Brain dead but still in treatment?

But the ventilator is keeping her breathing and not open to the elements. This is America not some poor 3rd world country where the sick are laying in dirt. G-d will take her when he/she is ready. G-d does not need our help.

And letting her organs rot instead of saving lives with them is also gods plan. He hates the interference of organ transplants.
 
"I don't know what I'm talking about, but..."

Oddly, it would seem that a Fox news audience is much more likely to believe someone who starts their statement with 'I have no idea what I'm talking about' than they are someone who begins 'I have 12 years of medical training and experience'
 
She's dead, SG. Read Heidi Flori's report. She is not in a coma.

Rolfe.

Heidi Flori's report is one (potentially politically-laden) medical opinion. Keep that in mind. And, to respond to your :rolleyes:, Rolfe...

Brain death is a tricky area for a lot of people to get their head around, pardon the pun. Yes, we have determined that she is legally dead, in that her brain being the cradle of the person that she was will no longer recovery. It is a technical diagnosis. Therefore, we agree that brain death = death.

The body, however, (and here's where I disagree with Dr. Flori) is not a rotting corpse. For one example, many people's intestines "slough off" after hypoxic injury. I've seen this, and I've seen this recover in a few days when the lining grows back. Dr. Flori was probably merely justifying why they wouldn't do a tracheostomy and putting a feeding tube, which may have presented the dilemma of keeping her vital functions going for an indefinite amount of time. Reading her opinion, I can distinctly detect frustration. But, perhaps that's just my reading between the lines having read countless "chart battles" in medical records over the past 20 years.

The bigger point is, there is absolutely no long-term chance that she is going to get better and no point in continuing to intervene. As soon as you remove her from the intensive care protocols and machines that are supporting the body's vital functions, the heart will stop beating very quickly and the body will then be completely lifeless. We call this principle "futility" of care. It would be like subjecting a Stage IV widely disseminated cancer patient to a major operation when they are going to die anyway. There is no point.

That's the part that they parents aren't getting. Sadly, this often becomes an emotionally laden semantics argument... on both sides. I think Dr. Flori was a unnecessarily theatrical in her report. I know why she did it. But, I still didn't like it.

It is a physician's responsibility to dispassionately present the facts. This was a legal affidavit. Not a medical report.

~Dr. Imago
 
Last edited:
However, she made the disctinction between "brain death" (cessation of all cortical function, and what about the cerebellum?) and brain stem death. I thought that was the important thing.

If this girl isn't dead, neither are a lot of organ donors.

Rolfe.
 
However, she made the disctinction between "brain death" (cessation of all cortical function, and what about the cerebellum?) and brain stem death. I thought that was the important thing.

If this girl isn't dead, neither are a lot of organ donors.

Rolfe.

This is the tricky part.

The spinal cord contains the thoracolumbar portion of the sympathetic nervous system. If you artificially support respirations, provide hormonal regulation, and feed the body, you can maintain vital functions indefinitely.

Minus these interventions, the body's vital functions will cease very rapidly. In my book, that equals "already dead". But, we have blurred the lines with our ability to keep the body's vital functions going artificially with external machines.

That's why I originally said "years". And, the death is bad because we are meant to be up moving around and without plastic tubes going in and out of us. Interventions include turning, feeding, maintaining ventilation, administering medications to prevent clotting, and insuring that nothing gets infected. The latter is the "bad death" that usually awaits people who still have a part of their brainstem intact but will never wake-up... a far more gray area than Jahi.

~Dr. Imago
 
Thank goodness I don't have to deal with these grey areas! If my patients are headed in one direction only, they get a wee helping hand.

Rolfe.
 
Oddly, it would seem that a Fox news audience is much more likely to believe someone who starts their statement with 'I have no idea what I'm talking about' than they are someone who begins 'I have 12 years of medical training and experience'

Yeah, I agree. I have 9 years of formal medical training and am dually board-certified in anesthesia and critical care medicine. And, I'm often less certain about what's going on than a lot of these armchair pundits and talking heads on such programs.

~Dr. Imago
 
Yeah, I agree. I have 9 years of formal medical training and am dually board-certified in anesthesia and critical care medicine. And, I'm often less certain about what's going on than a lot of these armchair pundits and talking heads on such programs.

~Dr. Imago

Misplaced certainty is the best sort of authority.
 
I'm a nosey git and want to know how you say it!!:boxedin:

Usually, we start with an objective conversation. "Your BMI is X, and this puts you at additional risk(s) of Y."

To the other poster who says people know they're fat. Well, you'd be surprised. They may think they're a little overweight, but they have no real idea about what that means with regards to their long term health.

I try to have conversations with patients who show-up pre-op (for various interventions) in their 30's and early 40's. That is really the time to talk about long term risks. Past your 40's, it becomes very difficult to make long term changes that have a positive impact on your health... but, it can be done.

I also happen to know some outstanding weight-management physicians in the area who are excellent at addressing the entire multitude of reasons why the person got that way. One is a personal friend, and she tells me that a lot of the problem starts in early childhood with mis-patterned eating and "food-reward" cycles that can be very hard to break. Some of her patients are even referred for psychotherapy, which is part of their multidisciplinary approach.

Sadly, this approach is costly. And, the patient has to be highly motivated to change (much like quitting smoking, stopping ethanol abuse, etc.) or the results are fleeting, and usually they revert back to their former ways. Having a good external support system is critical. It's making a life change. And, that is insurmountable for many people.

Highly functioning, highly intelligent people (like most who populate this forum) find difficulty relating to these people who don't really understand what they're doing to their bodies. You might be surprised that some of those who are less-educated, less-well-informed, and have a quick-fix mentality really don't have a clue that they're that fat, and they're the ones who take offense when you mention it tactlessly. In their minds, I'm hungry = let's go to McDonalds... I didn't lose 25lbs this week... I'm going to McDonalds... exercise hurts, food tastes good... Etc.

That's why the pharmaceutical industry is desperate to find a medication that will curb appetite safely, effectively, and long term. Of course, this doesn't get to the underlying problem, does it?

~Dr. Imago
 
Before my knee replacement I made a concerted effort to start losing weight. I am definitely fat. I have managed to lose 10 percent of my previous weight and keep losing. I am 63 and it is work. All my physicians have pointed ir out- my orthopod even at one time pointing out that replacing the knee was akin to putting a Ferrari suspension under a mack truck....
It does have an effect.
 
Someone on another site pointed out that they most likely just want her out of the hospital. Referring to someone's newly dead child as a "dead body" is a low blow.
But completely accurate. The decomposing corpse is using medical resources that could be better used by actual living people.
I have a feeling once they get her out of there and somewhere where they feel they have more control and dignity, they will let her go on their terms.
She's "gone". All that's left is the corpse.

Oh wow, that's horrible. I think the family is being manipulated by the lawyer and the right-to-life crowd that want to make an example of this case like Terri Schiavo.
This seems highly likely
Since she's black they can say that Jahi's not getting the same attention and consideration as a white woman even though the circumstances appear to be completely different. Many of the race-orientated articles I read today emphasized that this was a routine tonsillectomy and made no mention of obesity or sleep apnea or multiple surgeries or inpatient treatment.
Given the state of US journalism they may not be aware of these facts.
The family talks about not letting the doctors play god but god didn't hook her to the ventilator, science did. When it was up to god all she got was a heart attack and brain death. It seems like using the ventilator is playing god.
Well said.

It seems to me that the hospital has created a Catch 22. They are glad to have her transferred to another facility, but they refuse to insert the feeding tube that is required for such a transfer to take place.
I believe the legal situation was that they weren't allowed to do so without coronial authority, as she was a corpse.
If I were the hospital director, I would say, insert the tube and get her out of here.
And leave yourself open to legal action? :rolleyes:

link. "Dr. Paul Byrne, a pediatrician who has questioned the definition of brain death, says in court documents that he visited Jahi's bedside and observed her responding to her grandmother's voice and touch with a squirming movement.
Was this recorded? Similar claims were made in cases of PVS that video recording showed were wishful thinking.
I have no special knowledge or training in these issues, and for all I know Dr. Byrne might be completely wrong. My reason for bringing this up is that it may be relevant to the question of why the family is taking the path that it is.
Didn't the EEG show a lack of brain activity?

Many doctors tend to mention it.

Rolfe.
I am a doctor. I tell people they're fat all the time. T-a-c-t-f-u-l-l-y.

It's not what you say; it's how you say it.

Many healthcare professionals, though, choose to avoid the issue. That is doing a disservice to both that person and society. Part of a doctor's job is to educate a person on their condition, and the potential consequences of it. Including obesity, it sometimes includes such delicate topics smoking, drug and alcohol abuse, removing oneself from an abusive relationship, etc. where the patient may not be at the point that they see it as a true problem.

Sometimes the road to getting better starts with one brave conversation. And, sadly, it is my experience that the cowards outweigh the courageous in my profession.

~Dr. Imago
About fifteen years ago my doctor told me "You need to loose at least two and a half stone", just like that. I did, actually 18kg. So it worked for me.

Fat people know they are fat. It is not a surprise to them and if they could lose weight, they would have done it a long time before some Doc "told em". Lap Band Surgery is the only answer. They have a right to be "fat".
And some obese people can be convinced to loose weight without surgical intervention.
I don't like calling this poor child who lost her life at 13, a corpse.
Why? It's a completely accurate description. Cadaver, dead body.......
We need to be respectful to the dead then that. The family will let this child go to her final resting place when they are ready to do so. They don't need either friends or strangers tell them what they should do.
In in the meantime others suffer because medical resources are wasted indulging the family and aerating a corpse.

But the ventilator is keeping her breathing and not open to the elements. This is America not some poor 3rd world country where the sick are laying in dirt. G-d will take her when he/she is ready. G-d does not need our help.
She's dead, in the remote chance a god exists she's already been "taken".

The family is squandering medical resources by keeping a corpse hooked up to a ventilator for over three weeks now. Should medical professionals be obliged to do *anything* to support the fantasies of deluded family members ?

It's very sad but the patient died three weeks ago.
This. Sorry if I appear callous but this business is just stupid.
 
It's still called a coma.:rolleyes:

Only by people who do not know what they are talking about. It is only a coma until an EEG records a complete absence of brain activity, at that point it is no longer a coma, it is death. Despite what you want to believe, no one who has met the criteria for "brain dead" has ever recovered.

ETA: You will notice that the experts in this case do not say she is in a coma, they say she is dead. That illustrates the difference quite well.
 
Last edited:
I'm going to shotgun some anecdotes:

As a wee child, I had a simple tonsillectomy and hemorrhaged on my way home from the hospital two days later. Presumably that would mean the medical staff felt my post-op recovery was within acceptable parameters. It happens.

I have also been Super Morbidly Obese, and functioned in a support capacity to others, and hypersensitivity about weight was certainly evident and widespread. Many, in fact most doctors are believed to be insensitive to SMO patients for the simple reason that in waiting rooms, there are no chairs SMO patients can sit in. Even Dr. Imago's "Your BMI is x" is a losing proposition.

SMO/MO people already know their condition, they know about healthy and unhealthy diets, they've tried them all. They hear about diets and their failures from friends and strangers alike.
 
I have seen no indication that the nurse's missed any sign of trouble. Doc's are in charge of the case not the nurses. I do agree that the Hospital and Docs went too fast in this tragedy as did the coroner. Who is ever pronounced dead while still on a ventilator? Nature will take it's course.

Happens all the time. My grandma was pronounced dead while still on vent. The reason for that is that when you are brain dead, you are D.E.A.D.. it does not matter if autonomic function still go on or are maintained artificially with mechanical device.
 
Last edited:
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom