Brain dead but still in treatment?

A life time of long standing pain and sorrow is time healing. There is only inconsolable grief, learning to live without the person, learning to live with the pain and missing them for the rest of our lives.

For some. Others of us work to find joy and beauty and rebuild our lives as a tribute to the person we lost. I can think of nothing worse than the notion that those I love would spend the rest of their lives wallowing in misery if I died. I know those I've lost felt the same and I've tried very hard to honor them and their love for me by having the best life I can manage.

It's hard and sometimes it takes work, but taking the things you learned from knowing someone and using them in your life, sharing their story with others, smiling when you think of them are all far better than sobbing because they're not there with you...at least IMO.

Personally, I hope her family can find that point in their lives, remember her and the good times, love her always, but accept that what's left isn't really her and let her go.
 
However...let me say right now, in print and on record: if it was one of my children, I reserve my right to harbor whatever delusions I need or want!

This is the rub.

It's an incredibly selfish act of the surviving family members to take such a stance. It's not just about the futility of the deceased laying there utilizing resources that may be better suited to a child that has a chance. No, it is for the family's own personal need to process what has befallen them, and nothing else. It is the "false hope" and naked narcissism that, despite the fact that the treating team has been in this situation numerous times before and know the ineluctability of the outcome, that somehow they might still be wrong, that God will intervene, etc. etc.

We understand this. We try to help family through this. Most will "get" it after a couple days. But, then there are the cases like this that fall into the realm of delusion. And, someone will ultimately have to pay for this extraneous and pointless medical care. It benefits no one, though, and potentially robs some other patient of a bed. It is utterly selfish, understandable in the short run, but that can quickly spill over into just a form of arrogance and narcissism that puts the survivor needs above all else. And, that sentiment is exactly what we're talking about in this case at this point.

~Dr. Imago
 
Most will "get" it after a couple days. But, then there are the cases like this that fall into the realm of delusion

I agree it is selfish. However, we humans are a selfish lot in general, and much moreso when it comes to giving up anything -or anyone- we love.

I also agree this family has taken it a few notches too far. However, I still find it very understandable. Reading through the thread (I don't think I followed any of the links) I got the impression there may have been multiple mistakes made that led to the girl's death. If so, that's part of why they're refusing to risk making another, irrevocable, fatal decision now.

We know she's dead. However, they're afraid that just maybe she isn't. They're being forced into the position of taking more advice from health care professionals -the same industry that admitted her, and discharged a corpse- and they've stopped believing anything they're being told by them.

I'm guessing that members of a second, altogether different profession (probably lawyers, maybe theologians, or both) are helping them enabling their delusion by creating and maintaining false hopes.

Edited for clarity of intent
 
Last edited:
Reading through the thread (I don't think I followed any of the links) I got the impression there may have been multiple mistakes made that led to the girl's death. If so, that's part of why they're refusing to risk making another, irrevocable, fatal decision now.

First off, there is no additional "fatal" decision. She's already dead. The only fatality may have been a patient who didn't get that ICU bed while this was been dragged out.

Secondly, part of the "multiple mistakes" made include over-feeding this child. And, that started years ago. In some circles, that even might be considered child abuse. But, again, no one is really talking in detail about that aspect of this case, are they?

~Dr. Imago
 
First off, there is no additional "fatal" decision.

Right. But the parents don't believe that, do they?

Secondly, part of the "multiple mistakes" made include over-feeding this child.

Yes. From their perspective, they already screwed up once. They're not willing to risk doing it again.

But, again, no one is really talking in detail about that aspect of this case, are they?

<shrug> I'm not shirking that aspect. I just think it was only ONE of a series of bad decisions, and now the parents are working overtime not to make what they're afraid will prove to be another one.
 
While I have a few minutes, here are a few cases of apparently 'dead' people that weren't....

http://www.foxnews.com/health/2011/05/11/husband-celebrates-miracle-brain-dead-wife-wakes-hospital/

http://metro.co.uk/2010/10/21/cance...-hospital-after-being-pronounced-dead-555577/

http://theness.com/neurologicablog/index.php/brain-dead/

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/health/h...teen-declared-brain-dead-by-four-doctors.html

There are plenty more. :(

In this age of the internet, instant news and constant bickering opinion leaves lots of room for doubt without the occasional genuine case of doctors having it wrong. Once those are tossed into the mix, grieving parents do not know who to trust or what the best course is. They're going to err on the side of hope, in the face of everything but full rigor mortis.
 
Wasn't there some reporting that the girl was not taken care of properly after the surgery? By which I mean, her family encouraged her to talk when she should have been kept utterly silent to allow her throat to heal, and gave her solid foods when she should have been on a liquid diet? And then too, the nurses and doctors did not halt this behavior (assuming they saw it)?
 
Why is this paramount?

Well, it's paramount to THEM because she is their daughter. It's important (I hope) to the rest of us because some day it will be someone WE love. I hope we all treat this family as we would want ourselves and our family members treated.

And, from the rest of your post, sounding more and more like you're one of the doubting Thomases....

~Dr. Imago

Not in this case, I'm not. However, I've been made aware of plenty of situations where I believe there is a lot more room for doubt than most of the medical professionals want to admit to. Seems to me far too many are willing to adamantly declare a black-n-white judgment, defend it in the face of all doubts, and then find themselves wearing eggs when a similar case somewhere proves it's not always so cut and dry.
 

Nothing in this story, at least how discussed, indicates this patient at any point met brain death criteria.

url]http://metro.co.uk/2010/10/21/cancer-patient-wakes-up-in-hospital-after-being-pronounced-dead-555577/[/url]

What was he final outcome on this one? Let me guess.


This is completely dissimilar to the Jahi case. And, if anything, shows a nice critique of how the process was not followed appropriately (again, unlike Jahi's case). I've never been involved in such a case so early on. Brain death is a clinical diagnosis, not a radiographic one. I wasn't there. But, I wouldn't have signed-off on this one, nonetheless.


Thank you for sharing sensationalistic anecdotes from the lay press. We know they always get it right, after all. This is what fuels the disdain and mistrust that I have to deal with on a routine basis.

None of this refutes the specific details in Jahi's case. She was at a tertiary referral center and got the best possible care after her injury. I stand by everything I've said thus far. There is no indication that anyone got the diagnosis wrong at any point in her care. And, such anecdotes as you've shared (with their potentially dubious agendas) serve no real purpose in examining this specific case. And that's the point.

~Dr. Imago
 
However, I've been made aware of plenty of situations where I believe there is a lot more room for doubt than most of the medical professionals want to admit to. Seems to me far too many are willing to adamantly declare a black-n-white judgment, defend it in the face of all doubts, and then find themselves wearing eggs when a similar case somewhere proves it's not always so cut and dry.

No blood flow to the brain for many days (weeks?). Zero electrical activity. It is pretty clear.
 
Thank you for sharing sensationalistic anecdotes from the lay press. We know they always get it right, after all. This is what fuels the disdain and mistrust that I have to deal with on a routine basis.

I'm the first to admit journalists are not doctors. I understand there is nearly always more to the story than what has made it into print, and I understand doctors are people -and people will always make mistakes.

You are correct: stories like these are the source of the mistrust; and very likely the reason this family is holding tight.

And, such anecdotes as you've shared (with their potentially dubious agendas) serve no real purpose in examining this specific case.

No. They do serve, however, to warn those of us who are not doctors to tread carefully when it comes to deciding whether or not to remove a loved one from life support.

I have no reason to believe either the diagnosis in this case was wrong, or that there's any hope. I am just defending my reasons for being able to understand and sympathize with the family and their adamant refusal to allow any more harm.
 
Nothing in this story, at least how discussed, indicates this patient at any point met brain death criteria.



What was he final outcome on this one? Let me guess.



This is completely dissimilar to the Jahi case. And, if anything, shows a nice critique of how the process was not followed appropriately (again, unlike Jahi's case). I've never been involved in such a case so early on. Brain death is a clinical diagnosis, not a radiographic one. I wasn't there. But, I wouldn't have signed-off on this one, nonetheless.



Thank you for sharing sensationalistic anecdotes from the lay press. We know they always get it right, after all. This is what fuels the disdain and mistrust that I have to deal with on a routine basis.

None of this refutes the specific details in Jahi's case. She was at a tertiary referral center and got the best possible care after her injury. I stand by everything I've said thus far. There is no indication that anyone got the diagnosis wrong at any point in her care. And, such anecdotes as you've shared (with their potentially dubious agendas) serve no real purpose in examining this specific case. And that's the point.

~Dr. Imago

Yup. . . so many people want to believe they are special and will make the claim they were brain dead or the doctors gave up on them but faith pulled them through. Seldom (read 'never') do the facts line up with the claims though. You see the same claims from members in AA with everyone wanting to out "bottom out" everyone else.
 
I'm the first to admit journalists are not doctors. I understand there is nearly always more to the story than what has made it into print, and I understand doctors are people -and people will always make mistakes.

You are correct: stories like these are the source of the mistrust; and very likely the reason this family is holding tight.

:confused: The parents got the report of their daughter's death from the newspapers?

No. They do serve, however, to warn those of us who are not doctors to tread carefully when it comes to deciding whether or not to remove a loved one from life support.

Show one where the proper protocol was followed, as it was in this case, and the patient recovered. Just one . . .

I have no reason to believe either the diagnosis in this case was wrong, or that there's any hope. I am just defending my reasons for being able to understand and sympathize with the family and their adamant refusal to allow any more harm.

Justifying woo is still woo.
 
DragonLady said:
have no reason to believe either the diagnosis in this case was wrong, or that there's any hope. I am just defending my reasons for being able to understand and sympathize with the family and their adamant refusal to allow any more harm.

And that's the point. No harm can be done other than false hope and delaying the inevitable.

~Dr. Imago
 
:confused: The parents got the report of their daughter's death from the newspapers?

Did I say that?

Show one where the proper protocol was followed, as it was in this case, and the patient recovered. Just one . . .

I agree; however in this case it sounds like there just might have been mistakes made. A teen girl went in for surgery. She came out dead. I don't blame the parents for not wanting to trust any more medical opinions for a while.

Justifying woo is still woo.

It is, yes. However, being unable to see both sides of the equation and have some sympathy for this family can paint skeptics as being cold, unfeeling people.

I'm only saying: I understand where they're coming from. And if I was in their shoes, I'm not sure I might not feel and behave the same way 'til I was truly certain recovery was no longer possible. Obviously, they're not there yet.

And that's the point. No harm can be done other than false hope and delaying the inevitable.

Exactly. Now how much harm is that, exactly? We can argue about the costs involved, but who among us wants to put money above a girl's life? We can argue about the bed space being needed for another patient, but is it? Has anyone been turned away? We can argue her organs are beyond being salvaged, but was the family going to donate them anyway?

I understand -and generally agree- with the need for triage and careful allocation of resources. I'm not disagreeing at all that continued "care" in this case is futile and I'm certainly not going to argue with anyone who says "I'm not wasting MY time or MY money here".

However, I'm not going to count those who do harbor hope as being complete fools either. Delusions, false hopes, and the wishes for a 12th hour miracle are simply hallmarks of loving parents -and in this case, likely fueled by more than a little guilt and self-reproach too.

All that said...the best case scenario would be for someone to make them understand the realities of the situation, but I'm guessing someone else (some third party) is preventing anyone qualified from having a real opportunity.
 
Last edited:
Well, I hear tell that if ABC10 goes down to their local police station, strips naked, dry humps the leg of the officer manning the desk, attaches the probes from a tazer to his genitals and begs for them to "Zap me good!" the child will awake from her sleep and be back to her old self, so it is immoral for you to not try it. :p


Wow, was that ridiculous post necessary?
 
This is the rub.



It's an incredibly selfish act of the surviving family members to take such a stance. It's not just about the futility of the deceased laying there utilizing resources that may be better suited to a child that has a chance. No, it is for the family's own personal need to process what has befallen them, and nothing else. It is the "false hope" and naked narcissism that, despite the fact that the treating team has been in this situation numerous times before and know the ineluctability of the outcome, that somehow they might still be wrong, that God will intervene, etc. etc.



We understand this. We try to help family through this. Most will "get" it after a couple days. But, then there are the cases like this that fall into the realm of delusion. And, someone will ultimately have to pay for this extraneous and pointless medical care. It benefits no one, though, and potentially robs some other patient of a bed. It is utterly selfish, understandable in the short run, but that can quickly spill over into just a form of arrogance and narcissism that puts the survivor needs above all else. And, that sentiment is exactly what we're talking about in this case at this point.



~Dr. Imago


Denial is a very real defense mechanism and it's not conscious or deliberate.
It's obvious to me that her mothers is indeed in deep denial.
While it may appear narcissistic and selfish to you, it appears to me to be a combination of limited education, culture of mistrust, a belief in miracles and OVERWHELMING grief she is unable to process right now.
She deserves nothing but compassion and sympathy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom