Dr Adequate said:And a singularly inept example: given the best we know about how life evolved, there should be some more of it out there.
Hmm... is this true? I can understand one saying that, given what we know about the evolution of life on Earth, it is not implausible to suggest a theory involving life coming from elsewhere. I'm not sure that it constitutes evidence that life came from elsewhere, though. Do you claim otherwise?
But let's assume for a minute that this is true. Now suppose our physical science were far more advanced than our biological science, and we knew nothing of evolution and had no good evidence about our origins. Would a creator of SETI@home then be labeled a woo for creating the program? I think (new) Dr. Kitten is trying to point out that, by your assertions, he would.