Are you a sceptic who used to Believe Weird Things?

Dr Adequate said:
And a singularly inept example: given the best we know about how life evolved, there should be some more of it out there.

Hmm... is this true? I can understand one saying that, given what we know about the evolution of life on Earth, it is not implausible to suggest a theory involving life coming from elsewhere. I'm not sure that it constitutes evidence that life came from elsewhere, though. Do you claim otherwise?

But let's assume for a minute that this is true. Now suppose our physical science were far more advanced than our biological science, and we knew nothing of evolution and had no good evidence about our origins. Would a creator of SETI@home then be labeled a woo for creating the program? I think (new) Dr. Kitten is trying to point out that, by your assertions, he would.
 
new drkitten said:
I disagree vehemently.

What distinguishes a woo-woo, in my opinion, is not evidence (or lack of evidence), but one's reaction to the evidence that exists. A skeptic will respond to an open question (one for which no clear-cut evidence exists) by searching for evidence. A skeptic will also revise her opinion when presented with evidence. But a proper skeptic is also suspicious of the evidence itself.
You may be disagreeing vehemently, but not with me.
Just as an example, you claimed earlier that "we've done lots of experiments which WOULD demonstrate astrology if true." If you're really a scientist, as you claim, you should know that we've done nothing of the sort. We've refuted many specific claims about astrology.
I.e. traditional sun-sign astronomy, if you want to be picky. But not Welsh Methodist Moon Sign Secret Order Of Orpheus (Reformed), no, we haven't. Woe, woe, you have found an error in Dr Adequate. "If you're really a scientist." I am. Despite referring to sun-sign astrology as astrology. That's not how you find out if someone's a "real scientist". Most of them would do that.
new drkitten said:
We've also seen astrologers squirm on the hook, twisting like crazed weasels, as they explain that "my method is different, I don't make those sorts of claims," etc. But exactly because every claim is different, you can't make a blanket statement that "this experiment WOULD demonstrate astrology is true." Showing that claim X is false does not, of itself, disprove claim Y. That's the classic "black swan" fallacy --- I don't care how many white swans you show me, but you will never demonstrate the non-existence of black swans.

Similarly, it doesn't matter how many dowsers Randi tests; there's always the possibility that, although the last thousand have been misguided charlatans, the thousand and first will be The Real McCoy. That's why he keeps testing. Someday, he may find that person and have to give away his million -- and a proper skeptic will adjust his opinion about whether or not dowsing works. A proper skeptic is also aware of this, and doesn't make asinine statements about how dowsing (or astrology) can't possibly work, because a proper skeptic is well aware of how a single well-done and replicable experiment can annihilate such a statement.
I know all this. But since I said astrology when I meant sun-sign astrology, you've chosen to lecture me on the bleedin' obvious. I hope you enjoyed it.
 
flyboy217 said:
But let's assume for a minute that this is true. Now suppose our physical science were far more advanced than our biological science, and we knew nothing of evolution and had no good evidence about our origins.
Then it would still be worth a shufti. But evolutionary theory is certainly encouraging in that respect.

The difference between SETI and woos is, as ever in the difference between real and pseudoscientists, entirely methodological. Someone researching the hypothesis using one of those radio dish things... scientist... same hypothesis... aerial made out of a coathanger attached to his head... woo.
 
flyboy217 said:
I think (new) Dr. Kitten is trying to point out that, by your assertions, he would.
Yes, he's trying to, but as that is not what I have asserted, am aswserting, or ever will assert, he is boldly fighting a straw man around the neck of which he has hung my name. If he wishes to know what I meant by
Dr Adequate said:
"Recall that the distinction between the woo-woo and the normal is lack of evidence, nothing else."
then he could have the courtesy to ask me. But he prefers to make stuff up.

My meaning is simply that the paranormal is not a "natural kind". What do Weird Things have in common... yeti, spoonbending, alien abductions, Nessie, mediums, sun-sign astrology...? ANSWER: a certain nebulousness about the quality of the evidence: and that's all they have in common.
 
Dr Adequate said:
Yes, he's trying to, but as that is not what I have asserted, am aswserting, or ever will assert, he is boldly fighting a straw man around the neck of which he has hung my name.

Er but wait a minute:

Flyboy217:
Here it seems almost implied that, to be a skeptic, one must have beliefs that paranormal things are not true.

Dr. Adequate:
No, but you mustn't have beliefs that they are true.

So if the SETI@home guy has beliefs that ETs might be trying to communicate, he should not be labeled as a skeptic by your claim, even though he's investigating thoroughly with Fast Fourier Transforms and the Arecibo dish? Keep in mind I am using the "Dr. Hawking" version of the word "belief."

Also, you never answered my question about whether our knowledge of evolutionary science is sufficiently strong to label it as evidence that life exists elsewhere. Since I would answer "not really," I believe the SETI question might be pertinent even today.
 
Dr Adequate said:


My meaning is simply that the paranormal is not a "natural kind". What do Weird Things have in common... yeti, spoonbending, alien abductions, Nessie, mediums, sun-sign astrology...? ANSWER: a certain nebulousness about the quality of the evidence: and that's all they have in common.

So who asserted that the paranormal is a natural kind or that paranormal beliefs have to have something in common?

Again, this isn't skepticism, but prejudice, something that a scientist should try to avoid. Or do you think that by showing that belief in Nessie is incorrect, that actually illustrates anything about spoon-bending? Are you asserting that anyone who believes in mediums must believe in sun-sign astrology?

I'm sorry -- you were berating me for a perceived lack of courtesy. Allow me to ask you explicitly, then -- what did you mean by the paragraph quoted above?
 
new drkitten said:
....A proper skeptic....doesn't make asinine statements about how dowsing (or astrology) can't possibly work, because a proper skeptic is well aware of how a single well-done and replicable experiment can annihilate such a statement.
Is "Homoeopathy can't possibly work" an asinine statement also?
 
flyboy217 said:

So if the SETI@home guy has beliefs that ETs might be trying to communicate, he should not be labeled as a skeptic by your claim, even though he's investigating thoroughly with Fast Fourier Transforms and the Arecibo dish? Keep in mind I am using the "Dr. Hawking" version of the word "belief."
Keep in mind that you are talking to me and not to Dr Hawking. Keep in mind that "believe" has a wide range of uses, from the person who says "I believe that Jesus is my saviour" to the person who says "I believe it'll rain tomorrow".
flyboy217 said:
Also, you never answered my question about whether our knowledge of evolutionary science is sufficiently strong to label it as evidence that life exists elsewhere. Since I would answer "not really," I believe the SETI question might be pertinent even today.
I thought I did, but, yes, the principle of mediocrity and the laws of evolution do suggest that there should be Life Out There.

SETI is a bit of a red herring. That's something for which there's no direct evidence, but probably exists in theory (compare, say, the search for a molecule carrying genetic information. There should have been one, so they looked for it even though they hadn't seen it.) By contrast, theory is neutral as to some Weird Things (the yeti) and positively against some, such as ESP. But there may be evidence for both of them.
 
new drkitten said:
So who asserted that the paranormal is a natural kind or that paranormal beliefs have to have something in common?
You, in your next sentence, apparently. At least, you seem to be disagreeing either with what I've said, and that's what I've said. But perhaps you're disagreeing with another of the opinions you're so fond of inventing for me. It's hard to tell with you... so much irrelevant spam, so little actual reasoning...
new drkitten said:
Again, this isn't skepticism, but prejudice, something that a scientist should try to avoid.
Very well, it's mere prejudice to say that that's all they have in common. You will please correct my prejudice by telling me what else the yeti has in common with tarot reading.
new drkitten said:
Or do you think that by showing that belief in Nessie is incorrect, that actually illustrates anything about spoon-bending? Are you asserting that anyone who believes in mediums must believe in sun-sign astrology?
I am asserting the precise opposite: they do not form a "natural kind". One consequence of this is that evidence for or against one isn't evidence for or against the others.

I suppose a man equippped only with a rubber sword is obliged to fight only with straw men...
new drkitten said:
I'm sorry -- you were berating me for a perceived lack of courtesy. Allow me to ask you explicitly, then -- what did you mean by the paragraph quoted above?
Exactly what I said. Though I don't expect you to believe that. Instead, you will fantasise some opinion for me which I have never held, and possibly which no-one has ever held, explain that THAT must be what I meant, and then flail away at your ridiculous straw man with your ridiculous toy sword. Enjoy.
 
BillyJoe said:
Is "Homoeopathy can't possibly work" an asinine statement also?


Consider the statements "Continents can't possible move," "a ruler remains the same length no matter how it moves," and "rocks can't fall from the heavens."

All of which were firmly believed by the scientific establishment at one point and have since been firmly refuted by experimental evidence.

The best we can say at this point is that we have no evidence that homeopathy works, that we have no mechanism to explain how they possibly could work. I'll even go along with "homeopathy is extremely unlikely to work." But, no, "can't possibly" is asinine, since you're claiming to have knowledge of experiments that haven't been done yet.
 
Originally posted by new drkitten:

Consider the statements "Continents can't possible move," "a ruler remains the same length no matter how it moves," and "rocks can't fall from the heavens."

All of which were firmly believed by the scientific establishment at one point and have since been firmly refuted by experimental evidence.

...experimental evidence which homeopathy seems quite incapable of providing ...same old ... same old. gets a bit repetitive around here sometimes, doesn't it?

first post ... apologies if I've messed up formatting/whatever - still trying to get the hang of this.

btw. voted skeptic, but used to believe all sorts of weirdness, mostly but not exclusively including god.
 
apollo13 said:
...experimental evidence which homeopathy seems quite incapable of providing ...same old ... same old. gets a bit repetitive around here sometimes, doesn't it?

first post ... apologies if I've messed up formatting/whatever - still trying to get the hang of this.

btw. voted skeptic, but used to believe all sorts of weirdness, mostly but not exclusively including god.

Let's clear something up.

Is "Homoeopathy can't possibly work" an asinine statement also?

"Can't possibly work" and "experimental evidence has not demonstrated that it works" are two very different things. People here very often confuse "there is no good evidence for X" with "X does not/cannot exist."

I'd chalk it up to it being your first post, but it's certainly not just you.
 
flyboy217: fair enough. maybe I'll read through the debate before sounding off next time. :(

just too keen to get that first post up.
 
apollo13 said:
flyboy217: fair enough. maybe I'll read through the debate before sounding off next time. :(

just too keen to get that first post up.

Er... I wasn't expecting you to buckle so quickly. It's nice to get a point through so quickly for a change, though ;)
 
new drkitten said:
... and I still think you're being unnecessarily narrow-minded, to the point of being simply wrong. Consider the person who wrote the SETI@home program, as an example. Basically, what you're saying is that if this person actively disbelieves in life elsewhere in the universe and wrote this program to shut believers up, then he's a skeptic. If this person doesn't hold an opinion, then he's still a skeptic. But if this person believes that there is life elsewhere in the universe and wrote this program to test whether or not the belief is true, then suddenly he's no longer a skeptic?

I disagree vehemently.

What distinguishes a woo-woo, in my opinion, is not evidence (or lack of evidence), but one's reaction to the evidence that exists. A skeptic will respond to an open question (one for which no clear-cut evidence exists) by searching for evidence. A skeptic will also revise her opinion when presented with evidence. But a proper skeptic is also suspicious of the evidence itself.


I agree. It doesn't make the slightest difference what anyone personally believes, it's how they ACT that counts. It would make no material difference to anyone else if (in the absence of evidence to the contrary) someone personally and privately held a provisional belief. And provided they did not attempt to proselytise and were prepared to amend that belief accordingly in the face of evidence then I see no reason why they should not be considered a skeptic.

A good example is religion. A skeptic may well be religious, but the fact that they choose to hold a private belief which they cannot rationally prove, does not mean that they cannot be an (otherwise) good skeptic.

To say, "No you mustn't have beliefs that they are true" is frankly ridiculous. Every scientist believes that what they currently know is true, but they are also aware that such beliefs are PROVISIONAL and subject to amendment in the face of new evidence. The distinction lies in recognising the provisional nature of scientific and other "truth". Yes, there may be fine pedantic and semantic distinctions, but I agree with Dr Kitten, that to all practical intents and purposes, in general, scientists believe their current theories to be true - if they did not believe them to be true they would not be worth pursuing further. The key difference between woo and skeptic in such circumstances is the willingness of the skeptic to abandon the belief when the evidence goes against it. The woo holds on to the belief and defends it in spite of the evidence.

The distinction lies not in whether the evidence EXISTS, but rather in what one does with it when presented with it.
 
flyboy217 said:
"Can't possibly work" and "experimental evidence has not demonstrated that it works" are two very different things. People here very often confuse "there is no good evidence for X" with "X does not/cannot exist."
I agree, but (especially in the case of homeopathy) people also seem to confuse "I have an explanation as to how this might work" with "there is evidence that this works."
 
apollo13 said:
btw. voted skeptic, but used to believe all sorts of weirdness, mostly but not exclusively including god.
If you will Tell All, we might manage to return this thread to the purpose for which I started it. I'm interested to know, not just what "weirdness" you believed in, but also how you stopped.
 
Yes, "Homoeopathy can't possibly work" means that there is no mechanism by which it can work, which is different from "There is no evidence that Homoeopathy works". However, an interesting question is "Is it worth your time attempting to collect experimental evidence for something for which there is no possible mechanism."

Or to generalize, picking anything at random that has no evidence and no mechanism, what is the chance you'll find the evidence you're looking for?

bj
 
BillyJoe said:
Yes, "Homoeopathy can't possibly work" means that there is no mechanism by which it can work

Which is why it's asinine, I think. This is different from "there is no known mechanism by which it can work," which is perfectly valid.

Compare to 1790, when Lavoisier (purortedly) declared that rocks couldn't fall from the sky because there were no rocks in the sky. There were no mechanisms by which rocks could appear from above, so it was in fact impossible. Until evidence came along much later, that is.

My point is that, should evidence come tomorrow that homeopathy works somehow, we (or at least I) would feel foolish having today just said "it is impossible, and there cannot be any mechanism by which it could ever work."
 
Originally posted by Dr Adequate

If you will Tell All, we might manage to return this thread to the purpose for which I started it. I'm interested to know, not just what "weirdness" you believed in, but also how you stopped.

Okay, but it'll probably have to come in instalments. Where do I start?

Here's a good one (you did ask...):

I was really tied up in what was basically a pretty fundamentalist christian group (although the fundie term was never used) in my early- to mid- teens. To my credit (if I say so myself!) - I can honestly say I never truly believed the "less scientific" aspects (6 day creation and all that nonsense) - though many there did.

There was a great deal of nonsense though that I did buy into - speaking in tongues, for one - that whole holy spirit spirt thing. Still makes me cringe thinking about it.

Two things cleared my thinking: First thing: I had a dance with a (non-church-approved) girl at a local disco & the next day (literally) the story had got through to a couple of the great & good. Two of them came around (independently) to show how much they cared & offered to pray with me to help me "through the temptation". The arrogance really was astounding - Who TF did they think they were? Essentially they were just a couple of control freaks who got their kicks from trying to run the lives of a group of teenagers & this was the first time I'd seen it. I started asking questions about the whole thing after this.

The second happened a few weeks later when I turned up for a prayer group. We had a 'special guest' who was some bloke who had attended the group a few years before & had then gone off to study theology somewhere. He came back & was treated like a local hero. My attitude was already shifting & it didn't really take much to push me over. He started 'intrerpreting' the bible. Well, this guy started telling us about his preferred translation - which actually varied depending upon the point he was trying make. At one point he had the audacity to go back to the 'original' (his assertion) greek and give his own translation (based on his two years at college) - NIV and King James weren't good enough apparently. It was just laughable - although I probably wouldn't have thought this maybe two/three months previously.

It's always struck me as being a little odd that these people insist on a literal interpretation of the good book, so long as it's their own.

Part of me is still angry about the whole thing (even though it was some twenty years ago) - chalk it up to experience I guess. I went off to university and never looked back.

That was surprisingly therapeutic. Tune in next week folks, when things probably won't be quite so personal.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom