Are you a sceptic who used to Believe Weird Things?

apollo13 said:
Two things cleared my thinking: First thing: I had a dance with a (non-church-approved) girl at a local disco & the next day (literally) the story had got through to a couple of the great & good. Two of them came around (independently) to show how much they cared & offered to pray with me to help me "through the temptation".

Out of curiosity, was it the dancing or the girl, and was "non-church-approved" about her? Was she just not a member of your denomination, or was it something more prejudicial?

BTW, funny story about "tongue speakers." One day, back in college, I was strolling through the Student Union and I suddenly heard a blood-curdling scream coming from one of the conference rooms. Doing my civic duty, I went running in the direction of the scream to find out what was going on and what assistance I could render. Peeking inside the room I saw a bunch of students I knew where members of the local chapter of Campus Crusade For Christ standing around, eyes closed shut or staring out into space, mumbling, shouting or screaming incomprehensible nonsense with "amens" and "hallelujahs" thrown in.

Even though I was still a Christian (Roman Catholic) then, I backed out of the room veeeeeerrrrrry slllllooooowwwwlly.
 
Mark: The church was 'officially' denominated as just a plain old Methodist - nothing too radical in that. However, in the place where I was growing up (N Ireland), and at that particular time, there was a real 'grass roots' thing going on and it wasn't unusual for reasonably mainstream churches to have groups of fundamentalist hangers-on.

No idea what it's like any more though - suspect it hasn't changed to much. Anybody out there know any different?

... so when I said 'non church approved', I meant not a member of our particular group, nor affiliated to a similar group elsewhere established. She was actually a pretty decent sort if I remember correctly - the sort you could bring home to your mother. But not 'one of us'.

I have no idea which of 'dancing' or 'girl' bothered the high and mighty. I think it was the 'not one of us' that bothered them most.
 
And while we're on the subject of tongue speakers, I spent quite a bit of time last night wondering if my first post should be on this topic but posted on the "Ever seen something you couldn't explain" thread.

Because I really can't explain it.

But not quite in the sense operaider meant;)
 
fb,

flyboy217 said:
Which is why it's asinine, I think. This is different from "there is no known mechanism by which it can work," which is perfectly valid.
You are correct, of course. But....

flyboy217 said:
My point is that, should evidence come tomorrow that homeopathy works somehow, we (or at least I) would feel foolish having today just said "it is impossible, and there cannot be any mechanism by which it could ever work."
Do you really think this applies to homoeopathy? Do you think there is any risk at all that some day a mechanism for homoeopathy will be found? I mean, it's like saying that whenever I say "faeries do not exist", one faery dies. There is no known mechanism by which this could work, but there is also no real risk that a mechanism will ever be found.

The whole idea of homoeopathy is asinine.

bj
 
Formerly alt-woo

My confession: Back in the 1970's I had an intractable injury and since, over the years tried osteopathy, acupuncture, Feldenkrais exercises, yoga, meditation, massage therapy, chiropractic, Mattol and other juices, biofeedback therapy. Nothing helped. Later I found out that these treatments lacked both a good rationale and research evidence, and stopped blaming myself for their lack of success.

Now, I'll note that conventional treatment has not always helped either, and in the case of anti-inflammatory meds it caused me significant stomach problems.

But I now know it's a total non sequitur to say that, simply because "allopathic" medicine can have harmful side effects, one should try "alternative" medicine. The point is that in view of these side effects, anti-inflammatories drugs have changed since the 1970's. Conventional treatment, unlike alt-woo, PROGRESSES.

The one thing that has helped a LOT is, duh, ordinary physiotherapy -- ice, stretching, strengthening, trigger point release.

Older and wiser, but I wish I had the money back.
:)
 
BillyJoe said:


Do you really think this applies to homoeopathy?


I don't know.

Three simple words, upon which so much of scientific progress depends.

I acknowledge a lack of omniscience. I do not claim a supernatural awareness of the results, not only of experiments yet to be run, but yet to be designed. I consider it to be possible that someday, somewhere, someone even smarter than myself will be born, someone capable of looking at a problem with a previously alien insight, one capable of casting aside a few more shadows in this world that we see but through a glass, darkly.

Obviously, you're not bound by such limitations.

I hope I'm being suitably respectful in the presence of such a demideity as yourself, one who knows beforehand what experiments will be done five hundred years hence, one who can recite verbatim the contents of the textbooks from which students at Starfleet Academy will be taught.

However, I do ask a boon of you. Can you at least tell me what experiment will finally and completely falsify the theory that "homeopathy works"? If you're feeling generous, I'd like the name, dates, and publication information, too, so I can make a point of buying that journal when it comes out....
 
That's just given me an image of Beverly Crusher scanning a badly injured crew member, waving her medical tricorder over the injury then asking for 30cc of Rescue Remedy.

But seriously newdrkitten would you be so scathing if BillyJoe had said the same thing about belief in faries? The Loch Ness monster? Martians?
There is equal evidence for those as functioning homeopathy and science holds them all to be equally likely of future existence.

"I don't know" is one thing, but "We can be fairly sure" of quite a lot of things.

Science may take a purely objective view in saing we cannot ever fully rule X out, but we as people are entitled to an opinion backed up by every experiment ever caried out about a subject.

The idea of homeopathy IS asanine.
 
flyboy217 said:
Yes. But so is the statement that it "cannot possibly work."
Talking to a homeopath, useless. Down the pub, perfectly acceptable. Of course it can't bleedin' work. But round here, it's sensible to stick to the point that it doesn't work, otherwise you get accused of worshipping the laws of physics or sumpin.
 
Ashles said:
That's just given me an image of Beverly Crusher scanning a badly injured crew member, waving her medical tricorder over the injury then asking for 30cc of Rescue Remedy.

But seriously newdrkitten would you be so scathing if BillyJoe had said the same thing about belief in faries? The Loch Ness monster? Martians?
There is equal evidence for those as functioning homeopathy and science holds them all to be equally likely of future existence.

Yes, I would be equally scathing.

Which part of "I don't know" do you find it morally repugnant to admit?
 
new drkitten said:
Yes, I would be equally scathing.

Which part of "I don't know" do you find it morally repugnant to admit?

If EVERYONE was prepared to admit "I don't know", it would obviate a lot of meaningless argument, as I've said in the past elsewhere.

All the business of what is "possible", "may be possible" etc., is just as misleading as any definite article to the effect that "x IS y".

There are plenty who will argue that if we don't know something for a fact we should always say "well, it may be possible". WRONG! Because in reality they don't KNOW whether it is possible or not, and so even to say "It may be possible" is wrong, if in fact, they do not KNOW whether it may be possible.

"May be possible", means "it is possible that it is possible". Well it isn't, if in fact it is IMPOSSIBLE. But nobody knows that... So IMO less "it is possible" and less "it IS so", and more "it is unknown", all round would be better.

O.K. you guys can carry on now...! :D
 
It's got nothing to do with "I don't know" – everyone makes personal judgement calls as to how seriously they take certain claims.

If I told you I could make chocolate appear from the ends of my fingers would you accept that? Would you utterly disbelieve me? Would you say "Maybe that's true, I just don't know?"

The scientific method might require you to say option three but in true fact you would instantly disbelieve me and my claim, so stop trying to pretend you are being a true sceptic and super open-minded because you claim to treat all paranormal claims utterly equally.
No-one actually treats all these claims equally – everyone will have some claims they dismiss out of hand as being utterly stupid. Even the believers treat some claims with disdain.

This is how I treat homeopathy. You don't have to agree, but I think the whole field of homeopathy is a huge waste of time and I feel certain that nothing useful (other than some plaebo effects for mior ailments) will ever come of it.

Don't worry, I'm not in chage of global science, so the research will continue and if something comes of it then I'll turn out to have been wrong.

Which part of "having an opinion" do you find so scary?
 
Ashles said:

The scientific method might require you to say option three but in true fact you would instantly disbelieve me and my claim, so stop trying to pretend you are being a true sceptic and super open-minded because you claim to treat all paranormal claims utterly equally.

Gasp! You mean, I might actually believe something for which no formal proof exists?

Yeah. That's been my point from the first post in this thread. We all, skeptic and woo-woo alike, believe lots of things that haven't been proven true. And most scientific progress comes from the "skeptics" who believe things, albeit without proof, and the go on to investigate the question in depth, to search for evidence and "proof," and eventually find something.

This isn't to say that everything that people believe is true. People believe false things, too -- I'd probably even agree that more beliefs are false than are true. And if you were to ask me to place a bet on whether or not an actual effect will be found in homeopathy, I'd bet against. I'd even give substantial odds.

But I'm at least open to the possibility that I might lose the bet, and I have respect for the person who is genuinely trying to investigate whether or not homeopathy can be made to work. (How many substances did Edison go through before he came up with a working light filament?)

So then we get comments from Dr. Adequate like "someone who believes woo-woo stuff is no true sceptic." Dr. Adequate doesn't believe that it's even possible to research the question, because obviously continents don't move, and rocks never fall from the sky, and the Edison's first thirty experiments show that electrical light will never become possible. And Dr. Hawking becomes a woo-woo because he believed something that wasn't proven (remember Dr. A's definition of "wierd" as "unproven by the scientific method.").
 
Ashles said:
It's got nothing to do with "I don't know" – everyone makes personal judgement calls as to how seriously they take certain claims.

If I told you I could make chocolate appear from the ends of my fingers would you accept that? Would you utterly disbelieve me? Would you say "Maybe that's true, I just don't know?"

The scientific method might require you to say option three but in true fact you would instantly disbelieve me and my claim, so stop trying to pretend you are being a true sceptic and super open-minded because you claim to treat all paranormal claims utterly equally.
No-one actually treats all these claims equally – everyone will have some claims they dismiss out of hand as being utterly stupid. Even the believers treat some claims with disdain.

This is how I treat homeopathy. You don't have to agree, but I think the whole field of homeopathy is a huge waste of time and I feel certain that nothing useful (other than some plaebo effects for mior ailments) will ever come of it.

Don't worry, I'm not in chage of global science, so the research will continue and if something comes of it then I'll turn out to have been wrong.

Which part of "having an opinion" do you find so scary?

I don't know if you are addressing me or Dr Kitten.

If you are addressing me, then I don't disagree with you at all. I believe that certain claims are crap. I will continue to believe so unless/until the evidence appears to the contrary.

If you made the chocolate claim, I would personally say I don't believe it. However if someone asked me whether or not it was possible I would have to say "I don't know". I personally wouldn't feel inclined to say "it MAY be possible" if I simply had no evidence that it was true and I could see no way in which it COULD be possible.
 
But I'm at least open to the possibility that I might lose the bet, and I have respect for the person who is genuinely trying to investigate whether or not homeopathy can be made to work. (How many substances did Edison go through before he came up with a working light filament?)
This is what I don't understand - likening homeopathy (no part of which makes any sense in terms of real science) and Edison (whose work was entirely understandable within scientific knowledge - he merely discovered an excellent way of applying it).

Edison's inventions did not require an entire change in how we view the world or science. It's not really comparable.

Great leaps in scientific thinking have been made before by people with incredible theories which were not widely accepted and often thought to be incompatible with the observable universe.
But experimentation and repeated testing proved them to be right and the new knowledge was accepted into out thinking.

Homepathy has been around for 200 years without any successful evidence supporting it. How many other scientific breakthroughs have equated to that kind of negative evidence only to suddenly be found convincing?

And Dr Hawking does have some weird theories, some of which I believe even he has changed his mind about.
However we can research those theories and test them against observable data. If we did that for 200 years and what he claimed did not match the observed facts, I think we might draw conclusions that he was incorrect in his theories.
 
Pragmatist said:
Not if it ultimately turns out that it CANNOT possibly work...:D

Sort of like if it turns out that the universe will never end? Gonna have to be around for a loong time to prove that one, ya know?
 
Ashles said:

Homepathy has been around for 200 years without any successful evidence supporting it. How many other scientific breakthroughs have equated to that kind of negative evidence only to suddenly be found convincing?

Democritus and the atom?

The particle nature of light (which Newton conclusively demolished in the 1600s, only to see reborn in 1905)?





And Dr Hawking does have some weird theories, some of which I believe even he has changed his mind about. However we can research those theories and test them against observable data. If we did that for 200 years and what he claimed did not match the observed facts, I think we might draw conclusions that he was incorrect in his theories.

Yeah, we might draw conclusions. As long as you don't think that your conclusions are in any way definitive, absolute, or guaranteed to be experiment-proof, then you can draw conclusions in a lot less than 200 years.
 
flyboy217 said:
Sort of like if it turns out that the universe will never end? Gonna have to be around for a loong time to prove that one, ya know?

Ed, give me the wisdom to prove the things that can be proved, the serenity to not try proving that which cannot be proved, and the wisdom to know the difference! :D
 
The particle nature of light (which Newton conclusively demolished in the 1600s, only to see reborn in 1905)?
Are you writing this from poorly recalled memories or something?

Newton was a SUPPORTER of the particle theory of light:

From the Wikipedia entry on light
Pierre Gassendi, an atomist, proposed a particle theory of light which was published posthumously in the 1660s. Isaac Newton studied Gassendi's work at an early age, and preferred his view to Descartes' theory of the 'plenum'. He stated in his Hypothesis of Light of 1675 that light was composed of corpuscles (particles of matter) which were emitted in all directions from a source.

Also, as you can see work was continued by others in the meantime (Hooke, Huygens, Euler etc.). It wasn't a static research field by any means.

Finally, and this is the really important distinction, they were trying to form a theory to understand KNOWN OBSERVABLE EFFECTS.

This is totally different to homeopathy which does not have known effects to observe in the first instance. It's pointless trying to build a theory around an effect that has never been shown to exist.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom