Are you a sceptic who used to Believe Weird Things?

I was pretty much the same curious kid you guys were.In elementary school I just couldn't find any interest in books of fiction.So I would read the sports bios,it wasn't long before I had read all of them,some twice.So then i'd read about Abe Lincoln etc.After awhile the only "non fiction"books left were of ufo's,bigfoot,Bermuda Triangle,mindreading etc.I spent a good three months trying it myself.In search of was one of my favs also.What finally got me was when my mother would spend days doing someones chart for astrology.We debated off and on for a week about it,she still believes,that was it for me Iwas about 14. She loves Sylvia,I e-mailed her a link to JREF and Internet Infidels,she probably took one glance and didn't want her "boat rocked".
 
Ashles
Just because I've heard of them before doesn't mean they are ruled out - correct , but that's not why I've already ruled them out.
This is how I feel I can rule them out :
She was tested for exhaustively for magnets and threads.
The container would have guarded against air-currents.
She moved objects which are too heavy to move by static charges alone & also levitated certain objects as well as just sliding and rolling them.
You say there could be other forms of trickery involved - Someone name them.
I wouldn't want to ask the medium's permission to record - if the medium was fake they might be angry, if they were genuine they might permit it but could take offence at scepticism as well as other believers, most of them are sensitive by nature.

Loki
What do you mean by a better class of medium ?
Just out of interest, what kind of psychic did you visit ?
A psychic as in a medium ?
A palmist ?
A tarot consultant ?
An oracle / rune interpreter ?
A tea leaf reader ?
An astrologer ?
An all round psychic ?
 
"Just because I've heard of them before doesn't mean they are ruled out - correct , but that's not why I've already ruled them out.
This is how I feel I can rule them out :
She was tested for exhaustively for magnets and threads."

You claim she was tested, based on what you have read - as I have said before, the tests appeared very amateur.

"The container would have guarded against air-currents."

But not against magnets or threads. Watch the video again.

"She moved objects which are too heavy to move by static charges alone & also levitated certain objects as well as just sliding and rolling them."

Well we still haven't ruled out magnets or threads. Or the method by which the guy in the video lit a suspended cigarette. Have you come up with an explanation for that?

"You say there could be other forms of trickery involved - Someone name them."

I don't know all forms of tricks, eg, the one I've just mentioned with the cigarette.

"I wouldn't want to ask the medium's permission to record - if the medium was fake they might be angry, if they were genuine they might permit it but could take offence at scepticism as well as other believers, most of them are sensitive by nature."

Nice cop-out. Standard stuff though. Why would their sensitivity be bothered by a recording?
They all tend to be very 'sensitive' about their readings, then turn quite agressive and rude when you question them. That's my personal experience.

It is clear that you want to believe. The reason I find this to be a shame is that if you did as much research into a scientific subject as you do into psychic ability you would probably be a real help to some university. You could run tests and discover real things.

Things discovered by science:
Television
Radio
Trains, planes and automobiles
Space travel
Computers
Heart bypass operations
Chemotherapy
Telephones
Central heating
etc.

Things discovered by a belief in psychic ability:
- - - -

I don't wish to sound harsh but an obsession with unproven phenomena seems a waste of a decent intellect. No-one is saying you can't believe what you like, but to reject all possible alternatives has been a mental dead-end for many people. People I have known.

I am curious as to what your plans are in life. Because an obsession with this stuff (whether it is real or not) could really hinder you.
 
The criteria for such tests is "controlled conditions". As we have been so clearly shown by Randi, Joe Nickel, and others, the concept tends to be a little loose in the supposedly pragmatic Soviet states. PBS's Nova did a nice 2-hour segment on Randi's investigations in the former Soviet Union.
In fact, the lack of acumen in investigating these things is shocking. Randi attributes it to living under a totalitarian state for so long; folks are conditioned to believe and accept.

Geller's stunts were impressive enough to fool supposedly hard-nosed physicists and other scientists, but professional conjurors quickly saw through them, and were able to duplicate and even surpass them.
Randi says that having professional conjurors present should be a standard of all such testing.
 
RE: Testing of 'psychics' and 'mediums'

Testing needs to be double-blind, independent, and tightly controlled, and even then a talented conjuror may still slip the noose -this has happened repeatedly throughout 150 years of modern 'psychic' research and testing. Scientists know physical law, scientific method, and how to design and implement proper controlled testing, but unfortunately, their education and experience does not prepare them for the possibility of a test lab rat with an agenda to fool the tester -this is where the need for conjurers comes in. This combination is much more likely to effect the necessary controls. Still, a skilled con artist may still fool.

One test cannot stand alone. Successful 'psychic' tests must be replicated by yet other independent testers. Each successful testing lends data which allows new theories as to what is occurring, new theories for which new tests are designed, which in turn, if successful, produce new data, still newer theories, new tests, and so on until a new science emerges. I wouldn't hold your breath for another 150 years waiting on this process.

Testing of psychics which fails to deduce the tricks used is often contrived by the psychic and his/her agents themselves, a shill or ringer situation. Also, those 'researchers' who thrust themselves to the front of the "we'll test you!" line when a new 'psychic' star emerges are usually hopeless bleevers -they are merely advocates wearing false robes of 'science' and 'objectivity'. The history of psychic investigation is rife with hilarious episodes of inept researchers, tests, etc. (A must read on this history is "A Skeptic's Handbook Of Parapsychology" edited by Paul Kurtz, publ. Prometheus Books).

To have some psychic from Russia pass dubious tests by unknown 'scientists', particularly from behind the once-Iron Curtain where pseudoscience is an Olympic sport, is hardly surprising nor impressive. To afford these 'successes' any weight you have to make grand leaps of trust in an unknown and unknowable set of researchers, plus trust the source of the reports of their efforts. Pravda? lol. Oh, I don't think 'truth' enters the picture.

~*~

Does it never occur to psychic bleevers that these so-called psychic powers have led to precisely and absolutely zero practical applications? There is zero historical precedent for such a miraculous power leading to anything of practical, reliable use or value beyond utterances of "wow!" and "golly!" by the credulous wannableevers. Why, it's almost as if these powers didn't actually exist, that its bleevers are reacting to the emotional rather than practical gains of their faith-based blind bleef. It just tends to make me doubt if they actually exist.*















*Sarcasm Alert.
 
Ashles
Actually as far as I'm concerned I can discard the magnets explanation - she was tested with sensitive instruments.
As for the the thread one - it is only possible in some experiments,
you could rule out this explanation in the experiments with the egg and the frog's heart.

I don't understand what you're saying about being of value to a university, being a spiritualist or having a belief / interest in paranormal issues doesn't really have anything at all to do with this.
Many high up individuals had backgrounds in spiritualism or the paranormal. A classic example of this would be the scientist Sir William Crookes who was a very serious and obsessive spiritualist.
What I want to do with my life hasn't really got anything to do with my beliefs in mediumship or the paranormal, I actually plan to become a medical microbiologist.
 
I actually plan to become a medical microbiologist.
So what will you do if hypotheses you propose do not match up to the experimental evidence? Ignore them and focus on an experiment that took place 20 years ago? Because that appears to be your scientific approach.

Many high up individuals had backgrounds in spiritualism or the paranormal.
Not very many at all. Maybe a couple of, what we would consider to be 'serious' scientists have had such interests. By this I mean scientists who have pushed forward scientific knowledge in some way. I'm not talking about scientists who pursue solely paranormal activities, because they have not, as yet, been involved in one single scientific breakthrough of note.

Actually as far as I'm concerned I can discard the magnets explanation - she was tested with sensitive instruments.
As for the the thread one - it is only possible in some experiments,
you could rule out this explanation in the experiments with the egg and the frog's heart.
For the final time in regard to Nina - and you seem to be almost delibarately ignoring my comments about this - she could have used trickery that was not detected. The scientists may not have been particularly stringent with their testing (this seems to be the most likely). We just don't know and can't know now.
What you cannot do is raise a twenty-odd year old case which certainly had some severe protocol problems and in which the lead player is now dead, and declare it to be in any way a definitive proof of psychic ability.
You are very emotionally married to this one series of experiments. As a potential scientist you will learn this is not the way it works and is a very counter-productive way to learn anything new. If something can be shown to be real it can be shown repeatably. If it cannot be shown repeatably some problem is likely with the initial test.

If you become a medical microbiologist you will learn how scientific procedure works.

If you told me evolution was a stupid theory and Darwin's finches werre all lies made up by Darwin, I could happily point out reams of other evidence to you.
But you have only a single experiment on which you base all your theories about psychic ability. It just doesn't hold water.
 
Jambo,

I realize you're being asked a lot of questions here (thank you for answering them honestly and civilly), and it seems like mine may have gotten lost in the fray. I really am curious to know if you're familiar with Steve Shaw and Project Alpha, and if so, how you would compare that to the testing that Nina underwent.

Since you mentioned the possibility, or lack thereof, of using air currents, I thought I'd point out that one the tests described in the link deals with exactly that. It was a PK test that was specifically designed to guard against air currents, yet Steve was still able to get around the controls and use air currents to move the object. Had you heard of this before?
 
If my hypotheses didn't match the experimental evidence then my hypotheses would simply be wrong. Still has nothing to do with Psi.
And in regard to Nina - accept it, no magician or sceptic has ever given an explanation which can't be dismissed by the tests carried out with her. I believe in Nina's psychokinesis because no one has given me any better explanation - 'unidentified means of trickery', doesn't cut it with me.
I have read about project Alpha.
 
Originally posted by jambo372 but edited by me.
If my hypotheses didn't match the experimental evidence then my hypotheses would simply be wrong. Still has nothing to do with Psi.
And in regard to David Blaine - accept it, no magician or sceptic has ever given an explanation which can't be dismissed by the tests carried out with him. I believe in David Blaine's psychokinesis because no one has given me any better explanation - 'unidentified means of trickery', doesn't cut it with me.
I have read about project Alpha.
 
Belief by default. Blaine is 'guilty' of psychokinesis unless and until proved otherwise. (Argument from ignorance).

This is no way to run a brain.
 
As I say I have no better explanation for the Kulagina phenomena - No one has ever successfully challenged her claims even if she is dead.

Quote from Grendel with modifications ;
Nina Kulagina is innocent of fraud until proved otherwise.
 
Jambo372,

Sorry I missed your earlier questions...
What do you mean by a better class of medium ?
Well, one that's prepared to be recorded. In fact, she insists upon it, as a permanent record of what was said, and as a means for the victim --- er, I mean client --- to be able to reflect and consider what was said. Quite common here in Australia, apparently.

Just out of interest, what kind of psychic did you visit ?
A 'aura reader', who used the "colour" and the "state" of my aura to communicate with my "higher self". Apparently, most of the stress and problems we experience in our lives are because our earthly bodies make choices and decisions that are sometimes 'out of step' with what our higher (spiritual) self desires. This leads us into a conflict between our higher self and our earthly self which the higher self seeks to correct by 'gentle nudges' to get us back on track. The psychic's role was to 'read the messages' from my higher self via my aura, and relay them to my earthly self.

She asked no questions, and I said no more than 10 words for the entire hour and 15 minutes. She didn't even stop to ask for confirmation on most of her comments. Most of what she said was a rambling, vague mess of generalisations. She made several specific comments that were highly accurate. She made several clear predictions that have yet to come true, and which had a 'time limit' that is rapidly approaching.

All in all, she was better at it than I expected, and she certainly didn't use cold reading (except, possibly, reading my body language). I suspect hot reading for the hits, because they were so accurate and so unlike the surrounding morass of vague mumblings that filled most of the session.
 
I can't remember actually ever believing in God. I had an upbringing with regular attendence to Saturday services, Hebrew school and all that. And I did probably suppose that there was a God, because I didn't have the intellectual capacity to question it, but I can't remember ever really getting into it. Then when I was old enough to actually consider these things, my naturalistic beliefs came quite ... naturally. I think the difference was that God was never discussed in my home. I have to thank my parents for the benign neglect.
 
Jambo, alright already, you believe that woman is genuine, now get onto a different subject. I'm beggin' ya.
 
I have believed vaguely in a lot of weird ideas, but the only one I ever had an abiding belief in was levitation. I believed that it was only a matter of time before I levitated myself off my bed.
 
BillyJoe said:
I have believed vaguely in a lot of weird ideas, but the only one I ever had an abiding belief in was levitation. I believed that it was only a matter of time before I levitated myself off my bed.
Can you tell us why you believed this? I'm fascinated.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom