Are you a sceptic who used to Believe Weird Things?

Nex said:
With that knowledge, I began a journal of all my predictions, spells, and ESP practices. Over the course of about 9 months, I kept carefully logging everything I did and the results.
Hooray, double hooray, and yippee! At last, someone realizes that using your memory to recall the results is completely inadequate.

Thanks for telling your great story and welcome!

~~ Paul
 
I'm going to bust out laughing soon since i looked up otherkin. The first link from google was nearly too much.

I think I was a bit like you, Nex. I never went that far into it, but I had a decent collection of books by Crowley and ceremonial magic and the like. It was always about wanting to believe something like that for me. Congrats on breaking the spell as it were and count a couple of kudos from me for your basket.
 
new drkitten said:
Surely there should be a choice for "I am a skeptic who still believes in weird things." Is there no one on this forum who believes in Quantum Mechanics or the Continuum Hypothesis?

Seriously, though. "Weird" is in the eye (and vocabulary) of the beholder; a lot of the beliefs that most of us take quite seriously will be considered "weird" by others. Most importantly, "skeptic" does not mean "disbeliever." It's quite possible to believe something without evidence, while still searching (critically) for that evidence.

I like this tack. Dr. Adequate, thoughts?
 
flyboy217 said:
I like this tack. Dr. Adequate, thoughts?
OK, most of the world is extremely weird, OK. But for the purposes of this thread, it's not weird if it's been proved true by the scientific method.

I mean, that's what's wrong with woos really. They're motivated, just like scientists, to find out new things which are necessarily a bit weird, or at least rather surprising, 'cos if they weren't, we'd already know about them. They want to push the frontiers of knowledge, but they go about it the wrong way. When they go about it the right way (Merrissa, Nex) they lose faith in pseudoscience and gain faith in real science. (Or they discover that The Scientific Method Doesn't Work And Is Probably Evil...)
 
Temporal Renegade said:
Yes, I used to be a Van Daniken-ite; ancient astronauts? UFO roads in Peru? Atlantis, built by (then destroyed by) aliens? Seemed reasonable...

Then a VERY attractive girl in school one day asked me why I believed in them, and if I ever looked up any alternate theories or reasons concerning them. I looked, and Lo! was blinded by the Light O' Truth.
And I saw her FACE... Now I'm NOT A BELIEVER... There's a TRACE... of DOUBT in my MIND...

Clearly what the world needs is more pretty scepchicks.
 
Dr Adequate said:
Here's a fascinating piece by a lapsed New Ager who actually used to write books on it, before she sussed it out. Interesting quote:

Thanks for the link! Her story parallels my own in some ways.

From that page:

I know he would not like to hear this, but it's still true: James Randi's behavior and demeanor were so culturally insensitive that he actually created a gigantic backlash against skepticism, and a gigantic surge toward the New Age that still rages unabated.

This is so true. The animosity towards Randi and the skeptical community in general is so strong and so blind... for True Believersâ„¢, there's nothing Randi or the skeptics can say or do that will make them listen. They firmly believe that the skeptical community as a whole has a vendatta against The Truthâ„¢. It's really scary how closed-minded and vitriolic the new age/occult community can get, the moment you mention "skeptic" or "Randi."
 
Dr Adequate said:
OK, most of the world is extremely weird, OK. But for the purposes of this thread, it's not weird if it's been proved true by the scientific method.

So you'll get back to me as soon as the scientific method "proves" something true, will you?

Oh, I guess you didn't mean "prove." You meant "currently provisionally accepted by the scientific establishment until someone else comes along with a new set of experimental evidence that blows what we currently believe to be true into tiny, little, disproven fragments lying helplessly on the floor gasping for breath and wondering what's happened to them." Well, I can understand your wanting to use an abbreviation, since that's a bit long-winded.

The problem is, by a strict reading of the definition of "not wierd" above, every practicing scientist believes in wierd things -- things that haven't been proven true, things for which no evidence may yet exist, but things for which the scientist is actively (and critically) searching for that evidence. Almost all of the Nobel Prizes in the sciences have been given to skeptics who believed in wierd things, skeptics who had the balls (and brains) to take their beliefs seriously and to look for evidence regarding the truth of their beliefs.

And, of course, who had the luck to have their wierd beliefs come out true. But we don't know which wierd beliefs will come out to be true until after we've done the experiments. Heck, there may actually be some predictive validity to astrology -- we just haven't done any experiments yet that demonstrate it.


I mean, that's what's wrong with woos really. They're motivated, just like scientists, to find out new things which are necessarily a bit weird, or at least rather surprising, 'cos if they weren't, we'd already know about them. They want to push the frontiers of knowledge, but they go about it the wrong way. When they go about it the right way (Merrissa, Nex) they lose faith in pseudoscience and gain faith in real science. (Or they discover that The Scientific Method Doesn't Work And Is Probably Evil...)

I think you're right that they're going about it the wrong way. But I think you're overlooking a third option -- some people, when they discover that their beliefs don't stand up to the current scientific set of beliefs neither lose faith in science nor in their beliefs, but instead sit down and try to design and run better experiments. I'd also suggest that "skeptics who believe wierd things" quite well describes this third group, and that they're the ones who generate the most interesting and influential science.
 
new drkitten said:
So you'll get back to me as soon as the scientific method "proves" something true, will you? ]Oh, I guess you didn't mean "prove." You meant "currently provisionally accepted by the scientific establishment until someone else comes along with a new set of experimental evidence that blows what we currently believe to be true into tiny, little, disproven fragments lying helplessly on the floor gasping for breath and wondering what's happened to them."
It's not happened yet... instead, our knowledge of nature is progressively refined... but if you know that the laws of nature are going to change tomorrow, tell Randi.
The problem is, by a strict reading of the definition of "not wierd" above, every practicing scientist believes in wierd things -- things that haven't been proven true, things for which no evidence may yet exist, but things for which the scientist is actively (and critically) searching for that evidence.

No. They don't BELIEVE them. They TEST them as hypotheses. They BELIEVE them when the predictions are validated.

Almost all of the Nobel Prizes in the sciences have been given to skeptics who believed in wierd things
This is an oxymoron. Perhaps you are confusing "skeptics who believed in wierd things" with "scientists who test new hypotheses" which, so far from being an oxymoron, is a tautology.
and to look for evidence regarding the truth of their beliefs.
Can you say "HYPOTHESES"?
But we don't know which wierd beliefs will come out to be true until after we've done the experiments.
And since we don't know until we've done the experiment, we don't BELIEVE, and we call it a HYPOTHESIS.
Heck, there may actually be some predictive validity to astrology -- we just haven't done any experiments yet that demonstrate it.
[church-of-harry-potter mode]So you'll get back to me as soon as the scientific method "demonstrates" something true, will you? Oh, I guess you didn't mean "demonstrate." You meant "currently provisionally accepted by the scientific establishment until someone else comes along with a new set of experimental evidence that blows what we currently believe to be true into tiny, little, disproven fragments lying helplessly on the floor gasping for breath and wondering what's happened to them."[/church-of-harry-potter mode]

We've done lots of experiments which WOULD demonstrate astrology if true.
I think you're right that they're going about it the wrong way. But I think you're overlooking a third option -- some people, when they discover that their beliefs don't stand up to the current scientific set of beliefs neither lose faith in science nor in their beliefs, but instead sit down and try to design and run better experiments.
I'm not sure I follow you. Do you mean that when they find that the scientific method invalidates their beliefs, they adopt a different methodology? Agreed, people do that. They are woo-woos. That's what makes them woo-woos. To make new science, you've got to work with what's there: there is no methodological leap into the blue. Would that there were!
 
I grew up on miracle stories by people like von Däniken and Berlitz, thought they were fascinating. But as I remember it, I wasn't into it in the sense that I regarded them as truthfull, rather that they were just fascinating. And I vaguely remember Uri Geller's performance on Swedish television -- nothing happend in our house so I was a bit disappointed.

As most people in Sweden, I was taking part in the traditional (lutheran protestant state) church ceremonies but my priest in confirmation class -- I was 14 -- considered me a pain in the a_s because of the questions I asked. I think that was my break with mysticism. At the time, it wasn't all that conscious -- more of a revolution in line with me turning into a punk rocker and holding The Clash and The Jam in higher regard than the almighty.

My "skepticism" developed from an interest in 19th century history and I guess I was hooked when I opened Flim-Flam.

And there ain't no turning back... ;o)

Best regards,
Chateaubriand
 
I never bougft into religious thinking. I had a voracious appetite for scientific books and magazines, as well as science fiction, since the earliest grades.

But in high school, back in the 60s, I did believe that flying saucers were real. I had doubts about the claims that the government was covering things up, but only because I was too naive to belive the government would lie (this was before the Gulf of Tonkin fiasco). The concept of extraterrestial beings seemed plausible. It was exciting to think we were on the verge of contact with an alien civilization. It was a very topical theme. My 9th grade science teacher, who inspired and encouraged me in so many ways, was, saddly, a believer himself, and encouraged us to keep an open mind. After a few years at college I learned about all the logical fallacies and realized that the UFO hype was nothing but unsupported hysteria.

My college years was also around the emergence of all the "New Age" crap. I knew a lot of people who believed in OBEs and witchcraft, etc. Mysticism was also popular at the time. Parapsychology was fairly new and full of promise. It was a turbulent time, and for awhile I droped out of engineering and became a liberal arts student. I wanted to believe there was some truth to it all, but I was never able to find any hard evidence for any of it. Just the standard anecdotes, third hand reports, and false logic.

Martin Gardiner, through his scientific American column and books, was one influence that helped me learn to think clearly. Eventually I discovered my passion for computer programming and happily returned to a technical curriculum. By that time I had a much deeper understanding of, and faith in, the scientific method.

Years later, alarmed at the continued rise in fuzzy thinking (and media profiteering off the gullible), I discovered the skeptical community - a welcome island of light in an increasingly crazy world.
 
Dr Adequate said:

No. They don't BELIEVE them. They TEST them as hypotheses. They BELIEVE them when the predictions are validated.

This is an oxymoron. Perhaps you are confusing "skeptics who believed in wierd things" with "scientists who test new hypotheses" which, so far from being an oxymoron, is a tautology.

Never met many scientists, have you?

I don't think I've ever met a scientist who didn't believe, personally, in the major hypothesis she or he was currently working on. There are just too many true things left to be discovered to be wasting time looking for things that you expect to be untrue.

We had a very good example in the international press only a few months ago. John Preskill won a bet (and an encyclopedia) from Stephen Hawking about whether information can escape from a black hole.

There's even a a formal statement from the parties involved available on the web. Note the phrasing: "Whereas Stephen Hawking and Kip Thorne firmly believe that," and "whereas John Preskill firmly believes that."

So which party do you think was lying and didn't actually hold the belief they attribute to themselves?

Edited for crucial typo fix
 
Dr Adequate said:

I think that you and I are using the word "believe" in radically different ways.

Perhaps. But I also suggest that my use of the word "believe" is in accord with the use given to it by Drs. Hawking, Preskill, and Thorne -- as well as as standard philosophical and linguistic usage.

Encyclopediae aren't cheap, and Hawking isn't a stupid man. Hawking wouldn't have made that bet if he didn't expect to win it. At the time he made the bet he almost certainly held the statement "information cannot escape from a black hole" to be true, even though he didn't have scientifically valid evidence to support the belief, and even though the statement eventually turned out to be false.

So, I'm using the word "believe" in its conventional sense of "hold to be true." The OED supports me in this definition ["To give credence to, to accept (a statement) as true; With clause or equivalent inf. phrase: To hold it as true that... ." (Emphasis drkitten)]. How are you using it?
 
new drkitten said:
So, I'm using the word "believe" in its conventional sense of "hold to be true." The OED supports me in this definition ["To give credence to, to accept (a statement) as true; With clause or equivalent inf. phrase: To hold it as true that... ." (Emphasis drkitten)]. How are you using it?
To hold it as proven that...

If you want to argue over linguistic minutiae, try Interesting Ian.
 
Dr Adequate said:
To hold it as proven that...

If you want to argue over linguistic minutiae, try Interesting Ian.

It seems to me that this is more than simply linguistic minutiae (although I myself would try CFLarsen).

If you were to ask Dr. Hawking, Dr. Thorne, or Dr. Preskill if they "believed" their ideas to be true, all would (in fact did) answer "yes." I would imagine that beliefs (as such) are necessary for conviction. And conviction seems crucial for success, especially at the edges of science where little is known.

That's what baffles me about much of what I read here. Here it seems almost implied that, to be a skeptic, one must have beliefs that paranormal things are not true. For example, in the spoon bending thread, I thought the anecdotal evidence was strong enough to support sending my friends to such a party. For this, I was practically labeled a "woo woo." Even after I went myself, investigated, and posted a debunk of it, I was harangued (if you'll recall).

I do not believe that "paranormal" events are false, and I also do not believe they are true. But I do believe that, if one really hoped to make any progress in paranormal research, he would have to have beliefs (or at least convictions) in the sense that other scientists do.
 
flyboy217 said:
That's what baffles me about much of what I read here. Here it seems almost implied that, to be a skeptic, one must have beliefs that paranormal things are not true.
No, but you mustn't have beliefs that they are true. Recall that the distinction between the woo-woo and the normal is lack of evidence, nothing else. So someone who believes woo-woo stuff is no true sceptic. Someone who doesn't positively disbelieve, fine. I don't think the yeti etc have been proved nonexistent. Flying saucers? It could happen... But I don't Believe in them.
For example, in the spoon bending thread, I thought the anecdotal evidence was strong enough to support sending my friends to such a party. For this, I was practically labeled a "woo woo." Even after I went myself, investigated, and posted a debunk of it, I was harangued (if you'll recall).
I do. I chastised CFLarsen with my Powers Of Adequacy... but he was the only one carrying on like that, everyone else was on your side. And it must have occurred to you that this is nothing personal, CFL just has a lot of troll blood in him and can't help it.
I do not believe that "paranormal" events are false, and I also do not believe they are true. But I do believe that, if one really hoped to make any progress in paranormal research, he would have to have beliefs (or at least convictions) in the sense that other scientists do.
No, you can be for or against it, so long as your experimental protocol was right. I've proved things my gut told me were false, it didn't matter, evidence is evidence. And as Carl Sagan, I think it was, said: "I try not to think with my guts". The proof of the earliest good wave theory of light was proved by someone trying to debunk it, I seem recall, though irritatingly I've forgotten the names of the two guys involved... anyone?
 
Dr Adequate said:
I do. I chastised CFLarsen with my Powers Of Adequacy... but he was the only one carrying on like that, everyone else was on your side. And it must have occurred to you that this is nothing personal, CFL just has a lot of troll blood in him and can't help it.

The problem is that it is more dangerous than that. He is one of the most vocal members here--and he even has his own website. For anyone already predisposed to disbelieve in the paranormal (and who doesn't like ridiculing woo woos, right?), and who perhaps cannot be arsed to really think through the discussion, one might actually not see anything wrong with the harrassing.

I admit I'm not knowledgable enough about the skeptical community to know whether such attacks are generally applauded or frowned upon. From my few months of posting, I would have leaned toward the former. I was (pleasantly) surprised to not see more people joining his nonsense attacks.


No, you can be for or against it, so long as your experimental protocol was right. I've proved things my gut told me were false, it didn't matter, evidence is evidence. And as Carl Sagan, I think it was, said: "I try not to think with my guts". The proof of the earliest good wave theory of light was proved by someone trying to debunk it, I seem recall, though irritatingly I've forgotten the names of the two guys involved... anyone?

I would think that the people in the best position to design the experimental protocols are the ones who have strong convictions (if not beliefs) about it. It can also be argued that they would leave open the most room for fraud/deception/cheating/etc. So it also seems appropriate that their methodology should be inspected carefully by disinterested third parties. But I still believe that the design of those experiments is best left up to those who "believe" in them, and that they should not be ridiculed for it.
 
Dr Adequate said:
No, but you mustn't have beliefs that they are true. Recall that the distinction between the woo-woo and the normal is lack of evidence, nothing else. So someone who believes woo-woo stuff is no true sceptic. Someone who doesn't positively disbelieve, fine. I don't think the yeti etc have been proved nonexistent. Flying saucers? It could happen... But I don't Believe in them.

... and I still think you're being unnecessarily narrow-minded, to the point of being simply wrong. Consider the person who wrote the SETI@home program, as an example. Basically, what you're saying is that if this person actively disbelieves in life elsewhere in the universe and wrote this program to shut believers up, then he's a skeptic. If this person doesn't hold an opinion, then he's still a skeptic. But if this person believes that there is life elsewhere in the universe and wrote this program to test whether or not the belief is true, then suddenly he's no longer a skeptic?

I disagree vehemently.

What distinguishes a woo-woo, in my opinion, is not evidence (or lack of evidence), but one's reaction to the evidence that exists. A skeptic will respond to an open question (one for which no clear-cut evidence exists) by searching for evidence. A skeptic will also revise her opinion when presented with evidence. But a proper skeptic is also suspicious of the evidence itself.

Just as an example, you claimed earlier that "we've done lots of experiments which WOULD demonstrate astrology if true." If you're really a scientist, as you claim, you should know that we've done nothing of the sort. We've refuted many specific claims about astrology. We've also seen astrologers squirm on the hook, twisting like crazed weasels, as they explain that "my method is different, I don't make those sorts of claims," etc. But exactly because every claim is different, you can't make a blanket statement that "this experiment WOULD demonstrate astrology is true." Showing that claim X is false does not, of itself, disprove claim Y. That's the classic "black swan" fallacy --- I don't care how many white swans you show me, but you will never demonstrate the non-existence of black swans.

Similarly, it doesn't matter how many dowsers Randi tests; there's always the possibility that, although the last thousand have been misguided charlatans, the thousand and first will be The Real McCoy. That's why he keeps testing. Someday, he may find that person and have to give away his million -- and a proper skeptic will adjust his opinion about whether or not dowsing works. A proper skeptic is also aware of this, and doesn't make asinine statements about how dowsing (or astrology) can't possibly work, because a proper skeptic is well aware of how a single well-done and replicable experiment can annihilate such a statement.
 
new drkitten said:
... and I still think you're being unnecessarily narrow-minded, to the point of being simply wrong. Consider the person who wrote the SETI@home program, as an example. Basically, what you're saying is that if this person actively disbelieves in life elsewhere in the universe and wrote this program to shut believers up, then he's a skeptic. If this person doesn't hold an opinion, then he's still a skeptic. But if this person believes that there is life elsewhere in the universe and wrote this program to test whether or not the belief is true, then suddenly he's no longer a skeptic?
People who live in straw houses shouldn't huff and puff. That's not what I said. And a singularly inept example: given the best we know about how life evolved, there should be some more of it out there. The person who proclaims that the rest of the universe is sterile would be a woo, and almost certainly a Creationist woo.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom