Are you a sceptic who used to Believe Weird Things?

Dr Adequate

Banned
Joined
Aug 31, 2004
Messages
17,766
Are you a sceptic who used to Believe Weird Things?

If so, what Weird Thing did you believe? Why did you believe them? Why did you stop? Is this one of the reasons why you're an active sceptic?
 
I was a child once, I believed in Santa Claus, the tooth fairy, god, the easter bunny, etc.

I mean, what do you mean by 'weird things'? Seems like everyone has believed in something weird at one time or another, especially as a child or when younger.
 
Oh I believed in lots. UFOs (not specific ones, but the whole idea), precognition, telekinesis, lots of stuff.

Why? Well it was really exciting to be able to quote facts and dates at people to 'prove' your point. And they would invariably have stories of their own.

Now this was pretty harmless and I look back and think, well, whoever I was talking to they must have believed a bit too because no-one ever argues.

I never saw anything to give me any real evidence these things were real - it was all stories. Then I started hearing about these urban legends - those stories that everyone has been told are true but actually are totally made up.
The first one I was told was when I was 13 and it involved someone relaxing on their bed, listening to their headphones and a cup of tea brought by their mother. I won't go into the details (it's a bit rude) but it's a fairly well known story.

Anyway, a couple of years later I was told the exacty same story by someone else whose friend it had happened to. This got me suspicious and my suspicion about these 'well known facts' has continued ever since. I discovered that many well known truths (the violence on a full moon, the LA gangbangers and their lights, the police using psychics etc.) were not true. In some cases they were half-truths, but mostly entirely made up.

The difference is research and considering all the aspects of a story. The more I look into these things the less plausible they seem. Now with the internet we can look at many different stories from many sides with relative ease and have access to scientific studies and references that would have been much more time-consuming to find before.

The evidence just goes against paranormal phenomena again and again.

And I won't even start on my time working in a holistic healig centre...
 
I used to be a christian, so I believed many weird things associated with that. I also used to believe that there were psychics that the government kept hidden from people. I've grown up to realize how silly those beliefs are.
 
If the belief in UFOs is weird, then I was one of them. A catholic altarboy also (though I've never been molested by a priest to the best of my knowlege)

I was (and still is) a sci-fi nut and I desperately wanted to believe in extraterrestial life. I read every UFO publication that was printed in the 70s and 80s. All that Van Daneken (sp?) stuff too.

It wasn't untill I started seeing russian space technology being labeled as "alien autopsy tables" and such that I began to think that the publishers of the magazines and books were just out to get my hard earned allowance money. After that I started questioning the things I was reading. Then Sagan's Cosmos series started to run on PBS. That changed my life. I became a skeptic and never looked back. (although I still hold a candle out for intelligent extraterrestial life.)
 
I used to believe in psychics, aura readings, ghosts, etc. Why did I stop? In short, I grew up. Sure, I was already in my early 30's when it happened, but it's never too late.
 
Marian said:
I was a child once, I believed in Santa Claus, the tooth fairy, god, the easter bunny, etc. I mean, what do you mean by 'weird things'? Seems like everyone has believed in something weird at one time or another, especially as a child or when younger.
I don't really count the lies grown-ups tell to children. Unless you go on believing them when you're grown up, of course. "Weird" --- million dollar stuff. Y'know. Weird as in "weird". It's hard to define, but you know it when you see it. Or hear unsubstantiated anecdotes about it.
 
I took some Scientology courses and did some auditing.

Used to waste 50 bucks a week at the chiropractor

Used to put vitamin E on cuts to prevent scars from forming.

used to swear by ketogenic diets

Then the internet came and a world of info and research was at my fingertips.
 
I, by the way, am an ex-xian. And I should like to say that I believed in the immortality of the soul, the resurrection of the dead, that Jesus loved me, that I would go to heaven, that there was an omnipresent all-powerful force for good in the universe, that deep down everything makes sense, that Jesus walked on water, and that "now we see as through a glass darkly, then we shall seee him face to face". I was open-minded about the Rapture. Whereas you wasted your credulity on chiropractors? All that gullibility, just thrown away.

Why did I deconvert? Well, you may have noticed that in that little list there is ONE statement that's testable, and unfortunately it's the crucial one.
 
Used to believe in psychics and the like, but never UFOs coming to earth. Then I started looking at the other people that believed in those things and it scared me straight.
 
I always asked questions. I still do.

I accepted, by being told, the idea of a soul, etc, until I got old enough to examine the idea for itself. I read a lot of UFO literature when I was a teenager, my BS meter saturated about after the first book, I mean, if there are that many of them around, etc, etc.

So in some sense, I guess I started to "believe" things, but I seem more minded to accept anything provisionally until something with clearer evidence and/or formulation (that fits the present evidence) comes along.
 
Marian said:
I was a child once, I believed in Santa Claus, the tooth fairy, god, the easter bunny, etc.

I mean, what do you mean by 'weird things'? Seems like everyone has believed in something weird at one time or another, especially as a child or when younger.

What Marian said. I was brought up with the usual lore of the religions that inhabited Thailand and South East Asia - Ghosts, spirits, the afterlife, burnt offerings, Chinese Gods, etc etc, and I unfortunately didn't start thinking much about them until I came to Hong Kong in my mid-childhood years and reality gradually began to sink in.
 
When I was in high school, back in the early 60's, I loved all that UFO, Strange Tales, Charles Fort sort of thing. They had pictures!

That one guy actually talked with the aliens, and went up in the mother ship! Pretty heady stuff to a 14-15 year old.

Gradually, my other love, science, came to the rescue.
 
I was raised in a Southern Baptist household, what kind of weird things do you think I believed in?

Add to that:
* Alien abductions
* Telekinesis
* Psychic Communication
* Precognition

Fortunately I never bought into spoon-bending...
 
I was lucky and grew up in a skeptical household (but my parents never interfered with my reading), but I believed in UFO's and Monsters (Loch Ness, bigfoot, Ogopogo) until I was 9 or 10 and we got the internet....first sight I ever looked up was http://www.csicop.org
 
I'm in the minority. I did believe in Santa Claus untill I was 12 or so. I went to Catholic School, but I never took the bait. I was luke warm until about 5th grade. I learned the term atheist around 9th grade and it fit. Never saw an alien so I assumed that it was just stories. Same with ghosts.
And I'm a little smart and only half educated.
In short, I've never believed easily.
I got lucky.
 
I used to do tarot when I was in University. Hey! It seemed to work! (Although I was never really sure if I knew the right ideas for the right cards, but it didn't seem to matter so long as I was sincere)

I remember when Geller used to be on British TV a lot more, and our whole family sat around trying to bend our cutlery.

So, yeah. I guess I feel like a bit of a fool.
 
I'm an only child and my parents were believers. Yoga, reincarnation, healing, auras, telepathy, clairvoyance, astrology, pyramid power, Bermuda Triangle, UFOs (abductions were never vogue in Denmark), von Däniken ..... well, I think that mostly covers it.

And I loved Sci-Fi, still do.

My disenchantment started, I think, with pyramid power. I had started an education on engineering, and I read this book about pyramid power, and I saw that most of the explanations were mumbo-jumbo.

Then I reread von Däniken and started to trace his stories in other sources, and I thought: "WTF? The man is a liar, and he is speculating wildly!"

Then I researched the Bermuda Triangle stories and found them 50% fiction (and 50% normal events). As I became better educated, I realized just how unlikely the UFO stories were. From then on the walls were crumbling fast.

I think what took me the longest time to adjust to, in fact is still surprises me, is that people are able to, metaphorically, look straight at something and not see it, and that they will lie straight in your face. Its not that I never lie myself, but I do my best to avoid it, and I feel bad when I do lie.

So, according to my personal experience, a believer can be made to see the light. Perhaps that is the reason I am usually quite patient in debates here. I actually think there is a chance to put a wedge into the wall of delusion.


Hans
 
As I child I believed strongly in ESP. Magzines like The Unexplained fed my belief, and I’d buy books like “World’s Greatest Mysteries/Ghosts/UFOs” and stuff like that. I was also into palm-reading for a while. My scepticism was sparked by the fact that different books on the subject said different things. Then one day I was doing a reading for someone and the person standing next to us said “That’s amazing, you’ve described me perfectly!” That shut me up, and I dropped paml-reading and parapsychology for the next ten years or so.

In that time I turned to popular science books, and found that the stories they told were (and are) much more interesting than the stuff I’d read in parapsychology books. Then I read a web site about the Shakespeare forgeries and that got me interested in fakes, which lead to Piltdown Man, which lead to creationism, which led me to the JREF and back to parapsychology.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom