Heidi Flori's report is
one (potentially politically-laden) medical opinion. Keep that in mind. And, to respond to your

, Rolfe...
Brain death is a tricky area for a lot of people to get their head around, pardon the pun. Yes, we have determined that she is
legally dead, in that her brain being the cradle of the person that she was will no longer recovery. It is a technical diagnosis. Therefore, we agree that brain death = death.
The body, however, (and here's where I disagree with Dr. Flori) is not a rotting corpse. For one example, many people's intestines "slough off" after hypoxic injury. I've seen this, and I've seen this recover in a few days when the lining grows back. Dr. Flori was probably merely justifying why they wouldn't do a tracheostomy and putting a feeding tube, which may have presented the dilemma of keeping her vital functions going for an indefinite amount of time. Reading her opinion, I can distinctly detect frustration. But, perhaps that's just my reading between the lines having read countless "chart battles" in medical records over the past 20 years.
The bigger point is, there is absolutely
no long-term chance that she is going to get better and no point in continuing to intervene. As soon as you remove her from the intensive care protocols and machines that are supporting the body's vital functions, the heart will stop beating very quickly and the body will then be completely lifeless. We call this principle "futility" of care. It would be like subjecting a Stage IV widely disseminated cancer patient to a major operation when they are going to die anyway. There is no point.
That's the part that they parents aren't getting. Sadly, this often becomes an emotionally laden semantics argument... on both sides. I think Dr. Flori was a unnecessarily theatrical in her report. I know why she did it. But, I still didn't like it.
It is a physician's responsibility to dispassionately present the facts. This was a legal affidavit. Not a medical report.
~Dr. Imago