Brain dead but still in treatment?

Is that your best response? What age does that make you?

Rolfe.

Oh and for the record, I can only read the abstract but geni's link only showed healthcare worker's concerns about raising the issue. If there is a chart in there that shows how many actually do get huffy, it would be support. This study, from the abstract, appears to be about concerns and lack of knowledge on how to actually address the issue, which was the second part of my post. The second link addresses how to discuss the issue with a patient, further supporting my second point; if they are getting huffy, perhaps the healthcare worker needs to work on their bedside manner. The study did show only 9% address the topic with an actual solution.
 
I've been following the news reports and comments and I found a comment that I think is worth reading
"
1 in 12,000 post tonsillectomy patients die, usually from hemorrhage (as did Jahi).

She also had two ohter surgeries, a UPPP and sinus surgery, though the tonsillectomy was the most serious.

She hemorrhaged after surgery. Whether that was in part because (as reported) her family let her talk and laugh, and didn't encourage her to use the white board to write to them on; or that they gave her some food she shouldn't have had, or that the grandmother, an LPN, suctioned out her throat (the most likely thing, in my opinion, because it could well have dislodged the clot that is important to stay over the site of the tonsillectomy), we just don't know as of yet. May never know for sure, but there are many rumors like these floating around, and repeated enough that it makes me wonder if there is some truth in some or all of them.
(from an RN)"
http://edition.cnn.com/2014/01/06/health/jahi-mcmath-girl-brain-dead/#comment-1189093591
 
I am a doctor. I tell people they're fat all the time. T-a-c-t-f-u-l-l-y.

It's not what you say; it's how you say it.

Many healthcare professionals, though, choose to avoid the issue. That is doing a disservice to both that person and society. Part of a doctor's job is to educate a person on their condition, and the potential consequences of it. Including obesity, it sometimes includes such delicate topics smoking, drug and alcohol abuse, removing oneself from an abusive relationship, etc. where the patient may not be at the point that they see it as a true problem.

Sometimes the road to getting better starts with one brave conversation. And, sadly, it is my experience that the cowards outweigh the courageous in my profession.

~Dr. Imago
 
I am a doctor. I tell people they're fat all the time. T-a-c-t-f-u-l-l-y.

It's not what you say; it's how you say it.

Many healthcare professionals, though, choose to avoid the issue. That is doing a disservice to both that person and society. Part of a doctor's job is to educate a person on their condition, and the potential consequences of it. Including obesity, it sometimes includes such delicate topics smoking, drug and alcohol abuse, removing oneself from an abusive relationship, etc. where the patient may not be at the point that they see it as a true problem.

Sometimes the road to getting better starts with one brave conversation. And, sadly, it is my experience that the cowards outweigh the courageous in my profession.

~Dr. Imago


I'm a nosey git and want to know how you say it!!:boxedin:
 
Sometimes the road to getting better starts with one brave conversation. And, sadly, it is my experience that the cowards outweigh the courageous in my profession.

~Dr. Imago

I have a family member who chose their doctor because the doctor was also overweight and never mentioned weight during visits. Now, in their late sixties, this person is finally on a very healthy diet and is exercising daily. I'm so happy about the recent weight loss that I'm overlooking the fact that weight was ignored for decades.
 
Fat people know they are fat. It is not a surprise to them and if they could lose weight, they would have done it a long time before some Doc "told em". Lap Band Surgery is the only answer. They have a right to be "fat".
I don't like calling this poor child who lost her life at 13, a corpse. We need to be respectful to the dead then that. The family will let this child go to her final resting place when they are ready to do so. They don't need either friends or strangers tell them what they should do.
 
Last edited:
This is a really sad case and poorly managed from the first nurses missing the trouble the patient was in to the hospital's inability to help the family accept the loss. Taking the kid off life support too soon for the parents and just before Christmas was a medical decision that didn't include the parent's needs as part of the care.

But now what will happen is the patient is not going to live for years on a ventilator like people imagine. There will be medical complications, kidney failure probably first, and no hospital is likely to readmit the patient to treat the additional organ failure. Eventually the lungs will no longer function and the heart will stop. Probably a couple months at most.
 
Fat people know they are fat. It is not a surprise to them and if they could lose weight, they would have done it a long time before some Doc "told em". Lap Band Surgery is the only answer. They have a right to be "fat".

I don't like calling this poor child who lost her life at 13, a corpse. We need to be respectful to the dead then that. The family will let this child go to her final resting place when they are ready to do so. They don't need either friends or strangers tell them what they should do.


Totally agree with this post and the one right below it.
 
This is a really sad case and poorly managed from the first nurses missing the trouble the patient was in to the hospital's inability to help the family accept the loss. Taking the kid off life support too soon for the parents and just before Christmas was a medical decision that didn't include the parent's needs as part of the care.

But now what will happen is the patient is not going to live for years on a ventilator like people imagine. There will be medical complications, kidney failure probably first, and no hospital is likely to readmit the patient to treat the additional organ failure. Eventually the lungs will no longer function and the heart will stop. Probably a couple months at most.


Years. It's eventually a really, really bad death.

~Dr. Imago


:rolleyes:

Rolfe.
 
I don't like calling this poor child who lost her life at 13, a corpse. We need to be respectful to the dead then that. The family will let this child go to her final resting place when they are ready to do so. They don't need either friends or strangers tell them what they should do.

The problem is that it's not generally considered respectful to artificially make a body appear alive by pumping air and fluids into it either. So referring to the body as a corpse seems relatively mild compared to what else is going on.

In general, yes, families should be allowed to bury/cremate bodies when and how they choose, but I dunno... does society have a right to step in if someone decides to keep grandma's embalmed body in a chair in the livingroom for a few weeks, as long as it's well-preserved, just in case a miracle brings her back to life? Because that's essentially what this is.
 
The problem is that it's not generally considered respectful to artificially make a body appear alive by pumping air and fluids into it either. So referring to the body as a corpse seems relatively mild compared to what else is going on.

In general, yes, families should be allowed to bury/cremate bodies when and how they choose, but I dunno... does society have a right to step in if someone decides to keep grandma's embalmed body in a chair in the livingroom for a few weeks, as long as it's well-preserved, just in case a miracle brings her back to life? Because that's essentially what this is.


Happens at wakes and viewings all the time;)
 
Jahi's body is not embalmed or preserved in any way, from what I've read. I can't even imagine what it must be like to witness her body decomposing, as this family has chosen to do. What a horror. I am not a religious person but if I were, I would be praying for her heart to stop to satisfy the family's stubborn insistence that they will not consider her truly dead until that happens.
 
This is a really sad case and poorly managed from the first nurses missing the trouble the patient was in to the hospital's inability to help the family accept the loss. Taking the kid off life support too soon for the parents and just before Christmas was a medical decision that didn't include the parent's needs as part of the care.

But now what will happen is the patient is not going to live for years on a ventilator like people imagine. There will be medical complications, kidney failure probably first, and no hospital is likely to readmit the patient to treat the additional organ failure. Eventually the lungs will no longer function and the heart will stop. Probably a couple months at most.

Isn't the body sloughing the gut a symptom of death that would be prior to kidney failure?
And the liquefaction of the brain tissue deprived of blood circulation because of death?
Wouldn't that be prior to kidney failure as well?
 
This is a really sad case and poorly managed from the first nurses missing the trouble the patient was in to the hospital's inability to help the family accept the loss. Taking the kid off life support too soon for the parents and just before Christmas was a medical decision that didn't include the parent's needs as part of the care.

But now what will happen is the patient is not going to live for years on a ventilator like people imagine. There will be medical complications, kidney failure probably first, and no hospital is likely to readmit the patient to treat the additional organ failure. Eventually the lungs will no longer function and the heart will stop. Probably a couple months at most.


I agree with this assessment. I also think it's personal to them and they feel the need to get her out of their hands even if she dies somewhere else. I think the best thing would be to let them take her somewhere else and when she dies there she will be among those who tried to save her instead of those who wrote her off.

This is a horrible situation and I feel so bad for her mom.
 
Isn't the body sloughing the gut a symptom of death that would be prior to kidney failure?
And the liquefaction of the brain tissue deprived of blood circulation because of death?
Wouldn't that be prior to kidney failure as well?
I don't know why the gut would slough? I've not seen that.

As for the brain liquifying, that finding in the Teri Schiavo (sp?) case likely took years. This girl will not last that long. It is true that non-viable brain tissue is going to be an issue. There would be some necrosis expected.

I've seen comatose people on ventilators too long in the ICU. It's not like a quadriplegic who lives on a ventilator but is awake. They don't live too long, lung infections do them in. But adding coma drastically changes the outcome.

For a comatose person on a vent, total organ failure soon sets in, typically kidney failure ensues followed by a lot of edema and then cardiac insufficiency. Numerous different infections might cause the death before organ failure but it's usually organ failure that starts the cascade.

This issue that was most important though was the problem that is gong to occur when organ failure sets in. I don't think they'll be able to treat it in a nursing home and acute care hospitals are not likely to allow readmission. But what happens when the nursing home calls 911 as the patient's blood pressure drops is anyone's guess.
 
I don't know why the gut would slough? I've not seen that.

As for the brain liquifying, that finding in the Teri Schiavo (sp?) case likely took years. This girl will not last that long. It is true that non-viable brain tissue is going to be an issue. There would be some necrosis expected.

I've seen comatose people on ventilators too long in the ICU. It's not like a quadriplegic who lives on a ventilator but is awake. They don't live too long, lung infections do them in. But adding coma drastically changes the outcome.

For a comatose person on a vent, total organ failure soon sets in, typically kidney failure ensues followed by a lot of edema and then cardiac insufficiency. Numerous different infections might cause the death before organ failure but it's usually organ failure that starts the cascade.

This issue that was most important though was the problem that is gong to occur when organ failure sets in. I don't think they'll be able to treat it in a nursing home and acute care hospitals are not likely to allow readmission. But what happens when the nursing home calls 911 as the patient's blood pressure drops is anyone's guess.

She is not comatose. She is dead. She has zero brain activity, not even from the brain stem which would allow her to control her temperature and adjust blood pressure, etc. Without those abilities the body is decomposing.

She is not on life support, there is no life to support. Her gut is sloughing because she is dead. Forcing air, oxygen and food into her will do nothing. She does not have the ability to process food anymore because she has no brain activity.
 
She is not comatose. She is dead. She has zero brain activity, not even from the brain stem which would allow her to control her temperature and adjust blood pressure, etc. Without those abilities the body is decomposing.

She is not on life support, there is no life to support. Her gut is sloughing because she is dead. Forcing air, oxygen and food into her will do nothing. She does not have the ability to process food anymore because she has no brain activity.

G-d will take her soon enough. He/She needs no help from friends or strangers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom