Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

The cost of insurance is scandalous, and when it's all tallied up, there's no excuse for the bulk of the cost, save for greed.

Any ideas how to get that cost down?

A mandate to buy insurance. Coupled, however, with fewer mandates on what each policy must offer. Then there would be multiple products out there with a larger price range and cafeteria-style options. The mandate to buy is coupled with the mandate that someone has to cover you, but the coverage can be limited to mitigation of unacceptable risk - i.e., catastrophic coverage.

But if the concept of a mandate is eliminated that mechanism for spreading the risk won't work.
 
Uh, no. Japanese Americans were forced into internment camps because they didn't have any choice. Again, the alternative to purchasing health insurance is paying a tax because if you wind up in an emergency room, everyone else will have to pay for your care. Not the same thing, I'm afraid.

-Bri

It's not quite the same thing, but your reasoning is likewise flawed. First off, it's not simply a tax, it's explicitly a penalty. And as such, it could be raised to arbitrarily high levels. No one has argued that its constitutionality depends on the size of the penalty, nor do I see any logical argument for how it could. So there is no limiting principle to how large this penalty could be, and the "choice" is not much of a choice at all.
 

I agree that the structural problems of the current system - mainly that the ability to get (buy) insurance is largely dependent on holding a full-time job - are going to become more obvious in the relatively short term and might even depolarize the issue. Sooner or later 99 percent of us will have a pre-existing condition - athlete's foot, migraines, whatever - that may justify denial of coverage. And it may become obvious that "being in your 50s" is the real pre-existing condition.

In fact, I've always thought Romneycare was constitutional, although I didn't LIKE it.

It really seemed like the Bamster admin had a blatant disregard for constitutionality in what they tried to do here. I'm not saying that the SC rules one way or another, it just seems that they wanted this power grab, so they grabbed for it.

Or maybe it had to do with a desire to both broaden coverage and mitigate the "free rider" problem which so clearly distorts the risk picture. Who in politics isn't going to grab power while they can? That's what political office is for. Elections are a rough corrective on political megalomania. Don't tell me that Obama et al. acted with "blatant disregard for the constitutionality"; I'm sure they prepared a reasonably persuasive case in advance. "Constitutionality," perhaps unfortunately, is also subject to a vote. Constitutionality will come down to the opinion of a swing member on the Supreme Court. They'll be able to find case law to justify their position.
 
I really like how focused this discussion is vs. general consideration of UHC. Maybe I've said that.
 
Oral arguments concluded yesterday and the matter is now in the hands of the court. I am very interested to know what people here think is the most likely outcome based on the pointed questions of the Justices. Let's assume the court has three choices:
  1. They do nothing and leave the entire law intact.
  2. They sever the mandate but leave most other parts alone.
  3. They strike down the entire act.
What do you think?
I think you should start a thread with those poll questions; don't forget the Planet X option.
 
  • Forcing people to pay for Medicare is not an infringement on personal liberty.
  • Forcing people to buy medical insurance or pay a fine is an infringement on personal liberty.
?
 
Minoosh;8154750.... Or maybe it had to do with a desire to both broaden coverage and mitigate the "free rider" problem which so clearly distorts the risk picture. Who in politics isn't going to grab power while they can? That's what political office is for. Elections are a rough corrective on political megalomania. Don't tell me that Obama et al. acted with "blatant disregard for the constitutionality";[B said:
I'm sure they prepared a reasonably persuasive case in advance. [/B]"Constitutionality," perhaps unfortunately, is also subject to a vote. Constitutionality will come down to the opinion of a swing member on the Supreme Court. They'll be able to find case law to justify their position.
Well, that's something of a puzzle. Reading the transcript and listening to the proceedings, uh.....

That reasonably persuasive case didn't seem to come up. That was why I concluded that perhaps they actually didn't examine the issue of constitutionality early on. But yeah, we do seem to live in a SC world of 5-4 decisions.
 
It's not quite the same thing, but your reasoning is likewise flawed. First off, it's not simply a tax, it's explicitly a penalty. And as such, it could be raised to arbitrarily high levels. No one has argued that its constitutionality depends on the size of the penalty, nor do I see any logical argument for how it could. So there is no limiting principle to how large this penalty could be, and the "choice" is not much of a choice at all.

They'd have to creep those increases in, and they certainly could do that later - say as a rider to a Defense Appropriations bill that basically had to be passed.

But as it is written now, it starts at $95 and cannot exceed 2.5% of annual income.
 
  • Forcing people to pay for Medicare is not an infringement on personal liberty.
  • Forcing people to buy medical insurance or pay a fine is an infringement on personal liberty.
?

From a constitutional perspective, this is completely the wrong question. The question is, what power does Congress have? The health care mandate is being justified on the basis of the commerce clause. I do not think that clause justifies the mandate. Nor do I think Medicare is justified by the commerce clause. So the question of constitutionality doesn't split nicely along your ideological divide, but that doesn't mean we should ignore it.
 
Yes, words do have meanings. Your use of the word "force" to say that the government is "forcing" people to purchase health care (even going so far as to use a gun to the head analogy) when they have another viable choice (and many are likely to choose the tax rather than purchase health care) is unusual to say the least.
Unusual? No. Normal accepted use of the word. And "viability" has nothing to do with it. If there was no force issue, the SCOTUS wouldn't have bothered with this. Maybe you'd care to explain why they erred in accepting the case an examined this very issue, since none of the other defenders of the individual mandate that claim it's a non - issue have been willing to do so.
 
It's not quite the same thing, but your reasoning is likewise flawed. First off, it's not simply a tax, it's explicitly a penalty. And as such, it could be raised to arbitrarily high levels. No one has argued that its constitutionality depends on the size of the penalty, nor do I see any logical argument for how it could. So there is no limiting principle to how large this penalty could be, and the "choice" is not much of a choice at all.

One of the arguments made to the Supreme Court was that the size of the tax (which I believe is far less than the price of most health insurance) is such that it is a viable choice and doesn't force people to purchase health insurance.

-Bri
 
One of the arguments made to the Supreme Court was that the size of the tax (which I believe is far less than the price of most health insurance) is such that it is a viable choice and doesn't force people to purchase health insurance.

-Bri
The "get something for ALMOST nothing" argument. Kagan did better that not, arguing "what was bad about free stuff"?

I rather liked that one. But no I won't reactivate the "free stuff" thread.
 
One of the arguments made to the Supreme Court was that the size of the tax (which I believe is far less than the price of most health insurance) is such that it is a viable choice and doesn't force people to purchase health insurance.

-Bri

Why does the constitutionality hinge on the affordability of the fine? How is that determination made, and who gets the power to make it? What standards are we to adopt to make such a determination? And if the government institutes other mandates for other things, each of which it is individually "viable" to pay the penalty for, but not in total, what then?
 
The "get something for ALMOST nothing" argument. Kagan did better that not, arguing "what was bad about free stuff"?

I rather liked that one. But no I won't reactivate the "free stuff" thread.

I would argue that without the ACA people are getting free medical treatment. With the ACA they would have to pay for it. As someone who doesn't appear to want people to have "free stuff" you seem to be arguing with yourself once again.

-Bri
 
Why does the constitutionality hinge on the affordability of the fine? How is that determination made, and who gets the power to make it? What standards are we to adopt to make such a determination? And if the government institutes other mandates for other things, each of which it is individually "viable" to pay the penalty for, but not in total, what then?

One argument against the ACA is that it contains a mandate -- forcing people to purchase something. A pro-ACA argument is that there's no problem with a strict mandate since everyone already participates in health care.

Another pro-ACA argument is that even if making you buy health insurance is deemed unconstitutional, giving you a choice between buying health insurance and paying a tax may not be unconstitutional. One counter-argument is that if the tax is too high, you don't really have a choice. A counter-counter-argument is that there are strict limits set on the tax that would prevent it from being so high as to not be a true choice.

-Bri
 
One of the arguments made to the Supreme Court was that the size of the tax (which I believe is far less than the price of most health insurance) is such that it is a viable choice and doesn't force people to purchase health insurance.

-Bri
At the end of the day America can force everyone to pay for health insurance. It's an empirical fact as we have been doing it for some time now.

The idea that to make everyone pay through the general fund is not an infringement but ACA is an infringement might be technically true but it's intellectually dishonest.
 
"Free Stuff"

GOP framing. It's a sound bite. Buzz term. It's not an argument. It's simply sophistry.
 
I would argue that without the ACA people are getting free medical treatment. With the ACA they would have to pay for it. As someone who doesn't appear to want people to have "free stuff" you seem to be arguing with yourself once again.

-Bri
You mean except for those who don't have to pay for it, or who refuse to pay for it, or who are exempted from the fine, or exempted from the ACA, or whose 1200+ companies are exempted from the ACA, or who simply are "not in the system", like a large percentage of the 30M illegals?

Is that what you mean by saying "people would have to pay for it?"

And no, Randfan, read Kagan's interaction about "Free Stuff" in the transcript. Last I heard she ain't GOP.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom