Brain dead but still in treatment?

Nope, they are removed from all external support first.

Swing and a miss, slugger:


You can be pronounced dead while connected to the machines. Not to sound too macabre, but this is the best scenario for organ procurement, and the numerous lives the surviving family saves by not protesting the organ donor process is the only good thing that comes out of such situations.

~Dr. Imago

Thank you for your info here Doctor. Threads like this definitely benefit from commentary from an actual expert in the field.
 
Swing and a miss, slugger:




Thank you for your info here Doctor. Threads like this definitely benefit from commentary from an actual expert in the field.

Huh??????????
 
Last edited:
ABC says death cannot be pronounced while the body is hooked up.
The good doctor says, yes it can be, and is.
The good doctor is the expert.
Whence the 'huh'?

The good Doc has a disclaimer on his "opinions" refining his "expert" status.
Can the dearly departed be declared dead while their chest is going up and down?
 
Last edited:
The good Doc has a disclaimer on his "opinions" refining his "expert" status.
Can the dearly departed be declared dead while their chest is going up and down?

Does that disclaimer therefore mean any other person's 'opinions' are equally valid?

Yes. That is why we stop making the chest go up and down.
 
Can the dearly departed be declared dead while their chest is going up and down?

YES!
CALIFORNIA CODES HEALTH AND SAFETY CODE SECTION 7180:

7180. (a) An individual who has sustained either (1) irreversible cessation of circulatory and respiratory functions, or (2) irreversible cessation of all functions of the entire brain, including the brain stem, is dead.

It is an "or" thing, not an "and" thing and whether the person is on a respirator, or not, doesn't matter.

She was declared dead based on #2. If she were not on the respirator she could be declared based on #1 as well.
 
The good Doc has a disclaimer on his "opinions" refining his "expert" status.

The disclaimer does not refine his professional status. It only clarifies what the advice in the posts should be used for, that is education and information purposes.
 
This is all very bewildering to me. I certainly accept that if all brain function has stopped, then the patient is irreversibly dead. What I'm confused by is the whole respirator thing. I presume that if you take a dead body from the morgue and hook them up to a respirator, they would begin to decompose at the same rate as a cadaver who (which?) was not hooked up to the respirator. Is this not so?

And if this is so, how long can we expect this woman's corpse to last without decomposition? She is not being fed, and I find it difficult to believe that she is metabolizing the fat stored in her body.

I am not a Dr., I'm just trying to figure out how long a dead body can be preserved through this means without any brain at all.
 
The good Doc has a disclaimer on his "opinions" refining his "expert" status.
Can the dearly departed be declared dead while their chest is going up and down?

The doctor is a professional and I believe his knowledge on the matter supercedes yours by more than a small stretch. If you want to quit being called out on nonsensical comments of which you have very little knowledge, simply quit making said statements.
 
And a follow up question;

How the hell would a feeding tube keep her fed? Doesn't her digestive system depend on some brain input? Wouldn't you just be forcing food through her digestive tract like pushing soup through a hose? Wouldn't it come out the other end undigested?

Sorry if that's an unpleasant image.
 
From what I've read on the story your gruesome image is accurate. Some of the body is apparently already breaking down. The sad part of this is Jahi could have "lived on" had the parents agreed to donate organs, but instead they've selfishly allowed the body to move past the point of usefulness.
 
The family seemed inordinately concerned with getting the feeding tube put in, having been fed (sorry, bad pun) false hopes that it might help her recover. That's a tragic irony given contributory factor of the child's weight issue. The last thing she needs is more food.

I've read a lot of reports on the case, and one of them mentioned an IV drip providing fluids, nutrients, hormones and antibiotics to Jahi's body. It baffles me that a anyone thought a feeding tube would offer any additional benefit. But obviously these parents are not interested in logic, reason, or medical facts.
 
I've read a lot of reports on the case, and one of them mentioned an IV drip providing fluids, nutrients, hormones and antibiotics to Jahi's body. It baffles me that a anyone thought a feeding tube would offer any additional benefit. But obviously these parents are not interested in logic, reason, or medical facts.

I read that as well.

Antibiotics. To a dead person.

:confused:
 
The doctor is a professional and I believe his knowledge on the matter supercedes yours by more than a small stretch. If you want to quit being called out on nonsensical comments of which you have very little knowledge, simply quit making said statements.

:jaw-dropp This is a discussion board and we are here to, well, discuss. Hopefully, without the need for personal jabs, although, I have no issue with posters opinions so "nonsensical comment", away. Discuss is why we are here and what we do.
We are big girls and boys.
 
Last edited:
This^

And the ludicrous crap continues.

In no post have I argued this girl is not doomed. I've posted the indisputable fact, people in her condition do not live on for years, it'll be weeks, a couple months at most if you start counting from the day she went downhill.

Coma has a specific meaning. It does not have the imaginary meaning being argued with, nor do I hold that imaginary meaning simply because I used the term coma, and lay people here aren't familiar with the term. As for using Merck as a source, babycondor, it's not just any source, it's the source, it's a standard reference used very broadly by a large section of the medical community.

But none of that is very important. What is important are the continual attacks in this forum that make an intelligent discussion of issues impossible. There are still a few decent people here, but there are fewer every day. And this thread is a good example of why that is.

So when does coma stop? If the family donated her organs and her heart was beating in someone else's chest would it still count?
 
Doctor, I have a question.

Can a person be pronounced dead while connected to these machines or do they have to be removed from them before a determination of death can be made?

Thanks for all your excellent info in this thread.

She is a case where that was the case. She is dead as far as medicine and the law care. Parts of her haven't gotten the message yet but that won't be long.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom