Brain dead but still in treatment?

Maybe, but how low can you talk down to someone? Apparently "she's dead" ain't sinking in.

I honestly don't know. :(

But I can kinda see both sides of it:

how can she be dead if her heart still beats?
how can she be dead if she can still seem to breathe with a machine?
how can she be dead if her foot is twitching?
how can she be dead if she's making noise when air comes out of her mouth?
how can she be dead???

Vs

she's dead. Despite the lifelike appearance and occasional (or even constant) movements and sounds that mimic digestion or attempts to speak.

It's.... I just feel for everyone involved. I really do.
 
I honestly don't know. :(

But I can kinda see both sides of it:

how can she be dead if her heart still beats?
how can she be dead if she can still seem to breathe with a machine?
how can she be dead if her foot is twitching?
how can she be dead if she's making noise when air comes out of her mouth?
how can she be dead???

Vs

she's dead. Despite the lifelike appearance and occasional (or even constant) movements and sounds that mimic digestion or attempts to speak.

It's.... I just feel for everyone involved. I really do.

Solid points. As a parent myself, I can't imagine their pain. But denial isn't healthy either.
 
Solid points. As a parent myself, I can't imagine their pain. But denial isn't healthy either.

Agreed.

However...let me say right now, in print and on record: if it was one of my children, I reserve my right to harbor whatever delusions I need or want!

And I (for one) am glad I don't need -and would not willingly- be the person who has to clear the cobwebs from these grieving parents!
 
Agreed.

However...let me say right now, in print and on record: if it was one of my children, I reserve my right to harbor whatever delusions I need or want!

And I (for one) am glad I don't need -and would not willingly- be the person who has to clear the cobwebs from these grieving parents!

And if it was your child dying because these delusions where preventing them from getting the organ they need?
 
I honestly don't know. :(

But I can kinda see both sides of it:

how can she be dead if her heart still beats?
how can she be dead if she can still seem to breathe with a machine?
how can she be dead if her foot is twitching?
how can she be dead if she's making noise when air comes out of her mouth?
how can she be dead???

Vs

she's dead. Despite the lifelike appearance and occasional (or even constant) movements and sounds that mimic digestion or attempts to speak.

It's.... I just feel for everyone involved. I really do.

Spinal reflexes are the hardest thing for lay people to understand. The movements are completely purposeless.

As for everything else, the intervention is what keeps the vital functions going. Absent all the support of the modern medical machines, you would not have a beating heart for very long to add to the confusion.

~Dr. Imago
 
No, it's so people like you don't try to sue me.

~Dr. Imago

Me? Sue? I don't even know your real name. Isn't it about establishing bono fides?
In any event, pulling the plus disconnects ventilator and artificial support ceases.
 
Last edited:
Me? Sue? I don't even know your real name. Isn't it about establishing bono fides?
In any event, pulling the plus plug disconnects ventilator and artificial support ceases.

Fixed it for you.

Thank you for clarifying that point, although I think we are all in agreement there.
 
but for sure her family will be feeling worse with inconsolable, heartbreaking, never ending grief and sorrow.


You keep saying this, but it is seldom what happens. People grieve, but life goes on. Time heals. Other things heal, too.

Blessed are they that mourn, for they shall be comforted.

Rolfe.
 
You keep saying this, but it is seldom what happens. People grieve, but life goes on. Time heals. Other things heal, too.

Blessed are they that mourn, for they shall be comforted.

Rolfe.
A life time of long standing pain and sorrow is time healing. There is only inconsolable grief, learning to live without the person, learning to live with the pain and missing them for the rest of our lives.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the depressing prognosis, but I'm doing better than that. The souls of the righteous are in the hand of God, and no torment will ever touch them.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the depressing prognosis, but I'm doing better than that. The souls of the righteous are in the hand of God, and no torment will ever touch them.

Rolfe.

Jahi's mother was quoted as saying, "If I felt my child was suffering, I would not keep her on that machine."

The reason Jahi is not suffering is because she is dead. Apparently the mother does not see the irony here.
 
Agreed.

However...let me say right now, in print and on record: if it was one of my children, I reserve my right to harbor whatever delusions I need or want!

And I (for one) am glad I don't need -and would not willingly- be the person who has to clear the cobwebs from these grieving parents!

I am not asking to be argumentative, but I do want to know.

If the doctors pulled your child out of the imaging machine and showed you the images indicating that blood was not flowing to any part of her brain right now and that blood had not flowed to any part of her brain in the past several days, would your hope still be strong enough to refuse to pull the plug?
 
Last edited:
A life time of long standing pain and sorrow is time healing. There is only inconsolable grief, learning to live without the person, learning to live with the pain and missing them for the rest of our lives.

That's what it means to be human and alive. Why do people think that life comes with the guarantee that they will not be exposed to bad things or the resulting feelings? Time to grow up or seek professional help.
 
I am not asking to be argumentative, but I do want to know.

If the doctors pulled your child out of the imaging machine and showed you the images indicating that blood was not flowing to any part of her brain right now and that blood had not flowed to any part of her brain in the past several days, would your hope still be strong enough to refuse to pull the plug?

I don't know. I hope like hell I never, ever, ever have any opportunity to find out.

I just know "Denial" isn't a river in Egypt, and when it comes to our children, our brains can take some strange turns to protect us from the truth.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom