Brain dead but still in treatment?

This is a really sad case and poorly managed from the first nurses missing the trouble the patient was in to the hospital's inability to help the family accept the loss. Taking the kid off life support too soon for the parents and just before Christmas was a medical decision that didn't include the parent's needs as part of the care.

But now what will happen is the patient is not going to live for years on a ventilator like people imagine. There will be medical complications, kidney failure probably first, and no hospital is likely to readmit the patient to treat the additional organ failure. Eventually the lungs will no longer function and the heart will stop. Probably a couple months at most.

I have seen no indication that the nurse's missed any sign of trouble. Doc's are in charge of the case not the nurses. I do agree that the Hospital and Docs went too fast in this tragedy as did the coroner. Who is ever pronounced dead while still on a ventilator? Nature will take it's course.
 
Last edited:
There is nothing there to kill. There is a rotting corpse being stored open to the elements in a hospital.
But the ventilator is keeping her breathing and not open to the elements. This is America not some poor 3rd world country where the sick are laying in dirt. G-d will take her when he/she is ready. G-d does not need our help.
 
I agree with this assessment. I also think it's personal to them and they feel the need to get her out of their hands even if she dies somewhere else. I think the best thing would be to let them take her somewhere else and when she dies there she will be among those who tried to save her instead of those who wrote her off.



This is a horrible situation and I feel so bad for her mom.


I don't think it was too much to ask given the circumstances
 
But the ventilator is keeping her breathing and not open to the elements. This is America not some poor 3rd world country where the sick are laying in dirt. G-d will take her when he/she is ready. G-d does not need our help.

God took her, it's the family that won't let her go.
 
Who is ever pronounced dead while still on a ventilator? Nature will take it's course.

Everyone who is on a ventilator when they die is pronounced dead while still on a ventilator. :rolleyes:
 
G-d will take her soon enough. He/She needs no help from friends or strangers.

Not much of a choice for me, really: Considering you carry it with you the rest of your life, would you prefer to have your last memory of your daughter be how she was upon her death or how she was once her body putrefied.

God is such a great guy. :rolleyes:
 
Not much of a choice for me, really: Considering you carry it with you the rest of your life, would you prefer to have your last memory of your daughter be how she was upon her death or how she was once her body putrefied.

God is such a great guy. :rolleyes:
Neither makes a difference in overwhelming, inconsolable, unending grief.
 
Neither makes a difference in overwhelming, inconsolable, unending grief.

If the family needs help with grief, they should seek a therapist.

And you know what that therapist would probably say? "You need to stop propping up your dead daughter and pretending she's alive."
 
G-d will take her soon enough. He/She needs no help from friends or strangers.

When you say that, are you speaking in a metaphorical or euphemistic manner or are you asserting that there is a Supreme Being who is letting this situation unfold in this manner (perhaps as part of some larger plan or to teach a valuable life lesson)?

in any case, God has already taken her. She is dead.
 
Ridiculous. My ex was on a ventilator, pronounced dead (brain dead due to an accident), and they kept her on the ventilator up until they removed her donated organs.
 
When you say that, are you speaking in a metaphorical or euphemistic manner or are you asserting that there is a Supreme Being who is letting this situation unfold in this manner (perhaps as part of some larger plan or to teach a valuable life lesson)?

And even granting all of that, perhaps it is the doctors who are carrying out his will, and the parents who work to counteract it.

Religion is funny like that.
 
Neither makes a difference in overwhelming, inconsolable, unending grief.

You saw that in a movie, right? Because you obviously don't know what you're talking about.
 
Ridiculous. My ex was on a ventilator, pronounced dead (brain dead due to an accident), and they kept her on the ventilator up until they removed her donated organs.
Of course, for the organs to be usable. There is a short 4-5 hour time span where the organs can be removed and reused in sick people. Your ex gets a gold star for thinking of others in her life time and giving the gift of life.
 
Last edited:
This is a great opportunity to show the power of prayer. God could heal her as a free sample. I'd be impressed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom