Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

The above considerations do not rebut the argument against a State role in the medical services or health insurance industries. The first point is an argument against government-mandated employer-funded health insurance, seems to me (or, generalized, against corporate income taxes). Employer-funded health insurance originated as a dodge around corporate income taxes. As a benefit to the employee, they function as tax-exempt income. As a "cost" to the corporation, they reduce exposure to corporate income taxes. The second point applies at least as strongly to government-operated or government-subsidized services as to producers in an unsubsidized competitive market. Just substitute "(rationally ignorant) voters" for "customers".

The difference may be the possibility of voting on services. I think this is borne out in the "untouchability" of medicare. Although I tend to agree with the rationally ignorant part for voters, this at least gives a free market style mechanism where one is missing now.

It seems a dodge to claim, on the one hand, that free market forces will keep private insurance in line but then dismiss those same decision makers when they are voters.
 
Last edited:
But isn't part of the problem the separation of customer from services? The customer, in many cases, is the business buying a health plan. The one seeking services is an employee of that business. Without changing jobs, employees aren't free to shop elsewhere for services.

This leads to a system where the patients' satisfaction is secondary to the satisfaction of the corporation buying the policy.

Another problem is the ability of insurance companies to deny care. They are in a position where it is to their advantage to lose some (very ill) customers and retain those that don't use their services as much. One of the problems UHC is meant to address is the inability of those who most need the services to find any willing seller at all. As long as this pool of underserved is small, it has no real voice in the market and a threat of "taking my business elsewhere" is no threat at all.
Why would these two points matter? You've just offered two "problems" of a semi free market system. One of them is economic in nature (yes, employees are free to shop elsewhere for services, they just might be paying twice) the second is a matter that regulation addresses.

You haven't made any argument against the absence of a government health plan. I take it there is a pre existing presumption that a government plan "doesn't have these problems" and that somehow it "doesn't have these problems and doesn't create other problems that are worse or equal".

But that's not what you said.

In any case, if we are running 40% over revenue now, there's no money to cause the PROMISES OF POLITICIANS to be fulfilled, regardless of how much you like their promises.
 
Why would these two points matter? You've just offered two "problems" of a semi free market system. One of them is economic in nature (yes, employees are free to shop elsewhere for services, they just might be paying twice) the second is a matter that regulation addresses.

You haven't made any argument against the absence of a government health plan. I take it there is a pre existing presumption that a government plan "doesn't have these problems" and that somehow it "doesn't have these problems and doesn't create other problems that are worse or equal".

Actually, I was trying to point out that free market ideas don't apply very well.

In any case, if we are running 40% over revenue now, there's no money to cause the PROMISES OF POLITICIANS to be fulfilled, regardless of how much you like their promises.

Well, here's a thought. Take the money being spent now on health care in the private sector and make that public. But still, it would cost more. At least partly because the purpose is to do more. If the goal is to insure more people, you would expect it to cost more.

Suppose the government took all the money now being put into employee insurance programs? I don't know if that's being counted or not, and what I am describing is a one payer system, so that's not quite what AHC is addressing -- however, arguments about funding should include shifting current spending around, not simply an unfunded addition to public spending.

Whether or not the government can manage the task for the same money is another question. How much in additional funds would be required to insure the currently uninsured is another question. But these are things we can argue about -- is it worthwhile to the nation to insure everyone or not?
 
Last edited:
Actually, I was trying to point out that free market ideas don't apply very well.
I heard that in essence. But I don't see the ability to complain or find faults about something as even an indication that "free market ideas don't apply very well". You could as well note that free market ideas don't work very well with aircraft transportation because someone who doesn't have money can't do it. I can complain about anything, really, but that doesn't imply that even a very good alternative when applied is better (and Baaaamstercare is not that).

....Well, here's a thought. Take the money being spent now on health care in the private sector and make that public. But still, it would cost more. At least partly because the purpose is to do more. If the goal is to insure more people, you would expect it to cost more.

Suppose the government took all the money now being put into employee insurance programs? I don't know if that's being counted or not, and what I am describing is a one payer system, so that's not quite what AHC is addressing -- however, arguments about funding should include shifting current spending around, not simply an unfunded addition to public spending.

Whether or not the government can manage the task for the same money is another question. How much in additional funds would be required to insure the currently uninsured is another question. But these are things we can argue about -- is it worthwhile to the nation to insure everyone or not?
That's what I'm trying to get at. And it's not pleasant - it's a rather harsh reality. Take a government that spends 40% more than it takes in, and order it to increase it's total services by 10%.

Sooner or later anything that's not sustainable is going to change so that it is sustainable, and in this case that means huge cuts in entitlements. The likely outcome is that the additional funding will get soaked up elsewhere, and people will simply get cheated out of what they were promised.

There is simply no way that the products promised can be delivered.
 
As an aside, "tribes" are obsolete.

In your private language, maybe this means something. "Obsolete" or not, tribes still exist as functioning legal entities.

3. Are Coke and Pepsi also public utilities? It's not the health issue that makes waterworks public utilities, but infrastructure economies of scale, seems to me.

Mea culpa on contributing to thread drift. I didn't mean to turn this into a discussion of water utilities. Interesting for comparison though.

I can see a case for product safety regulation, and "regulation" grades smoothly into "State ownership".

What do you mean by "grades smoothly"? Do you mean that the case for product safety regulation too easily becomes a justification for state ownership? I'm not disagreeing, just trying to figure out what you're saying.

Corporate oversight is a public good, and the State itself is a corporation. Therefore, oversight of State functions is a public good which the State itself cannot provide.

And therefore ... what?

Recently, Hawaii newspapers reported on a complaint ....

You've lost me here. I wanted to see evidence to support your claim that there is no benefit to society in having health care-delivery questions dealt with on a macro scale. The bit about the Hawaii legislature and a sex-abuse reporting scandal seems completely unrelated.

It presupposes - "allocated" that a central government ALREADY OWNS THE INDUSTRY. Then and only then may they "allocate".

Note that I was speaking in the voice of gobsmacked JREF participants in the UK, Canada and Australia who by and large are happy that health care is considered a right, not a privilege.

And all you've really done is praise the virtuous behavior of "big government", while conservatives tend to note the evil nature of big government.

I want it to be the right size to get the job done. I'm not dismissing the idea of market forces in health care. But the two-tiered system - insured, uninsured - is crap. A hospital bills insurers $7K for an emergency appendectomy but private individuals $34K. And access to the $7K appendectomy is limited to people who can obtain insurance. And really the only reliable way to get insurance is to have a full-time job with an employer that negotiates group rates.

Whether I can pay "out of pocket" does have something to do with whether they bill me $7K or $34K, don't you think?
 
I heard that in essence. But I don't see the ability to complain or find faults about something as even an indication that "free market ideas don't apply very well". You could as well note that free market ideas don't work very well with aircraft transportation because someone who doesn't have money can't do it. I can complain about anything, really, but that doesn't imply that even a very good alternative when applied is better (and Baaaamstercare is not that).

At this point, I'm losing the substance of this particular digression. However, in an attempt to be pedantic, here's how I think it got here.

I think someone was saying that one benefit or the current system was the free market aspect. I understood this to mean that competition would tend to drive down prices and raise efficiency. I wanted to point out that the customers in the current system aren't really the patients, but employers who pay for healthcare policies. I'm not against the free market or necessarily dismissive of the benefits, just that the current system doesn't feel the same pressures as a classic free market. That's all.

I think Obama care is a poor patchwork that often comes with compromise. I think something much more radical has to emerge, providing we want to give some guaranteed level of healthcare to everyone in the US. If we don't want to do that, then the system as it is will continue along on inertia if nothing else.

To say one style of doing things is "broken" and another goes to far is a reflection of where you want to set the dial and what goals you want to accomplish.
 
Aggregates can mislead. Total expenditures differ in what is counted (do British totals include nursing homes, hospice care, or payments for private care or "medical tourism", for example). Aggregate age-adjusted life expectancy statistics vary according to what is counted. Are death to premature babies counted in "infant mortality, for example. Aggregate death statistics will vary due to factors that have little to do with quality of care, such as speed limits and diet.
Further...Here.
A persistent health-care myth is that the U.S. system is uniquely wasteful versus the European countries that spend far less per patient as a result of tight government control. Only the establishment experts who spread this myth will be surprised, but new research shows American patients are often getting more value—better outcomes and longer lives—in return for those extra dollars.
 
The US also has worth health issues due to cheaper greasy, fatty food. Further studies show that, should you have heart problems, you get better care in the US.
 
The US also has worth health issues due to cheaper greasy, fatty food. Further studies show that, should you have heart problems, you get better care in the US.

America spends far more on health care than other nations that provide UHC or more comprehensive public health care. And our costs are rising faster than all other nations.

Yeah, cherry picking is one way to make a case but in the end we spend more and get less (see link). Defending the status quo for statistical outliers doesn't make a lot of sense.
 
[America spends far more on health care than other nations that provide UHC or more comprehensive public health care. And our costs are rising faster than all other nations.

Yeah, cherry picking is one way to make a case but in the end we spend more and get less (see link). Defending the status quo for statistical outliers doesn't make a lot of sense.
Not "less". That generalization fails. As above, aggregates mislead. In some areas, US post-diagnosis survival rates look good. The supposition that governments elsewhere can provide medical services on a per-operation basis cheaper than can US market-oriented providers fails to one simple observation: if trhat were true, there would be "money on the table" available to countries that claim to operate at lower cost. They could split the difference between their per-unit costs and US per-unit costs and make money providing services to US citizens. Instead we see medical tourism from Britain (and the US) to private clinics in Spain, India, and Costa Rica.
I don't see anyone "defending the status quo".
 
At this point, I'm losing the substance of this particular digression. However, in an attempt to be pedantic, here's how I think it got here.

I think someone was saying that one benefit or the current system was the free market aspect. I understood this to mean that competition would tend to drive down prices and raise efficiency. I wanted to point out that the customers in the current system aren't really the patients, but employers who pay for healthcare policies. I'm not against the free market or necessarily dismissive of the benefits, just that the current system doesn't feel the same pressures as a classic free market. That's all.

I think Obama care is a poor patchwork that often comes with compromise. I think something much more radical has to emerge, providing we want to give some guaranteed level of healthcare to everyone in the US. If we don't want to do that, then the system as it is will continue along on inertia if nothing else.

To say one style of doing things is "broken" and another goes to far is a reflection of where you want to set the dial and what goals you want to accomplish.

The current US health care system can be well described as having been "regulated into failure" by the US government. Ninety percent of it's craziness is due to this. So you have a typical situation where progressives create a problem by their government interventions, then they propose a solution which is just more control or takeovers, essentially more socialism. When someone creates a problem that if existent may be repaired by his taking your assets, should not it be wise to be suspicious?

One of the first things the Baaaamstercare would do is to prevent me from buying prescription drugs from Canada at 40% the in-USA cost.
 
The US also has worth health issues due to cheaper greasy, fatty food. Further studies show that, should you have heart problems, you get better care in the US.
Do not worry. Forcing the population to buy guns and bibles will protect them from the ugly prospects of progressives trying to take away their cheap, greasy and fatty food. That is, in the absence of federal laws requiring purchase of cheap, greasy and fatty food.

;)
 
The supposition that governments elsewhere can provide medical services on a per-operation basis cheaper than can US market-oriented providers fails to one simple observation: if trhat were true, there would be "money on the table" available to countries that claim to operate at lower cost.
It's not supposition, it's fact. You can't wave away the data just because your don't like the results. You are an ideologue.
 
It's not supposition, it's fact.1 You can't wave away the data just because your don't like the results. You are an ideologue.2
1. Cheaper per operation is a fact? As I wrote, that implies that there's "money on the table". I expect the "fact" to which you refer is the claim that countries with single payer plans and/or State-operated medical services have lower aggregate costs and greater age-adjusted life expectancy. These "facts", even if true, involve numerous dubious assumptions about what is counted.
2. "Ideological" is an uncomplimentary way to say "systematic" or "principled" and I try to be systematic. Antonyms include "scatter-brained" and "unscrupulous".
 
Instead we see medical tourism from Britain (and the US) to private clinics in Spain, India, and Costa Rica.
I don't see anyone "defending the status quo".

More medical tourism would help. Understand though that to gauge how big of a factor this is you'd need more than anecdotal evidence that it happens sometimes.

Per the New Yorker (generally good reputation despite left-of-center opinions) you can get a hip replaced in Costa Rica for $15K vs. $90K here. U.S. insurers would offer more support for this practice if they didn't have deep discounts negotiated at U.S. hospitals. See earlier post re: Individual getting billed $34K vs. insurance getting billed $7K for emergency appendectomy surgery. It appears here like a case of price-fixing for the purpose of gouging a captive audience that has no way of becoming part of the privileged (insured) caste.

Surefire insurability too often has been limited to two special classes - those holding full-time employment with a benefits package and those eligible for public benefits. In fact the insurance issue is a good reason to seek employment in the public sector vs. the private, or to stay in a job that is not the highest economical use of your time. Stats, anyone, on how many private vs. government employers even offer health insurance?

Insurance pools are collectivist enterprises to begin with meaning someone else does the haggling for you. An employee can't just negotiate on his or her own; that would defeat the whole purpose of insurance pools.

I see little justification for arguing that the current hybrid two-tiered U.S. "system" is supple enough to embrace free-market principles and corrections - just repeated assertions that it should be, in theory.

The mandate system at least has the potential to promote transparency and competition, which of course is why conservatives came up with it. I'm on board with competition. But the system now is weighted against it, it's a hybrid and there's no going back. So how do we go forward?
 
It's not supposition, it's fact. You can't wave away the data just because your don't like the results. You are an ideologue.

Sure he can, he does it all the time. I find it frustrating because I'd like to hear arguments beyond "everyone dies." OK. Now, is there anything we can do to improve health care delivery? Should we bother trying? Free-market systematic thinkers have lots of highly defensible ideas about how to proceed if you're starting from scratch, but not much to say about how to improve what actually exists.
 
There are no perfect systems. Medical tourism is simply more cherry picking. Nations with lower costs of living will have lower costs for medical care. That demonstrates nothing.

BTW: Spain has UHC.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom