Brain dead but still in treatment?

But the ventilator is keeping her breathing and not open to the elements.
The ventilator is inflating her lungs like balloons. Calling it "breathing" is a bit misleading at this point. Hook any recently-deceased person up to a ventilator and you will get the same effect.

And the ventilator has nothing to do with her being open to the elements. That's the result of her body not being stored appropriately.

This is America not some poor 3rd world country where the sick are laying in dirt. G-d will take her when he/she is ready. G-d does not need our help.
She isn't sick. She's dead. A ventilator making the lungs inflate doesn't change that. G-d has already taken her. All that's left is a corpse that is going to slowly decay--and, sadly, it looks like it's going to do so while the family watches.
 
I don't like calling this poor child who lost her life at 13, a corpse.

Why? She's dead, or at least the person and personality is. It's a corpse to me.

We need to be respectful to the dead then that.

There's no need to be "respectful to the dead". They are dead! They don't mind. If people wanted to act respectfully to them they should have taken time to do it while they were alive and could actually notice, rather than just pandering to their own sensibilities.
 
I have seen no indication that the nurse's missed any sign of trouble. Doc's are in charge of the case not the nurses. I do agree that the Hospital and Docs went too fast in this tragedy as did the coroner. Who is ever pronounced dead while still on a ventilator? Nature will take it's course.
You don't have a patient bleed enough post op from a tonsillectomy (or whatever tissue they removed) to fill a lung and compromise breathing unless you are negligent.

Sorry, I know that for a fact. Nursing 101, it's a high risk surgery for bleeding. The job of the nurse is to monitor the patient post op. Someone didn't. This was a completely preventable death.
 
If the family needs help with grief, they should seek a therapist....
Most medical providers would see the family's grief as part of the care they are responsible for. You aren't taking care of a machine, you are taking care of a person and the family is part of that care complex.
 
Ridiculous. My ex was on a ventilator, pronounced dead (brain dead due to an accident), and they kept her on the ventilator up until they removed her donated organs.
Sorry to hear that happened to your ex-wife. That must have been hard for people who cared about her to go through.
 
Most medical providers would see the family's grief as part of the care they are responsible for. You aren't taking care of a machine, you are taking care of a person and the family is part of that care complex.

The family is squandering medical resources by keeping a corpse hooked up to a ventilator for over three weeks now. Should medical professionals be obliged to do *anything* to support the fantasies of deluded family members ?

It's very sad but the patient died three weeks ago.
 
This may be callous of me to ask but what exactly is going on in her body? If her brain has no activity or blood flow what is signaling her heart to keep beating? It's morbid but I am a bit fascinated with this.
 
Declaration by Heidi Flori Opposing Petitioner's request.

There is rather specific information in the changes that have occurred to the body since death.

Not just brain dead, but d-e-a-d dead. Declared on December 12. I'll re-post this link by the attending physician:

Heidi Flori

That spells it out in no uncertain terms, that girl is deceased. Death is not an opinion, it's an objective fact that isn't determined or altered by anyone's opinion. The participation of the family in determining death is irrelevant and is as inappropriate as the doctor dictating funeral decisions.

I'm not harping on you bc, your post just gave me something to build on.

ETA: to correct spelling.

I don't know why the gut would slough? I've not seen that.

As for the brain liquifying, that finding in the Teri Schiavo (sp?) case likely took years. This girl will not last that long. It is true that non-viable brain tissue is going to be an issue. There would be some necrosis expected.

I've seen comatose people on ventilators too long in the ICU. It's not like a quadriplegic who lives on a ventilator but is awake. They don't live too long, lung infections do them in. But adding coma drastically changes the outcome.

For a comatose person on a vent, total organ failure soon sets in, typically kidney failure ensues followed by a lot of edema and then cardiac insufficiency. Numerous different infections might cause the death before organ failure but it's usually organ failure that starts the cascade.

This issue that was most important though was the problem that is gong to occur when organ failure sets in. I don't think they'll be able to treat it in a nursing home and acute care hospitals are not likely to allow readmission. But what happens when the nursing home calls 911 as the patient's blood pressure drops is anyone's guess.

The sloughing of the gut lining is mentioned in dr Flori's report.
Is there a difference between being comatose and being legally dead?
 
I have seen no indication that the nurse's missed any sign of trouble. Doc's are in charge of the case not the nurses. I do agree that the Hospital and Docs went too fast in this tragedy as did the coroner. Who is ever pronounced dead while still on a ventilator? Nature will take it's course.

What the hell--if nature had been left to take its course, she wouldn't be breathing anymore.

She's being kept artificially "alive" with machines. Sadly, she's long gone, for good.
 
Does the heart keep beating in the case of brain death such as this? If not, then how is blood being circulated throughout the body?
 
This may be callous of me to ask but what exactly is going on in her body? If her brain has no activity or blood flow what is signaling her heart to keep beating? It's morbid but I am a bit fascinated with this.

Heart beats do not depend on signals from the nervous system. They can be completely controlled by pace maker cells in the heart. Breathing on the other hand requires signals from the brain stem.
 
I have seen no indication that the nurse's missed any sign of trouble. Doc's are in charge of the case not the nurses. I do agree that the Hospital and Docs went too fast in this tragedy as did the coroner. Who is ever pronounced dead while still on a ventilator? Nature will take it's course.

Organ donars. But hey no chirstian would support that right?

Beating heart cadavers like her are not that uncommon. It is the level of denial from the family that is noteworthy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom