Are you a sceptic who used to Believe Weird Things?

Azrienoch said:
No, I'm a skeptic who still believes weird things.
You may be an oxymoron. Or No True Scotsman.

What Weird Things do you still Believe? WE CAN CURE YOU.
 
DA,

Dr Adequate said:
Can you tell us why you believed this? I'm fascinated.
I was about 13 or 14 at the time so I don't clearly remember why I believed this. Perhaps I thought it would be cool to float into the air. Imagine my brother's surprise when he woke to find me levitating towards the ceiling. I think I had read matter of fact reports of people who could levitate and got the impression that there was no question about the phenomenon existing, just a question about whether I was one of these people. I used to try every morning after waking. I would close my eyes and concentrate really hard. Unlike present day levitationists, I would relax all my muscles and imagine myself feeling as light as a helium balloon. On several occasions I fully believed that I was in fact floating high above my bed. Unfortunately, on every occasion when I opened my eyes, the ceiling was never any closer.
I eventually decided that I just could not do it.
A year or two later, about the time I discovered that there was no evidence for God, I also decided that levitation was not possible.

BJ
 
Her having not yet been 'convicted' of fraud lends absolutely zero credence to your belief in her pranormal abilities. I was pointing out that you are founding your beliefs not on evidence in the affirmative, but rather on the absence of proof of fraud. This is the argument from ignorance, a logical fallacy, and the surest road to errant belief.

Believers seem incapable of withholding judgment until all the evidence is in.
 
Nina has shown that she can do it .
Basically I'm saying she has shown that she can do it regardless of how she does it but no one has shown that she can't do it or uses conjuring to do it.

I'll put forward a question to you Grendel ;
What would you consider to be proof in this case ? I am not expecting that you'd except proof even if it was shown to you.
 
jambo372 said:
Nina has shown that she can do it .
Basically I'm saying she has shown that she can do it regardless of how she does it but no one has shown that she can't do it or uses conjuring to do it.

I'll put forward a question to you Grendel ;
What would you consider to be proof in this case ? I am not expecting that you'd except proof even if it was shown to you.

I'm curious...have you read any of the actual, original experimental reports on her? I'm not talking about summaries found in psi books, the internet, or Pravda, but the first-hand accounts of her feats? If so, where?
 
jambo372 said:
The first hand accounts would mostly be in Russian.

Yes, so I understand. Can you read Russian, and if so, have you read these accounts? It's vitally important, especially if one comes to this forum, to be intimately familiar with all the research for any case one is presenting. Summaries from psi books and the internet will not give you nearly the amount of information you need to be able to render a decision.
 
Contrary to skeptical bumper stickers, I do not require extraordinary evidence for extraordinary claims. I would accept as proof the same level of scientific evidence required for any physical claim, no more, no less. The Randi Challenge would be sufficient.

Jambo, when you make statements about a total stranger that you'd expect them to refuse any level of 'proof', all you accomplish is to establish the very thing you are being correctly tagged with: a predisposition to form beliefs prior to investigation. You've done it with this Nina, and you're doing it with me. It's no way to run a brain.

Here's what you've done with this belief in Nina:

1) Disregarded the fact that 99% of the history of paranormal research and testing is comprised of fraud and ineptitude, thereby negating any attempt on your part to check out the testing protocols and efficacy.

2) Formed a belief without having scrutinized the evidence whatsoever. I know you think you have, but you've only scanned
reports on the testing.

3) Spent your time defending a pre-held, biased belief instead of actually investigating this latest of 10,000,000 claims of paranormal 'proof' from Russia.

4) Established walls to prevent the intake of any information that might amend that preheld belief.

5) Fooled yourself into believing she has proved her ability thereby justifying your belief in her, when all that's really occurred is that reports of her powers have merely validated a belief you already held -that there are real psychics.

I could go on, but the point is made. The proof is in the pudding not in the bowl (that is, it's all about the evidence, the Evidence, the EVIDENCE, not about dubious reports from unknown reporters about unknown testers).
 
Yeah, and I've got the books to prove it. I had an interest in UFOs, divination of many forms (astrology, tarot, palmistry and so on), graphology and a few other things. Fortunately, I gave up those stupid and insane beliefs when I started asking for evidence of things. None of those had any to validate themselves. They remain as they should be - childhood delusions. Beyond about 12 or 13, I can't remember respecting any of those forms of BS.
 
Query: Back in the dim and misty (in college) I twice took the psi card test along with all my classmates. As I recall my scores were 2 right on the first test and 3 on the second. Obviously I showed a vast improvement from test one to test two. My question is should I pursue a career in the exciting field of the paranormal in lieu of my present unexciting field of mechanicl engineering?




When I was a kid we had a stallion pony named Whiskey, meanest herbivore on the planet. He used to routinely kick the living metabolic residue out of my Doberman.
 
Dr Adequate said:
If you have to ASK us for our opinion, stick to engineering.

AAAH, I see. The classic "if they're psychic why do we have to call them?" paradox. Thank you I shall now remain in the dreary, mundane world of mechanics and the magic of known, tested and quantified physical properties, etc. Another easy money scam shot down by reality.

Lets face it folks, we could do that crap too, problem is we're too honest for our own wallets. In addition I have it on reliable authority that I am too ugly for radio.




...ever notice how superman stands there and lets the bullets bounce off his chest. Then when the crook throws the empty gun at him he ducks. David Brenner:D
 
Dr Adequate asked me to tell my woo-woo story, so tell I shall. It's a doozy, so fetch a cuppa joe or a beer and kick back.

I will ask you all not to ridicule anything in here. Not that I think you will, but I feel better asking you not to. I'm still a little embarrassed about some of this, OK? Thanks.
These beliefs and practices were born of gullibility, wishful thinking, and self-delusion. At least I have the cajones to admit it. :D

When I was a little kid, my parents sent me to Catholic school and Sunday school. I never really believed in the christian god or in Jesus, I don't know why I didn't, but I didn't. The nuns and priest didn't like me much-- even as a kid I had way too many questions. My parents put me in public school from second grade onwards.

Now, I should say that my father is very superstitious Roman Catholic. He introduced me to ESP and UFOs when I was only 5. He used to tell me stories about how there were aliens living under the polar ice caps, and how my grandmother's house had ghosts in it, and a whole slew of other things. My father is a high-school dropout, and a recovering alcoholic and narcotic drug addict. At the time that he was telling these stories, he was using continuously. (Thankfully, my father is 100% clean now)

These stories about ESP, ghosts, UFOs and the like naturally caught my imagination, so all through my childhood and teen years I read about them. I still didn't have any sort of religion, and the primary concept of a deity just sounded... weird. I find it funny now that all these other ideas didn't sound weird to me.

By the time I turned 13, I had quite a base knowledge in the arena of the supernatural/paranormal. I'm by nature an avid reader, and had exhausted both the public and school libraries, having read everything they had on hand about all of this, plus owning many books of my own. I became interested in some of the religions based around ESP and other supernatural practices, mainly Wicca and other pagan religions. I proclaimed myself pagan at the age of 15.

From that point onwards I began really working at things like Tarot, astrology, and ESP. I had lost interest in crop circles and UFOs, although I can't really explain why. I also had a keen interest in herbal remedies.

I went off to college at 19, after taking 2 years off from high school. I lived in an apartment with 4 other people. I did tarot readings for them a lot, and noticed I got "better" at it when I was thoroughly drunk, as opposed to sober. I wondered why that was, and couldn't figure it out. That question stayed in the back of my mind, unanswered.

I had to drop out of school after a year due to financial trouble. By this point I had a boyfriend and we lived together in a smaller apartment. I began going on "ghost hunts" with a mutual friend of ours named John, taking pictures and recordings, usually in graveyards. We never got anything. John insisted it was because our "energy" wasn't tuned right. I asked how you would tune it correctly, and he didn't answer me, just said something about the stars or something. I forget exactly what, because it sounded like utter crap to me even back then.

But, I kept trying. The most we ever got, after over a year of going out every other weekend on "hunts," was I got pelted with a few acorns from a direction where we both knew no one was. Creepy, but out of all that time, it still came up to squat.

I still believed though. It's amazing how strongly you hold onto a belief when you start to see it unravel. The more tenuous it is, the tighter you need to hold on, because if you let go you end up in uncharted territory where you don't know anything, and for someone like me, that's really frightening.

After that, I kind of gave up ghost hunting. I went on one more hunt in an old theatre with a group of "professionals" a couple years ago, but that was it. That one didn't give us much of anything either. Actually, it turned up nothing. Some pictures and video of dust wafting around, that they called "orbs." I hadn't heard of this "orb" theory before, so I pointed out nicely that it just looked like dust to me. They said no, dust looks two-dimensional on film, and this was THREE-dimensional, so it must be "spirit orbs." This sounded so odd I just had to nod my head and walk away, because if I didn't I think I would have laughed in their faces.

Shortly afterwards, I married the boyfriend I mentioned earlier. We're still going strong! :D

I began setting my sights on ESP and "magick," the magical prayer stuff of pagans, witches, and various other occultists. The occult world is a really varied one, and I actually do suggest reading up on it sometime if you're interested in that sort of thing. Just from a psychological point of view, it's fascinating.

I began "training" in psionics, and also working on casting spells and other mumbo-jumbo. I was still using Tarot, but had dropped astrology because I had figured out the Forer effect (though I didn't know it had a name) and was starting to find out that what I was doing with Tarot was cold reading, even though I didn't know that had a name either. I was slowly debunking myself.

The final year of my woo-woo days was almost a frantic grasping at straws, trying to find anything I could to believe in. I don't think it would have mattered what it was, as long as it was something.

I tried ceremonial magic, which was heralded by the Ordo Templi Orientis and Aleister Crowley, but it gave me nothing. What results I got were wholly within my own mind, and I knew it.

I stumbled across chaos magic accidentally. I found it very interesting, as the motto for that is "Nothing is true, everything is permitted. Everything is false, nothing is punished." On the surface, chaos is about finding what works and throwing the rest away. However, going deeper into the theory, it is fundamentally about manipulating belief and playing with your own mind.

I became a chaote, and began playing with the mechanics of my own belief. I created and destroyed more pantheons of gods than I think ever existed. It was fun, and I learned a lot about how my mind works. The downside, or upside depending on your point of view, was that practicing chaos magic brought me to the crux of the whole matter-- reality is truly what you believe it to be.

My personal reality could be changed at will with just a thought. It was exhilerating and scary, and it drove home the fact that it was ALL in my head. I didn't alter reality itself, only my perception of it.

With that knowledge, I began a journal of all my predictions, spells, and ESP practices. Over the course of about 9 months, I kept carefully logging everything I did and the results. After careful review, I realized that all I was really doing was pissing in the wind-- none of this DID anything except make me feel better. It made me feel like I had some control.

So, with that, I dropped it all. My full bookcase-and-a-half of new-age/supernatural books were sold to used bookshops or given away, I got rid of all my "magical" paraphernalia, and got myself enrolled in college. I'm now a nursing student (ADN/RN) with plans to go on and get a Master's in nursing anesthesia. I'd like to be part of medical research someday, and help make our world a better place.

Sometimes I miss having beliefs in these things. It feels kind of like homesickness. But I wouldn't go back to all those superstitions and woo-wooness if anyone paid me, because really I'm much happier now.

This story also explains my signature line, because of my systematic reduction of superstitions/beliefs to the point where there were none.

I'm an active skeptic now because, in training to become a medical professional, I've come to really hate the "alternative" health stuff that's out there. People die every year from scams like these, and I feel it's my duty to actively work against pseudo-scientific claims about cure-alls and snake oil and the like. Herbal remedies really upset me because they contain active chemicals, and can do serious damage. I don't like homeopathy, but at least plain water won't poison someone.



I hope you liked my really-way-too-long story. Maybe it'll help you see into the minds of believers a little bit better. They're not stupid, sometimes they just need something to believe in. ;)

***edit***

I forgot to mention the 3-4 months I spent researching "otherkin." Google it, it's the best.
Basically, "otherkin" are people claiming to be partially mythological, like part-elf, or part-dragon, or part-werewolf, or whatever. I never believed it, but it was... interesting.
 
I will ask you all not to ridicule anything in here.

Far from ridicule, I'd call this a heroic story displaying a difficult journey that few would complete. Kudos!
 
apoger said:
Far from ridicule, I'd call this a heroic story displaying a difficult journey that few would complete. Kudos!

Thank you. I'm just kind of shy about it still. I appreciate your kind words and support! :)
 
Nex said:
With that knowledge, I began a journal of all my predictions, spells, and ESP practices. Over the course of about 9 months, I kept carefully logging everything I did and the results. After careful review, I realized that all I was really doing was pissing in the wind
I agrree with apoger. You had the persistence and conscienciousness to prove yourself wrong: most people don't even try. Have another kudo for your collection.

Here's a fascinating piece by a lapsed New Ager who actually used to write books on it, before she sussed it out. Interesting quote:
For instance, an understanding of cold reading would have helped me a great deal. I never knew what cold reading was, and until I saw professional magician and debunker Mark Edward use cold reading on an ABC News special last year, I didn't understand that I had long used a form of cold reading in my own work! I was never taught cold reading and I never intended to defraud anyone - I simply picked up the technique through cultural osmosis.
 
Great story, thanks.

Just out of interest, how much money do you think you spent on new-age stuff?
 
Thank you again for your kind words. If this keeps up, I'll need a special basket to keep all my kudos in. :D

TheBoyPaj said:
Great story, thanks.

Just out of interest, how much money do you think you spent on new-age stuff?

Well, my interest spanned over almost 20 years. I have never had much money, so couldn't buy as much as some do. Books alone, probably a few thousand. I didn't spend much on other things though, as the new age community is very willing to share. For example, I had a scrying mirror that would probably fetch about $80 that was given to me for free.

Over all, I have no idea. Way too much money.

As an aside, the city I live in could very well be Woo Central of the Eastern US. You wouldn't believe all the organizations and shops here! We even have our very own mascot, Joshua P. Warren, who has cornered the market on all things "ghostie."

Asheville, NC, if you were curious... ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom