Brain dead but still in treatment?

I have every sympathy for what the family are going through, but remaining in denial will only make the grief harder to cope with when they do eventually have to accept it.
There is no coping or worse. Only heartbreaking, inconsolable grief and it is forever.
 
There is no coping or worse. Only heartbreaking, inconsolable grief and it is forever.

I lost my husband quite suddenly, 3 years ago, at a pretty young age (38). It still hurts now, but not so acutely. And over the last 3 years I've been gradually getting my life back and can think of him with happiness now rather than tears. If things had been different and I kept him on life support for a long period, I would be in an infinitely worse state now. You have to let go once they have gone.
 
There is no coping or worse. Only heartbreaking, inconsolable grief and it is forever.

Then they just need to find the $7k per month in their budget and spend the rest of their lives at her bedside?

You really don't seem to grasp that children die every day. Parents grieve every day. People move on every day. No, life will never be the same, but it does not consist of only inconsolable grief forever.
 
But at least they can spread the grief around. Think of the lives she could have saved. Pitty they will die so her organs can rot in her corpse.
 
Neither do I. She will go with her G-d soon enough. Yank the plug? "yank the plug" means that artificial breathing will cease as she is no longer ventilated. Who has an interest in going to her bedside, dusting my hands off while stating "Well, that's it, we are yanking the plug". and pulls it out of the socket? Will this action mean that stranger's lives will be getting better or happier? RIP child.

If there is a gOd to go with, she has already done it. She is dead.
I don't think anyone is interested in dusting your hands off.

(What is this nonsense of leaving out the 'o' in god? Wouldn't it be more respectful to leave out the 'g' and 'd' as well? I would be interested in a sidetrack to hear your reasoning behind this quirk)
 
This video shows an interview with Jahi's grandmother (who apparently has some nursing training) wherein she describes how she suctioned Jahi after the surgery. There has been speculation that this may have contributed to the hemorrhaging by dislodging the clot over the wound. If so, this points to possible mistakes made by the family during the post-operative period.

Keep in mind that the hospital has not yet been able to tell their version of events.



http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=2ZhhTWhlW9c

Thanks for the link!



Neither do I. She will go with her G-d soon enough. Yank the plug? "yank the plug" means that artificial breathing will cease as she is no longer ventilated. Who has an interest in going to her bedside, dusting my hands off while stating "Well, that's it, we are yanking the plug". and pulls it out of the socket? Will this action mean that stranger's lives will be getting better or happier? RIP child.

What do you mean by "She will go with her G-d soon enough. "?
Are you saying that as long as the heart beats, that person is alive?
 
And where exactly did you read her family fed her solid food? As far as I'm concerned it's nothing but a malicious rumor.

Allow me to point out the relevant portions of my post to you:

She didn't come out dead. She hemorrhaged post-op (in other words, outside of the operating room). I had read some reporting that this may have been due to her family giving her solid foods, which should have been prohibited due to post-op procedures, but I'm not certain of that. Certainly the hospital bears some blame for not stopping them if that is in fact the case, but the fact remains, the girl was alive following her surgery; she later hemorrhaged and all blood flow ceased to her brain as a result. According to this article, she was awake and asking for a popsicle because her throat hurt (understandably so, considering they were operating on the region) once she woke up after the surgery. It wasn't until she was in her hospital bed in the ICU that she began to hemorrhage.

I tried looking for the article this morning to see if I could locate it, but was unable to. I simply recall that I had heard something of the sort in reporting, but given the lack of corroborating evidence, I was unwilling to subscribe to it as anything more than a rumor, and I tried to make that clear in my post. You'll note I ascribed equal blame to the hospital for not making it clear to her family, IF IN FACT THAT WAS THE CASE, that she should not have solid foods.

As far as I'm concerned her family bears some blame in this case for their lack of care for their daughter prior to her requiring surgery, evidenced by her obese state and diagnosis of sleep apnea, which would have been easily managed if they had just kept her on a balanced diet and gotten her to lose some weight. It doesn't mean I have any less sympathy for them; losing a daughter, or any family member really, is heartbreaking and is not something I would wish on my worst enemy. But living in a state of denial is not healthy for her family; any psychologist would say the same. When no less than three separate neurologists tell you that your daughter has absolutely no blood flow to the brain and is utterly, unalterably brain dead, the right thing to do is to let her go, and grieve for her. Over time, the pain will soften, and life will go on. That may sound heartless, but it is something that has been demonstrated to me over the past ten years or so, after first losing my stepfather to lung cancer, and then my mother to brain cancer. I still miss them; but as time has passed, I focus on the good times over the bad and remember them with love. The grief is still there, but my life has gone on, and my grief has simply become a part of me, integrated into the whole of me, shaping who I am today, and I like to think I am stronger for it.
 
Right now the family is paying an A+ hospice facility to provide end of life care to her, at about $7,000 a month. That is what is right for this child now. Course, it does interfere with all the willing hands fighting to "yank the plug".

Putrefying because her family cannot let go is not what is right for the child.
 
There is no coping or worse. Only heartbreaking, inconsolable grief and it is forever.

Not really sure where you're getting this idea; it's a fairly widely accepted truth that grief has four stages:

1. Anger
2. Denial
3. Bargaining
4. Acceptance

No one goes through all the stages in the same order, and two or more stages may happen at the same time (I'd venture the opinion that Jahi McMath's family is currently going through Denial and Bargaining), but everyone eventually reaches the Acceptance stage. Eventually, once they've let her go, Jahi's family will be able to remember the good times with their little girl and focus on those to the exclusion of the bad. The way you're characterizing it, her family would be heartless beasts if they aren't weeping and wailing every day for the rest of their lives, and that just isn't the case. You might want to learn a little bit about psychology; just saying.
 
Then they just need to find the $7k per month in their budget and spend the rest of their lives at her bedside?

You really don't seem to grasp that children die every day. Parents grieve every day. People move on every day. No, life will never be the same, but it does not consist of only inconsolable grief forever.

When your argument is founded on the drama-queen defense, it does. :D
 
When your argument is founded on the drama-queen defense, it does. :D

If they talk to those folks that do the plasticized bodies do you think they can find a way to replace the rotting bits with plastic while keeping the ventilator going so that we can drag this out for even more time?

We may never have to grieve if we can just bring the right technology to bear on this problem . . . why should we ever pull the plug!
 
If they talk to those folks that do the plasticized bodies do you think they can find a way to replace the rotting bits with plastic while keeping the ventilator going so that we can drag this out for even more time?

Maybe this is another application for 3D printing!

We may never have to grieve if we can just bring the right technology to bear on this problem . . . why should we ever pull the plug!

Exactly. We can have buildings filled with corpses all over the country. And the death rate will be so much lower!
 
Then they just need to find the $7k per month in their budget and spend the rest of their lives at her bedside?

You really don't seem to grasp that children die every day. Parents grieve every day. People move on every day. No, life will never be the same, but it does not consist of only inconsolable grief forever.
$60,000 plus has already been donated to the family for her care.
 
This case is no different from those parents who use their religious beliefs to refuse treatment for their children. The hospital gave this family ample opportunity, the courts gave them more, now they have gotten someone to give them even more, and the child gets to putrefy because these parents are having a problem dealing with the issue.



Tough. When a parent won't, at some point society has to step in and do what is right for the child.


According to you this child is dead, she doesn't need protection.

In the case of a parent refusing treatment to a child that will die without it... and likely be cured with. The child needs protection.

Apples and oranges. IMO

If the odds of survival with treatment are low, the parents should decide. It's a family decision.
 
Then they just need to find the $7k per month in their budget and spend the rest of their lives at her bedside?

You really don't seem to grasp that children die every day. Parents grieve every day. People move on every day. No, life will never be the same, but it does not consist of only inconsolable grief forever.

Folk say that till it is their kid.
 
$60,000 plus has already been donated to the family for her care.

So you contend that as long as they can get enough donations to cover the cost they are best served by allowing them to inflate and deflate the chest of their dead daughter for as long as they want?

This reminds me of some stupid mirror from the Harry Potter books.
 
I have every sympathy for what the family are going through, but remaining in denial will only make the grief harder to cope with when they do eventually have to accept it.


Harder how?

At least now the mom will know she did everything she possibly could. IMO mom will never believe she should have let her go sooner. That will not happen. She sees everyday she spends holding her daughters hand and talking to her as a gift, a blessing. Who are you or anyone else to take that away from her?
 
Folk say that till it is their kid.

What did I say that was not demonstrably true?

They will grieve. Their lives will never be the same. But, they need not spend the remainder of their lives sitting by a bed inflating and deflating their daughters dead body. They need to leave that room and start the grieving process, not continue to delay it.
 
I lost my husband quite suddenly, 3 years ago, at a pretty young age (38). It still hurts now, but not so acutely. And over the last 3 years I've been gradually getting my life back and can think of him with happiness now rather than tears. If things had been different and I kept him on life support for a long period, I would be in an infinitely worse state now. You have to let go once they have gone.


Grieving is a deeply personal & individual process.

The presumption that it must be your way of thinking or it's somehow unhealthy is incorrect.

This mother is in denial because she literally can not deal right now. She's mentally incapable. Let her walk her path and be thankful you didn't have someone telling you how to walk yours.
 
Allow me to point out the relevant portions of my post to you:







I tried looking for the article this morning to see if I could locate it, but was unable to. I simply recall that I had heard something of the sort in reporting, but given the lack of corroborating evidence, I was unwilling to subscribe to it as anything more than a rumor, and I tried to make that clear in my post. You'll note I ascribed equal blame to the hospital for not making it clear to her family, IF IN FACT THAT WAS THE CASE, that she should not have solid foods.



As far as I'm concerned her family bears some blame in this case for their lack of care for their daughter prior to her requiring surgery, evidenced by her obese state and diagnosis of sleep apnea, which would have been easily managed if they had just kept her on a balanced diet and gotten her to lose some weight. It doesn't mean I have any less sympathy for them; losing a daughter, or any family member really, is heartbreaking and is not something I would wish on my worst enemy. But living in a state of denial is not healthy for her family; any psychologist would say the same. When no less than three separate neurologists tell you that your daughter has absolutely no blood flow to the brain and is utterly, unalterably brain dead, the right thing to do is to let her go, and grieve for her. Over time, the pain will soften, and life will go on. That may sound heartless, but it is something that has been demonstrated to me over the past ten years or so, after first losing my stepfather to lung cancer, and then my mother to brain cancer. I still miss them; but as time has passed, I focus on the good times over the bad and remember them with love. The grief is still there, but my life has gone on, and my grief has simply become a part of me, integrated into the whole of me, shaping who I am today, and I like to think I am stronger for it.


Seems to me a doctor should have encouraged, aided or otherwise referred this child for weight loss before cutting her open then.

If she died as a result if being over weight...was every doctor she saw more interested in a quick fix and making money than this child's real issue?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom