Brain dead but still in treatment?

I think you need to read the things the specialist doctors have been saying about this. Things about specialised blood flow studies and so on.

Rolfe.
OK, so due to hemorrhaging and swelling there's no blood getting to the brain.

This argument is ludicrous. Take it up with the Merck editors and the rest of the medical community or show some source that says brain death is not appropriately called a comatose state.

Why are you belaboring this nonsense?
 
The Merck definition is misleading, IMHO. People can recover from a comatose state, but not from brain death, so the two conditions are different.

This thread is about the definition of death (among other things), so I think it is worth clarifying terms.

The OP asked, "Dead is dead, right?" Apparently it is not so clear cut.
 
OK, so due to hemorrhaging and swelling there's no blood getting to the brain.

It doesn't matter why there is no blood flow.

At least three neurologists have confirmed that Jahi was unable to breathe on her own, had no blood flow to her brain and had no sign of electrical activity.

Brain cells die without blood flow and autopsies in such cases have shown that the brain liquefies.

Without oxygen the brain dies in minutes, not months.

According to the Uniform Determination of Death Act:

An individual who has sustained either (1) irreversible cessation of circulatory and respiratory functions, or (2) irreversible cessation of all functions of the entire brain, including the brain stem, is dead. A determination of death must be made in accordance with accepted medical standards.

This girl is not in a coma.
 
Since there is no reason to believe blood would circulate to the face but not also to the brain we can assume from the fact her face has not turned black and shriveled, that blood is still circulating in her head, ergo in her brain as well.

Nope.

When you get sufficient brain swelling, blood can still go from the external carotids and supply the face, scalp, etc. But not to the internal carotids, cerebral arteries, circle of Willis (etc.) and thus not the brain.

~Dr. Imago
 
Last edited:
It doesn't matter why there is no blood flow.

Without oxygen the brain dies in minutes, not months.

According to the Uniform Determination of Death Act:
This girl is not in a coma.

This was all spelled out in a landmark paper, published in JAMA in 1968. They use the term 'irreversible coma' - it is an important diagnostic criteria in determining brain death.
source

In contrast, we have National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke stating
A coma, sometimes also called persistent vegetative state, is a profound or deep state of unconsciousness. Persistent vegetative state is not brain-death. An individual in a state of coma is alive

I don't have a horse in the race. I would speculate that probably that the JAMA paper, written by the Harvard Medical School, was more or less the point at which coma stopped being used when there is brain death. I certainly mistook the 'coma' reference to imply that the poster thought the person was alive, though I readily accept her declaration to the contrary. I'd of course accept correction from the posting doctors, but to me it is kind of like saying 'roger has the sniffles' when I have the plague. Okay, yes, my nose is running, but at that is one of several symptoms of a rather more serious condition. Likewise, saying I'm in a coma when I'm brain dead isn't quite right; part of my state is a vegetative, unconscious state, sure, but then there is that other part of being dead, with brain tissue in a state that will never support brain function again.

I don't care what the final answer is, it is just a bit of interesting language use to me. I don't see anyone disagreeing with the 'dead' part of the diagnosis.
 
The Merck definition is misleading, IMHO. People can recover from a comatose state, but not from brain death, so the two conditions are different.

This thread is about the definition of death (among other things), so I think it is worth clarifying terms.

The OP asked, "Dead is dead, right?" Apparently it is not so clear cut.
Take it up with Merck if you don't like it.

This kind of petty sidetrack nitpicking over something as ridiculous as a person using a medical term correctly is an example of why this forum continues to be so negative.
 
Relax, Ginger. No one is 100% correct 100% of the time.

~Dr. Imago
Riight, because it's all me, no one else is being a jerk in this thread. :rolleyes:

I keep waiting for this forum to get back to normal and instead it just gets worse and worse.
 
...The body, however, (and here's where I disagree with Dr. Flori) is not a rotting corpse. For one example, many people's intestines "slough off" after hypoxic injury. I've seen this, and I've seen this recover in a few days when the lining grows back. ... It is a physician's responsibility to dispassionately present the facts. This was a legal affidavit. Not a medical report.

~Dr. Imago

Now that WAS interesting. I had no idea the intestinal lining could grow back.
Also, thank for reminding us dr Flori's statements are from an affidavit, not a medical report.
Good catch!


Since there is no reason to believe blood would circulate to the face but not also to the brain we can assume from the fact her face has not turned black and shriveled, that blood is still circulating in her head, ergo in her brain as well.
Nope.

When you get sufficient brain swelling, blood can still go from the external carotids and supply the face, scalp, etc. But not to the internal carotids, cerebral arteries, circle of Willis (etc.) and thus not the brain.

~Dr. Imago

Thanks for the information, Dr. Imago. I can imagine those circumstances would confuse someone confronted with the death of a friend or family member.
 
If the success of American entire medical system depends on pulling the plug on a little girl, we are in serious trouble .

I'm sure that this one case will not in itself undermine the entire U.S. medical system but it would set a precedent that relatives can demand whatever treatment they want regardless of how pointless it is or deluded they are.

Should all corpses be kept artificially respirated just in case they spring back into life ?

Will people who sadly lose a child use such terms in describing their loved ones as the corpse, dead body, the rotting body? I doubt it.

I don't know about children (I don't have any) but when my mother died i certainly referred to her as a corpse and a dead body. She didn't have much opportunity to be a rotting body because, unlike this case, the undertaker was allowed to do their job properly and she was cremated soon after her death.
 
If the success of American entire medical system depends on pulling the plug on a little girl, we are in serious trouble . Will people who sadly lose a child use such terms in describing their loved ones as the corpse, dead body, the rotting body? I doubt it.
That you dislike the terms doesn't make them inaccurate in any way. The girl is dead, bury her or cremate or, or have her stuffed, but stop wasting medical resources on a delusion.

I, too, want to line up on the side of the folk trying to do the best for this child.
That'd be the bury/burn option then.

Riight, because it's all me, no one else is being a jerk in this thread. :rolleyes:

I keep waiting for this forum to get back to normal and instead it just gets worse and worse.
Well you're the one continuing the pointless cma derail.

I'm sure that this one case will not in itself undermine the entire U.S. medical system but it would set a precedent that relatives can demand whatever treatment they want regardless of how pointless it is or deluded they are.

Should all corpses be kept artificially respirated just in case they spring back into life ?
I suspect that'll depend on if someone can make a profit from much treatment. :(
 
I don't have a horse in the race. I would speculate that probably that the JAMA paper, written by the Harvard Medical School, was more or less the point at which coma stopped being used when there is brain death. I certainly mistook the 'coma' reference to imply that the poster thought the person was alive, though I readily accept her declaration to the contrary. I'd of course accept correction from the posting doctors, but to me it is kind of like saying 'roger has the sniffles' when I have the plague. Okay, yes, my nose is running, but at that is one of several symptoms of a rather more serious condition. Likewise, saying I'm in a coma when I'm brain dead isn't quite right; part of my state is a vegetative, unconscious state, sure, but then there is that other part of being dead, with brain tissue in a state that will never support brain function again.

It reminds me of the who's-an-atheist arguments. If "not believing in god" is all that's required to be labeled an atheist, then one can argue a newborn is an atheist. But, then, one can argue that a tree or a rock is an atheist too, which starts to sound silly. If "coma" is "a profound or deep state of unconsciousness," well, dead people do lack consciousness, but so do trees and rocks.

Seems there is an underlying assumption that consciousness should be at least theoretically possible, but I can see the problem that in the context of a physician trying to decide whether a person is alive or brain dead, there is an assumption that the person could be alive, so one needs to list what separates "dead" from "alive."

For what it's worth, here's the Merck Manual page on brain death: http://www.merckmanuals.com/profess...a_and_impaired_consciousness/brain_death.html
 
So who's paying? I'm genuinely baffled. (And I thought you guys didn't have death panels! :rolleyes: )

Rolfe.
A gofundme site has been started. No insurance will pay for medical care for a corpse, unless it is an autopsy or it is organ donation.
 
I'm sure that this one case will not in itself undermine the entire U.S. medical system but it would set a precedent that relatives can demand whatever treatment they want regardless of how pointless it is or deluded they are.

I was wondering whether mental illness could be invoked at any point? In other words, if someone insists something is true when medical and legal professionals have shown it isn't, how far can an individual legally force others to comply with their delusion? Surely there's some point where society can say: no, you're nuts.

But then there's also the view that people can do what they wish with their own property, and I'm guessing a child's dead body legally belongs to the parents. If something is not a danger to public health and the parents are paying the expenses, does the state have any interest in telling people what they can do with their property? There are bodies in cryogenic storage, after all.

That's assuming a dead body is just property, but apparently that's not legally true.

The following (layman's) article indicates that traditionally families don't have a property right in bodies.

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/jurisprudence/2002/03/habeas_corpses.html
But you don't get to do as you please with your dead because a very long legal tradition rejects the notion that family members own the remains of their loved ones. This rule stems from the 17th-century British belief that human souls have the right to reclaim their bodies on Resurrection Day, therefore they can't transfer those rights to their descendants. American courts still refuse to find a property right in the body of the deceased, and so crimes against dead bodies are treated leniently for the most part. The Model Penal Code provision concerning abuse of a corpse only makes it a misdemeanor, explaining, "[G]reater penalties seem plainly excessive in light of the fact that the harm involved is only outrage to sensibility." In other words, the law permits survivors to recover for emotional damage and trauma but not for damage to the dead as their property.
So following that tradition, does that mean a person can't pay to have someone do whatever the person wants with their loved one's dead body? For example, if I paid a hospital enough and they agreed, I could contract with them to display a photo that I owned in the lobby, but if someone pays enough and a hospital agrees, can a person make any contract they wish for the dead body they (actually legally don't) own?

The Don said:
I don't know about children (I don't have any) but when my mother died i certainly referred to her as a corpse and a dead body. She didn't have much opportunity to be a rotting body because, unlike this case, the undertaker was allowed to do their job properly and she was cremated soon after her death.

Same here.
 
Last edited:
I was wondering whether mental illness could be invoked at any point? In other words, if someone insists something is true when medical and legal professionals have shown it isn't, how far can an individual legally force others to comply with their delusion? Surely there's some point where society can say: no, you're nuts.

My fear is that the longer this goes on, the worse it will be psychologically for the family afterward.

But then there's also the view that people can do what they wish with their own property, and I'm guessing a child's dead body legally belongs to the parents. If something is not a danger to public health and the parents are paying the expenses, does the state have any interest in telling people what they can do with their property? There are bodies in cryogenic storage, after all.

No idea about the US. There are requirements in the UK to have a body decently disposed of, IIRC. It's not generally an issue to have a body at home for a short period prior to burial/cremation though I'm not sure if any specific timescale is defined.
 
Riight, because it's all me, no one else is being a jerk in this thread. :rolleyes:

I keep waiting for this forum to get back to normal and instead it just gets worse and worse.

I am personally sorry if I in any way embarrassed or humiliated you. That was never my intent. You offer a lot of good insight and valuable opinion to this forum.

~Dr. Imago
 
I was wondering whether mental illness could be invoked at any point? In other words, if someone insists something is true when medical and legal professionals have shown it isn't, how far can an individual legally force others to comply with their delusion? Surely there's some point where society can say: no, you're nuts.

In this case (as in the past), they involved the court system to attempt to solve this issue. And, the judge mucked it all up by offering a temporary restraining order.

Thus, in my opinion, the undercurrent of vitriol in Dr. Fiori's statements.

~Dr. Imago
 
A gofundme site has been started. No insurance will pay for medical care for a corpse, unless it is an autopsy or it is organ donation.

It should be covered. Under Obamacare, being dead might count as a preexisting condition.
 
I was wondering whether mental illness could be invoked at any point? In other words, if someone insists something is true when medical and legal professionals have shown it isn't, how far can an individual legally force others to comply with their delusion? Surely there's some point where society can say: no, you're nuts.

But then there's also the view that people can do what they wish with their own property, and I'm guessing a child's dead body legally belongs to the parents. If something is not a danger to public health and the parents are paying the expenses, does the state have any interest in telling people what they can do with their property? There are bodies in cryogenic storage, after all.

It will be interesting to see what comes of this. I think the facility has a lot of ethical questions coming its way. I wonder how the child's new doctors are feeling about the facility taking on a body as a patient.

Perhaps it will be a new trend.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom