Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

I meant that you can't be jailed or face criminal punishments for not purchasing health insurance. The only penalty for not purchasing health insurance is a tax penalty. And I don't believe they can take your house or seize your bank account. But they can withhold tax refunds.

-Bri
Nobody cares what you believe. Like I said, there is virtually nothing that's better understood than IRS procedures for tax collection. There is no "separate process" for collection of taxes, interest due, or penalties. Seizure of bank accounts and/or property is standard process. Also standard is some means for negotiating, establishing time payment plans and so forth.

Tell ya what you just give it a try and report back on how you do.

Hint: There is no warm and friendly and cuddly "Mr. Nice Guy" here. Never was, never will be. Not in this country or in the history of taxation.

Nobody will use a gun or anything that could reasonably be considered "force." ....-Bri
Basically, now you are lying. Force is the very essence of taxation. Duhh.....
 
Last edited:
Bri, do you think the ACA is the best that we can do?

I'm not saying the GOP has better ideas or defending them in this, but if this bad law gets struck down before it entrenches itself into our system I think we'll be much better off. Replace it with something much better.

Actually, it's not quite the issue that the GOP could do better - The Democrats should have and could have done better. Maybe it would have taken different leadership, who knows.

If it's a bad piece of legislation it should be canned. Even if the Supremes find it was constitutional, it is still a bad piece of legislation and should be canned.
 
I think the best approach would be to make incremental improvements to the ACA.

-Bri

I am starting to doubt that. I think WildCat may have a valid point (shudder to think). The ACA as is further entrenches the private insurers. I think it just may make it harder to move to a true UHC system.
 
As far as the Constitution is concerned, any measure that might obtain revenue for the government can be described as a tax. The distinction between "tax" and "fine" might matter to lay people, but the Constitution makes no such distinction.

Yet the supreme court seemed very interested in the distinction during questioning. Are they "lay people"?
 
The distinction between "tax" and "fine" might matter to lay people, but the Constitution makes no such distinction.

The Constitution most certainly does make a distinction between a tax and a fine. Article I of the Constitution specifically uses the word tax while the eighth amendment specifically uses the word fine.
 
Cut and pasted but here's one take on a limiting principle under the Commerce Clause:

Even in a world with an individual mandate, “Congress cannot mandate a mode of provision for payment when there’s no claim and no showing that without the mandate, there will be a substantial effect for interstate commerce."

It's bascially an argument about the scale of an individual requirements impact on interstate commerce. It it's large, it's allowed; if it's not, it's not.
 
The Constitution most certainly does make a distinction between a tax and a fine. Article I of the Constitution specifically uses the word tax while the eighth amendment specifically uses the word fine.
Here's my opinion. I routinely pay tax in October, not April 15. So based on the accuracy of my estimate of taxes, I may have some interest and or penalties. This is routine for a lot of people who file after 4-15. There is nothing at all wrong with doing this, incidentally.

So it's either the case that I get a refund, or I get a notice saying I owe some interest and penalties.

Now, what do I consider the check I write? It's a check for TAXES.

Say you have a traffic ticket, and don't pay it. They send you a notice. The notice says you owe the 109 for the ticket, and 100 for late charges (penalties). You pay 209, grudgingly. What did you pay?

A TRAFFIC TICKET.

A penalty for non payment of taxes is nonetheless a tax collection process.

Operationally there's no difference of course.

You WILL DO BUSINESS with these insurance guys, Chump, or else - you'll pay me these here (penalties, fines, taxes).

If that's not flat nuts I don't know what is...

I am starting to doubt that. I think WildCat may have a valid point (shudder to think). The ACA as is further entrenches the private insurers. I think it just may make it harder to move to a true UHC system.
It's not just a giveaway to the private insurers (well until the government wants to toss them under the bus of course) but also the pharmaceutical company.
 
Last edited:
I am starting to doubt that. I think WildCat may have a valid point (shudder to think). The ACA as is further entrenches the private insurers. I think it just may make it harder to move to a true UHC system.

I disagree. Right now the debate is between the ACA and nothing. If the ACA is dismantled entirely, there is no way the Republicans would allow anything you would consider UHC.

After people start to see the advantages of having health care, the debate will be between different forms of UHC because it will be politically impossible to take it away (the "nothing" option will be off the table). Only then can positive changes be made to the current system (or a better system can take its place).

-Bri
 
Nobody cares what you believe. Like I said, there is virtually nothing that's better understood than IRS procedures for tax collection. There is no "separate process" for collection of taxes, interest due, or penalties. Seizure of bank accounts and/or property is standard process. Also standard is some means for negotiating, establishing time payment plans and so forth.

According to PolitiFact, you're wrong:

An individual mandate. This requires people to buy insurance unless they qualify for a hardship exemption. The law was intended to cover everyone, either through their employer, the new health care exchanges, the Veterans Administration, Medicaid or Medicare. People who don't buy insurance would have to pay a penalty on their taxes, but they can’t be jailed or face criminal penalty if they don’t pay. The government could withhold their tax refunds, though. This is one part of the law that is being challenged before the U.S. Supreme Court.​

Basically, now you are lying. Force is the very essence of taxation. Duhh.....

So someone will hold a gun to your head and physically force you to buy health insurance? No, you can opt to pay the tax penalty instead.

Even if you don't do either, they still won't hold a gun to your head and take the money from you by force as Neally described. They won't even jail you or file criminal charges against you. They might withhold tax refunds.

-Bri
 
Yet the supreme court seemed very interested in the distinction during questioning. Are they "lay people"?

Scalia was pushing the solicitor to see how far he would go with the argument to see if the Solicitor really would not describe the provision as a tax even to win the case. That's why there is so much squirming going on there. Nobody else cared, and I'd be surprised if Scalia hung his opinion on the fact that Obama called it a fine and not a tax.

The Constitution most certainly does make a distinction between a tax and a fine. Article I of the Constitution specifically uses the word tax while the eighth amendment specifically uses the word fine.
Yes. The Eighth Amendment is using it in a criminal context, which requires guilt proven beyond reasonable doubt. The healthcare act does not require that burden to be sustained before imposing its "fine" , and therefore the Health Care Act's fine is not a "fine" as that term is used in the Constitution. Rather, it should fall under Article I, Section 8, which states:

The Congress shall have Power To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States; but all Duties, Imposts and Excises shall be uniform throughout the United States​

The "fine" included here is a flat fine for failing to obtain healthcare. It's not a criminal fine (which would trigger the Eighth Amendment), but rather a civil one, which can be termed a tax, duty, or impost.fn
Again, the nomenclature of the Constitution need not match the words chosen by Congress. It's the function, not the form, that matters.

Of course, if the Supreme Court decides otherwise, I'm wrong. But until then, I'm fairly confident in my analysis.
 
Last edited:
I meant that you can't be jailed or face criminal punishments for not purchasing health insurance. The only penalty for not purchasing health insurance is a tax penalty. And I don't believe they can take your house or seize your bank account. But they can withhold tax refunds.
You don't know much about IRS enforcements of non-payment of taxes. Once a judgement is obtained, any and all collection procedures are available including wage garnishments, seizing bank accounts and any other assets, etc.

I think broccoli and cell phones are bogus.

1) There is no compelling need to madate purchasing broccoli. Indeed some are allergic. Broccoli is never a must-have item for anyone, and has reasonable alternatives for interested consumers.
The hypothetical point is that if a compelling case was made as to the health benefits of something, or the value of a cell phone for emergencies, could the government compel people to buy them.

According to PolitiFact, you're wrong:

An individual mandate. This requires people to buy insurance unless they qualify for a hardship exemption. The law was intended to cover everyone, either through their employer, the new health care exchanges, the Veterans Administration, Medicaid or Medicare. People who don't buy insurance would have to pay a penalty on their taxes, but they can’t be jailed or face criminal penalty if they don’t pay. The government could withhold their tax refunds, though. This is one part of the law that is being challenged before the U.S. Supreme Court.​
It's true that the mandate states there would not be any criminal penalty, but that's the only limitation. Read it for yourself here: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/5000A



So someone will hold a gun to your head and physically force you to buy health insurance? No, you can opt to pay the tax penalty instead.

Even if you don't do either, they still won't hold a gun to your head and take the money from you by force as Neally described. They won't even jail you or file criminal charges against you. They might withhold tax refunds.
I never said they would hold a gun to your head and you are quite wrong that the only thing they will do is withhold tax refunds. That is the easiest way for them to keep/collect what is owed to them, but their collection efforts can go way beyond that as I mentioned above.

The individual mandate FORCES people to have coverage or pay a penalty which then can be FORCIBLY collected by the IRS just as they can collect anything owed to them. Kind of one of the main reasons why the SCOTUS is looking that this.
 
...
So someone will hold a gun to your head and physically force you to buy health insurance? No, you can opt to pay the tax penalty instead.

Even if you don't do either, they still won't hold a gun to your head and take the money from you by force as Neally described. They won't even jail you or file criminal charges against you. They might withhold tax refunds.

-Bri
I don't mean to be rude, but you simply don't know what you are talking about. As I mentioned in my first post, it's common knowledge what happens if you don't pay taxes or penalties. I cited the code sections and the details. They will send you an "asset seizure notice". The procedures for this and the subsequent actions are spelled out.

There isn't any reason to discuss this more but I have a final comment. It is only because of strong opposition that the "jail" option was taken out of the Bamster's health power grab. That strong opposition remains.

There's simply no "Nice Guy" anywhere in this so please stop trying to make it seem like it's something it's not.
 
Nobody will use a gun or anything that could reasonably be considered "force." The current law allows the IRS to withhold your tax refund to pay it (which makes perfect sense if it's a tax).

-Bri
Maybe not 'force' according to physics.

But according to the law, telling people that something unpleasant will happen if they don't give you money, is called 'constructive force'.
 
Maybe not 'force' according to physics.

But according to the law, telling people that something unpleasant will happen if they don't give you money, is called 'constructive force'.

That's not the type of force Neally was describing in the post to which I was responding. There's not even "constructive force" to buy health insurance, since everyone has the option of paying the tax instead.

-Bri
 
The notion that health insurance reform is not interstate commerce because health insurance cannot be sold across state lines is wrong. The S Ct. has already ruled in many cases that even the economic activity of a single person in an isolated town can, in the aggregate, amount to interstate commerce. It's the "what if everybody did it" argument.

In any event, I don't see how this is clearly not interstate commerce as the health care industry is one of the largest in the country and affects everyone at some level.

As for requiring someone to do something-- the government does that all the time. We are required to get licenses for various things. Permits/ grants/variances... inspections... USDA anyone? Can't get a new drug on the market without being required to pay for the FDA review.

As Oliver W. Holmes pointed out, if the government can compel you to enter military service where you could be killed. What can't it do, given the exigency?

The health care crisis in this country is very real. 116 billion dollars last year in uninsured usage of our system-- forced on us all to pay one way or another.

This law doesn't have to be right, just a reasonable basis to justify acting at all.
I too wish we had simply expanded medicare/medicaid. Simplest way to do it.
But does anyone think we have a chance at that, given the $$$ of the health insurance industry?

Getting back to basics here-- I wonder why no one is arguing the Political Question doctrine. That body of S Ct. law simply holds that something like this is an inherently political question and the Ct. will let the politicians decide. If anything ever was a purely political question, it's this.

Something has to be done. My wife at age 42 with 2 children in middle school was diagnosed with breast cancer. At the time we were on COBRA. I had been looking into individual coverage, but once she got that diagnosis, she was uninsurable.

UNINSURABLE!

What does that say about the Republicans' ******** arguments about giving us all 5000 dollar vouchers to buy insurance in the private market?

There is no free market in this industry. Almost by definition there cannot be. The only way to spread the risk effectively is for there to be 1 insurer. As it is, it's a largely do whatever it wants to do cartel, arguably much worse than the Oil Cartel.

Before our COBRA ran out, I was able to find a part time employer (I am a full time professional in my own practice. I used to be able to get group coverage, but no more-- they priced it at 3000 a month for anything remotely decent). Yep.. had to work at a Starbucks for about a year from 4:30 in the morning until 7 every single day just to pull this off.

I did it for about 1.5 years. Went on their COBRA for 1.2 years. Now I have a situation where one of my clients who can't afford my regular fees but does have a generous health care plan, put me on as a retained employee. We once again have coverage.

But for how long with that last. Don't know. If something happens down the road and we lose that coverage... I can't get a family plan at any price due to my wife's c/a diagnosis (she had surgery and is on a 5 year hormone plan. We are hopeful that the c/a is gone). What if I get something like this while on a group plan??

It's a disaster. The insurance industry is raping us. The current law is the best thing we've been able to do. If I thought anything else had a chance, I'd go for it. But to kill off this law is wrong.

skeptifrenic
 
You don't know much about IRS enforcements of non-payment of taxes. Once a judgement is obtained, any and all collection procedures are available including wage garnishments, seizing bank accounts and any other assets, etc.

No guns, physical force, jail time, or criminal charges can be used to force you to pay the penalty. If the collection procedures you listed can be used (and it's unclear to me that they can based on PolitiFact and other articles I've read) then the same is true if you refuse to pay any tax. Why do you only have a problem with this one?

The hypothetical point is that if a compelling case was made as to the health benefits of something, or the value of a cell phone for emergencies, could the government compel people to buy them.

I haven't seen anyone lay out a slippery slope argument that makes any sense. Everyone already participates in health care, so it is different than cell phones or broccoli.

I never said they would hold a gun to your head and you are quite wrong that the only thing they will do is withhold tax refunds.

You said:

Ah the old, "it's not really forcing anybody to do anything". Like when someone holds a gun to your head and demands a wallet. It's not really force-- you could always refuse and choose the bullet to the head instead.​

The individual mandate FORCES people to have coverage or pay a penalty which then can be FORCIBLY collected by the IRS just as they can collect anything owed to them.

You're upset because if you owe taxes the IRS has the power to make you pay it? The outrage!

-Bri
 
No guns, physical force, jail time, or criminal charges can be used to force you to pay the penalty. If the collection procedures you listed can be used (and it's unclear to me that they can based on PolitiFact and other articles I've read) then the same is true if you refuse to pay any tax. Why do you only have a problem with this one?
It's not about the level of the force of the enforcement. It's about the fact that there is any force, that people are being forced to buy something that they may neither want nor need, or pay a penalty.

I haven't seen anyone lay out a slippery slope argument that makes any sense. Everyone already participates in health care, so it is different than cell phones or broccoli.
Then you haven't been following the slippery slope arguments that the justices presented.


You said:

Ah the old, "it's not really forcing anybody to do anything". Like when someone holds a gun to your head and demands a wallet. It's not really force-- you could always refuse and choose the bullet to the head instead.​
And that has nothing to do with the way the IRS actually enforces the penalty. It's an example to show the nonsense of, "no one is forced to do anything". There are always choices, even with a gun to your head, that doesn't mean there is no force like you claim.
You're upset because if you owe taxes the IRS has the power to make you pay it? The outrage!
Yeah! Wait, no. Total strawman.
 
It's not about the level of the force of the enforcement. It's about the fact that there is any force, that people are being forced to buy something that they may neither want nor need, or pay a penalty.
You mean like wars in Iraq? The FDA? The War On Drugs? et al... ETA: To clarify this response: We are all taxed in such a manner that we are forced to pay for things that we feel we may neither need nor want. Yes, I know, it's not me directly purchasing weapons that are used in Iraq, but that's a distinction without a difference. Whether I buy the weapons directly or the Gov't does it as a proxy for me with the taxes I've paid, I am still being forced to buy something I feel I do not want, nor need.

Then you haven't been following the slippery slope arguments that the justices presented.
Or you haven't. The slippery slope argument is "if the Gov't can force people to buy healthcare, what can they not force people to buy". The proper response is "if a compelling case can be presented that everyone must eat broccoli and that this has a significant effect on interstate commerce, then by the Constitution and jurisprudence, Congress can force people to eat broccoli".

And that has nothing to do with the way the IRS actually enforces the penalty. It's an example to show the nonsense of, "no one is forced to do anything". There are always choices, even with a gun to your head, that doesn't mean there is no force like you claim.
Yeah! Wait, no. Total strawman.
Bri was pointing out that you're the one that brought physical force into the discussion. Choose your metaphors/similes wisely.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom