Another Vaccination Scare?

Replaced it with what? We still use the non-live vaccine today, and only use the live one in places where polio is still a threat. I don't believe it was replaced, rather Sabin's won out as more effective, yet not as safe.


Bah, semantics. I just don't put much weight on the whole conspiracy theory that seems prevalent amongst all this. There was politics too. And the other crazy theory that the polio vaccine brought in the HIV to our populations has been thoroughly debunked, but that seems wrapped up with all this too.
 
Replaced it with what? We still use the non-live vaccine today, and only use the live one in places where polio is still a threat. I don't believe it was replaced, rather Sabin's won out as more effective, yet not as safe.
We didn't switch back over to the killed vaccine till 2000. IPV was only used initially for a few years before OPV began being rushed through. In the late 70's they figured out a new way of growing polio that greatly increased the viral yeild, so the IPV in use now is not the same vaccine. (the new one is called "enhanced potency IPV"...or eIPV). It's still not as effective as OPV, but it's a lot better than the original IPV was.

Bah, semantics. I just don't put much weight on the whole conspiracy theory that seems prevalent amongst all this. There was politics too.
Well, yeah...it's politics. Is "WMD in Iraq" a conspiracy theory thing or politics?

There was politics too. And the other crazy theory that the polio vaccine brought in the HIV to our populations has been thoroughly debunked, but that seems wrapped up with all this too.
No, they're not related.
The only relation there is that Cox worked for Hilary Kaprowski, who was testing/manufacturing OPV in the Congo at the same time.
 
Last edited:
I think I am coming to a preliminary conclusion here.

Vaccines are dangerous, and there is a valid scientific controversy surrounding their safety. However, as it often is, one side is not into legitimate scientific discussion, but instead tries to censor and bully the other side into submission.

Objections to their efficacy have to be evaluated further. Given the argument that the efficacy and the safety of a drug is often evaluated by the same groups, and the safety testing have been shown to be lacking beyond simple scientific error, (but rather systematic disinformation) one can assume that the allegations about vaccines' complete lack of immunizing effects may well be prove true.

Do you agree, robinson?

I'm not sure. I tend to approach both sides with skepticism, and there is not enough data or testing to know yet. Obviously animal studies would show what effect 25 vaccines do, especially since Chimps have a much quicker development cycle than humans.

That experiments have not been done, is the most obvious fact. With the amount of money and health of children at stake, you would think at the first sign of any possible trouble with vaccines and health, the obvious studies would be done, with rats, monkeys, chimps, dogs, whatever it takes, to assure a billion parents that there is no chance of illness, death, or a lifetime disability associated with vaccinations.

The money spent by drug companies to combat any possible debate over the issue would have funded multiple studies, and the issue would be settled.

The SV40 contamination of the polio vaccine has still not been studied, nor do we even know what SV40 does to people, and even with it being found in people with cancer tumors, we still don't know much about it.

It is obvious that there is a problem, and it isn't with the people questioning medical science, you have every right to question, demand answers, and insist on proper science and research when it comes to your health, or your children. People who try to short circuit inquiry into these issues, who don't focus on the facts, but rather go for the idiocy of claiming something that hasn't been shown to be true, are dumb.

Obviously vaccines are a huge boon to mankind. Prevention of disease by vaccine is one of the most important tools medicine has for many diseases. Like antibiotics, vaccines changed the nature of medicine. And just like antibiotics, they are not a perfect tool, with no dangers, no flaws in methodology or practice. Insisting everything is fine, when it obviously is not, is just dumb, or perhaps criminal.
 
The diagnostic change was this:
1) they didn't know that other viruses like echoviruses, coxsakievirus, etc, caused paralysis before then, so any case of sudden paralysis was called polio.
2) they lengthened the time someone needed to be paralysed for a reporting of "polio".
3) polio "the gut infection" was no longer reportable

Read the second (righthand) column here:
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV605.jpg

Fascinating stuff kelly. I'm going to go over a lot of this new info before responding. I love it when people find stuff and share it, rather than just posting insulting tripe and insisting they are right yadda yadda yadda.

2002 Pediatric paper concerning autism and mercury
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/content/full/111/3/674

Links between Environmental Mercury, Special Education, and Autism in Louisiana
http://etd.lsu.edu/docs/available/etd-04032006-222421/unrestricted/Rury_thesis.pdf

There is also increasing evidence showing that skin disorders and autism in Hong Kong children are related to their high Hg body loadings (hair, blood and urine), through prenatal methyl Hg exposure.
http://www.sciencedirect.com/scienc...serid=10&md5=867b05446c5f88641753b510caf41bf9
 
Last edited:
The amount of misinformation spouted by dab and robinson is just dumb and bordering on criminal.
Yes, posting scientific papers from peer reviewed journals that dispute methyl mercury's harmlessness or point out that the effects of mercury poisoning have an eerie similarity to autism should be outlawed.
robinson said:
I'm not sure. I tend to approach both sides with skepticism, and there is not enough data or testing to know yet.
There is enough data to ascertain that there is a controversy that has a scientific basis, and that there appears to be a concerted effort to suppress this controversy and diffame proponents of a certain viewpoint. For HIV, the same is true.

I'm not saying we have solved the mystery. We can't do that by just going through papers and websites. What we can figure out is if there is any merit to alternative viewpoints, and how they are treated. But aren't there more topics like this that should be discussed? I mean, I'm not here to convince anyone but myself.

(Thank you Eos & Detee and the others)

I want to know more topics, rather than to beat this one ad delirium. Are there other interesting topics to research? I'm not in the mood of going back to discussing 9/11. You seem like a sensible guy, any ideas?
 
Last edited:
Well, I guess you could take a look at Morgellons disease, Air powered cars, Pig Bladders growing new fingers, Language and instinct, a cheap safe cure for Cancer, Hydrogen from sunlight, global warming, sonar and doppler radar weapons, F# up your bunghole curing cancer, Vitamin C, Bees vanishing, Magnetism, Coley's Toxins, Pearl Harbor, Simian Sign-Language, and maybe firewalking.


Just for a start.

I'm thinking of advocating to put Mercury in teeth myself. Always good for a few laughs.
 
There is enough data to ascertain that there is a controversy that has a scientific basis, and that there appears to be a concerted effort to suppress this controversy and defame proponents of a certain viewpoint.

Of that I have no doubt.
 
Well, I guess you could take a look at
*Morgellons disease: Just googled it. Very likely environmental, rather than an infectious disease like the Morgellons Research Foundation claims.
*Air powered cars: Compressed air? A much more interesting topic I find is the push to hydrogen and fuell cell as an energy source for cars, both of which are ridiculously inefficient and expensive technologies, basically red herrings that distract from real alternatives.
*Pig Bladders growing new fingers: teratoma?
*Language and instinct: What's there not to research?
*a cheap safe cure for Cancer: Duesberg's just published some works on his hypothesis on the aneuploid cause of cancer
*Hydrogen from sunlight: I was under the impression that plants are more effective at using sunlight when producing bio-fuels
*global warming: I seriously couldn't care less
*sonar and doppler radar weapons: What about them? One supposedly kills whales and the other one's a microwave oven without shielding?
*F# up your bunghole curing cancer:
*Vitamin C: thedoctorwithin has a nice hypothesis on it. basically, ascorbic acid is not vitamin C, only with several cofactors, ascorbic acid becomes part of vitamin C. As an important basis for this hypothesis he cites a paper, where ascorbic acid alone failed to cure scurvy, while lemons worked as usual. Deserves some follow-up I think.
*Bees vanishing: I've heard of that one, but I'm not interested enough in bees. The culprit is probably going to be some sort of pollutant.
*Magnetism: There's actually some nice alternative cosmological theories that explain dark matter, that are more in line with tesla's works on plasma resonance, but I'm under the impression this isn't really a matter of controversy covered up by the politics of science, its one of cosmologists and physicists not having the tools yet to properly investigate the universe.
*Coley's Toxins: Just googled it. This looks interesting.
*Pearl Harbor: The US lured the japanese into attacking Pearl Harbor in order to be able to engage germany. Is anyone still buying the suprise theory?
*Simian Sign-Language: How's that interesting?
*and maybe firewalking: Or that?
Just for a start.

I'm thinking of advocating to put Mercury in teeth myself. Always good for a few laughs.
I'll advocate sex with HIV+ people then. Hey, everybody needs a bit of love, and there's some scientific papers that claim frequent sex with HIV+ people will immunize from HIV.

What I'm looking for is basically, scientific controversies that aren't a matter of public debate because of the politics of science. Controversies where the field investigations have been performed, where the data is there. Stuff that one can research using the internet. I find this to be a higher priority than to actually do field research. What good is field research if its results are unpopular and is going to be supressed?
 
*Morgellons disease: Just googled it. Very likely environmental, rather than an infectious disease like the Morgellons Research Foundation claims.
*Air powered cars: Compressed air? A much more interesting topic I find is the push to hydrogen and fuell cell as an energy source for cars, both of which are ridiculously inefficient and expensive technologies, basically red herrings that distract from real alternatives.
*Pig Bladders growing new fingers: teratoma?
*Language and instinct: What's there not to research?
*a cheap safe cure for Cancer: Duesberg's just published some works on his hypothesis on the aneuploid cause of cancer
*Hydrogen from sunlight: I was under the impression that plants are more effective at using sunlight when producing bio-fuels
*global warming: I seriously couldn't care less
*sonar and doppler radar weapons: What about them? One supposedly kills whales and the other one's a microwave oven without shielding?
*F# up your bunghole curing cancer:
*Vitamin C: thedoctorwithin has a nice hypothesis on it. basically, ascorbic acid is not vitamin C, only with several cofactors, ascorbic acid becomes part of vitamin C. As an important basis for this hypothesis he cites a paper, where ascorbic acid alone failed to cure scurvy, while lemons worked as usual. Deserves some follow-up I think.
*Bees vanishing: I've heard of that one, but I'm not interested enough in bees. The culprit is probably going to be some sort of pollutant.
*Magnetism: There's actually some nice alternative cosmological theories that explain dark matter, that are more in line with tesla's works on plasma resonance, but I'm under the impression this isn't really a matter of controversy covered up by the politics of science, its one of cosmologists and physicists not having the tools yet to properly investigate the universe.
*Coley's Toxins: Just googled it. This looks interesting.
*Pearl Harbor: The US lured the japanese into attacking Pearl Harbor in order to be able to engage germany. Is anyone still buying the suprise theory?
*Simian Sign-Language: How's that interesting?
*and maybe firewalking: Or that?
I'll advocate sex with HIV+ people then. Hey, everybody needs a bit of love, and there's some scientific papers that claim frequent sex with HIV+ people will immunize from HIV.

What I'm looking for is basically, scientific controversies that aren't a matter of public debate because of the politics of science. Controversies where the field investigations have been performed, where the data is there. Stuff that one can research using the internet. I find this to be a higher priority than to actually do field research. What good is field research if its results are unpopular and is going to be supressed?

You took 40 minutes to go through this long list of Robinson's, "research" the items within (by googling them and checking what "thedoctorwithin" had to say) and write a response.

Thank you for confirming for us all the extent to which you are willing to look for evidence.

Some people place you and Robinson in the same boat.
This could not be further from the truth. Robinson will take a concept, go away and research it in depth and come back, sometimes days later, with a detailed new or interesting slant on the topic. You merely do the most shallow perfunctory search possible by checking what your favourite woo web site has to say on the topic, seeking only information that already confirms your underlying bias.

People here have scant regard for any opinion you come up with on any subject. Do you understand why?
 
You took 40 minutes to go through this long list of Robinson's, "research" the items within (by googling them and checking what "thedoctorwithin" had to say) and write a response.

Thank you for confirming for us all the extent to which you are willing to look for evidence.

Some people place you and Robinson in the same boat.
This could not be further from the truth. Robinson will take a concept, go away and research it in depth and come back, sometimes days later, with a detailed new or interesting slant on the topic. You merely do the most shallow perfunctory search possible by checking what your favourite woo web site has to say on the topic, seeking only information that already confirms your underlying bias.

People here have scant regard for any opinion you come up with on any subject. Do you understand why?
I disagree. There's too much to research to research everything in depth. I've spent months researching circumcision in order to come to an informed, coherent conclusion, also learning about the politics of science. I'm experienced. I no longer need months of research to come to a conclusion whether or not a controversy is legitimate in terms of science.

What I did there was a 40 minute google search to try to identify potential candidates for further research. This is of course very much subject to my personal bias. You claim I claim I had researched all of these now, I didn't, and didn't.

With regards to robinson, I value his skeptical approach, he may be better than I am even at this skepticism business. But I have a different goal, and thus a different approach. I want to be able to explain a controversy as clearly as possible, in plain terms, without sacrificing the scientific accuracy of my argument too much. Robinson values the scientific accuracy more than I do, as he is more inclined to formulate utter uncertainty. Constant self-doubt is of course scientific, but being able to make a clear, coherent and realistic assessment of a situation [without being unaware of science's uncertain nature] is more useful when talking to non-academics. Which the majority of people on the world are.

Furthermore I don't ask you to believe me, I ask you to convince me that I'm wrong. I may still be wrong about vaccines and HIV and those other things, maybe the HIV dissidents got it all wrong, maybe the research claiming vaccines may be ineffective and dangerous are fraudulent, but you simply have failed to convince me not to advocate those positions as scientifically legitimate.
 
Last edited:
If you haven't understood yet, why a medical journal can be (and often is) an unreliable source, and a random whackjob on the internet can be dead on, (and often is) then you need to learn a lot more about the politics of science.

Science isn't a holy process of gathering knowledge, it is a business. The power goes where the money goes, and whoever has the power is going to do everything to consolidate it. Many scientists aren't happy with this, as they see science still as a way to find truth and stuff. They are driven so mad by the business of science that they prefer to work on the fringes of the institution rather than to have their jobs dependant on people who tell them what the results of their findings should be, rather they would live the rest of their lives being constantly bullied and attacked vigorously than to surrender their scientific integrity to the politics of science.

Of course this is the minority, the vast majority of scientists simply prefers a 9-to-5 job that pays well and has some prestige.

You don't have that on the outskirts of what's accepted by the scientific institution. If scientist rejects a mainstream hypothesis that has good amounts of money behind it, the only option those people have is to basically spread their particular understanding of the truth on their own, on the internet. How do you differ the good scientist there from the actual whackjob? Only by investigating their every argument.

Sometimes, sound science gives it away: A good scientist that leaves the mainstream has surrendered all the benefits of "orderly" science in order to spread his findings: You simply don't do that easily, if only for a cause that you are deeply convinced of, and solely for the purpose to be freed of the shackles of the politics of science. Yes, even "good" lone wulf scientists can be wrong. But how often, compared to the mainstream where there are the bounds and shackles of the politics of science?

A real whackjob will not "selectively cite studies", and provide ample evidence he benefitted from a sound scientific training, he won't even know what a damn study is, won't be able to tell you what "Energy" is, because his theories stem from ignorance, i.e. are all out of his butt.

But I understand it is too complicated if there's all those different theories and different arguments and stuff, how should you know which ones are right? Not knowing what's right and what's wrong is certainly a frightening state, I understand you chose the easier path and instead unquestioningly accept what the majority of scientists subscribe to.

What you are doing is describing the Mona Lisa, without ever having seen it, based on a description written by someone with cataracts and untreated glaucoma, to a group of people with unimpaired vision who are looking at the painting as you speak.

The problem that you have to overcome is that many of us here are real scientists. We know all about the politics of science because we live it every day, not because we read a description from a whackjob in order to attempt to create a picture in our mind.

Linda
 
Oh dear, we really need a forum feature that will ensure that substantial quotes from posters on our ignore lists can also be blocked.

It says it's a troll. I see no reason to dispute that. Why are we feeding the troll, again?

Rolfe.
 
I disagree. There's too much to research to research everything in depth. I've spent months researching circumcision in order to come to an informed, coherent conclusion, also learning about the politics of science. I'm experienced. I no longer need months of research to come to a conclusion whether or not a controversy is legitimate in terms of science.

Just out of curiousity, what is your profession?
 
Mercury poisoning:
Autism:
You look at this and you don't see the glaring parallels?

You are comparing descriptions rather than comparing the conditions. That the Mona Lisa and the Birth of Venus are both described as a painting of a woman does not mean that they are the same thing.

Linda
 
Your logic is fallacious. Incidence of autism by US diagnostic standards wasn't scope of the investigation. The article doesn't add much to the discussion either way.

The health of the population in the Minamata area has been pretty closely monitored. Are you saying that there could have been an exceptionally high incidence of autism, without any competant researchers noticing and screening the population for autism :jaw-dropp
 
I dunno...even the Cochrane Collaboration thought the original and post marketing studies were indequate:

http://www.cochrane.org/reviews/en/ab004407.html

A note of caution about the Cochrane Collaboration....

The analytic strategy used for their reviews is quite rigid. It works well when answering specific types of questions and when the bulk of the available information follows current practice in the design and implementation of research studies. However, it begins to fail when attempting to answer questions that fall outside of these constraints. The above referenced MMR study is a good example of the latter. And that is what the authors are saying with their statement - even though an overview of all the available information clearly demonstrates the benefit of MMR, using only the information allowed by the rigid rules of the Cochrane Collaboration would lead to a different conclusion.

Linda
 
Just out of curiousity, what is your profession?
For all you care, I work in the marketing department of a company that manufactures and distributes homeopathic remedies and equipment for colon hydrotherapy.

You are comparing descriptions rather than comparing the conditions. That the Mona Lisa and the Birth of Venus are both described as a painting of a woman does not mean that they are the same thing.
You are confusing the condition with the symptoms. A condition is diagnosed based on the symptoms, as well as circumstantial evidence, not because of divine insight into the inner cause of the symptoms.

Think of an autistic kid and compare it with a kid with mercury poisoning. Both seem unaware of their surroundings. Do you think "Impaired peripherial vision and hearing" or do you think "unaware of the surroundings"

Diagnoses of mentally tarded kids are usually pronounced by others. A mercury poisoning on the other hand occurs in adults, who may be capable of giving accurate descriptions of their symptoms.

Both may well be the same, but in the instance of autism, a third person is reporting the observed symptoms, and in the other instance, the patient is reporting the perceived symptoms themselves.

And that is all still ignoring that kids, with their many brain functions still developing, may have different, possibly more severe symptoms from mercury poisoning. Like autism, mercury poisoning doesn't just go away. Has anyone ever investigated the possibility of how much autism may be caused by mercury poisoning? That genetic markers may determine the tolerance of mercury to a point where a pregnant mother merely eats a bit much fish, causing subsequent autism in her child? And that the rest is just within bounds of normal human behaviour? What idiot declared it a "condition" not to like people??
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom