Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

The notion that health insurance reform is not interstate commerce because health insurance cannot be sold across state lines is wrong. The S Ct. has already ruled in many cases that even the economic activity of a single person in an isolated town can, in the aggregate, amount to interstate commerce. It's the "what if everybody did it" argument......


I disagree with your analysis, but sympathize with your personal situation. I doubt you'd see a Republican bill that didn't handle some of the more glaring issues, like pre existing conditions, and fixing the gaps in Cobra. Health care is a regulated industry, and there are few people that would argue that it is not or should not be. It's not the case that "only good" would come from a government takeover, which is what the Bamster's plan really is.
 
Maybe not 'force' according to physics.

But according to the law, telling people that something unpleasant will happen if they don't give you money, is called 'constructive force'.

Hence, one of the reasons I oppose this. It would be one thing if coverage were offered, it's another when you're basically being coerced into it.
 
Okay, now what the hell...?

The "Cornhusker Kickback" was the derogatory nickname of one of several sweetheart deals designed to ensure that the law had enough votes to pass. Amid a public uproar, lawmakers ultimately stripped the measure from the law.

But no one—not Scalia's eight colleagues on the highest court in the land, not Deputy Solicitor General Edwin Kneedler, there to represent Obama, and not the superstar lawyer challenging the law on behalf of 26 states, Paul Clement—challenged his claim.
 
The hypothetical point is that if a compelling case was made as to the health benefits of something, or the value of a cell phone for emergencies, could the government compel people to buy them.

Yes*, and that isn't materially different from any other program the government purchases directly for you. Government has decided you need an insurance program when you retire or are otherwise unfit to work. The government compels you to purchase this service (even if you never use it, and at the point of a gun no less!) via taxation.

The destructive element of this line of logic is that what you are doing is tying the hands of Congress into a position where in order to achieve UHC, the US must adopt a single-payer system. It's overstepping the role of the judiciary to give Congress zero latitude regarding how to implement UHC. It's asking for single-payer or bust.

*provided it meets the other criteria as well (i did list three)
 
Last edited:
It's not about the level of the force of the enforcement. It's about the fact that there is any force, that people are being forced to buy something that they may neither want nor need, or pay a penalty.

Everyone participates in the health care system because hospitals have to treat people who wind up in the emergency room even if they can't prove that they can pay. So while you might decide you don't want or need health insurance, others would call it "freeloading."

I have no problem with a tax on freeloaders. And I think the tax should be enforced.

There are always choices, even with a gun to your head, that doesn't mean there is no force like you claim.

I said there is no force like you claimed (i.e. anything approaching a gun to your head). In fact, there is no force at all to purchase health insurance -- you can choose to pay the tax instead.

-Bri
 
You mean like wars in Iraq? The FDA? The War On Drugs? et al... ETA: To clarify this response: We are all taxed in such a manner that we are forced to pay for things that we feel we may neither need nor want.
We covered this bogus argument multiple times in the debate over this. First, this is not a tax that is leveled against everyone to fund some government program that everyone benefits from like your examples. If it was, there would be no constitutional issues. Second, the penalty is just that, not a tax.


Or you haven't. The slippery slope argument is "if the Gov't can force people to buy healthcare, what can they not force people to buy".
I never said otherwise.

The proper response is "if a compelling case can be presented that everyone must eat broccoli and that this has a significant effect on interstate commerce, then by the Constitution and jurisprudence, Congress can force people to eat broccoli".
The question where to draw the line remains. As been said before, if no one bought broccoli the interstate market WOULD be affected. Does that justify congress mandating everyone buy it, for the good of the interstate commerce of broccoli? That line of argument would essentially give no boundries to what congress might do.

Bri was pointing out that you're the one that brought physical force into the discussion. Choose your metaphors/similes wisely.
Bri was trying to use my metaphor as if I claimed it was actually how the IRS was poised to enforce the penalty.

IchabodPlain said:
Yes*, and that isn't materially different from any other program the government purchases directly for you. Government has decided you need an insurance program when you retire or are otherwise unfit to work. The government compels you to purchase this service (even if you never use it, and at the point of a gun no less!) via taxation.
This is not a tax that is leveled against everyone to fund some government program that everyone benefits from like your example. If it was, there would be no constitutional issues.

The destructive element of this line of logic is that what you are doing is tying the hands of Congress into a position where in order to achieve UHC, the US must adopt a single-payer system.
No one is forcing the congress to implement UHC. That they have to follow the constitution in what they do only becomes troubling when you want them to do something that is unconstitutional.
 
Everyone participates in the health care system because hospitals have to treat people who wind up in the emergency room even if they can't prove that they can pay. So while you might decide you don't want or need health insurance, others would call it "freeloading."
Health insurance <> health care. Health insurance like all insurance is to mitigate unacceptable risk. If a person is wealthy enough to be self insured, they may neither want nor need health insurance.

I said there is no force like you claimed (i.e. anything approaching a gun to your head). In fact, there is no force at all to purchase health insurance -- you can choose to pay the tax instead.
And I and others say, claiming that there is no force involved is the same as claiming there is no force involved if someone holds a gun to your head and demands your car keys -- you can choose to take a bullet to the head. Maybe this will help, but I doubt it:

Force: to compel, constrain, or oblige (oneself or someone) to do something. You know, like to compel someone to buy health insurance under threat of penalty?
 
I'm not saying the GOP has better ideas or defending them in this, but if this bad law gets struck down before it entrenches itself into our system I think we'll be much better off. Replace it with something much better.
And how many more decades before something like that actually happens?
 
Either way the court decision goes, in the fall it's going to be a battle between those who want to 'f' the poor and those who think the poor are human beings.

If the current law dies in the worst way it will pave the way to single payer.
 
RandFan: I don't want to be forced to pitch in and buy a trillion dollar Jet Fighter for America.
Federal Govt: Since when did you think you had the freedom to say no?
RandFan: I wants my freedoms.

ETA: Yes I understand the conflict between tax and fine.
 
And I and others say, claiming that there is no force involved is the same as claiming there is no force involved if someone holds a gun to your head and demands your car keys -- you can choose to take a bullet to the head.

I'm sorry, but that's a faulty analogy. Someone holding a gun to your head and demanding your car keys isn't a choice because the alternative is death. In that scenario you are, in fact, being forced to give up your car keys. The alternative to health insurance is paying a freeloader tax. Huge difference. You are not being forced to buy health insurance.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
This is not a tax that is leveled against everyone to fund some government program that everyone benefits from like your example. If it was, there would be no constitutional issues.

Like i said, youre taking the narrowest view possible. It amounts to single-payer or bust. Your comment is a distinction without a difference. You can tax everyone to pay for A or you can have everyone individually pay for A.

No one is forcing the congress to implement UHC. That they have to follow the constitution in what they do only becomes troubling when you want them to do something that is unconstitutional.

Oh, come on. Obama was elected on the platform of health care reform. The public supports UHC. But hey, no one's forcing them. Laughable.
 
Either way the court decision goes, in the fall it's going to be a battle between those who want to 'f' the poor and those who think the poor are human beings.

If the current law dies in the worst way it will pave the way to single payer.
I think you may very well be right. It's rather bizarre that we are the lone hold out among industrialized nations. *Given that we demonstrably pay the most and get the least it is unfathomable. Give the rich and powerful in America this, they can sell dog food to the average American and convince them its freedom. Funny thing is, Americans pay for steak already. Someone has to pay for all those emergency services the poor can't afford.

*U.S. scores dead last again in healthcare study
 
Health insurance <> health care. Health insurance like all insurance is to mitigate unacceptable risk. If a person is wealthy enough to be self insured, they may neither want nor need health insurance.
Right or wrong, a lot of people have come to think that the purpose of heath insurance is to pay for all kinds of sundry things - routine doctor visits, contraceptives, "well child care", on and on and on. This is similar to automobile insurance paying for tires, batteries, a collection of CDs for your car, and of course, carwashes.

That's the central problem. If the public, included the low income sectors, understood "health insurance" to be "catastrophic medical coverage" then it'd actually be affordable for most people.
 
It bothers the hell out of me that the Federal Government is taking an all or nothing approach to this. It would be one thing in my mind if there were something akin to Assigned Risk, which was supposed to be affordable insurance for automobiles, only in this instance, for health care, but no one seems to think that's a workable idea.

The cost of insurance is scandalous, and when it's all tallied up, there's no excuse for the bulk of the cost, save for greed.

Any ideas how to get that cost down?
 
Do you really think Democrats are going to get another 60 seat majority in the coming decade? And this time a solid one.
 
As posted above:

If the aggregate effects of domestice violence (sending lots of people to the hospital for emergency medical care, etc.) is not directly related to interstate commerce as the Court held in U.S. v. Morrison (2000), I'm still having a hard time understanding how people not doing something (i.e. not buying private health insurance) is so related.
 
Last edited:
As posted above:

If the aggregate effects of domestice violence (sending lots of people to the hospital for emergency medical care, etc.) is not directly related to interstate commerce as the Court held in U.S. v. Morrison (2000), I'm still having a hard time understanding how people not doing something (i.e. not buying private health insurance) is so related.
Thanks. I was not familiar with the case. It's a good question.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom