Are you a sceptic who used to Believe Weird Things?

Kitty Chan said:
It doesnt seem available on dvd either :(

Hey pick your brain if you dont mind what was the show with the guy that did inventions or what have you in the shed in his backyard? He had a sidekick called Rex?? I liked that one too, ring any bells??

Hmm. Not sure. Was that Wilf Lunn?

He was probably responsible for my love of gadgets!
 
Wasnt he called Jack,smoked a pipe,he used to have a shed cant remember if its the one though.Used to have lots of horse brass hanging? Wilf Lunn came to my junior school once I recall.Thanks for that reminder paj;)
 
I'm tellin' ya she's talking about "The Secret Life of Machines"" with Tim Hunkin and Rex Garrod.

6.gif
 
Azrael5--- Ha! Jack Hargreaves "Out of Town", (and even earlier on the childrens' show, "How?"). That dates you. (And me).

Interesting man, Jack. I enjoyed his programmes.
 
Yes thats the man Jack Hargreaves! Thanks Sam.Obviously I remember him from Out of Town initially-forgot he was on How?;)
Beats the hell out of TV these days,that and Farmhouse kitchen,lol
 
jambo372 said:
Uri Geller was proved fraudulent. Nina Kulagina was tested by various investigators over a period of at least 10 years and no investigator has ever found a fitting rational explanation for her experiments & demonstrations.
The same could be said of Steve Shaw, now known professionally as Banachek. He too was tested by investigators over a period of years and was declared to be the real deal, before admitting he was 100% fake. If he could fool researchers, why couldn't Nina?

jambo372 said:
You would have to see the medium to know what I was talking about.
I couldn't think of a rational explanation, it didn't really fit with cold/hot reading.
It is entirely possible that if I had seen this medium with you, I wouldn't be able to think of a rational explanation either. But that wouldn't necessarily mean that there wasn't one. Providing people with experiences for which they can't think of a rational explanation is what fraudulent mediums do for a living, and many of them are very, very good at it.

I won't bother with asking you for further details, because in order to provide a rational explanation, one would need all the facts. And even if you came forward with every last detail about what did and didn't happen, we still wouldn't have all the facts. We would have our understanding of your description of your memory of what you think you saw and heard. There are four places where that can break down: 1) What we understand might not be what you're trying to describe. 2) What you remember may not be what you actually experienced. 3) What you think you saw and heard may not have been what you actually saw and heard. And 4) what you actually saw and heard may not have been all that was there to see and hear.

It doesn't seem like your intention here is to try to convince us anyway, but bear in mind that your own evaluation is subject to the above weaknesses also. Okay, not so much number 1, since you're unlikely to misunderstand yourself, ;) but the others do affect you. Your memory, like everyone's, is fallible; your perception, like everyone's, is fallible; and you have no way of knowing what was happening that you weren't aware of. Something to bear in mind when you look back at this experience.
 
Jambo, I was just wondering. A while back you mentioned on another post that you aren't allowed to bring recording devices into a seance or reading. I was wondering if anyone (by which I mean a psychic) has explained why? You had said that it disrupts their concentration or chi or something. I was just trying to figure out how this happens from such a simple device. Micro recorders don't produce any radiation or emit anything that could interfere with thoughts being transferred. They don’t produce anything. The light bulb used in the séance room gives off more energy than a tape recorder. As I said, they are very simple devices, they simply record sound waves. So why are they banned? Is there any chance you could ask someone at your church how a device that doesn’t give off any form of energy could disrupt a psychic connection.
 
It's not the mediums who ban the recording - it's the law.

Several rational explanations ?
Name them.
I've heard the magnets, threads,static & air currents stories before.
 
Whether it's illegal or not depends solely on which state you live in. If you tell me what state you live in, I can tell you exactly what is permitted.
 
jambo372 said:
It's not the mediums who ban the recording - it's the law.

Several rational explanations ?
Name them.
I've heard the magnets, threads,static & air currents stories before.

What state? I think you may be misreading something. Many states have laws about whether recordings are admissable or not, but in most states the knowledge and consent of only a single party is needed (in other words, if you know you're recording then it's okay). I'm not sure what issues this would fall under as far as law is concerned...unless these people claim their performances are protected under copyright laws?
 
operaider,

Jambo, I was just wondering. A while back you mentioned on another post that you aren't allowed to bring recording devices into a seance or reading. I was wondering if anyone (by which I mean a psychic) has explained why?
Jambo needs to find a better class of medium/psychic. At the reading I had done a few years back (paid for by believer friends trying to convert me) I was told to bring an audio tape along, and have the entire one and a half hour reading recorded. That includes the several clear - and timed - predictions that have only a few months in which to eventuate. Times running out for that particular psychic...
 
It's not the mediums who ban the recording - it's the law.
No it's not the law. If both parties are aware of the recording it's perfectly fine. It's only illegal to do it when one party is unaware. If the medium agrees then it's no problem (hence phone services inform you that some calls may be recorded)
BTW Operaider, jambo is in the UK

I've heard the magnets, threads,static & air currents stories before.
Well, just because you've heard them before doesn't make it not true.
Imagine someone believeing in Uri Geller and being told he just bends them with his hands really quickly. Most people, even some sceptical, might reject that as being too mundane and stupid to be true. Of course we now know (and have seen the video evidence) that this is exactly how he does it, at least some of the time.
Also, even if it is not one of these methods (which I think it is personally), trickery is still by far the most likely method.

It is such an easy thing to test, so why can no-one in the world today do this? The test protocol would be really easy and straightforward.

All these great and gifted psychics and telekinetics were in the past, why has this ability suddenly disappeared?
 
Did I used to believe weird things? Hell yes!

I used to hang out in the 130s section of the library studying UFOs, ESP, Bigfoot, the Loch Ness Monster and other eldritch topics. I did so because I was a BIG science fiction fan and I wanted "proof" that all the cool stuff I saw in the Star Trek re-runs and in the Star Wars movies could come to pass.

Of course I was also raised to be a strict Roman Catholic, so I believed (or was expected to believe) all sorts of things: That there was an omnipotent super-being who loved us but would punish us with we so much a questioned him. That there was a Hebrew carpenter who could perform cheap magic tricks that was really the scion of said super-being. That virgins could get pregnant via the “holy spirit.” The people could rise from the dead three days after being crucified. That you weren't suppose to even THINK about sex, much less have it until you're married, and forget about masturbation--that's just as bad as fornication.

(e.g. When I was 13-years old, my parents went through our medicine cabinets and removed anything that I could use as a lubricant, thus discouraging me from committing the sin of "onanism.")

What prompted me to become a skeptic?

When it came to religion, I've always sensed that there was something "wrong" in what I was being taught during Mass and CCD. How could there have been an Adam & Eve when scientists found fossils of dinosaurs, trilobites, and cavemen? For that matter, why did an omnipotent God need a day to "rest" after supposedly creating the world? Why is something as joyful and pleasurable as sex be considered "sinful" outside the confines of marriage (not to mention, heterosexuality)? If there was a God who supposedly loved and cared for us all let pain and suffering endure? If there was an afterlife, why bother with the mortal world? Why not just make Earth a Heaven and be done with it?

Believe it or not, my interest in pseudoscience was actually a tougher nut to crack. I used to watch TV shows like "In Search Of...," "Sightings," and "Unsolved Mysteries" and they also had what appeared to be "scientists" doing serious research to prove that psychic powers, alien abductions, and other phenomenon are occurring. This was, of course, before I found out that these "scientists" where really cranks and/or con-men, and that if the nonsense they spouted was true, then we'd have to throw out a large portion of our established sciences. As much as I wanted there to be science in science fiction, I wasn't prepared to go that far.
 
Mark A. Siefert said:
I did so because I was a BIG science fiction fan...

A point of clarification, I still am a BIG science fiction fan. (I'm watching "Stargate SG-1" as I'm typing this, and I regularly play that classic sci-fi RPG "Traveller.") However, I eventually learned that alot of what passes as "science" in science fiction--at least in cinematic and broadcast offerings--really wasn't science at all.

Good science fiction tends to rely on actual science while bad sci-fi promotes pseudoscience. True, you have to "suspend your disbelief" to some degree when consuming sci-fi, but there is a difference in suspending your disbelief and hanging it from the gallows of ignorance.
 
(e.g. When I was 13-years old, my parents went through our medicine cabinets and removed anything that I could use as a lubricant, thus discouraging me from committing the sin of "onanism.")

What prompted me to become a skeptic?
I think I can guess.;)
 
Ashles said:
I think I can guess.;)

Well, that was just an example of what kind of environment I grew up in. However, I started to earnestly reject religion around the same time I had my first sexual relationship in my mid-20s.

Getting laid has a tendency to change your outlook on a few things.
 
Blondin said:
I'm tellin' ya she's talking about "The Secret Life of Machines"" with Tim Hunkin and Rex Garrod.

6.gif

YES thats it! poor Rex :) Thanks Blondin eh

I wonder if Rex was a prototype for Beaker on the muppets

But Wilf seems interesting too, havent seen that one.

The only "British" (sorry if I get that wrong) show I watch lately is "A ----- is Born" hes restored a old Harley, built a plane he mildly reminds me of Tim But I think its the trusty sidekick.

And we would have to start another thread to talk about humour and comedy :D
 
jambo372 said:
Uri Geller was proved fraudulent. Nina Kulagina was tested by various investigators over a period of at least 10 years and no investigator has ever found a fitting rational explanation for her experiments & demonstrations. That's why I still believe in her and not Geller.
You would have to see the medium to know what I was talking about.
I couldn't think of a rational explanation, it didn't really fit with cold/hot reading.

Someone like David Copperfield would have probably millions of followers if he was a conartist like JE or SB.The man is amazing.As a matter of fact my last girlfriend mentioned once that she thought David Blaine had "powers";) .She was real goodlooking but obviously there was a tradeoff.:D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom