The above considerations do not rebut the argument against a State role in the medical services or health insurance industries. The first point is an argument against government-mandated employer-funded health insurance, seems to me (or, generalized, against corporate income taxes). Employer-funded health insurance originated as a dodge around corporate income taxes. As a benefit to the employee, they function as tax-exempt income. As a "cost" to the corporation, they reduce exposure to corporate income taxes. The second point applies at least as strongly to government-operated or government-subsidized services as to producers in an unsubsidized competitive market. Just substitute "(rationally ignorant) voters" for "customers".
The difference may be the possibility of voting on services. I think this is borne out in the "untouchability" of medicare. Although I tend to agree with the rationally ignorant part for voters, this at least gives a free market style mechanism where one is missing now.
It seems a dodge to claim, on the one hand, that free market forces will keep private insurance in line but then dismiss those same decision makers when they are voters.
Last edited: