Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

I'm sorry, but that's a faulty analogy. Someone holding a gun to your head and demanding your car keys isn't a choice because the alternative is death. In that scenario you are, in fact, being forced to give up your car keys. The alternative to health insurance is paying a freeloader tax. Huge difference. You are not being forced to buy health insurance.

-Bri
The analogy works just fine. Harshness or magnitude of the "or else" is not the defining factor of "force", or maybe you'd like to explain the line:

1.Is a $1000 fine bad enough to qualify as "force"? How about $10K, $100K?
2. Is a literal slap on the wrist bad enough to qualify as "force"? How about a kick in the butt, punch in the stomach?
3. Is a 2 hour incarceration bad enough to qualify as "force"? How about a 2 day, 2 month?

Maybe, just maybe, you ought to go by what we as a society mean when we use words, rather than your made up definitions in order to satisfy your political objectives?

Force: to compel, constrain, or oblige (oneself or someone) to do something. You know, like to compel someone to buy health insurance under threat of penalty?
 
Here's a legal question that occurred to me:

If the SC rules that the individual mandate is unconstitutional, wouldn't that affect Massachusetts' law too? Or is this something that the states can do but not the Federal Government?
 
The analogy works just fine. Harshness or magnitude of the "or else" is not the defining factor of "force"....
By Bri's reasoning, American people of Japanese descent were not forced into camps in WWII. Yes, there were soldiers standing around with rifles. Yes, there were orders from the US Government. But no BULLETS were actually fired. The guns were not USED.

Why, what "force" was used? What in the world are you talking about?

And if you are arrested for traffic tickets, did anyone even POINT a gun at you? Why, no. You just went along peacably. Nobody "forced you".

And so on.
 
By Bri's reasoning, American people of Japanese descent were not forced into camps in WWII. Yes, there were soldiers standing around with rifles. Yes, there were orders from the US Government. But no BULLETS were actually fired. The guns were not USED.

Why, what "force" was used? What in the world are you talking about?

And if you are arrested for traffic tickets, did anyone even POINT a gun at you? Why, no. You just went along peacably. Nobody "forced you".

And so on.

Uh, no. Japanese Americans were forced into internment camps because they didn't have any choice. Again, the alternative to purchasing health insurance is paying a tax because if you wind up in an emergency room, everyone else will have to pay for your care. Not the same thing, I'm afraid.

-Bri
 
Here's a legal question that occurred to me:

If the SC rules that the individual mandate is unconstitutional, wouldn't that affect Massachusetts' law too? Or is this something that the states can do but not the Federal Government?

This is something the States can do, but not the Federal government, because the federal government is a government of limited powers. Everything Congress enacts has to be authorized by something in Article I of (or an Amendment to) the Constitution. The government argues this act is authorized by Congress power to regulate interstate commerce. So the question becomes whether a law that regulates people not buying health insurance implicates interstate commerce. If inaction implicates interstate commerce, what doesn't implicate interstate commerce?
 
The analogy works just fine. Harshness or magnitude of the "or else" is not the defining factor of "force", or maybe you'd like to explain the line:

1.Is a $1000 fine bad enough to qualify as "force"? How about $10K, $100K?
2. Is a literal slap on the wrist bad enough to qualify as "force"? How about a kick in the butt, punch in the stomach?
3. Is a 2 hour incarceration bad enough to qualify as "force"? How about a 2 day, 2 month?

Maybe, just maybe, you ought to go by what we as a society mean when we use words, rather than your made up definitions in order to satisfy your political objectives?

Force: to compel, constrain, or oblige (oneself or someone) to do something. You know, like to compel someone to buy health insurance under threat of penalty?
You chose to use lethal force (a firearm/bullet to the head) rather than any of these other examples of force, not anyone else. Bri simply pointed out that your example is a bit extreme.

As I said before, choose your similes and metaphors wisely.
 
This is something the States can do, but not the Federal government, because the federal government is a government of limited powers. Everything Congress enacts has to be authorized by something in Article I of (or an Amendment to) the Constitution. The government argues this act is authorized by Congress power to regulate interstate commerce. So the question becomes whether a law that regulates people not buying health insurance implicates interstate commerce. If inaction implicates interstate commerce, what doesn't implicate interstate commerce?

So the Fed Gov't can't force people to buy anything, but the individual states can? I think the individual States thing is a bit scarier, to be honest. And that's without even discussing the actual Constitutional factor of the Fed doing this.
 
Uh, no. Japanese Americans were forced into internment camps because they didn't have any choice. Again, the alternative to purchasing health insurance is paying a tax because if you wind up in an emergency room, everyone else will have to pay for your care. Not the same thing, I'm afraid.

-Bri
Bull. They could have fought it out, refused and gone to prison, instead of camp, left the country, etc. Stop making things up.
 
So the Fed Gov't can't force people to buy anything, but the individual states can? I think the individual States thing is a bit scarier, to be honest. And that's without even discussing the actual Constitutional factor of the Fed doing this.
Because the derivation is from the Commerce Clause (US Federal only) and it's possible meanings.

What's "scary" is not part of the equation.

In fact, I've always thought Romneycare was constitutional, although I didn't LIKE it.

It really seemed like the Bamster admin had a blatant disregard for constitutionality in what they tried to do here. I'm not saying that the SC rules one way or another, it just seems that they wanted this power grab, so they grabbed for it.
 
You chose to use lethal force (a firearm/bullet to the head) rather than any of these other examples of force, not anyone else. Bri simply pointed out that your example is a bit extreme.

As I said before, choose your similes and metaphors wisely.
There's no need to. "At the point of a gun" is a widely understood analogy used to refer to the coercive action of government forcing people to do things.

You may (and Bri) may not like it. But this phrase has been around a hundred years, used in this context. And nobody's going to change their use of it because of some Internet babble about whether it's "accurate" or "politically correct" or whatever.

If you have trouble understanding the phrase and it's meaning, Neally and I will gladly assist you. It has the actual meaning of the implied and ready use of a gun (force) to insure compliance, not the actual gun being pointed. For example, the cop who asks you to do something nicely is a case of "at the point of a gun". But he's only got his hand on the holster, to show that he's ready to pull it own. Similarly, soldiers in Iraq may commonly ask someone to do something, with their weapon pointed at the ground.
 
Bull. They could have fought it out, refused and gone to prison, instead of camp, left the country, etc. Stop making things up.

So you don't think they were forced? Another poster named "mhaze" apparently disagrees with you:

By Bri's reasoning, American people of Japanese descent were not forced into camps in WWII. Yes, there were soldiers standing around with rifles. Yes, there were orders from the US Government. But no BULLETS were actually fired. The guns were not USED.​

A choice between purchasing health insurance or paying a tax is not equivalent to forcing someone to do something by pointing a gun at their head. I suspect that many people will choose the tax since it will be cheaper than purchasing health insurance. I don't know how you can call that forcing them to choose health insurance.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
There's no need to. "At the point of a gun" is a widely understood analogy used to refer to the coercive action of government forcing people to do things.

Usually used when the government is actually forcing people to do something, such as paying taxes.

If you have trouble understanding the phrase and it's meaning, Neally and I will gladly assist you. It has the actual meaning of the implied and ready use of a gun (force) to insure compliance, not the actual gun being pointed. For example, the cop who asks you to do something nicely is a case of "at the point of a gun". But he's only got his hand on the holster, to show that he's ready to pull it own. Similarly, soldiers in Iraq may commonly ask someone to do something, with their weapon pointed at the ground.

Yet in this case, nobody is being forced to purchase health insurance, and I suspect that many will choose the tax over purchasing health insurance.

-Bri
 
So the Fed Gov't can't force people to buy anything, but the individual states can?
The individual States are governed by different Constitutional provisions (as well as their own provisions) which are not issue in this case because this case is about a federal statute.

But, yes. Massachusetts forces people to buy health insurance or pay a fine, and nobody thinks that is unconstitutional.
 
Usually used when the government is actually forcing people to do something, such as paying taxes.

Yet in this case, nobody is being forced to purchase health insurance, and I suspect that many will choose the tax over purchasing health insurance.

-Bri
Right, excepting for the people that don't have any intention of paying the tax and every intention of getting free stuff.

But leaving that aside, you've highlighted exactly why the existing law won't work economically. If you go into a store and can buy beer A for $2.00 a sixpack and Beer B for 10.00 a sixpack, beer A will get lots of business. That's why people will choose the tax instead of getting insurance. Then right at the time they discover they have cancer, need a kidney transplant, etc, they go and buy insurance. The insurance companies can't refuse them. Now the companies are faced with a sure - lose situation. They all go broke, then the government has "no option" except to go single payer. And IT's an EmERgeNCY!

It's like being able to go get car insurance only after you have a wreck. This is actually not "INSURANCE" but something totally different.

Who do you think doesn't see through all these smarmy weaselings?

Bad Law = Bad Law = Bad Law.

But if you disagree, why not quote some gems of wisdom regarding constitutionality from the defendant at the SC?
 
Last edited:
Oral arguments concluded yesterday and the matter is now in the hands of the court. I am very interested to know what people here think is the most likely outcome based on the pointed questions of the Justices. Let's assume the court has three choices:
  1. They do nothing and leave the entire law intact.
  2. They sever the mandate but leave most other parts alone.
  3. They strike down the entire act.
What do you think?
 
But leaving that aside, you've highlighted exactly why the existing law won't work economically. If you go into a store and can buy beer A for $2.00 a sixpack and Beer B for 10.00 a sixpack, beer A will get lots of business. That's why people will choose the tax instead of getting insurance.

Not really. Given the choice between paying for something that has value (health insurance) and paying a somewhat smaller amount of money but getting nothing in return, most will probably chose the health insurance.

Then right at the time they discover they have cancer, need a kidney transplant, etc, they go and buy insurance. The insurance companies can't refuse them. Now the companies are faced with a sure - lose situation. They all go broke, then the government has "no option" except to go single payer. And IT's an EmERgeNCY!

Health insurance typically covers prescription drugs (including birth control!), doctor visits, preventative care, and all sorts of other things that people use routinely. So I'm not so sure everyone would simply pay the tax, forego all the things insurance pays for, and get nothing in return.

People who would pay the tax and then only get insurance when something happens to them are often the people who don't get insurance anyway and wind up in the emergency room for everyone else to pay for. I'd rather they pay the tax in the meantime to cover at least some of their costs when something happens to them.

ETA: You and that mhaze guy really should start your own thread where you argue whether everyone will choose the tax or whether the government is forcing everyone to purchase health insurance.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Here's how-words have meanings. Learn what they are. You don't get to create your own meanings to suit your arguments.

Yes, words do have meanings. Your use of the word "force" to say that the government is "forcing" people to purchase health care (even going so far as to use a gun to the head analogy) when they have another viable choice (and many are likely to choose the tax rather than purchase health care) is unusual to say the least.

-Bri
 
Oral arguments concluded yesterday and the matter is now in the hands of the court. I am very interested to know what people here think is the most likely outcome based on the pointed questions of the Justices. Let's assume the court has three choices:
  1. They do nothing and leave the entire law intact.
  2. They sever the mandate but leave most other parts alone.
  3. They strike down the entire act.
What do you think?
Good question, one which they did discuss on Weds. They can't leave it intact. Of the other two options, they might find someway to dodge the bullet and tell "Congress, fix this mess. You created it".

Barring that, I'd go with the simple answer.

Obamacare doesn't have (for what reasons is actually a mystery) a severability clause. This is the clause commonly seen in contracts that says if one part is found not to stand, the rest is unchanged. In this case, as a federal law, the issue would be constitutionality. But in business contracts, we see this type of clause commonly.

The Justices did discuss the lack of a severability clause. Legally, then, it seems the second and third options both result in Obamacare being struck down. I assume this would apply to all the riders and earmarks to the Obamacare bill, most of which were unrelated and many of which were probably reasonable.

Maybe someone else can explain if there's a way around this outcome.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom