Brain dead but still in treatment?

http://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/loca...-Academy-Friends-Believe-Alive-239629891.html

Quote:
Most kids are Christian here,” [the academy's chief operating officer Lisa] Blair said, “and they believe that if you continue praying, there’s always a possibility. The students understand the debate. They’re just choosing spirituality over science.”


A possibility? Jesus said "Ask and it shall be given to you,'' not "Ask and I'll consider improving the odds in your favor."

Steve S
 
The family seemed inordinately concerned with getting the feeding tube put in, having been fed (sorry, bad pun) false hopes that it might help her recover. That's a tragic irony given contributory factor of the child's weight issue. The last thing she needs is more food.

I've read a lot of reports on the case, and one of them mentioned an IV drip providing fluids, nutrients, hormones and antibiotics to Jahi's body. It baffles me that a anyone thought a feeding tube would offer any additional benefit. But obviously these parents are not interested in logic, reason, or medical facts.

I imagine the family will argue that the denial of the feeding tube for over three weeks contributed to her death (once they finally accept that she is dead). I'm willing to give the benefit of the doubt to the hospital but its not impossible that some malpractice or wrongdoing was involved. The hospital would now all the time constraints and all the delays in the bureaucratic process so that if there was even a slight chance of her recovery on 12 December that chance would be gone by the time the process wound its way through the legal system (I don't mean to sound like a conspiracy theorist).

This case reminds me of the criticisms of psychics and people who speak with the dead. These people were in a vulnerable state and it seems like somehow someone got to them and told them what they wanted to hear about their daughter and that the hospital was against them and they aren't letting it go. Under any other similar circumstances the family would be grieving and making funeral arrangements within a day or two of 12 December but instead they started a national discussion on whether or not to pull the plug on dead people.
 
If a doctor or licensed nurse told me my child was "comatose" I wouldn't be willing to pull the plug either.

Even after reading this whole thread, the word still means "slightly alive" to me.
 
If a doctor or licensed nurse told me my child was "comatose" I wouldn't be willing to pull the plug either.

Even after reading this whole thread, the word still means "slightly alive" to me.

I don't think anyone at the hospital told them that. It was external forces that told them that(with their own vested interests that don't necessarily coincide with the best interests of the daughter or her family). Those external forces probably also told them not to trust the hospital.
 
Last edited:
Do you think they've tried sacrificing a chicken?

Anything that might help the sad situation.
I doubt strangers to this child and family will be feeling better after this child goes to her G-d nor their lives getting better or happier, but for sure her family will be feeling worse with inconsolable, heartbreaking, never ending grief and sorrow. It makes a difference whose kid it is.
Pulling the plug means taking the patient off the ventilator, all and any mechanical devices.
 
Last edited:
If a doctor or licensed nurse told me my child was "comatose" I wouldn't be willing to pull the plug either.

Even after reading this whole thread, the word still means "slightly alive" to me.

Same here. I don't actually understand the definitions and differences between "coma", "comatose", "brain dead", and "persistent vegetative"

I had always thought that a person in a coma would be "comatose", and might make a full recovery. I had also assumed that a person who was in a persistent vegetative state was brain dead, but based on the discussion here that does not seem to be the case. I'm assuming that when a Dr. uses these words, they each have a very specific medical definition. When the laity use these words, there's quite a bit of slop.
 
Same here. I don't actually understand the definitions and differences between "coma", "comatose", "brain dead", and "persistent vegetative"

I had always thought that a person in a coma would be "comatose", and might make a full recovery. I had also assumed that a person who was in a persistent vegetative state was brain dead, but based on the discussion here that does not seem to be the case. I'm assuming that when a Dr. uses these words, they each have a very specific medical definition. When the laity use these words, there's quite a bit of slop.

I would also assume that the hospital staff gave the appropriate advice on how to go forward in this specific situation and there probably wasn't a racial, political, or financial ulterior motive to be misleading.
 
Anything that might help the sad situation.

Well, I hear tell that if ABC10 goes down to their local police station, strips naked, dry humps the leg of the officer manning the desk, attaches the probes from a tazer to his genitals and begs for them to "Zap me good!" the child will awake from her sleep and be back to her old self, so it is immoral for you to not try it. :p
 
It seems that someone has either, though ignorance, planted some terribly cruel false hope in the family's mind, or there are people who are enabling the mother's delusion that there is some hope.

It is a truly heartbreaking situation, but the unexpected death of any loved one is naturally going to be so. The double tragedy is this sick drama being played out over the decaying body of the deceased.
 
Same here. I don't actually understand the definitions and differences between "coma", "comatose", "brain dead", and "persistent vegetative"

<nods> The words have specific meanings to ME:

Coma or Comatose: unconscious, unresponsive, undreaming, unthinking...but very much alive, and a long ways from "beyond hope". Might recover fully, might slip into a persistent vegetative state, might die. But hasn't done any of those things just yet!

Brain Dead: Dead; no hope of recovery, but may still seem alive due to nerves and muscles that haven't fully stopped functioning yet. "Pulling the plug" may be gruesome and hard to watch, but the person is dead, and beyond feeling anything themselves. I'm very much in favor of organ donation, so have no problem with brain death being declared before removing machines or other supportive care.

Persistent Vegetative State: might be hell on Earth. :( Appears to be awake, and even responsive in subtle ways, but apparently cannot hear or speak. The fear here (for me) is there's more "alive" in there than we can tell, and the person may have some dim awareness of the greater world, but be unable to interact in a meaningful way. I don't think I could let a person go in that state, and I hope no one decides to pull the plug on ME in such a situation. I see this person as hanging onto the last lamp post between "alive" and "dead". I probably could argue it would be kinder and gentler to let this person go, but.... I'm not comfortable with human euthanasia for a variety of reasons, and medical advances are made all the time. Unless they require a respirator or daily heart massage, I count 'em among the citizens.

I had always thought that a person in a coma would be "comatose", and might make a full recovery. I had also assumed that a person who was in a persistent vegetative state was brain dead, but based on the discussion here that does not seem to be the case. I'm assuming that when a Dr. uses these words, they each have a very specific medical definition. When the laity use these words, there's quite a bit of slop.

Yes; and I'm unimpressed with using words to obfuscate or confuse, especially when we're talking about the life of a teenage girl.

Slightly OT:
On another forum a while back a hair dresser went into a rant about people complaining she cut too much off when they asked for "a trim". She spent three paragraphs telling us how that had a different meaning to the professionals like herself than it does to her customers. I can understand that: however, I fully believe it's her job to clarify what the people paying her mean, and then to do that.
/OT

In the case of doctors and hospitals, they need to make sure family members really understand what the full situation is. Using jargon to cover themselves in a cloak of superiority or to avoid a lawsuit or garner a larger insurance check isn't the right thing to do, no matter what the diagnosis or long-term prognosis is.
 
Same here. I don't actually understand the definitions and differences between "coma", "comatose", "brain dead", and "persistent vegetative"
....

Possibly helpful:
"Coma is distinguished from brain death by the fact that you can elicit responses from the brain, detect movements in response to pain, and it is not irreversible," says Stevens. "You can wake up from a coma."
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2014/01/140110-brain-dead-jahi-mcmath-marlise-munoz/

The term "life support" exacerbates the problem, too, because those who are brain dead do not have a life to sustain, said Arthur Caplan, director of the Division of Medical Ethics at NYU Langone Medical Center.
http://www.cnn.com/2013/12/28/health/life-support-ethics/
 
....
Slightly OT:
On another forum a while back a hair dresser went into a rant about people complaining she cut too much off when they asked for "a trim". She spent three paragraphs telling us how that had a different meaning to the professionals like herself than it does to her customers.
....

Just curious. What does a professional stylist think "a trim" means?
 
Just curious. What does a professional stylist think "a trim" means?

Apparently, it means to restore your original haircut -or whatever the stylist thinks your haircut was.

So for me (knee length hair) to say: I had a shoulder length bob, but have decided to grow it to my ankles. The ends are a bit ratty, and I would like a trim"

means:

cut it back to a shoulder length bob.

I can't find the thread now, or I'd send you a link.
 
Are you saying the hospital staff did this?

To give you a more full answer: back when the Schiavo case was in the news, I did a lot of research on PVS. Truth is: the condition scares the hell out of me.

In doing that, I came across a LOT of horror stories about hospitals, doctors, and other hospital staff refusing treatments, refusing even the simplest, routine care, even the most basic human needs to people they believed -sometimes quite wrongly- were beyond help. In fact, a bit of Googling in the last few minutes has turned up a trove more, and taken as a whole it can be a terrifying maze for those of us who do not have medical degrees and have to decide who to trust, who to disregard, when to stand up and say "I'm taking control here". Add in any questions or confusion about who is paying the bills, and the situation gets even thornier.

http://www.aitse.org/comfort-care-are-you-comfortable-with-it/

I fear the drug laws in the USA that prevent providing enough pain killers that will actually make the person make the person comfortable, right along side fearing those will administer so much of something that breathing becomes compromised.

I understand there reaches a point where so called "comfort care" is all that is possible, and where heroic measures or expensive treatments are futile. I recognize it's never an easy situation, and that we're all at the mercy of the best judgement of the people caring for us -not a pleasant place for any of us to be!

At the end of the day, I don't blame any family -especially when a child is involved- for wanting to cling to any hope whatever, and to build a distrust for hospital and staff. If someone -anyone- is applying the term "comatose" to a person who is brain dead, then I can't fault family members for refusing to let go. I understand the word has a specific, clinical definition, and it may be the person is using correctly; however it also has a much different meaning in common usage, and when confused I err on the side of hope.
 
In the case of doctors and hospitals, they need to make sure family members really understand what the full situation is. Using jargon to cover themselves in a cloak of superiority or to avoid a lawsuit or garner a larger insurance check isn't the right thing to do, no matter what the diagnosis or long-term prognosis is.

Maybe, but how low can you talk down to someone? Apparently "she's dead" ain't sinking in.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom