Brain dead but still in treatment?

I find it hard to believe that there are many locations were a hospital bed, staff and equipment would be UNDER utilised. Are you saying that there is nobody else - AT ALL - that needs this girl's place for treatment? And nobody who may have needed her organs? Seriously?

Just speaking from personal experience: I have never been in any hospital, for any reason, that did not have at least one empty bed somewhere.

Whether there's an empty bed where it is needed, or whether there's an entire empty room if someone needs isolation or such may be another matter. But an empty bed has never appeared to be a problem to me.
 
Just speaking from personal experience: I have never been in any hospital, for any reason, that did not have at least one empty bed somewhere.

Whether there's an empty bed where it is needed, or whether there's an entire empty room if someone needs isolation or such may be another matter. But an empty bed has never appeared to be a problem to me.
Enough that the units were cut for being unnecessary?
 
Enough that the units were cut for being unnecessary?

I have no idea. But, again, from person experience: I can only recall seeing ONE hospital get smaller in my whole life. So that probably does mean: there are enough beds filled to keep the place profitable, and there are enough empty beds to accommodate new...guests....
 
Just speaking from personal experience: I have never been in any hospital, for any reason, that did not have at least one empty bed somewhere.

Whether there's an empty bed where it is needed, or whether there's an entire empty room if someone needs isolation or such may be another matter. But an empty bed has never appeared to be a problem to me.

Hospitals don't treat dead people. They treat the living.
 
Hospitals don't treat dead people. They treat the living.

Agreed. The family of this girl is very much alive, and that is who is being "treated". Whether or not the treatment is what we generally agree to be best, they are the patients now.
 
She didn't come out dead. She hemorrhaged post-op (in other words, outside of the operating room). I had read some reporting that this may have been due to her family giving her solid foods, which should have been prohibited due to post-op procedures, but I'm not certain of that. Certainly the hospital bears some blame for not stopping them if that is in fact the case, but the fact remains, the girl was alive following her surgery; she later hemorrhaged and all blood flow ceased to her brain as a result. According to this article, she was awake and asking for a popsicle because her throat hurt (understandably so, considering they were operating on the region) once she woke up after the surgery. It wasn't until she was in her hospital bed in the ICU that she began to hemorrhage.


And where exactly did you read her family fed her solid food? As far as I'm concerned it's nothing but a malicious rumor.
 
Agreed. The family of this girl is very much alive, and that is who is being "treated". Whether or not the treatment is what we generally agree to be best, they are the patients now.

Then they should each have a bed on the psych ward and be paying for their care while the child gets a proper funeral.
 
You did not answer any of my questions, and I am interested in your response.

I find it hard to believe that there are many locations were a hospital bed, staff and equipment would be UNDER utilised. Are you saying that there is nobody else - AT ALL - that needs this girl's place for treatment? And nobody who may have needed her organs? Seriously?

As for the above nonsense, imagine this:
You are in a submarine with someone else. There's a problem, and you need to bail out and swim for the surface - several minutes away. Your companion is covering all the bets by ensuring that they have both the oxygen tanks - one of them is known to have only a little left in it, and the other is half full.
Are you happy to pray, and surrender yourself to the power greater than yourself and let the other person cover all theirt bets using prayer AND the available oxygen?


Even people that have faith in God, look both ways before crossing the street. Don't they?
 
There is something very wrong when we evolve to a point of worshipping the science and forgetting all about compassion and empathy for others. I see that as a lack of humanity.

I believe their daughter is never coming back, has been damaged beyond repair. I trust the science in this case. But I have nothing but compassion for her mother.

Why is everyone so hot to yank the plug? Is it about money? Is it about doing what's best for her mother? Is it out of respect for a brain dead child?

I don't get everyone else's stake in this at all,
 
So many strident opinions.

I wonder, how many here have heard the desultory click, as the inevitable decision is taken to switch it all off. And afterwards walk out and sign the affidavits identifying the corpse of a family member with the cops?

There comes a point where one must accept that all you have before you is some gently cooling meat. The person you once knew and loved is simply no longer present.
 
There is something very wrong when we evolve to a point of worshipping the science and forgetting all about compassion and empathy for others. I see that as a lack of humanity.

I believe their daughter is never coming back, has been damaged beyond repair. I trust the science in this case. But I have nothing but compassion for her mother.

Why is everyone so hot to yank the plug? Is it about money? Is it about doing what's best for her mother? Is it out of respect for a brain dead child?

I don't get everyone else's stake in this at all,

Neither do I. She will go with her G-d soon enough. Yank the plug? "yank the plug" means that artificial breathing will cease as she is no longer ventilated. Who has an interest in going to her bedside, dusting my hands off while stating "Well, that's it, we are yanking the plug". and pulls it out of the socket? Will this action mean that stranger's lives will be getting better or happier? RIP child.
 
Last edited:
There is something very wrong when we evolve to a point of worshipping the science and forgetting all about compassion and empathy for others. I see that as a lack of humanity.

I believe their daughter is never coming back, has been damaged beyond repair. I trust the science in this case. But I have nothing but compassion for her mother.

Why is everyone so hot to yank the plug? Is it about money? Is it about doing what's best for her mother? Is it out of respect for a brain dead child?

I don't get everyone else's stake in this at all,

This case is no different from those parents who use their religious beliefs to refuse treatment for their children. The hospital gave this family ample opportunity, the courts gave them more, now they have gotten someone to give them even more, and the child gets to putrefy because these parents are having a problem dealing with the issue.

Tough. When a parent won't, at some point society has to step in and do what is right for the child.
 
Neither do I. She will go with her G-d soon enough. "yank the plug" means that artificial breathing will cease as she is no longer ventilated. Stranger's lives won't be getting better or happier when that happens, but the families life way worse? RIP child.

Really? How so? :confused:
 
You did not answer any of my questions, and I am interested in your response.

I find it hard to believe that there are many locations were a hospital bed, staff and equipment would be UNDER utilised. Are you saying that there is nobody else - AT ALL - that needs this girl's place for treatment? And nobody who may have needed her organs? Seriously?

As for the above nonsense, imagine this:
You are in a submarine with someone else. There's a problem, and you need to bail out and swim for the surface - several minutes away. Your companion is covering all the bets by ensuring that they have both the oxygen tanks - one of them is known to have only a little left in it, and the other is half full.
Are you happy to pray, and surrender yourself to the power greater than yourself and let the other person cover all theirt bets using prayer AND the available oxygen?
Believe it! Sadly, some can't make their case without throwing personal jabs.
 
Last edited:
This case is no different from those parents who use their religious beliefs to refuse treatment for their children. The hospital gave this family ample opportunity, the courts gave them more, now they have gotten someone to give them even more, and the child gets to putrefy because these parents are having a problem dealing with the issue.

Tough. When a parent won't, at some point society has to step in and do what is right for the child.

Right now the family is paying an A+ hospice facility to provide end of life care to her, at about $7,000 a month. That is what is right for this child now. Course, it does interfere with all the willing hands fighting to "yank the plug".
 
Last edited:
I have every sympathy for what the family are going through, but remaining in denial will only make the grief harder to cope with when they do eventually have to accept it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom