Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

presumptive nonsense,
Interesting argument. Got any facts to support that? Oh, wait, there's no argumenent there.
I understand how such decisions might be made on Grandma, but "and you" is a bit of a problem. Who is the "you"?1 For example, is it the person standing closest to Grandma when the plug is yanked? Is it the local Democratic precinct chair?2
1. Freddie.
2. Everyone dies. Accident and intentional wounding kill most people between about 12 and 45. Between birth and age 1 year it's things that should have killed them during gestation (faulty wiring). Then it's diseases of development (leukemia, cancer, etc.) and accident. Then it's accident and intentional wounding. Finally, it's renal failure, cancer, heart disease and other slow-moving killers. Eventually, somebody or some body decides that another __x__ minutes or years of life is not worth another __y__ thousand dollars. There's no advantage to society at large in aggregating the decision into government hands where to draw that x,y line.
 
Now is that the best you can do to defend [the Affordable Care Act]?


I hope I translated your post correctly. Since the topic of this thread is the ACA, I'm assuming this is what the word jumble at the end of your post was intended to say.

If you'll take the time to read my post, you should be able to see that I haven't taken a position for or against the ACA. My post was simply to point out to Brainster a problem with his post.

Although I often disagree with Brainster in the political conclusions we reach, I respect Brainster as an honest skeptic and enjoy reading his posts. When I read this one and saw what appears to me to be a major skeptical error, I thought it worth pointing out.

Neither Brainster's post nor mine relate directly to the merits of the ACA, but rather to how popular/unpopular it is. Brainster's cited a poll which appeared to show that even a majority of Democrats oppose the ACA; my post was simply to point out the poll referred to was unreliable (a privately-commissioned partisan poll) and that more reputable polls had found different results.

I realize my posts tend to be long, and that some people don't have the patience or attention span to read them through. I hope this shorter summary helps you understand it better.
 
I hope I translated your post correctly. Since the topic of this thread is the ACA, I'm assuming this is what the word jumble at the end of your post was intended to say.

If you'll take the time to read my post, you should be able to see that I haven't taken a position for or against the ACA. My post was simply to point out to Brainster a problem with his post.

Although I often disagree with Brainster in the political conclusions we reach, I respect Brainster as an honest skeptic and enjoy reading his posts. When I read this one and saw what appears to me to be a major skeptical error, I thought it worth pointing out.

Neither Brainster's post nor mine relate directly to the merits of the ACA, but rather to how popular/unpopular it is. Brainster's cited a poll which appeared to show that even a majority of Democrats oppose the ACA; my post was simply to point out the poll referred to was unreliable (a privately-commissioned partisan poll) and that more reputable polls had found different results.

I realize my posts tend to be long, and that some people don't have the patience or attention span to read them through. I hope this shorter summary helps you understand it better.

I think I got it and understood what you were trying to say, but actually he didn't make a major skeptical error. I'm not sure how to reduce to simple words a large number of issues in survey design which translate into accuracy, and then to criticize (or not) a group of available surveys on that scientific basis.

But I am certain that you cannot take group ABC and automatically assume that their bias is reflected in the survey they did, or that this is a logical error.

Often, on a complex issue, one might take a variety of viewpoints into consideration, then reduce it to something brief, and state that.
 
I think I got it and understood what you were trying to say...


No. Reading your post, it's clear to me you didn't. Let me try again.

mhaze said:
... actually he didn't make a major skeptical error.


Yes, he did. I pointed it out in the first two paragraphs of my original post. I thought it was fairly clear, but apparently not. Here's a longer explanation for you.

As skeptics, we don't blindly accept evidence others offer; we want to know a number of key things about what's being put forward. One key piece of information we like to know is the source. This is all pretty elementary skepticism, so I assume you're with me so far.

I believe it's equally important, in the practice of skepticism, that when we are the ones offering evidence we provide the source. Consider it the Golden Rule as applied to skepticism: if you, as a skeptic, would like others with whom you are discussing a matter to behave in a certain way, then you should behave in that way yourself.

Skepticism should be about discerning what's true, not about scoring debating points. In a debate, one wants to prevail (even if the point one is making is false); but in skepticism one wants to prevail only if the point one is making is true. So just as a good skeptic refuses to give much weight to unsourced information, and wants to know where it comes from, a good skeptic should hesitate to provide unsourced information and should strive to always be clear where the evidence they are presenting comes from.

Brainster presented a poll as evidence -- but neglected to say who had done the polling. In this case that was a fairly important piece of information, as it turns out the poll was a privately-commissioned poll and the people commissioning it were strong opponents of the ACA. Failure to include the information that the poll results he quoted were from a poll commissioned by a right-wing opinion site is something I consider a skeptical error.

It's the kind of thing non-skeptics on this site do routinely. But I consider Brainster a skeptic, so I was surprised to see this in his post. I'd be equally surprised to see Darth Rotor (another person I disagree with politically, but whom I respect) doing this kind of thing.

I assume Brainster did not deliberately omit the information from his post. We all make careless errors. But I thought it was worth pointing out.


... I am certain that you cannot take group ABC and automatically assume that their bias is reflected in the survey they did, or that this is a logical error.


I did not automatically assume the poll commissioned was biased. Neither did I automatically assume the poll was unbiased.

If the poll had come from a well-known polling firm with a reputation for reliability, such as Gallup, I would have granted an assumption that it was a valid poll unless and until evidence to the contrary was presented.

But this poll did not come a well-known reputable firm. Therefore until its credentials are established its polling results are suspect and carry little weight. This is elementary skepticism.

What I did was look up polling done on this question by polling organizations with good reputations to see if these matched the results done by the polling-for-hire group. If it had, that would be strong evidence that the poll numbers Brainster presented were good.

But as it turned out, the polling-for-hire group's poll numbers were markedly different from the numbers obtained by Gallup and Kaiser. (And the polling-for-hire group's poll numbers happened to lend support to the position of the group which paid to have the polling done.)

This does not prove the polling-for-hire group's numbers are wrong. But -- and again this is elementary skepticism -- it's not my responsibility as someone being presented with evidence to prove that it's bad. It's the responsibility of the person presenting the evidence to establish that it's good.

Until some reason is presented why we should accept anomalous data from a source with unknown credibility when two sources with known credibility give us markedly different data, it would be very unskeptical to accept the anomalous data. To do so would be a skeptical error.

Is this clear now? I can try to explain again if you still don't understand.
 
No. Reading your post, it's clear to me you didn't. Let me try again.
......skeptical error.

Is this clear now? I can try to explain again if you still don't understand.

Except you have only confirmed the point I've raised, and you've proven or showed nothing. All you've done is - seemingly - showed some variation in polling results. But you haven't actually even done that, since a lot of variation is typically explained by differences in the exact questions asked or the population sample.

More words, and more use of key phrases such as "skeptic", doesn't make something more true.
 
There are two separate matters here. One is the skeptical error of omitting key information when presenting evidence. The other is the question of how much credence to put in the TMMI poll results as reported by Investors.Com.

1. skeptical error

Skeptics are interested in discerning what's true, not in scoring debating points. Therefore skeptics generally want to know the source of evidence when it's presented to them, and want to include the source of evidence when they're presenting it. Providing this information makes it easier for others to evaluate the evidence, so that if we have a good point they are able to see it more easily and if we have a bad point they are also able to see it more easily.

Brainster presented evidence (poll results) on a matter tangential to the ACA Supreme Court case (popularity/unpopularity of the ACA). But in presenting the poll results, Brainster failed to mention who did the poll. That is a significant skeptical error.

It is an error in skeptical practice regardless of whether the poll results eventually turn out to be correct or not.

If people take the attitude, I'm right so I don't need to present the evidence clearly, people should just take me at my word, then no one is going to present the evidence clearly. Creationists are as confident they are right as evolutionists; global warming deniers are as confident they are right as global warming confirmers. So skepticism is not about putting a burden to present evidence clearly on people who are wrong; it's about putting a burden to present evidence clearly on everyone who presents evidence.

The absence of the poll source piqued my interest so out of curiosity I looked it up. Whether the poll was from Gallup or from Gluesniffers, it was a technical lapse on Brainster's part not to mention who it was from; but when the poll turned out to be privately commissioned by a partisan group it became not simply a technical lapse but a significant one.

It's not like Brainster to deliberately omit key information, so I assume it was a careless error. But I thought it was worth pointing out -- a friendly tweak, a reminder to be more careful. I make many careless errors, and when I do it's often helpful if a friend can point it out if I haven't spotted it myself.

2. how much credence do the TMMI poll results deserve?

In addition to pointing out the skeptical error, I looked up polling on the question to see whether the poll results as posted by Investors.Com were correct.

It appears likely they were not; two reliable sources (Gallup and Kaiser) who polled on the same question came up with markedly different results from TechnoMetrica Market Intelligence. Gallup and Kaiser are reputable polling groups with good reputation as to their polling methods and polling results. Both Gallup and Kaiser, polling independently, came up with similar results: opinion fairly evenly divided, about 40% in favor and 40% opposed.

The Investors.Com item is an anti-ACA opinion piece, rather than a news item. They are reporting on the results of a poll they commissioned, in an editorial aimed at attacking the ACA. And they present only selected details from the polling results they paid for. So we really don't know how good or bad a job TMMI did. And until we do -- until someone cares to present evidence this is a reputable polling firm with reliable polling methods -- then the results as reported in the Investors.Com editorial should be given little to no weight.

It's all-too-common for people to give weight to evidence which supports their opinions and dismiss evidence which contradicts it. That's a bad practice, and hinders our ability to discern what's true from what's false. That's why it's important -- and a good skeptical practice -- to examine evidence and see how much weight it should be given. So far no reason has been provided for giving any weight to the numbers in the Investors.Com editorial.

If you'd care to provide evidence that the TMMI poll is reliable, and that the Investors.Com editorial accurately reports its results, please do so. Until then it would be foolish to accept those results unquestioningly.
 
Last edited:
There are two separate matters here. One is the skeptical error of omitting key information when presenting evidence. The other is the question of how much credence to put in the TMMI poll results as reported by Investors.Com.

1. skeptical error

Skeptics are interested in discerning what's true, not in scoring debating points. Therefore skeptics generally want to know the source of evidence when it's presented to them, and want to include the source of evidence when they're presenting it. Providing this information makes it easier for others to evaluate the evidence, so that if we have a good point they are able to see it more easily and if we have a bad point they are also able to see it more easily.

Brainster presented evidence (poll results) on a matter tangential to the ACA Supreme Court case (popularity/unpopularity of the ACA). But in presenting the poll results, Brainster failed to mention who did the poll. That is a significant skeptical error.

It is an error in skeptical practice regardless of whether the poll results eventually turn out to be correct or not.

If people take the attitude, I'm right so I don't need to present the evidence clearly, people should just take me at my word, then no one is going to present the evidence clearly. Creationists are as confident they are right as evolutionists; global warming deniers are as confident they are right as global warming confirmers. So skepticism is not about putting a burden to present evidence clearly on people who are wrong; it's about putting a burden to present evidence clearly on everyone who presents evidence.

The absence of the poll source piqued my interest so out of curiosity I looked it up. Whether the poll was from Gallup or from Gluesniffers, it was a technical lapse on Brainster's part not to mention who it was from; but when the poll turned out to be privately commissioned by a partisan group it became not simply a technical lapse but a significant one.

It's not like Brainster to deliberately omit key information, so I assume it was a careless error. But I thought it was worth pointing out -- a friendly tweak, a reminder to be more careful. I make many careless errors, and when I do it's often helpful if a friend can point it out if I haven't spotted it myself.

2. how much credence do the TMMI poll results deserve?

In addition to pointing out the skeptical error, I looked up polling on the question to see whether the poll results as posted by Investors.Com were correct.

It appears likely they were not; two reliable sources (Gallup and Kaiser) who polled on the same question came up with markedly different results from TechnoMetrica Market Intelligence. Gallup and Kaiser are reputable polling groups with good reputation as to their polling methods and polling results. Both Gallup and Kaiser, polling independently, came up with similar results: opinion fairly evenly divided, about 40% in favor and 40% opposed.

The Investors.Com item is an anti-ACA opinion piece, rather than a news item. They are reporting on the results of a poll they commissioned, in an editorial aimed at attacking the ACA. And they present only selected details from the polling results they paid for. So we really don't know how good or bad a job TMMI did. And until we do -- until someone cares to present evidence this is a reputable polling firm with reliable polling methods -- then the results as reported in the Investors.Com editorial should be given little to no weight.

It's all-too-common for people to give weight to evidence which supports their opinions and dismiss evidence which contradicts it. That's a bad practice, and hinders our ability to discern what's true from what's false. That's why it's important -- and a good skeptical practice -- to examine evidence and see how much weight it should be given. So far no reason has been provided for giving any weight to the numbers in the Investors.Com editorial.

If you'd care to provide evidence that the TMMI poll is reliable, and that the Investors.Com editorial accurately reports its results, please do so. Until then it would be foolish to accept those results unquestioningly.
None of what you've said is true.

You see, to compare polls, one must have some understanding of polling methods (this gets rapidly technical). Then you have to compare the exact wording of questions to be sure that its apples-to-apples. I believe you don't have the exact wording for any of the polls you talk of yet your argument presupposes exact similitude.

On this basis your entire construction falls.
 
I tend to be intrigued by what's left out of posts as much as by what's in them. In this case, I was curious why you didn't mention the source of the poll. It would seem like an obvious piece of information to include.

I hope it was simply an oversight on your part that you neglected to tell us the source. But it was a rather serious oversight, since the poll turns out to be a privately-commissioned partisan poll.

Many polls are privately-commissioned, including those by CBS, NBC, CNN, etc. And your determination that it was a partisan poll is laughable as we will see.

The article you quoted is from Investors.Com, which is run by Investor's Business Daily (IBD). And in the article it says:

TechnoMetrica Market Intelligence? Never heard of them, so I have no idea how reputable they are. But it's odd IBD had to commission and run their own poll, from this firm, rather than use polling results from one of the established firms such as Gallup. It's not as if no reputable firm has been doing polling on this question.

TIPP is TechnoMetrica's polling arm and they've been polling for IBD for about a decade.

So Investors.Com is not simply the source of the article detailing the results of the poll. They're also the source of the poll. Hmmm.

And when ABC News or the Washington Post commissions a poll, they are often the source of the article detailing the results of the poll as well. Hmmm.

Judging by the titles of the items listed on the side of the site as "Most Popular", and a quick glance at their editorial opinion section, this looks like a right-wing opinion site rather than a neutral news site.

For example:

You mean you've never heard of Investors Business Daily? It's a financial newspaper much like the Wall Street Journal. Been around for a long time. As for the story that "a quick glance" led you to assume it's a right-wing opinion site, perhaps you missed this part (although it's hard to imagine how, since it's the opening paragraph):

The Republican House of Representatives may soon follow the Democratic Senate and give the IRS the power to confiscate your passport on mere suspicion of owing taxes. There's no place like home, comrade.
Bolding added for emphasis.

That kind of over-blown rhetoric does not fill me with confidence that this is a reliable or unbiased source of poll results.

It's an editorial.

Question: If someone posted a poll on a contentious political issue that had been commissioned by ThinkProgress, would you accept that as reliable and authoritative? Or would you want to check it against results from independent polls, to see if reputable polling turned up the same results as the contracted polling did?

This isn't hard to check. I Googled Gallup "Affordable Care Act" and quickly got this, from February 27:

Sigh. I can see that you don't understand the difference between repeal of an act and striking down that act as unconstitutional.

The Kaiser Tracking Poll came up with similar results in a poll published March 15:

Again, you ask a different question, you get a different answer.


And from a Kaiser summary of polling results since the law was passed:

Ah, at last a poll that asks something close to what the IBD poll asked. And, not terribly surprisingly, the results are fairly well in line with the IBD poll. Should the law be upheld as constitutional? Kaiser found 28% said yes while IBD came up with 22%. I couldn't find the partisan breakdown on that particular question, so I don't know if all the results are as in line with the IBD poll.

Thanks for confirming the reliability of the poll.
 
Last edited:
...Should the law be upheld as constitutional? Kaiser found 28% said yes while IBD came up with 22%. I couldn't find the partisan breakdown on that particular question, so I don't know if all the results are as in line with the IBD poll.

Thanks for confirming the reliability of the poll.
So hardly anyone likes the Baaamster's pile of legislative dog turds? << Mhaze version of astute, stunningly brilliant skeptical examination of complex issue >>
 
Last edited:
There's no advantage to society at large in aggregating the decision into government hands where to draw that x,y line.

Sure there is. There is disadvantage too. Sorting out the net gain or loss would require information. Ideological pronouncements fall short.

Everyone dies. Brilliant, that.
 
Sure there is. There is disadvantage too. Sorting out the net gain or loss would require information.1 Ideological pronouncements fall short.2Everyone dies. Brilliant, that.3
1. I figured that "net" would be understood.
2. "Ideological" is an uncomplimentary way to say "systematic" or "principled". I try to be systematic. Antonyms include "scatter-brained" and "unscrupulous".
3. "Everybody dies" (obviously) rebuts the (obviously false) "under UHC, everybody gets the health care he needs". If "needed" means "without which one will die", NO ONE gets the care s/he "needs". Everybody dies.
 
Last edited:
Sure there is. There is disadvantage too. Sorting out the net gain or loss would require information. Ideological pronouncements fall short..

Already been done.

It's real simple.

You can play the game too.

Sort out between these options
  • Have someone figure net gains or losses who spends 40% more than they take in...like the US Government
  • Have someone like you or me figure net gains or losses who spends the same or less what they take in

I pick me.
 
A fine in the amount of $985, initially, once per transgression, stepping up to once per day of any given transgression to, and limited by the reportable income of the disobediant citizen in the year in question.

Please cite this.
 
I figured that "net" would be understood.
2. "Ideological" is an uncomplimentary way to say "systematic" or "principled". I try to be systematic. Antonyms include "scatter-brained" and "unscrupulous".
3. "Everybody dies" (obviously) rebuts the (obviously false) "under UHC, everybody gets the health care he needs". If "needed" means "without which one will die", NO ONE gets the care s/he "needs". Everybody dies.

I'm not against ideology per se. It's a starting point. A premise. The statement that there's no (net) benefit to making this a government rather than individual enterprise is - as far as I can tell - an expression of ideology. To evaluate the claim we would have to talk about what we meant by "benefit."

As I've said before, I'm not as much of a hand-wringer as some people are on health care (though, I should note that I'm pretty healthy). I used to be a newspaper reporter. Some agency would poor-mouth the government decrying a lack of, say, rural health care. Unlike a lot of reporters, I didn't start out liberal. Instead I'd think, DUH! Of course you're underserved! You don't deal with city congestion, pollution, street crime but the flip side is you have to drive a long way to a hospital.

Or, there would be an article on, say, raising the minimum wage. Often the story would start with how Debbie, a single mom with five kids, is having a tough time providing for her kids on minimum wage. Debbie could be the nicest, hardest-working person on the planet and I'd still think, DUH! Don't have five kids! Don't get knocked up by a rotter! You see the pattern: People had no one to blame but themselves, I would think.

Over time that changed. There's a reason the media is (are?) liberal. Reporters see how people can do everything right and still get screwed. It leads to a mind-set, well, maybe government can't solve every problem but it can address problems, mitigate things, have a coherent public policy based on harm reduction. It's what governments are for. Community college vocational programs for Debbie and her kids. A rural health van delivering preventative diabetes screening on an Indian reservation. These aren't actual examples, but close.

So: the old model was having a county hospital - with doctors and nurses and techs and aides, and you showed up and probably waited but got treated by professionals. The model changed. Instead the indigent would be covered by insurers who still got their money from the government, but now the indigent could go to any hospital because the hospital would bill the insurer, which was basically the government. Counties were no longer the default provider. The indigent had the same choices that people in the "market" did.

Right? Wrong? Who cares? It's been law now for decades. The emergency-treatment thingy is law. I've been reading a lot about China lately, most recently Shanghai in the '30s where the Westernized, factory-owning Chinese lived large but people shrugged at dead babies in the street. Health-care costs were manageable, all right. No one had anything coming, in the country you lived on what you could scrape from the earth and sometimes the earth itself. People starved to death in droves but so what? There was no shortage of Chinese.

Are Americans spoiled? Cry-babies who expect running water and electricity as a matter of course? Pretty much. I don't have health care coverage; in "feudal" China I'd be looking for a household where I could be a servant (my concubine days are pretty much over), sleep in a corner and work 16 hours for a couple of bowls of rice. When I got sick I would still work, stoical and steadfast, until finally I laid down and maybe some even lower-status woman would feed me drops of water and roll me over every now and then. And I would die. (It might do the great household dishonor, were I not taken care of).

I'm saying, I'm not unaware that everybody dies, and that it is useful to remember this and allocate resources accordingly. But hello, here we are in the industrialized West, on the JREF forum where UK/Canadian/Australian members can barely parse these debates over health care, because TIMES HAVE CHANGED and OF COURSE basic care should not be allocated on the basis of income! If you were making your arguments in 1900 or even 1950 they might make more sense. As it is, medicine can do far more for us than we'll ever be able to afford and it's all third-party payers and there are legitimate questions to raise about chemotherapy for a 35-year-old with curable cancer vs. transplants for 90-year-olds, and why not have that conversation as a society?

Because you've declared there is no point? I don't think so. Happily for those of your ideological ilk many in the U.S. are seeking to roll back any expectation that basic health care, like clean water, is a public utility that we promote because there's no good reason hundreds of thousands of people should die of cholera when a dollar's worth of chlorine could prevent it. Civilization is collectivization, sorry if you don't like it but "every man for himself" is not a recipe for advancement of the enterprise called humanity. Now: Show me your way is better. UHC advocates have trotted out their evidence; what, then, is yours?
 
Last edited:
...There's a reason the media is (are?) liberal. Reporters see how people can do everything right and still get screwed. It leads to a mind-set, well, maybe government can't solve every problem but it can address problems, mitigate things, have a coherent public policy based on harm reduction. It's what governments are for. Community college vocational programs for Debbie and her kids. A rural health van delivering preventative diabetes screening on an Indian reservation. These aren't actual examples, but close.1...
As it is, medicine can do far more for us than we'll ever be able to afford and it's all third-party payers and there are legitimate questions to raise about chemotherapy for a 35-year-old with curable cancer vs. transplants for 90-year-olds, and why not have that conversation as a society?2Because you've declared there is no point? I don't think so. Happily for those of your ideological ilk many in the U.S. are seeking to roll back any expectation that basic health care, like clean water, is a public utility that we promote because there's no good reason hundreds of thousands of people should die of cholera when a dollar's worth of chlorine could prevent it.3 Civilization is collectivization, sorry if you don't like it but "every man for himself" is not a recipe for advancement of the enterprise called humanity.4 Now: Show me your way is better. UHC advocates have trotted out their evidence; what, then, is yours?5
1. Good example. "Remote" is a matter of degree. If you have chosen to live away from people, you have chosen to live away from the services that people deliver. Like surfing big waves, there's a risk. Subsidized risk => moral hazard. As an aside, "tribes" are obsolete. At the time of the Constitutional convention, the US government had to deal with "foreign" governments within its borders. There's a tension between hereditary tribal status, on the one hand, and "equal protection of the law", and "no title of nobility" (i.e., no hereditary title), on the other.
2. Good idea. We are. Thanks for a civil tone.
3. Are Coke and Pepsi also public utilities? It's not the health issue that makes waterworks public utilities, but infrastructure economies of scale, seems to me. I can see a case for product safety regulation, and "regulation" grades smoothly into "State ownership". I don't see that recognizing the case for some regulation compels me to accept the end-of-the-line position of direct State operation, or even subsidy.
4. The government of a locality is the largest dealer in interpersonal violence in that locality (definition, after Weber). Corporate oversight is a public good, and the State itself is a corporation. Therefore, oversight of State functions is a public good which the State itself cannot provide. State assumption of responsibility for the provision of public goods transforms the "free rider" problem at the root of "public goods" analysis but does not eliminate it.

Recently, Hawaii newspapers reported on a complaint by a parent that one school here (Hawaii) ignored an accusation of child molestation by a teacher (did not report to police, as required by law). Our legislature is considering a bill to extend the statute of limitations on child abuse claims and has exempted government agencies from the expanded limits.

5. Randall G. Holcombe
Government: Unnecessary but Inevitable
The Independent Review Winter 2004

Eduardo Zambrano
"Formal Models of Authority: Introduction and Political Economy Applications"
Rationality and Society, May 1999
Aside from the important issue of how it is that a ruler may economize on communication, contracting and coercion costs, this leads to an interpretation of the state that cannot be contractarian in nature: citizens would not empower a ruler to solve collective action problems in any of the models discussed, for the ruler would always be redundant and costly. The results support a view of the state that is eminently predatory, (the ? MK.) case in which whether the collective actions problems are solved by the state or not depends on upon whether this is consistent with the objectives and opportunities of those with the (natural) monopoly of violence in society. This conclusion is also reached in a model of a predatory state by Moselle and Polak (1997). How the theory of economic policy changes in light of this interpretation is an important question left for further work.
Joel Fried
Pots and Kettles: Governance Practices of the Ontario Securities Commission
2. The Government’s Principal – Agent Problem
The principal-agent problem for the private sector is well known: the owner/principal delegates to a manager/agent the responsibility to provide some services for the principal. The problem is one of structuring contracts and institutions to insure that, in carrying out her duties, the agent acts in the principal’s interest rather than her own.
Citizens of a country also face a principal – agent problem. Citizens “own” the machinery of government and employ bureaucrats to act as their agents in running this machinery. To reduce the costs of monitoring, the principals choose a legislature/board of directors to oversee the agents. Monitoring mechanisms are similar to those in the private sector: there are financial accounting standards that are met for each budgetary unit, and an external auditor checks these internal accounts. Transparency is maintained, in part, through freedom of information regulations. Compliance with procedures and other regulations are met both through internal monitoring and checks by units external to the bureau. Finally, contracts are structured, at least in a limited manner, to align the incentives for agents with those of the principals.
There is, however, an additional problem in the public sector that does not exist for private firms. The firm has a well defined objective function – the maximization of profits – whereas the apparent objective for the government is the maximization of some index of a (weighted) level of welfare of the electorate. An unambiguous index of social welfare has been impossible to construct and, in its absence, monitoring the public sector is further complicated because data is generally lacking on whether or not the objective was actually approached and/or achieved and what the costs are that are linked to any specific objective. In effect, because of distribution issues and public goods, the cash flows measured with traditional accounting procedures will be, at best, only superficially correlated with that objective. Thus, looking at cash flows will provide the principals an extremely poor method of monitoring their public sector agents.
 
I'm not against ideology per se. .....There's a reason the media is (are?) liberal. Reporters see how people can do everything right and still get screwed.

It leads to a mind-set, well, maybe government can't solve every problem but it can address problems, mitigate things, have a coherent public policy based on harm reduction. It's what governments are for.

Community college vocational programs for Debbie and her kids. A rural health van delivering preventative diabetes screening on an Indian reservation.
.....
many in the U.S. are seeking to roll back any expectation that basic health care, like clean water, is a public utility that we promote because there's no good reason hundreds of thousands of people should die of cholera when a dollar's worth of chlorine could prevent it.

Civilization is collectivization, sorry if you don't like it but "every man for himself" is not a recipe for advancement of the enterprise called humanity. Now:

Show
me your way is better. UHC advocates have trotted out their evidence; what, then, is yours?

Massive numbers of ideological statements noted.

This statement is particularly interesting.

OF COURSE basic care should not be allocated on the basis of income!

It presupposes - "allocated" that a central government ALREADY OWNS THE INDUSTRY. Then and only then may they "allocate".

And all you've really done is praise the virtuous behavior of "big government", while conservatives tend to note the evil nature of big government.
 
Last edited:
So, your argument against using public sector delivered services vice private sector delivered services is that the index that can be used to measure success (ie the "unambiguous index of social welfare") is either too hard to construct or impossible to construct that we should fall back to the one that is intellectually easier - the balance sheet of a company or corporation?
 
So, your argument against using public sector delivered services vice private sector delivered services is that the index that can be used to measure success (ie the "unambiguous index of social welfare") is either too hard to construct or impossible to construct that we should fall back to the one that is intellectually easier - the balance sheet of a company or corporation?
The argument against a State role in any particular industry, beyond the role that the State plays in industry generally, an initial assignment of title and a reliable system of contract law, is as follows: the most effective accountability mechanism that humans have yet devised is a process that allows unhappy customers to take their business elsewhere. Where the State allows competition with its subsidiaries (e.g., the school industry) it puts its thumb on the scale (e.g., by restricting subsidies to the State-operated institution, or by exposing non-State institutions to greater legal liability, as I described above).
 
The argument against a State role in any particular industry, beyond the role that the State plays in industry generally, an initial assignment of title and a reliable system of contract law, is as follows: the most effective accountability mechanism that humans have yet devised is a process that allows unhappy customers to take their business elsewhere. Where the State allows competition with its subsidiaries (e.g., the school industry) it puts its thumb on the scale (e.g., by restricting subsidies to the State-operated institution, or by exposing non-State institutions to greater legal liability, as I described above).

But isn't part of the problem the separation of customer from services? The customer, in many cases, is the business buying a health plan. The one seeking services is an employee of that business. Without changing jobs, employees aren't free to shop elsewhere for services.

This leads to a system where the patients' satisfaction is secondary to the satisfaction of the corporation buying the policy.

Another problem is the ability of insurance companies to deny care. They are in a position where it is to their advantage to lose some (very ill) customers and retain those that don't use their services as much. One of the problems UHC is meant to address is the inability of those who most need the services to find any willing seller at all. As long as this pool of underserved is small, it has no real voice in the market and a threat of "taking my business elsewhere" is no threat at all.
 
But isn't part of the problem the separation of customer from services? The customer, in many cases, is the business buying a health plan. The one seeking services is an employee of that business. Without changing jobs, employees aren't free to shop elsewhere for services. This leads to a system where the patients' satisfaction is secondary to the satisfaction of the corporation buying the policy.1
Another problem is the ability of insurance companies to deny care. They are in a position where it is to their advantage to lose some (very ill) customers and retain those that don't use their services as much. One of the problems UHC is meant to address is the inability of those who most need the services to find any willing seller at all. As long as this pool of underserved is small, it has no real voice in the market and a threat of "taking my business elsewhere" is no threat at all.2
The above considerations do not rebut the argument against a State role in the medical services or health insurance industries. The first point is an argument against government-mandated employer-funded health insurance, seems to me (or, generalized, against corporate income taxes). Employer-funded health insurance originated as a dodge around corporate income taxes. As a benefit to the employee, they function as tax-exempt income. As a "cost" to the corporation, they reduce exposure to corporate income taxes. The second point applies at least as strongly to government-operated or government-subsidized services as to producers in an unsubsidized competitive market. Just substitute "(rationally ignorant) voters" for "customers".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom