Brain dead but still in treatment?

The sloughing of the gut lining is mentioned in dr Flori's report.
I'll look into it.

Is there a difference between being comatose and being legally dead?
Yes, one is a medical definition and one is a legal definition and they are not exactly the same.

It's only been since organ donations that anyone with a beating heart has been declared legally dead. There needed to be legal clarity if one was going to cut a beating heart out of a 'dead' person.
 
Does the heart keep beating in the case of brain death such as this? If not, then how is blood being circulated throughout the body?
The brain stem will keep the heart beating. You need one higher level of brain function to have breathing maintained. Rarely doctors misjudge and they take a vent off and the person sustains respirations, but in this case it is likely she has no spontaneous respiration effort at all. If they take the vent off, her heart will stop a few minutes later.
 
Heart beats do not depend on signals from the nervous system. They can be completely controlled by pace maker cells in the heart. ....
While that is true, a heart will not beat on it's own for very long without some central nervous system control. Without brainstem function, all the blood vessels would relax and there'd be no blood pressure maintained.
 
I'll look into it.

Yes, one is a medical definition and one is a legal definition and they are not exactly the same.
....

Multiple doctors have declared her dead and the coroner has declared her dead. What can you possibly be trying to say? By what conceivable definition is the girl not dead?
 
Only by people who do not know what they are talking about. It is only a coma until an EEG records a complete absence of brain activity, at that point it is no longer a coma, it is death. Despite what you want to believe, no one who has met the criteria for "brain dead" has ever recovered.
ETA: You will notice that the experts in this case do not say she is in a coma, they say she is dead. That illustrates the difference quite well.
I have no idea by what definition you go, but here in France/germany coma is reserved to unconsciousness, NOT to brain dead people. Unless you were joking (rolleyes smiley).
Dead people can still have a coma diagnosis? She isn't in a coma she is a beating heart cadaver.
She's dead, SG. Read Heidi Flori's report. She is not in a coma.
Rolfe.
I get it she is legally dead. I get it why the death certificate was issued. But the definition of coma still applies and is a descriptor of absent brain function.

So I guess the editors of the Merck Manual are as ignorant as I am. :rolleyes:
Brain death - Merck Manual
Brain death is loss of function of the entire cerebrum and brain stem, resulting in coma, no spontaneous respiration, and loss of all brain stem reflexes. Spinal reflexes, including deep tendon, plantar flexion, and withdrawal reflexes, may remain. Recovery does not occur.

The concept of brain death developed because ventilators and drugs can perpetuate cardiopulmonary and other body functions despite complete cessation of all cerebral activity. The concept that brain death (ie, total cessation of integrated brain function, especially that of the brain stem) constitutes a person's death has been accepted legally and culturally in most of the world.
Though I see from this I'll need to look closer at cardiac stimulus in this girl's case.
 
Last edited:
....
So I guess the editors of the Merck Manual are as ignorant as I am. :rolleyes:
...

Keep reading:
Prognosis
The diagnosis of brain death is equivalent to the person's death. No one who meets the criteria for brain death recovers. After brain death is confirmed, all supporting cardiac and respiratory treatments are ended. Cessation of ventilatory support results in terminal arrhythmias. Spinal motor reflexes may occur during terminal apnea; they include arching of the back, neck turning, stiffening of the legs, and upper extremity flexion (the so-called Lazarus sign). Family members who wish to be present when the ventilator is shut off need to be warned of such reflex movements.
http://www.merckmanuals.com/profess...a_and_impaired_consciousness/brain_death.html
 
Last edited:
Well, the facility she's at now has put in tracheostomy and feeding tubes.

http://news.yahoo.com/brain-dead-california-teen-gets-surgery-facility-court-062443175.html

I can sort of understand the family's perspective to some extent, but this is just going to hurt them more in the long run. Why isn't a doctor attempting to demonstrate to them what would happen if this girl is taken off of the life support machines, since they are the only things keeping her heart beating and her oxygen flowing? Why create more pain for yourself and keep your daughter's body in a state where, while she's beyond feeling pain, will only make her final death that much more pointless?

I can't begin to determine what I would do in a similar situation, but I'd like to think I would put my daughter's welfare above my own grief and would let her go. But then, grieving people aren't always rational, I suppose.
 
Nothing in your "read on" changes the meaning of 'coma'.

Honestly people, you'd think I was arguing she was not legally dead.

It sounds like you are contending that someone who is legally dead might not be medically dead. If by "coma" you mean "irretrievably unconscious and unresponsive," yes, I guess a dead person would be in a coma. But the problem with insisting that she's in a "coma" is that a coma can have all kinds of causes, and often people can recover from it. This might explain the family's misplaced hope, especially if their attorneys are kicking the word "coma" around. But nobody "recovers" from brain death. This girl is dead, and machines are maintaining limited physical functions.
 
It sounds like you are contending that someone who is legally dead might not be medically dead. If by "coma" you mean "irretrievably unconscious and unresponsive," yes, I guess a dead person would be in a coma. But the problem with insisting that she's in a "coma" is that a coma can have all kinds of causes, and often people can recover from it. This might explain the family's misplaced hope, especially if their attorneys are kicking the word "coma" around. But nobody "recovers" from brain death. This girl is dead, and machines are maintaining limited physical functions.
No, what it sounds like is I used a medical term and people who don't know the actual definition of coma read all sorts of crap about what it and/or I meant.

People in the thread who believe I meant something I didn't mean just wasted a page of thread space arguing against an imaginary position.
 
Last edited:
http://www.coma.ulg.ac.be/papers/vs/...Neurosci05.pdf
what is now known as brain death, using the term ‘coma dépassé’ (irretrievable coma) ... published a milestone paper defining death as irreversible coma ... Harvard Medical School Ad Hoc Committee defined irreversible coma as a new criterion for death ...
And so on and so on....

Great. We have used a technical term incorrectly. Here's the question: When does a coma end? If "coma" is one criterion for death, I would think that once "death" has been declared, the "coma" is over. Does a coma continue past death? Is everybody dead still in a coma? Do you contend this girl was in a coma, or is in a coma?
 
If the success of American entire medical system depends on pulling the plug on a little girl, we are in serious trouble . Will people who sadly lose a child use such terms in describing their loved ones as the corpse, dead body, the rotting body? I doubt it.
 
Last edited:
Great. We have used a technical term incorrectly. Here's the question: When does a coma end? If "coma" is one criterion for death, I would think that once "death" has been declared, the "coma" is over. Does a coma continue past death? Is everybody dead still in a coma? Do you contend this girl was in a coma, or is in a coma?

I'm with you, Bob.

She's brain dead. No other descriptor needed.

~Dr. Imago
 
I think the problem is that many people associate "coma" with "really deep sleep", rather than "lack of consciousness while homeostasis persists to some degree".
 
I get it she is legally dead. I get it why the death certificate was issued. But the definition of coma still applies and is a descriptor of absent brain function.

So I guess the editors of the Merck Manual are as ignorant as I am. :rolleyes:
Brain death - Merck ManualThough I see from this I'll need to look closer at cardiac stimulus in this girl's case.

So everyone dead is also in a coma?
 
Well if this is the case, a) I am sure you will have no problem backing it up and if a) then b) the doctors can try approaching with professionalism instead of critism and judging.

You fat? I am, I know it and do not get upset at the fact, or even someone pointing out the fact. I contol it, even given two serious back traumas and a host of reasons that make shedding weight a real challenge.

IMHO this sensitivity to weight is what causes food disorders, STOP BEING SO SENSITIVE. These kinds of problems need reality far more than sensitivity to make the biggest differences in quality of life.

ie, quality life doesn't care about how it hurt your feeling to be called fat.

Hard knock life is calling: GET OVER IT!
 
Last edited:
If the success of American entire medical system depends on pulling the plug on a little girl, we are in serious trouble . Will people who sadly lose a child us such terms in describing their loved ones as the corpse, dead body, the rotting body? I doubt it.

Look on the bright side the family is giving up the chance to save other peoples lives via organ donation. Because when else will they get to legally kill people and spend tens of thousands of other peoples dollars to do it? All to delay their acceptance of reality for a few weeks.
 
Look on the bright side the family is giving up the chance to save other peoples lives via organ donation. Because when else will they get to legally kill people and spend tens of thousands of other peoples dollars to do it? All to delay their acceptance of reality for a few weeks.

If someone has a defective organ, it would be against God's will to implant a new organ within them.

Now, this ventilator, on the other hand...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom