Brain dead but still in treatment?

With G-d, all things are possible.

So why bother then?

It's just as possible to give up the fight, cease the financial hemorrhaging, and go home to pray.

It's just as "all things are possible" that the daughter will return in a cloud of heavenly light as it is her corpse will get up and start walking around.
 
With G-d, all things are possible.

So why would anyone seek medical treatment in the first place, rather than just sit at home praying?

G-***********-d doesn't do anything. Tell you what--if this poor girl wakes up, I'll convert right away. Will you denounce your god if she doesn't?
 
And yet, as humans become more reliant on medicine, and less reliant on prayer, life expectancy has, mysteriously, gone up.

Religion is funny like that.

Indeed.

In my church-going believer years, I saw several fellow members either get a diagnosis of cancer or someone close to them did. And two things always happened.

1. They asked for prayers from the church family.
2. They availed themselves of the latest in science and medicine to treat it.

Funny; you'd think they would be ecstatic! Going to see Jesus!

Nope.
 
Indeed.

In my church-going believer years, I saw several fellow members either get a diagnosis of cancer or someone close to them did. And two things always happened.

1. They asked for prayers from the church family.
2. They availed themselves of the latest in science and medicine to treat it.

Funny; you'd think they would be ecstatic! Going to see Jesus!

Nope.

"Everybody wants to go to heaven, but nobody wants to die." - Joe Louis.
 
I'll vote irreversibly comatose. IMO she's closer to living than she is dead.
You really don't know what you're talking about do you?

With G-d, all things are possible.
But in the real world, they aren't. She's dead. She's going to stay dead and continue to rot regardless of all the prayers.

"Everybody wants to go to heaven, but nobody wants to die." - Joe Louis.
So true.
 
You really don't know what you're talking about do you?


But in the real world, they aren't. She's dead. She's going to stay dead and continue to rot regardless of all the prayers.


So true.


Do I think she can recover? No, I don't. Do I believe her mother should let go? Yes, absolutely.
 
"Life just keeps the meat fresh."----The Doctor, 'Silence in the Library'

Her meat's not staying fresh, so she's not alive. It's possible by now that most of her internal organs (no longer responding to brain impulses) are no longer viable for transplant. Moot I suppose, her parents are going to apply hope until she dissolves into goo.
 
So why would anyone seek medical treatment in the first place, rather than just sit at home praying?

G-***********-d doesn't do anything. Tell you what--if this poor girl wakes up, I'll convert right away. Will you denounce your god if she doesn't?

It's not an either/or situation. Wise people avail themselves of all the options.
 
Last edited:
Can a person be pronounced dead while connected to these machines or do they have to be removed from them before a determination of death can be made?

You can be pronounced dead while connected to the machines. Not to sound too macabre, but this is the best scenario for organ procurement, and the numerous lives the surviving family saves by not protesting the organ donor process is the only good thing that comes out of such situations.

~Dr. Imago
 
With G-d, all things are possible.
This confuses me in regards to what the parents think. If they really believe this, why not unplug everything and let God do his/her(?) work?

The doctors and courts are not God. :confused:
 
Last edited:
This confuses me in regards to what the parents think. If they really believe this, why not unplug everything and let God do his/her(?) work?

The doctors and courts are not God. :confused:
Grief and anger are the main actors here for these parents, god beliefs are likely secondary.
 
This confuses me in regards to what the parents think. If they really believe this, why not unplug everything and let God do his/her(?) work?

The doctors and courts are not God. :confused:
Wise people do all the options, prayer, modern medicine and anything else that we think might help. Not an either/or situation.
 
Wise people do all the options, prayer, modern medicine and anything else that we think might help. Not an either/or situation.

Some of the options are contradictory and might actually do harm, like praying to the wrong god and angering another god.
 
Some of the options are contradictory and might actually do harm, like praying to the wrong god and angering another god.

Or, trying toxic chemicals in South America, seeing faith healers, African witch doctors, Voodoo priestesses, homeopathy, etc.

Make it either or, and see how strongly patients believe in prayer or any of the other items listed.
 
Wise people do all the options, prayer, modern medicine and anything else that we think might help. Not an either/or situation.

Wise people put energy and resources into the treatment with the highest chance of success.

Ignorant people put their efforts into prayer.

Gullible people get taken in by shysters and waste energy and resources on lawsuits and quackery.
 
Wise people put energy and resources into the treatment with the highest chance of success.

Ignorant people put their efforts into prayer.

Gullible people get taken in by shysters and waste energy and resources on lawsuits and quackery.

Ah, but this is America where we can do it all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom