-------------------

Both Buddhism and biology are entirely products of man's mind, and both can only study human's affairs. I could enter a discussion regarding what is and what is not independent of human's minds. But it wont be a productive chat.​

Both Buddhism and biology are entirely products of man's mind... Entirely?

"It seems that International Pedantry Month has rolled around again." -- Ryokan #180 above.


Anyway, hahahaha softly.


Yrreg
 
should try though,meditation i mean.
Maybe you will learn to enjoy life much more then you knew. ^^
but if it seems like just sitting down doing nothing.. then it is ok. try yoga, or fishing, taichi is good also.
you have a great perspective on life. the thing about a 'god' seemed a little negative. but i lean towards agreeing with you.
you writings are your own thoughts, i appreciate them.

I've tried yoga. If anything can be called suffering, it's yoga. :p I'm not exactly the most flexible person in the world. I've also done taichi. Too much woo about mysterious "qi" enervating my health. As an exercise, I barely sweat. As for fishing, it's likely a remnant of my Buddhist upbringing for the thought of killing a live fish for sport just upsets me terribly.

I wouldn't say that I was seriously meditating. But there was one occasion when I experienced something that a more gullible person would have called OOBE. I reckoned I had a waking dream. Overall, I didn't find any tangible or intangible benefits associated with meditation. In fact, the struggle to keep out stray thoughts and focus only on my breathing stresses me. I like to think, even if I'm just imagining rubbish.
 
All good points. I have to agree with you.

ETA : In the sense that if you want to study the truths of Buddhism, you have to study Buddhists. You can, of course, study the subject of Buddhism without examening a single Buddhist.
Sorry, but I still disagree.

(And I'm surprised that someone who considers himself a "Buddhist" would say that the way to study the truths of Buddhism is to study Buddhists.)

My original observation on this subject stemmed from Yrreg's post:
There is something very peculiarly different between Buddhism which is a worldview and say biology which is a science, namely: you cannot study Buddhism without examining Buddhists, but you can study biology without examining biologists.
He made this comment in the context of explaining that he identifies himself as "Resident Buddhist Critic" in response to you calling yourself "Resident Buddhist." Part of his "skeptical criticism" is to examine you personally. How does Ryokan react? Is Ryokan equanimous? How about Bodhi Dharma Zen? How do the Buddhists on this forum conduct themselves, and what does that say about Buddhism? So that's one thing that "examining Buddhists" means. Examining Buddhists = Examining Ryokan.

What else does that mean, "examining Buddhists"? Epepke said it means "subjecting the claims of Buddhist that are attributed to Buddhism to skeptical study." What claims? Which ones? Whose? There are countless claims. You're going to get lost in the claims.

Examining Buddhists is a laborious and woefully inexact way of studying Buddhism. How does the Dalai Lama feel about this? What does Lama Surya Das say about that? What does Ryokan claim? How about Alan Wallace? How about S.N. Goenka? It can become an endless exercise in nitpicking and, yes, pedantry. You will never, never understand Buddhism by following this path of inquiry.

I'm not saying there's no value in studying Buddhists in the sense of delving deep into what they have to say. Especially after one has some authentic understanding of the basics. But focusing in on individual and possibly idiosyncratic points of view or behavior will be a distraction for a person who is seriously trying to grasp the fundamental concepts of Buddhism.

That is what we're trying to do, isn't it? Understand Buddhism, not just beat up on some straw-man version of it? If not, then this whole discussion is just a game of trying to find the most outrageous claims and poke holes in them. That might be fun, but it's not meaningful inquiry. To me it seems like a waste of time.

If that's what we're doing here, I don't think we should pretend that we're seriously trying to study Buddhism.
 
International Pedantry Month still around

Click on the boxed arrow above to see Bodhi's post, I will just react here to some lines from his message.

Dear Bodhi, first, let's have a good laugh, ala Fat Laughing Buddha, Hotei, I think as Ryokan informed me that's his name; and Merentha tells us the Fat Laughing Buddha is the next Maitreya to come, another Buddha reincarnate, and I read that he is the final one, to inaugurate the era of true Dharma and rule the world in peace and in prosperity -- shade of the rapture.

Hahahaha, hohohoho, hahahaha, hohohoho! And recall that Hotei, the Fat Laughing Buddha, he was a Zen monk himself. Now, if all you Zen guys get to be Fat Laughing Buddhas, mankind would have more mirth and fun.

-------------------

I seem to be in some deja vu here, reminiscent of Username and specially D David, who just got to put in their last word.

Allow me to invite you, good Bodhi, to be my teacher then, for this episode of the present thread. Let me seek instructions from you.

-------------------

Originally Posted by yrreg :
I used to like photography but as a kid and motorcycles also as a kid. Nowadays, I seem to be through with all such contrivances. You know photography? Okay, tell me in fifty (50) words or less the meaning of f22 in photography.

Bodhi:
With Google around those kind of questions are even boring. Don't you think?​
I just want to see you explaining f22 in fifty (50) or less words, so that I can use your draft as a model for KISS writing: Keep It Simple and Short. So, dear teacher, don't disappoint me, have a some compassion, or exercise a compassionate heart toward a student, a learner.



Originally Posted by yrreg :
Speech is difficult enough as it is, but Zen monks have to make speech even more difficult just to give the impression that they are saying something so dazzling. See if they can make a better mouse trap with their subtle dazzle of a speech habit.

Bodhi:
"just to give the impression", obviously, from your point of view. From mine, its a way to transcend words and see the meaning behind them. You have not read Wittgenstein, have you? He understood so well that the meaning of words is not as clear as you believe when you demand that Buddhists should be clear. Clear about what? Your personal preferences about what is ok and what is not?
​
Dear teacher Bodhi, please give me again in fifty (50) words or less, what Wittgenstein said about his having "understood so well that the meaning of words is not as clear as you believe..." Just tell me if Wittgenstein means that people can never be clear with their words as they think they are clear?

I am always very unhappy with people who bring in names of supposedly authorities, like Buddha and Wittgenstein, as though they themselves don't or they can't see at all the sense in anything, unless some authorities say it; and others are like them, who cannot see any sense unless some authorities are cited in support.

If Buddha says anything that makes sense to you and you are of average intelligence like Yrreg, then you can just tell it to me in your own words, and rest assured that I can accept it also because I can see the sense in it; so also with Wittgenstein. At most you can just give the credit to Buddha and to Wittgenstein for seeing the sense in something which you yourself can also see the sense thereof, once you do apply your at least average intelligence to the matter.

Anyway, tell me in your own words fifty (50) or less what Wittgenstein said in the present connection about the clearness or more correctly unclearness of words, from the standpoint of the speaker and from the standpoint of the listener. Is he trying to convince people that speaker and listener can never be clear about the words, their own, passing between them? That so? Why then does he even bother to talk to us? No, I am not being cryptic but really asking you, That so?

Please, for the love of Buddha or more appropriately, Hotei, the Fat Laughing Buddha, and also Wittgenstein, just because one Gautama and one Wittgenstein spoke, so we are supposed to be dumb and dumber and more dumb.

That is why I am prone to depression, aside from my genes, I see people moving around after having read Buddhist sutras and Zen-nic koans, behaving or appearing dumb and dumber and more dumb and expecting everyone to be and do likewise; otherwise they won't get to the ultimate reality of life and the universe in the case of Buddha's expectation, or Wittgenstein's expectation of clarity or its absence in words.



Originally Posted by yrreg :
I suggest they take up farming, that should bring them down to earth and really get them to impact on reality.

Bodhi:
Oh they do.
​
I will do some searching around on farming among Buddhist and Zen monks, and get back to you.



Yrreg

PS Please see next post.
 
Lifestyle of the rich and famous -- almost

I am back.

No, I can't find one Buddhist sangha (read that, monastery), not even of the Zen strain, doing farming for a living. At most they are landlords, others do the farming for them in their vast tracts.

But I came across good accounts of the wealth of Buddhist monasteries; they got so rich and influential that they could threaten kinds and emperors -- notwithstanding their profession of detachment from material things.

How do Buddhist monks get to be fabulous with material opulence?

Consider the following verities about how humans acquire wealth, which work also for Buddhist monks united in communities, and also any religious collectivity:

Rule 1: A group can gain wealth more and faster than an individual. Buddhist monks work as a community, thus they get rich faster and more, in the normal course of things.

Rule 2: Religious institutions always end up at the top of the money ziggurat; you don't believe that? then look around with eyes open, not shut like in meditation. Buddhist monks together constitute religious institutions.

Rule 3: People will pay for anything they have been convinced to be good for them. Buddhist monks teach people about earning merits for good karma in their next rebirth; merits can be earned by giving money to the sangha; of course so that the monks can teach more people more and better dharma, so that everyone will get to Nirvana after a series of good karmas and good rebirths.

Rule 4: Money will produce more money unless owners gamble it away; Buddhist monks don't gamble, but they invest their money in everything that is not conspicuously unsavory. Mortuaries are good investments, because everyone dies and everyone at the moment of dying wants to be in the hands of religious people having charge of their lot beyond the grave, like Buddhist monks.

Rule 5: Stick close to politicians and government people, you will make money with them and through them and make more money continuing with them. Buddhist monks inevitably find themselves on good terms with kings and emperors, because they have the hearts and minds of the masses, which they can turn toward loyalty to earthly rulers; so earthly rulers are motivated to load them with privileges amounting to material wealth.


Lesson to be learned here: If you want to get rich, and control man's hearts and minds, go into religion.



Yrreg
 
Compromised skepticism of Buddhist skeptics

The more I know of the Buddhists here the more I am convinced of the deep and wide chasm between Buddhist skeptics and non-Buddhist skeptics here.

I have read the posts of Buddhists here, and they exhibit a trend.

First they proclaim themselves to be skeptics, but at the same time also call themselves and proudly in one of them to be Buddhists. And I am sure I have read their logically calling themselves Buddhist skeptics.

No, they don't call themselves skeptical Buddhists, but Buddhist skeptics, meaning they are Buddhist first and skeptics second.

Is that possible? I don't think so, because when you are a skeptic you don't subsume your skepticism under any other kind of limiting qualification like Buddhist or Christian or Masonic.

You can call yourself resident skeptic or visiting skeptic or alien skeptic or Polish skeptic or Indian skeptic, these designations don't detract from your skepticism, they just inform people of your extra or intra domicile circumstance or your foreign or national or country of origin.

But when you call yourself a Buddhist skeptic, you already encapsulate your skepticism to within the capsule of Buddhism which is a worldview.

You tell me that your Buddhism does not include karma, rebirth, nirvana beyond the grave, just meditation, the Four Noble Truths, and the Eightfold Path, and nirvana only the kind within one's lifetime.

Still I can't see your kind of Buddhist skepticism to be anything else than compromised Buddhism. I feel that it's not the right kind of skepticism, well at least not the kind that is practiced by the founders and operators of the CSICOP and the JREF which runs this skeptical forum.

Why do I feel this way?

The reason is because the skepticism I see in the CSICOP and in the JREF is what I know to be scientific skepticism; but as you Buddhist folks here admit and even declare yourselves, Buddhism is not science and not scientific, how then can you in a way straitjacket a scientific advocacy into a non-scientific worldview?

Consider that even though you don't believe in karma, in rebirth, in some nirvana post death and beyond the grave; what you do believe and cultivate are not scientific, namely, meditation in order to attain some kind of science knows what knowledge or information or data about life and the universe.

What about the Four Noble Truths and the Eightfold Path, they are not scientific but moralistic principles, or components of a code of conduct; however I grant that although they are not science or scientific, yet they can be studied scientifically to discern, why and how and to what effects people choose to embrace them and practice them.

Now, I think I know what is really absent in your Buddhism however you delimit it only to meditation, the Four Noble Truths, the Eightfold Path, and nirvana in one's lifetime -- what's absent in them? There is no scientific evidence for them.

You see, skepticism for me is complete liberty of inquiry; but you guys for spousing Buddhism cannot be free completely, because you have imposed on your mental horizons the Buddhist cosmos with its alpha and omega against which and beyond which you are not allowed to tread.

Suppose let's say that you guys, Buddhists here, are bachelors but are now going into marriage; your brides-to-be ask you whether you can be on your own with all kinds of freedom to think and decide and act; you say, yes.

Then after the wedding when one of you guys with your bride board the plane to fly to your honeymoon destinations, there is your mother also coming into the plane. you explain to your bride that your mother just happens to be going on the same trip.

But then she also checks into the same hotel in your first stop; you explain to your bride that she just happens to choose the same hotel. Yet for the rest of your honeymoon you and your bride always have your mother hanging around, still you keep explaining to your bride that your mother just happens to be hanging around you, and that you are definitely and completely freed of your mother, to think and to decide and to act for yourself.

And that's what the Buddhists are doing all the time here, explaining and defending and qualifying and making reservations, in order to keep to their attachment to Buddhism and at the same time claim to be skeptics.


Hahaha softly. [i[[Sob sob sob, says your bride inside her.][/i]


Yrreg
 
Less than 50 words:

Think what you like dear Yrreg. ;)

ETA: Life is already complex without torturing yourself with pointless questions. You don't like Buddhism, thats fine. Now move on and have a nice day!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom