Brain dead but still in treatment?

Allow me to point out the relevant portions of my post to you:







I tried looking for the article this morning to see if I could locate it, but was unable to. I simply recall that I had heard something of the sort in reporting, but given the lack of corroborating evidence, I was unwilling to subscribe to it as anything more than a rumor, and I tried to make that clear in my post. You'll note I ascribed equal blame to the hospital for not making it clear to her family, IF IN FACT THAT WAS THE CASE, that she should not have solid foods.



As far as I'm concerned her family bears some blame in this case for their lack of care for their daughter prior to her requiring surgery, evidenced by her obese state and diagnosis of sleep apnea, which would have been easily managed if they had just kept her on a balanced diet and gotten her to lose some weight. It doesn't mean I have any less sympathy for them; losing a daughter, or any family member really, is heartbreaking and is not something I would wish on my worst enemy. But living in a state of denial is not healthy for her family; any psychologist would say the same. When no less than three separate neurologists tell you that your daughter has absolutely no blood flow to the brain and is utterly, unalterably brain dead, the right thing to do is to let her go, and grieve for her. Over time, the pain will soften, and life will go on. That may sound heartless, but it is something that has been demonstrated to me over the past ten years or so, after first losing my stepfather to lung cancer, and then my mother to brain cancer. I still miss them; but as time has passed, I focus on the good times over the bad and remember them with love. The grief is still there, but my life has gone on, and my grief has simply become a part of me, integrated into the whole of me, shaping who I am today, and I like to think I am stronger for it.


Sorry, while I want to express my sympathy at your losing your parents ...I do not think it compares to losing a child.
 
Maybe this is another application for 3D printing!







Exactly. We can have buildings filled with corpses all over the country. And the death rate will be so much lower!


Do you really believe there is a large amount of people wanting or needing to do this? Because Jahi's heart is still beating ...it's going to open some sort of flood gate and the masses will be demanding the same?

I do not. Moms condition and the circumstances of this case is what makes it newsworthy. It's rare.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, while I want to express my sympathy at your losing your parents ...I do not think it compares to losing a child.

Says who? You? Who died and made you the official arbiter of how devastating a particular loss is? You have absolutely no notion of how close I was to my mother, or my stepfather, or how I grieve the fact that I never got to say goodbye to either of them, as they both passed away while I was at least two hours drive away (more like two days drive in the case of my stepfather, as that is when I was on active duty and stationed in Fort Bliss in El Paso, TX) from my parents house. They both died relatively young; my mother was only 59. There are years and years of time that I can never get back with either of them. My two youngest nephews and my niece will never know their Nana; even my oldest nephew doesn't have many memories of her. Virtually none of them will know my stepfather, as he passed away when my oldest nephew was only a toddler and his brother was an infant; neither my youngest nephew or my niece were even born yet. Exactly what is it that makes my loss less devastating than Jahi McMath's mother?

Let me tell you something; you know NOTHING about my pain. There's a lot more that I could say here, but I'd likely be violating the MA if I did, so I'll kindly invite you to simply not engage me ever again, okay?
 
Do you really believe there is a large amount of people wanting or needing to do this? Because Jahi's heart is still beating is kept going by a machine....

FTFY

. . . it's going to open some sort of flood gate and the masses will be demanding the same?

Religious nutters probably will but if you read the post I was responding to it was merely one possible future that played into the joke.

I do not. Moms condition and the circumstances of this case is what makes it newsworthy. It's rare.

No, how sick this case is is what makes it news worthy. That people do goofy **** shouldn't come as any surprise to anyone above the age of 5.
 
What did I say that was not demonstrably true?

They will grieve. Their lives will never be the same. But, they need not spend the remainder of their lives sitting by a bed inflating and deflating their daughters dead body. They need to leave that room and start the grieving process, not continue to delay it.

^^^^^^^^^^^^^THIS^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
 
Says who? You? Who died and made you the official arbiter of how devastating a particular loss is? You have absolutely no notion of how close I was to my mother, or my stepfather, or how I grieve the fact that I never got to say goodbye to either of them, as they both passed away while I was at least two hours drive away (more like two days drive in the case of my stepfather, as that is when I was on active duty and stationed in Fort Bliss in El Paso, TX) from my parents house. They both died relatively young; my mother was only 59. There are years and years of time that I can never get back with either of them. My two youngest nephews and my niece will never know their Nana; even my oldest nephew doesn't have many memories of her. Virtually none of them will know my stepfather, as he passed away when my oldest nephew was only a toddler and his brother was an infant; neither my youngest nephew or my niece were even born yet. Exactly what is it that makes my loss less devastating than Jahi McMath's mother?



Let me tell you something; you know NOTHING about my pain. There's a lot more that I could say here, but I'd likely be violating the MA if I did, so I'll kindly invite you to simply not engage me ever again, okay?


Thank you for demonstrating my exact point so beautifully!
You are absolutely correct I have no flipping idea, no right to judge, compare and I have zero right to make such a statement. It's personal for you just as it's personal for her.

Do you see how you defended your position and believe it 100%? Who the hell are YOU or anyone else to make statements about THIS mother?
 
Last edited:
Thank you for demonstrating my exact point!
You are absolutely correct I have no flipping idea, no right to judge, compare and I have zero right to make such a statement.
Do you see how you defended your position and believe it 100%? Who the hell are YOU or anyone else to make statements about THIS mother?

Because it has been demonstrated that her adamant refusal to let her daughter go IS NOT HEALTHY FOR HER OR HER FAMILY. Until they accept that Jahi is not going to miraculously come back to life, their mental state is precarious at best.

I don't claim to be an expert, but I do have a degree in psychology, and there is chapter and verse in that field of study about people who live in states of denial. It never turns out well. I have said what I have said about this family's decision because of my concern for THEIR well-being. Jahi could care less that they've got her on machines; the girl has no brain functions at all, none, nada, zip. Their clinging to false hope is demonstrably unhealthy FOR THEM. Hence my stance that they need to let her go and begin to grieve for her loss rather than cling to false hope that will only make Jahi's inevitable deterioration that much more devastating. I am trying to SAVE THEM some pain; not cause it. Can you say that?
 
......
As far as I'm concerned her family bears some blame in this case for their lack of care for their daughter prior to her requiring surgery, evidenced by her obese state and diagnosis of sleep apnea, which would have been easily managed if they had just kept her on a balanced diet and gotten her to lose some weight.

For the medical professionals: Is the surgery this girl received, apparently quite a bit more extensive than a standard tonsillectomy, a common medical practice? Do the doctors share some blame for going to the scalpel before prescribing weight loss, CPAP, medication, etc.? I would do just about anything to avoid surgery, but some people seem to think an operation can solve any problem.
 
Because it has been demonstrated that her adamant refusal to let her daughter go IS NOT HEALTHY FOR HER OR HER FAMILY. Until they accept that Jahi is not going to miraculously come back to life, their mental state is precarious at best.



I don't claim to be an expert, but I do have a degree in psychology, and there is chapter and verse in that field of study about people who live in states of denial. It never turns out well. I have said what I have said about this family's decision because of my concern for THEIR well-being. Jahi could care less that they've got her on machines; the girl has no brain functions at all, none, nada, zip. Their clinging to false hope is demonstrably unhealthy FOR THEM. Hence my stance that they need to let her go and begin to grieve for her loss rather than cling to false hope that will only make Jahi's inevitable deterioration that much more devastating. I am trying to SAVE THEM some pain; not cause it. Can you say that?


I'm intelligent enough to know my opinion, in this case, has zero influence or impact.
I'm not trying to save anyone. I'm simply sharing my point of view. It's not personal for me. You may want to ask yourself why it's so personal for you...
 
I'm intelligent enough to know my opinion, in this case, has zero influence or impact.
I'm not trying to save anyone. I'm simply sharing my point of view. It's not personal for me. You may want to ask yourself why it's so personal for you...

And that, to quote a green Muppet, is why you fail.
 
And that, to quote a green Muppet, is why you fail.


Ha! I'm still waiting for you to dust off one of your psychology books and dazzle with some back up evidence that yanking the plug out of her daughter would be beneficial to treating the mother.
 
Last edited:
Even people that have faith in God, look both ways before crossing the street. Don't they?

You spelled it wrong. That's being disrespectful.

Right now the family is paying an A+ hospice facility to provide end of life care to her, at about $7,000 a month. That is what is right for this child now.

"End of life care". That is "what's right for this child now".

Do you hear yourself? She. Is. Dead.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom