I figured that "net" would be understood.
2. "Ideological" is an uncomplimentary way to say "systematic" or "principled". I try to be systematic. Antonyms include "scatter-brained" and "unscrupulous".
3. "Everybody dies" (obviously) rebuts the (obviously false) "under UHC, everybody gets the health care he needs". If "needed" means "without which one will die", NO ONE gets the care s/he "needs". Everybody dies.
I'm not against ideology per se. It's a starting point. A premise. The statement that there's no (net) benefit to making this a government rather than individual enterprise is
- as far as I can tell - an expression of ideology. To evaluate the claim we would have to talk about what we meant by "benefit."
As I've said before, I'm not as much of a hand-wringer as some people are on health care (though, I should note that I'm pretty healthy). I used to be a newspaper reporter. Some agency would poor-mouth the government decrying a lack of, say, rural health care. Unlike a lot of reporters, I didn't start out liberal. Instead I'd think, DUH! Of course you're underserved! You don't deal with city congestion, pollution, street crime but the flip side is you have to drive a long way to a hospital.
Or, there would be an article on, say, raising the minimum wage. Often the story would start with how Debbie, a single mom with five kids, is having a tough time providing for her kids on minimum wage. Debbie could be the nicest, hardest-working person on the planet and I'd still think, DUH! Don't have five kids! Don't get knocked up by a rotter! You see the pattern: People had no one to blame but themselves, I would think.
Over time that changed. There's a reason the media is (are?) liberal. Reporters see how people can do everything right and still get screwed. It leads to a mind-set, well, maybe government can't solve every problem but it can
address problems, mitigate things, have a coherent public policy based on harm reduction. It's what governments are for. Community college vocational programs for Debbie and her kids. A rural health van delivering preventative diabetes screening on an Indian reservation. These aren't actual examples, but close.
So: the old model was having a county hospital - with doctors and nurses and techs and aides, and you showed up and probably waited but got treated by professionals. The model changed. Instead the indigent would be covered by insurers who still got their money from the government, but now the indigent could go to any hospital because the hospital would bill the insurer, which was basically the government. Counties were no longer the default provider. The indigent had the same choices that people in the "market" did.
Right? Wrong? Who cares? It's been law now for decades. The emergency-treatment thingy is law. I've been reading a lot about China lately, most recently Shanghai in the '30s where the Westernized, factory-owning Chinese lived large but people shrugged at
dead babies in the street. Health-care costs were manageable, all right. No one had anything coming, in the country you lived on what you could scrape from the earth and sometimes the earth itself. People starved to death in droves but so what? There was no shortage of Chinese.
Are Americans spoiled? Cry-babies who expect running water and electricity as a matter of course? Pretty much. I don't have health care coverage; in "feudal" China I'd be looking for a household where I could be a servant (my concubine days are pretty much over), sleep in a corner and work 16 hours for a couple of bowls of rice. When I got sick I would still work, stoical and steadfast, until finally I laid down and maybe some even lower-status woman would feed me drops of water and roll me over every now and then. And I would die. (It might do the great household dishonor, were I not taken care of).
I'm saying, I'm not unaware that
everybody dies, and that it is useful to remember this and allocate resources accordingly. But hello, here we are in the industrialized West, on the JREF forum where UK/Canadian/Australian members can barely parse these debates over health care, because TIMES HAVE CHANGED and OF COURSE basic care should not be allocated on the basis of income! If you were making your arguments in 1900 or even 1950 they might make more sense. As it is, medicine can do far more for us than we'll ever be able to afford and it's all third-party payers and there are legitimate questions to raise about chemotherapy for a 35-year-old with curable cancer vs. transplants for 90-year-olds, and why
not have that conversation
as a society?
Because you've declared there is no point? I don't think so. Happily for those of your ideological ilk many in the U.S. are seeking to roll back any expectation that basic health care, like clean water, is a public utility that we promote because there's no good reason hundreds of thousands of people should die of cholera when a dollar's worth of chlorine could prevent it. Civilization is collectivization, sorry if you don't like it but "every man for himself" is not a recipe for advancement of the enterprise called humanity. Now:
Show me your way is better. UHC advocates have trotted out their evidence; what, then, is yours?