Dr Adequate said:
No, but you mustn't have beliefs that they are true. Recall that the distinction between the woo-woo and the normal is lack of evidence, nothing else. So someone who believes woo-woo stuff is no true sceptic. Someone who doesn't positively disbelieve, fine. I don't think the yeti etc have been proved nonexistent. Flying saucers? It could happen... But I don't Believe in them.
... and I still think you're being unnecessarily narrow-minded, to the point of being simply wrong. Consider the person who wrote the SETI@home program, as an example. Basically, what you're saying is that if this person actively disbelieves in life elsewhere in the universe and wrote this program to shut believers up, then he's a skeptic. If this person doesn't hold an opinion, then he's still a skeptic. But if this person believes that there is life elsewhere in the universe and wrote this program to test whether or not the belief is true, then suddenly he's no longer a skeptic?
I disagree vehemently.
What distinguishes a woo-woo, in my opinion, is not evidence (or lack of evidence), but one's reaction to the evidence that exists. A skeptic will respond to an open question (one for which no clear-cut evidence exists) by searching for evidence. A skeptic will also revise her opinion when presented with evidence. But a proper skeptic is also suspicious of the evidence itself.
Just as an example, you claimed earlier that "we've done lots of experiments which WOULD demonstrate astrology if true." If you're really a scientist, as you claim, you should know that we've done nothing of the sort. We've refuted many specific claims about astrology. We've also seen astrologers squirm on the hook, twisting like crazed weasels, as they explain that "my method is different, I don't make those sorts of claims," etc. But exactly because every claim is different, you can't make a blanket statement that "this experiment WOULD demonstrate astrology is true." Showing that claim X is false does not, of itself, disprove claim Y. That's the classic "black swan" fallacy --- I don't care how many white swans you show me, but you will never demonstrate the
non-existence of black swans.
Similarly, it doesn't matter how many dowsers Randi tests; there's always the possibility that, although the last thousand have been misguided charlatans, the thousand and first will be The Real McCoy. That's why he keeps testing. Someday, he may find that person and have to give away his million -- and a proper skeptic will adjust his opinion about whether or not dowsing works. A proper skeptic is also aware of this, and doesn't make asinine statements about how dowsing (or astrology) can't possibly work, because a proper skeptic is well aware of how a single well-done and replicable experiment can annihilate such a statement.