Brain dead but still in treatment?

Here's an opinion piece by a medical ethicist and philosopher who presents a well-reasoned argument for allowing parents to decide whether their child is dead, if they are willing to pay for the child's "post-death" care with their own funds. He also discusses some of the nuances in the definition of death.

If preserving life requires high-tech support like a ventilator, doctors are the ones who should provide it. The costs shouldn't be borne by the hospital. The health insurance company or Medicaid shouldn't pay. But if the family can raise the funds, like Jahi's parents are doing, and the patient is beyond feeling pain, no harm is done by continuing, especially if they can find a facility willing to take the case.

Link
 
I remember the case of an elderly lady who kept her Jack Russell terrier in her kitchen for about four months after the dog died. She was in denial, and kept washing and tending to the body.

That did not end well, and could have ended worse but for her doctor intervening to halt her prosecution under animal welfare legislation.

Rolfe.
 
Great. We have used a technical term incorrectly.
Get the narrative straight: you all jumped on my ass for using a technical term correctly.

Here's the question: When does a coma end? If "coma" is one criterion for death, I would think that once "death" has been declared, the "coma" is over. Does a coma continue past death? Is everybody dead still in a coma? Do you contend this girl was in a coma, or is in a coma?
It ends when the blood stops circulating in the brain.
 
I think the problem is that many people associate "coma" with "really deep sleep", rather than "lack of consciousness while homeostasis persists to some degree".
The problem is skeptics on a forum should know better than to make assumptions about what another person is posting. Not once did I say I disagreed that she was clinically dead.
 
but people like Jahi's parents should have the option to record their conscientiously held positions and allow pronouncements of death to be based on those beliefs
Can I declare that my grandmother is alive again? I mean, sure, we cremated her and all, but I sincerely believe that she would want to keep getting those social security checks.
 
Here's an opinion piece by a medical ethicist and philosopher who presents a well-reasoned argument for allowing parents to decide whether their child is dead, if they are willing to pay for the child's "post-death" care with their own funds. He also discusses some of the nuances in the definition of death....
While we don't know exactly what efforts the hospital made to help this family, and whatever they did failed, the hospital does make a good case for withdrawing the ventilator in the "Supplemental Declaration" filed in the court case. I agree with their reasoning that it is not ethical to keep a deceased person's heart beating and lungs exchanging air.
 
Here's an opinion piece by a medical ethicist and philosopher who presents a well-reasoned argument for allowing parents to decide whether their child is dead, if they are willing to pay for the child's "post-death" care with their own funds. He also discusses some of the nuances in the definition of death.



Link

The key phrase in that statement you quoted, to me, is "especially if they can find a facility willing to take the case."

It seems to me that is exactly what they have done in this case. They found a facility willing to take her. But that isn't the issue, is it? I thought it was about the expectations set upon the hospital she was in? That they should be required to continue supporting her? Or that they should be required to transport her to the place that was willing to take her?

Does this person think that the parents have the right to FORCE a facility to keep supporting the dead person? To use their resources for it, as long as the parents compensate them? What happens if they have another person who is alive and actually needs the equipment?

And what's to stop the facility for just making the cost of life support for a dead person so outrageously high that no one can afford it? You think the ACA is going to put price controls on life support for a person declared dead? That $47K they've raised won't go far when the hospital cost of life support for a dead person is $100K/day after the 3rd week. Don't like the cost? Find someone cheaper. Can you really accuse the hospital of charging too much for keeping a dead person on support?
 
Here's an opinion piece by a medical ethicist and philosopher who presents a well-reasoned argument for allowing parents to decide whether their child is dead, if they are willing to pay for the child's "post-death" care with their own funds. He also discusses some of the nuances in the definition of death.



Link

I'd think it pretty barbaric that the wealthy would get given longer to accept the passing of a relative than the poor. Money also seems like such an arbitrary factor to determine wether treatment continues, it has nothing to do with either the patient's or the family' sheath and well being.

I'd also disagree with the no harm being done. We have a culture of treating corpses with respect and certain things are not allowed to be done to them because of this. If assaulting a body with needles and tubes is ok to allow loved ones some comfort, surely necrophilia by partners is also allowable.
 
While we don't know exactly what efforts the hospital made to help this family, and whatever they did failed, the hospital does make a good case for withdrawing the ventilator in the "Supplemental Declaration" filed in the court case. I agree with their reasoning that it is not ethical to keep a deceased person's heart beating and lungs exchanging air.

I, too, want to line up on the side of the folk trying to do the best for this child.
 
Last edited:
Get the narrative straight: you all jumped on my ass for using a technical term correctly.

It ends when the blood stops circulating in the brain.

So as long as a pump is used to keep blood circulating to a brain that is decomposing, the body remains in a coma? Really? I can't find where Merck says that. And although the question was asked facetiously, what would prevent relatives from maintaining a body on a pump "in a coma" for ulterior motives (I don't think Social Security checks would be enough, but I can imagine estate and inheritance situations that would make it worthwhile.) Your expert position is that someone can be brain dead, pronounced dead by the coroner and remain in a coma?
 
So as long as a pump is used to keep blood circulating to a brain that is decomposing, the body remains in a coma? Really? I can't find where Merck says that. And although the question was asked facetiously, what would prevent relatives from maintaining a body on a pump "in a coma" for ulterior motives (I don't think Social Security checks would be enough, but I can imagine estate and inheritance situations that would make it worthwhile.) Your expert position is that someone can be brain dead, pronounced dead by the coroner and remain in a coma?
You really should stop digging. You are arguing with the wrong source of your grief. Argue with the medical establishment that applies the term, coma, when referring to brain death.

I used a term correctly. At least 5 people claimed I didn't. I showed that I did. Admit it or don't, but why would I agree with your logic when it has nothing to do with the actual use of the term in a medical setting?
 
Get the narrative straight: you all jumped on my ass for using a technical term correctly.

It ends when the blood stops circulating in the brain.

Correct me if I'm wrong, please, but that point was reached in mid-December.
 
So as long as a pump is used to keep blood circulating to a brain that is decomposing, the body remains in a coma? Really? I can't find where Merck says that. And although the question was asked facetiously, what would prevent relatives from maintaining a body on a pump "in a coma" for ulterior motives (I don't think Social Security checks would be enough, but I can imagine estate and inheritance situations that would make it worthwhile.) Your expert position is that someone can be brain dead, pronounced dead by the coroner and remain in a coma?

Or even potential large awards from lawsuits....
 
I, too, want to line up on the side of the folk trying to do the best for this child.

The time for that is long past. It would have been best if her weight had been managed so that she didn't develop a life threatening condition (sleep apnea) requiring complicated, risky surgery, in the first place.

The choice now is between pumping air and fluids through her body in a futile attempt to maintain the illusion of life, or letting her go. The parents have made their choice, we will see what happens next.
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, please, but that point was reached in mid-December.
Since there is no reason to believe blood would circulate to the face but not also to the brain we can assume from the fact her face has not turned black and shriveled, that blood is still circulating in her head, ergo in her brain as well.
 
Last edited:
I think you need to read the things the specialist doctors have been saying about this. Things about specialised blood flow studies and so on.

Rolfe.
 
You fat? I am, I know it and do not get upset at the fact, or even someone pointing out the fact. I contol it, even given two serious back traumas and a host of reasons that make shedding weight a real challenge.

IMHO this sensitivity to weight is what causes food disorders, STOP BEING SO SENSITIVE. These kinds of problems need reality far more than sensitivity to make the biggest differences in quality of life.

ie, quality life doesn't care about how it hurt your feeling to be called fat.

Hard knock life is calling: GET OVER IT!

I am 5'6", 128lbs. I am not just slim, I am health conscious, food conscious, and I rotate my workouts between running, yoga, and weight training, oh, and I am a below the knee amputee because for some reason the physical obstacles just makes it sound so much better. I just think it's an obnoxious way to treat people. I don't care what life cares about, I am a human being who feels this thing called empathy and refuses to hide behind the old "life sucks" mantra to get away with treating people like ****. Back when I worked a strenuous job, I couldn't keep weight on. When I got down to 119 lbs I experienced the opposite; unsolicited opinions about being "too skinny," "You need to eat something!" "You look sickly/like you have AIDS/Cancer." Yes life does suck but it can suck a little less when you put forth a little effort to treat other people kindly. My doctor not only found a way to address the extreme weight loss by not blurting out something like, "for christ sake, eat a burger," but giving me helpful suggestions.

Do you find it a bit of a double standard that you get to have a back problem excuse while all those other slobs are just too *********** sensitive? Do you think maybe, just maybe other people have reasons, too?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom