Another Vaccination Scare?

The health of the population in the Minamata area has been pretty closely monitored. Are you saying that there could have been an exceptionally high incidence of autism, without any competant researchers noticing and screening the population for autism :jaw-dropp
Or, exceptionally high incidences of mercury poisoning? Would you be able to tell?
 
You are confusing the condition with the symptoms. A condition is diagnosed based on the symptoms, as well as circumstantial evidence, not because of divine insight into the inner cause of the symptoms.

Think of an autistic kid and compare it with a kid with mercury poisoning. Both seem unaware of their surroundings. Do you think "Impaired peripherial vision and hearing" or do you think "unaware of the surroundings"

Neither. Because I have lots of first hand experience, I have a picture in my mind of a certain pattern, in the same way that I have a picture in my mind of an "elephant". The pattern that I have for "autism" or for any of the symptoms described by the use of certain words like "unaware of the surroundings" is different from the pattern for "mercury poisoning" or "impaired vision and hearing". If I am trying to decide whether or not the animal I am looking at is an elephant or a rhinocerous, I follow a process of matching it to my mental representation of those animals, rather than by comparing it to a checklist of "large", "grey hide", "sparse hair", etc.

A large component of the clinical portion of the training for physicians involves building a library of mental representations for various symptoms, signs, conditions, etc. Diagnoses are made on the basis of pattern-matching, not on the basis of checklists. Unfortunately, when things like the DSM are widely available, that distinction is lost on those who try their hand at making diagnoses in the absence of knowledge and experience.

Linda
 
What you are doing is describing the Mona Lisa, without ever having seen it, based on a description written by someone with cataracts and untreated glaucoma, to a group of people with unimpaired vision who are looking at the painting as you speak.

The problem that you have to overcome is that many of us here are real scientists. We know all about the politics of science because we live it every day, not because we read a description from a whackjob in order to attempt to create a picture in our mind.

Linda
Well put!

Here is a link to an article (PDF) discussing how people who are least informed on a topic think they are well-informed"

"If you can't understand; maybe it's you" http://www.apa.org/journals/features/psp7761121.pdf
 
For all you care, I work in the marketing department of a company that manufactures and distributes homeopathic remedies and equipment for colon hydrotherapy.
...
I wish I got paid to post here too... must be nice. Ironic for someone who says the medical profession is rife with conflicts of interest and are just paid mouthpieces for the pharmaceutical interests. So being a paid mouthpiece for homeopathy and enema fetishists is different how?

Edit:
I do realize that this post is a bit presumptive but you did say "marketing department". It's not like you just work in shipping and receiving or customer service.
 
Last edited:
Well put!

Here is a link to an article (PDF) discussing how people who are least informed on a topic think they are well-informed"

"If you can't understand; maybe it's you" [URL="http://www.apa.org/journals/features/psp7761121.pdf"]http://www.apa.org/journals/features/psp7761121.pdf[/URL]

Seconded. Very well put, Linda.

JJM, don't hold your breath waiting for Dabljuh to read that article - if something does not conform to his preconceptions he will dismiss it out of hand. Our Dubs is not someone who is willing to learn something new, particularly if it challenges his misrepresentation of reality.
 
Has anyone ever investigated the possibility of how much autism may be caused by mercury poisoning?

Yes, and to date there is no evidence to support this possibility.
 
Neither. Because I have lots of first hand experience, I have a picture in my mind of a certain pattern, in the same way that I have a picture in my mind of an "elephant". The pattern that I have for "autism" or for any of the symptoms described by the use of certain words like "unaware of the surroundings" is different from the pattern for "mercury poisoning" or "impaired vision and hearing".
And why? Isn't it possible your "mental patterns" are simply making a false dichtonomy? Simply because you're imagining things?
If I am trying to decide whether or not the animal I am looking at is an elephant or a rhinocerous, I follow a process of matching it to my mental representation of those animals, rather than by comparing it to a checklist of "large", "grey hide", "sparse hair", etc.
So you don't go "Does it have a proboscis" or "large flaccid ears or small pointy ears" or "tusks or a horn on the nose", you simply look at it. Of course. But what if you're only told about it, by a parent? How do you communicate symptoms of a condition?

The problem is you're trained insufficiently. Your mental images may be way off. You're not given a mercury-poisoned kid and an autistic kid to play with, to look at them, to learn how to keep them apart. In medical training, you're simply told what an autistic kid looks like, or what a mercury poisoned kid looks like.

Go to a toxicologist and he'll diagnose mercury poisoning in both. Go to a psychologist and he'll diagnose autism in both, I promise ya.

And you, by pure divine grace, you can tell them apart, because your hypothetical imaginings are so good. Geez.
A large component of the clinical portion of the training for physicians involves building a library of mental representations for various symptoms, signs, conditions, etc. Diagnoses are made on the basis of pattern-matching, not on the basis of checklists. Unfortunately, when things like the DSM are widely available, that distinction is lost on those who try their hand at making diagnoses in the absence of knowledge and experience.
Checklists ARE patterns. What you are talking about there is using INTUITION as a way to diagnose conditions based on their symptoms.

I don't say intuition is generally wrong, it can be faster and deliver better results than using abstraction and analysis. But intuitive reasoning can be wrong, and when it is, it's much harder to analyse why it's wrong.
 
A large component of the clinical portion of the training for physicians involves building a library of mental representations for various symptoms, signs, conditions, etc. Diagnoses are made on the basis of pattern-matching, not on the basis of checklists. Unfortunately, when things like the DSM are widely available, that distinction is lost on those who try their hand at making diagnoses in the absence of knowledge and experience.

Linda

This technique is exactly what caused my father to be diagnosed with having a TIA rather than a Brain Tumor. Whoops.
 
And why? Isn't it possible your "mental patterns" are simply making a false dichtonomy? Simply because you're imagining things?So you don't go "Does it have a proboscis" or "large flaccid ears or small pointy ears" or "tusks or a horn on the nose", you simply look at it. Of course. But what if you're only told about it, by a parent? How do you communicate symptoms of a condition?

The problem is you're trained insufficiently. Your mental images may be way off. You're not given a mercury-poisoned kid and an autistic kid to play with, to look at them, to learn how to keep them apart. In medical training, you're simply told what an autistic kid looks like, or what a mercury poisoned kid looks like.

You are making my point for me. Medical training involves being given a mercury-poisoned kid and an autistic kid to play with over and over and over again. So you don't need to rely only on what you are told or what you imagine.

Go to a toxicologist and he'll diagnose mercury poisoning in both. Go to a psychologist and he'll diagnose autism in both, I promise ya.

And you, by pure divine grace, you can tell them apart, because your hypothetical imaginings are so good.

No. My point is that I don't have to rely on hypothetical imaginings.

Geez. Checklists ARE patterns.

No. They are descriptions of patterns.

Linda
 
You are making my point for me. Medical training involves being given a mercury-poisoned kid and an autistic kid to play with over and over and over again. So you don't need to rely only on what you are told or what you imagine.
Riiiiight... And when there aren't any mercury-poisoned kids around to play with, you create some (what thread are we in again?)
 
Reminds me: Isn't autism several times more common in men than in females? That'd disprove my mercury hypothesis.

(Edit: At least partially. Men get tarded by mercury, females by nature? :duck:)
 
A diagnosis is confirmed via falsification of the alternatives I.e. the possible conditions and their symptoms are tested for. The conditions with symptoms that are not present in the patient are ruled out, as popularized on House and standard training for medical students in the UK.

Obviously, as a qualified physician becomes more arrogant experienced, she can diagnose want is wrong with me without performing any tests.

Ivor the anti-Semite

(as diagnosed by Linda MD)
 
A diagnosis is confirmed via falsification of the alternatives I.e. the possible conditions and their symptoms are tested for. The conditions with symptoms that are not present in the patient are ruled out, as popularized on House and standard training for medical students in the UK.

Obviously, as a qualified physician becomes more arrogant experienced, she can diagnose want is wrong with me without performing any tests.

Ivor the anti-Semite

(as diagnosed by Linda MD)

To be fair, that isn't what she said. Test results are part of a pattern, as well. What she said was that accurate diagnosis can't be done on the basis of a checklist, which is true. A person equating "loss of peripheral vision" with "inattentive to surroundings" has no clue to the types of behaviors/symptoms these two things refer to. Likewise, saying something as asinine as W's "they both make you crazy" is like saying "depression, sociopath, what's the difference?" The point she was making is that doctors know more than just a checklist of symptoms. They also see patients that are in these conditions, and know by first-hand experience what "loss of peripheral vision" is and what "inattentive to surroundings" is, and likewise know that the two symptoms are NOT the same thing. She was essentially agreeing with your first statement there.

Now, of course, I could be wrong, but that's how I took Linda's statements. I'm sure she'll offer her own staements if I've mis-interpreted her intent.

However, in this case she's 100% correct. Mercury poisoning and autism produce symptoms that, on paper, may look similar but are obviously different when seen first-hand. Likewise, I can tell the difference (with reasonable certainty) between insulin shock and drunkeness with a cursory examination, even though symptoms are almost identical.
 
A diagnosis is confirmed via falsification of the alternatives I.e. the possible conditions and their symptoms are tested for. The conditions with symptoms that are not present in the patient are ruled out, as popularized on House and standard training for medical students in the UK.

Obviously, as a qualified physician becomes more arrogant experienced, she can diagnose want is wrong with me without performing any tests.

Ivor the anti-Semite

(as diagnosed by Linda MD)
Perhaps she's had a lot of anti-semites to play with before.....:)

Clinical diagnosis is a mixture of art and science. There are a number of ways to look at it, even to the point of dispassionately forcing it into a numerical Bayesian construct with decision analysis. But Linda's example is a great analogy. This is why a clinician knows when she sees someone with chest pain that they are experiencing esophageal spasm and not angina. Of course diagnosis is not always accurate or easy, particularly when there are a lot of co-morbid medical conditions, but a skillful clinician will outdo a computer algorithm 9 times out of 10, or maybe even 99 times out of a hundred. Think Deep Blue. Similar principles apply.

My own analogy regarding diagnosis is asking someone to say whether the animal they saw was a dog. We all can tell the difference between a dog and the other candidates such as cats, racoons, badgers, rats or whatever. But when you are forced to run through the "checklist" to see if you are correct, you see that other animals might be easily mistaken for the dog - it may have sharp canine teeth, 4 legs, a tail, a hairy coat etc etc. Yet we also know that animals as different as a chiuhahua and a great dane are instantly recognisable as a type of dog using our mental map of dogginess.
 
Last edited:
Since we're totally off topic, do you docs think it's better when people try to do a bit of self diagnosis troubleshooting before showing up, or does that just make it harder for you guys?
There's a new book out called "How Doctors Think", and the author (a physician) actually advocates people troubleshooting things on their own a bit when possible to know potentially relevant information to give their physician.

Seems like a fine line to walk since so many people want to fixate on what *they* think is wrong with them, and will almost demand that their doc give them the exact diagnosis they've decided on at home...
 
Perhaps she's had a lot of anti-semites to play with before.....:)

Clinical diagnosis is a mixture of art and science. There are a number of ways to look at it, even to the point of dispassionately forcing it into a numerical Bayesian construct with decision analysis. But Linda's example is a great analogy. This is why a clinician knows when she sees someone with chest pain that they are experiencing esophageal spasm and not angina. Of course diagnosis is not always accurate or easy, particularly when there are a lot of co-morbid medical conditions, but a skillful clinician will outdo a computer algorithm 9 times out of 10, or maybe even 99 times out of a hundred. Think Deep Blue. Similar principles apply.

My own analogy regarding diagnosis is asking someone to say whether the animal they saw was a dog. We all can tell the difference between a dog and the other candidates such as cats, racoons, badgers, rats or whatever. But when you are forced to run through the "checklist" to see if you are correct, you see that other animals might be easily mistaken for the dog - it may have sharp canine teeth, 4 legs, a tail, a hairy coat etc etc. Yet we also know that animals as different as a chiuhahua and a great dane are instantly recognisable as a type of dog using our mental map of dogginess.

Don't be so sure about that. PubMed was correct 88% of the time when searched with a word-list of symptoms.
 
Don't be so sure about that. PubMed was correct 88% of the time when searched with a word-list of symptoms.

And I'd suspect that 99 out of 100 doctors would do better than that 88% rate. :D

kellyb:

I'm not a doctor, I'm military-trained medic. My training is somewhere between an EMT-I and paramedic (with a few specialty applications, such as chemical warfare symptoms, that civillians don't cover as much).

However, it drove me nuts when I'd be screening sick call, and I'd ask "What's wrong" and they'd tell me "Strep throat" or "flu". While I understand why they say that, not every sore throat is strep and not every cough is the flu. I've seen the same thing in other areas as wall, such as a group trip to Colorado where some of the adults were "sure" that a group of girls on the trip were "on drugs" just because they acted a bit wierd. Come to find out that, not only were they quite a bit higher in elevation (change in partial pressure of O2), but they'd also been avoiding meals to lose weight, and had not been drinking enough water. Being a trained medic, I told them of this possibility, and was informed that "no, that won't make you act that way".

Yeah.

But generally it's more an annoyance, until the arrogance of the untrained sets in. As a trained medic, even with over a dozen years experience, I'm hesitant to sound too confident when examining a paitent. this is because I know enough to realize that there are a LOT of possibilities for a particular symptom list. However, certain conditions are not identical, or even similar, in their symptoms even though the list of symptoms in a book might appear similar, and these I'm confident in telling apart. Drug use and dehydration, for example. Or insulin shock and intoxication. Bad gas and a heart attack. Severe constipation and appendicitis. And most of these from less than a minutes examination, with no tests done.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom