Brain dead but still in treatment?

And that's the point. No harm can be done other than false hope and delaying the inevitable.

~Dr. Imago

I agree. If they had just pulled the plug (which is what the family should have asked for), it would have left the family more angry and distrustful. This at least allows lets them let their daughter go on their terms.
 
I agree. If they had just pulled the plug (which is what the family should have asked for), it would have left the family more angry and distrustful. This at least allows lets them let their daughter go on their terms.

But can we afford to throw a few hundred thousand dollars at every family that demands it, to let their loved ones go on their terms? Because I'm guessing that "we" are the ones paying for it, by either the insurance company or the hospital passing on the loss to others.

I just can't work up much sympathy for a nutty family that expects everyone to cater to their extremely expensive delusions.
 
I agree; however in this case it sounds like there just might have been mistakes made. A teen girl went in for surgery. She came out dead. I don't blame the parents for not wanting to trust any more medical opinions for a while.

She didn't come out dead. She hemorrhaged post-op (in other words, outside of the operating room). I had read some reporting that this may have been due to her family giving her solid foods, which should have been prohibited due to post-op procedures, but I'm not certain of that. Certainly the hospital bears some blame for not stopping them if that is in fact the case, but the fact remains, the girl was alive following her surgery; she later hemorrhaged and all blood flow ceased to her brain as a result. According to this article, she was awake and asking for a popsicle because her throat hurt (understandably so, considering they were operating on the region) once she woke up after the surgery. It wasn't until she was in her hospital bed in the ICU that she began to hemorrhage.
 
But can we afford to throw a few hundred thousand dollars at every family that demands it, to let their loved ones go on their terms? Because I'm guessing that "we" are the ones paying for it, by either the insurance company or the hospital passing on the loss to others.

I just can't work up much sympathy for a nutty family that expects everyone to cater to their extremely expensive delusions.

The staff is being paid whether a patient is there or not. The family to date have had $60,000 donated to them for her current care in a Dignity Hospice.
 
The staff is being paid whether a patient is there or not. The family to date have had $60,000 donated to them for her current care in a Dignity Hospice.
Paying the staff is not the only cost. There is a bed - possibly a room - in use (that someone else may need), all the equipment, electricity, etc needed to keep her in the current state ...

You advocated doing anything possible, and praised the use of faith in these situations. What if those things conflict? How can anyone say miracles can happen, and that a god will intervene, and yet not put their full faith in that exact proposal by removing the external interferences with god's will?

If they think god will save her, why not give her over completely, and switch off the human side of things that might be interfering with god's will? And, if it is god's will that she die, then why defy that and yet still proclaim yourself to be of faith?
 
Paying the staff is not the only cost. There is a bed - possibly a room - in use (that someone else may need), all the equipment, electricity, etc needed to keep her in the current state ...

You advocated doing anything possible, and praised the use of faith in these situations. What if those things conflict? How can anyone say miracles can happen, and that a god will intervene, and yet not put their full faith in that exact proposal by removing the external interferences with god's will?

If they think god will save her, why not give her over completely, and switch off the human side of things that might be interfering with god's will? And, if it is god's will that she die, then why defy that and yet still proclaim yourself to be of faith?


Like it or not, this woman believes her prayers have been every step of the way thus far.

I will never understand faith, religion or belief in miracles. just because I have none doesn't give me the right to trample on someone else's beliefs.
 
The staff is being paid whether a patient is there or not. The family to date have had $60,000 donated to them for her current care in a Dignity Hospice.

The tragedy of the commons. Since hospital staff are being paid anyway, we can just slip one more patient in there free. And then there's a chorus from others: if they get to slip their family member in, then why can't I slip my family member in free? Why not? Nurses are notoriously underworked, and hospital beds and machines do tend to sit idle. :rolleyes:
 
She didn't come out dead. She hemorrhaged post-op (in other words, outside of the operating room). I had read some reporting that this may have been due to her family giving her solid foods, which should have been prohibited due to post-op procedures, but I'm not certain of that. Certainly the hospital bears some blame for not stopping them if that is in fact the case, but the fact remains, the girl was alive following her surgery; she later hemorrhaged and all blood flow ceased to her brain as a result. According to this article, she was awake and asking for a popsicle because her throat hurt (understandably so, considering they were operating on the region) once she woke up after the surgery. It wasn't until she was in her hospital bed in the ICU that she began to hemorrhage.

Hadn't heard the feeding allegations, but wouldn't surprise me.

This is how it usually goes in kids: airway problems, respiratory arrest, cardiac arrest, then either successful or unsuccessful resuscitation. And, in a chubby kid with probably already a difficult airway... that is now bleeding... can't argue against the team taking care of her, having been in such situations myself. Let's just say they are high sphincter tone moments for the people involved.

Depending on how long the hypoxemia occurred, that results in the amount of damage. In this case catastrophic.

~Dr. Imago
 
Paying the staff is not the only cost. There is a bed - possibly a room - in use (that someone else may need), all the equipment, electricity, etc needed to keep her in the current state ...

You advocated doing anything possible, and praised the use of faith in these situations. What if those things conflict? How can anyone say miracles can happen, and that a god will intervene, and yet not put their full faith in that exact proposal by removing the external interferences with god's will?

If they think god will save her, why not give her over completely, and switch off the human side of things that might be interfering with god's will? And, if it is god's will that she die, then why defy that and yet still proclaim yourself to be of faith?

Feeding tubes, ventilators, and pacemakers are in the Bible... somewhere. Just trust me on this one.
 
Anything that might help the sad situation.
I doubt strangers to this child and family will be feeling better after this child goes to her G-d nor their lives getting better or happier, but for sure her family will be feeling worse with inconsolable, heartbreaking, never ending grief and sorrow. It makes a difference whose kid it is.
Pulling the plug means taking the patient off the ventilator, all and any mechanical devices.

Why do you keep saying g-d? I'm assuming you mean god. Do you think it's blasphemous or something?
 
She didn't come out dead. She hemorrhaged post-op (in other words, outside of the operating room). I had read some reporting that this may have been due to her family giving her solid foods, which should have been prohibited due to post-op procedures, but I'm not certain of that. Certainly the hospital bears some blame for not stopping them if that is in fact the case, but the fact remains, the girl was alive following her surgery; she later hemorrhaged and all blood flow ceased to her brain as a result. According to this article, she was awake and asking for a popsicle because her throat hurt (understandably so, considering they were operating on the region) once she woke up after the surgery. It wasn't until she was in her hospital bed in the ICU that she began to hemorrhage.

If true, then that just serves to illustrate why they're so intractable now. If they suspect (or worse, KNOW) they're own actions caused or contributed to her death, they are now fully committed to never making another such mistake.

They apparently overfed the girl her whole life. So I can understand they may have disregarded medical advice not to let her eat something -after all, they disregarded such advice from everyone else on a regular basis. So now...they are "stuck" tight to their false hopes.
 
Why do you keep saying g-d? I'm assuming you mean god. Do you think it's blasphemous or something?
Actually, it is G-d with a capital G. A form of respect for the all powerful being.
 
Last edited:
Paying the staff is not the only cost. There is a bed - possibly a room - in use (that someone else may need), all the equipment, electricity, etc needed to keep her in the current state ...

You advocated doing anything possible, and praised the use of faith in these situations. What if those things conflict? How can anyone say miracles can happen, and that a god will intervene, and yet not put their full faith in that exact proposal by removing the external interferences with god's will?

If they think god will save her, why not give her over completely, and switch off the human side of things that might be interfering with god's will? And, if it is god's will that she die, then why defy that and yet still proclaim yourself to be of faith?

The bed and room are already present and accounted for as is the equipment, etc. I am a firm believer in covering all the bets. This child will go to her G-d soon enough.
In America, the land of the free and home of the brave, we believe what we want including but not limited to a Power greater than ourselves. Lot's of comfort praying.
If the bed, equipment and staff were under utilized, there would be cuts in the unit.
 
Last edited:
This video shows an interview with Jahi's grandmother (who apparently has some nursing training) wherein she describes how she suctioned Jahi after the surgery. There has been speculation that this may have contributed to the hemorrhaging by dislodging the clot over the wound. If so, this points to possible mistakes made by the family during the post-operative period.

Keep in mind that the hospital has not yet been able to tell their version of events.



http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=2ZhhTWhlW9c
 
Last edited:
The bed and room are already present and accounted for as is the equipment, etc. I am a firm believer in covering all the bets. This child will go to her G-d soon enough.
In America, the land of the free and home of the brave, we believe what we want including but not limited to a Power greater than ourselves. Lot's of comfort praying.
If the bed, equipment and staff were under utilized, there would be cuts in the unit.
You did not answer any of my questions, and I am interested in your response.

I find it hard to believe that there are many locations were a hospital bed, staff and equipment would be UNDER utilised. Are you saying that there is nobody else - AT ALL - that needs this girl's place for treatment? And nobody who may have needed her organs? Seriously?

As for the above nonsense, imagine this:
You are in a submarine with someone else. There's a problem, and you need to bail out and swim for the surface - several minutes away. Your companion is covering all the bets by ensuring that they have both the oxygen tanks - one of them is known to have only a little left in it, and the other is half full.
Are you happy to pray, and surrender yourself to the power greater than yourself and let the other person cover all theirt bets using prayer AND the available oxygen?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom