I'm a nosey git and want to know how you say it!!
Usually, we start with an objective conversation. "Your BMI is X, and this puts you at additional risk(s) of Y."
To the other poster who says people know they're fat. Well, you'd be surprised. They may think they're a
little overweight, but they have no real idea about what that means with regards to their long term health.
I try to have conversations with patients who show-up pre-op (for various interventions) in their 30's and early 40's. That is really the time to talk about long term risks. Past your 40's, it becomes very difficult to make long term changes that have a positive impact on your health... but, it can be done.
I also happen to know some outstanding weight-management physicians in the area who are excellent at addressing the entire multitude of reasons why the person got that way. One is a personal friend, and she tells me that a lot of the problem starts in early childhood with mis-patterned eating and "food-reward" cycles that can be very hard to break. Some of her patients are even referred for psychotherapy, which is part of their multidisciplinary approach.
Sadly, this approach is costly. And, the patient has to be highly motivated to change (much like quitting smoking, stopping ethanol abuse, etc.) or the results are fleeting, and usually they revert back to their former ways. Having a good external support system is critical. It's making a life change. And, that is insurmountable for many people.
Highly functioning, highly intelligent people (like most who populate this forum) find difficulty relating to these people who don't really understand what they're doing to their bodies. You might be surprised that some of those who are less-educated, less-well-informed, and have a quick-fix mentality really don't have a clue that they're that fat, and they're the ones who take offense when you mention it tactlessly. In their minds, I'm hungry = let's go to McDonalds... I didn't lose 25lbs this week... I'm going to McDonalds... exercise hurts, food tastes good... Etc.
That's why the pharmaceutical industry is desperate to find a medication that will curb appetite safely, effectively, and long term. Of course, this doesn't get to the underlying problem, does it?
~Dr. Imago