Brain dead but still in treatment?

Take it up with Merck if you don't like it.

This kind of petty sidetrack nitpicking over something as ridiculous as a person using a medical term correctly is an example of why this forum continues to be so negative.

:rolleyes:
I won't be "taking it up with Merck" because I am not the one who relied on their definition to make an inaccurate statement regarding the case being discussed here. People tried to point out your error, but you just got huffy.

It is neither petty, ridiculous nor negative to ask for clarity and accuracy in a forum dedicated to critical thinking. Nitpicking more or less goes with the territory.

Now that you have presumably had a chance to read up on the particulars of this case, would you characterize Jahi's condition (as reported in the media, since we cannot examine her ourselves) as being "comatose" or "irreversibly comatose" (i.e. "dead")?
 
As to her brain function, note that along with her GI lining sloughing, her body temperature must be externally maintained and her blood pressure has dropped to half what it was on admittance. As well, shifting the body's position to clean it and such causes extreme but temporary changes in pressure. Morbidity is also being demonstrated in skin and muscles. The girl is rotting.
 
Take it up with Merck if you don't like it.



This kind of petty sidetrack nitpicking over something as ridiculous as a person using a medical term correctly is an example of why this forum continues to be so negative.


I gotta agree with you. It's so negative, I can't be bothered even posting much because the bit picky BS that's sure to follow...it annoys me.
 
:rolleyes:

I won't be "taking it up with Merck" because I am not the one who relied on their definition to make an inaccurate statement regarding the case being discussed here. People tried to point out your error, but you just got huffy.



It is neither petty, ridiculous nor negative to ask for clarity and accuracy in a forum dedicated to critical thinking. Nitpicking more or less goes with the territory.



Now that you have presumably had a chance to read up on the particulars of this case, would you characterize Jahi's condition (as reported in the media, since we cannot examine her ourselves) as being "comatose" or "irreversibly comatose" (i.e. "dead")?


Personally, I like corpses to be cold, stiff and grey.

I'll vote irreversibly comatose. IMO she's closer to living than she is dead.
 
Personally, I like corpses to be cold, stiff and grey.

I'll vote irreversibly comatose. IMO she's closer to living than she is dead.

I disagree. Her whole body is decomposing, not just her brain. Were she not inflated by machines, her heart would have stopped weeks ago.
 
The problem is skeptics on a forum should know better than to make assumptions about what another person is posting. Not once did I say I disagreed that she was clinically dead.

Not really, the problem is that we are all in different juridiction. Where I am a coma *only* applies to a living person, and an irreversible coma to a PVS person. A brain dead person is never declared to be in coma (read : "comatose" where do you think the term is coming from ?).

That some juridiction use the stupid "coma irreversible" as brain dead is really the problem of that juridiction.

I think i remarked in another thread, calling heart stopping , a clinical death is depassé and completely stupid and make the term incomprehensible for lay person and is in effect a bad wording from long ago.
 
I gotta agree with you. It's so negative, I can't be bothered even posting much because the bit picky BS that's sure to follow...it annoys me.
This^

And the ludicrous crap continues.

In no post have I argued this girl is not doomed. I've posted the indisputable fact, people in her condition do not live on for years, it'll be weeks, a couple months at most if you start counting from the day she went downhill.

Coma has a specific meaning. It does not have the imaginary meaning being argued with, nor do I hold that imaginary meaning simply because I used the term coma, and lay people here aren't familiar with the term. As for using Merck as a source, babycondor, it's not just any source, it's the source, it's a standard reference used very broadly by a large section of the medical community.

But none of that is very important. What is important are the continual attacks in this forum that make an intelligent discussion of issues impossible. There are still a few decent people here, but there are fewer every day. And this thread is a good example of why that is.
 
Last edited:
This^
....
In no post have I argued this girl is not doomed. I've posted the indisputable fact, people in her condition do not live on [!] for years, it'll be weeks, a couple months at most if you start counting from the day she went downhill.
....

The girl has been determined to be dead. The sheriff's coroner has issued a death certificate. She cannot "live on" if she is dead. You seem to be contending that there is some state beyond death that the girl has not yet reached. That's hard to grasp, and that's why you're getting pushback. Do you say that "coma" continues until the machines are unplugged? One concern is that her family is being misled by lawyers who are telling her the same thing.
 
Last edited:
Heidi Flori's report is one (potentially politically-laden) medical opinion. Keep that in mind. And, to respond to your :rolleyes:, Rolfe...

Brain death is a tricky area for a lot of people to get their head around, pardon the pun. Yes, we have determined that she is legally dead, in that her brain being the cradle of the person that she was will no longer recovery. It is a technical diagnosis. Therefore, we agree that brain death = death.

The body, however, (and here's where I disagree with Dr. Flori) is not a rotting corpse. For one example, many people's intestines "slough off" after hypoxic injury. I've seen this, and I've seen this recover in a few days when the lining grows back. Dr. Flori was probably merely justifying why they wouldn't do a tracheostomy and putting a feeding tube, which may have presented the dilemma of keeping her vital functions going for an indefinite amount of time. Reading her opinion, I can distinctly detect frustration. But, perhaps that's just my reading between the lines having read countless "chart battles" in medical records over the past 20 years.

The bigger point is, there is absolutely no long-term chance that she is going to get better and no point in continuing to intervene. As soon as you remove her from the intensive care protocols and machines that are supporting the body's vital functions, the heart will stop beating very quickly and the body will then be completely lifeless. We call this principle "futility" of care. It would be like subjecting a Stage IV widely disseminated cancer patient to a major operation when they are going to die anyway. There is no point.

That's the part that they parents aren't getting. Sadly, this often becomes an emotionally laden semantics argument... on both sides. I think Dr. Flori was a unnecessarily theatrical in her report. I know why she did it. But, I still didn't like it.

It is a physician's responsibility to dispassionately present the facts. This was a legal affidavit. Not a medical report.

~Dr. Imago


Doctor, I have a question.

Can a person be pronounced dead while connected to these machines or do they have to be removed from them before a determination of death can be made?

Thanks for all your excellent info in this thread.
 
Last edited:
I don't have URL posting privileges, yet, but if one goes to the NBCBayArea news site, you can read about how the charter school the child attended has gotten on the family's religious bandwagon by promoting prayers for the child. The school is letting some of the kids believe that if they pray hard enough, Jahi will return to school.

Sad, sad, sad situation. I understand the family letting grief blind them to reality, but for a school to side step reality, as well… jeez...
 
....
The school is letting some of the kids believe that if they pray hard enough, Jahi will return to school.
...

The most terrible thing about that is that when she doesn't recover, the little kids will think it's their fault for not "praying hard enough." Borders on child abuse.
 
I don't have URL posting privileges, yet, but if one goes to the NBCBayArea news site, you can read about how the charter school the child attended has gotten on the family's religious bandwagon by promoting prayers for the child. The school is letting some of the kids believe that if they pray hard enough, Jahi will return to school.

Sad, sad, sad situation. I understand the family letting grief blind them to reality, but for a school to side step reality, as well… jeez...


Here's the story:

http://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/loca...-Academy-Friends-Believe-Alive-239629891.html

Most kids are Christian here,” [the academy's chief operating officer Lisa] Blair said, “and they believe that if you continue praying, there’s always a possibility. The students understand the debate. They’re just choosing spirituality over science.”

Deplorable.
 
Deplorable.

Agree.

"They’re just choosing spirituality over science.”

Cool! Then they can "pray communicate" with each other instead of using computers or the internet. They can get all the music they want down at the church via the organist hymnal, not MP3s or iPods. And their parents need to stop buying gasoline (fossil fuels). Oh, and if they get sick or injured, DO NOT go to a doctor or hospital.

Don't want them to get that ick sciency stuff all over them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom