mhaze
Banned
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2007
- Messages
- 15,718
The notion that health insurance reform is not interstate commerce because health insurance cannot be sold across state lines is wrong. The S Ct. has already ruled in many cases that even the economic activity of a single person in an isolated town can, in the aggregate, amount to interstate commerce. It's the "what if everybody did it" argument......
I disagree with your analysis, but sympathize with your personal situation. I doubt you'd see a Republican bill that didn't handle some of the more glaring issues, like pre existing conditions, and fixing the gaps in Cobra. Health care is a regulated industry, and there are few people that would argue that it is not or should not be. It's not the case that "only good" would come from a government takeover, which is what the Bamster's plan really is.