Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

No it isn't. Let's see some evidence that UHC would be the best system for the USA. Including how it's paid for and how it's implemented and ho the level of care won't drop in quality.


This is a skeptic forum, back up your claims

Sometimes. Sometimes it's a skeptic forum, sometimes it's a True Believer forum. Funny how that works, huh?

;)
 
I'm not sure you are asking an empirical question that can overcome significant conflicts. Not all costs and benefits are deemed equal by conservatives and liberals alike. What is the criteria for "best system"? At best individuals can advance what they think are their criteria and then argue how it accomplishes those goals. All one need do is disagree with the criteria. In which case, like most political solutions, we will need to compromise.

We don't live in a perfect world.

He made the statement "best system" I just called him on it.
 
I'm confused. Ken is responding to Malcolm and noting that Malcolm is engaging in a fallacy. Where did Ken state "best system"? Thanks.

he said "you refuse to see that UHC is better than ALL other systems that have existed and exist in the world."



That's saying best.
 
he said "you refuse to see that UHC is better than ALL other systems that have existed and exist in the world."

That's saying best.
Thanks. Yeah, it could have been better worded. FWIW, UHC isn't a single system. But there are very good arguments for why UHC is far more preferable is the health and welfare of citizens is a priority. Nations with UHC have the highest rates of HDI and other metrics. To be frank, as one who fought against UHC, I honestly can't find a valid, compelling reason to oppose it. From a utilitarian standpoint it really seems a non-starter. If the US had the lowest cost and its citizens were average or better in life expectancy and health for most of its citizens then I could support the status quo.

  • The US spends the most as a percentage of GDP.
  • Health care costs in the US are rising faster than any other nation with UHC.
  • Nations rated higher in economic freedom than the US (like Hong Kong) have UHC.
What is it exactly that we fear?
 
I'm confused. Ken is responding to Malcolm and noting that Malcolm is engaging in a fallacy. Where did Ken state "best system"? Thanks.
If you want to play with your fallacies, can't you do so in private? Why not just drop the word altogether? I say "A". You can say "Not A, B." "Fallacy" presumes the conclusion, that I'm wrong and you're right. That's to be established by argument, not by your embarassing fascination with your limp fallacies.
 
Thanks. Yeah, it could have been better worded. FWIW, UHC isn't a single system. But there are very good arguments for why UHC is far more preferable is the health and welfare of citizens is a priority. Nations with UHC have the highest rates of HDI and other metrics. To be frank, as one who fought against UHC, I honestly can't find a valid, compelling reason to oppose it. From a utilitarian standpoint it really seems a non-starter. If the US had the lowest cost and its citizens were average or better in life expectancy and health for most of its citizens then I could support the status quo.

  • The US spends the most as a percentage of GDP.
  • Health care costs in the US are rising faster than any other nation with UHC.
  • Nations rated higher in economic freedom than the US (like Hong Kong) have UHC.
What is it exactly that we fear?

I don't think anyone opposes it for any other reason than cost. It could double the annual federal budget really easily. One could also say that the middle class would see the biggest cost increase and biggest drop in the quality of their care too.
 
I don't think anyone opposes it for any other reason than cost. It could double the annual federal budget really easily. One could also say that the middle class would see the biggest cost increase and biggest drop in the quality of their care too.
Yeah, I think you and I went over this. Thanks. :)
 
Been out of this thread since I last posted, but sorry to see no skeptical response other than the general I disagree with your analysis (regarding whether health care is interstate commerce). Although I would greatly like to see a well reasoned argument as to how health care does not rise to the level of interstate commerce, I was really looking forward to seeing whether anyone here would bite on the political question doctrine:

Political question doctrine legal definition of Political question ...
legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Political+question+doctrineAn issue that the federal courts refuse to decide because it properly belongs to the decision-making authority of elected officials. Political questions include such ...
 
Been out of this thread since I last posted, but sorry to see no skeptical response other than the general I disagree with your analysis (regarding whether health care is interstate commerce). ...
I'd like to force you to buy guns and bibles. But don't worry, no one is forcing you to do anything. You can just pay the penalty instead.

......I was really looking forward to seeing whether anyone here would bite on the political question doctrine:

Political question doctrine legal definition of Political question ...
legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Political+question+doctrineAn issue that the federal courts refuse to decide because it properly belongs to the decision-making authority of elected officials. Political questions include such ...
Sure. Because unconstitutional political decisions are.....
 
I don't think anyone opposes it for any other reason than cost. It could double the annual federal budget really easily. One could also say that the middle class would see the biggest cost increase and biggest drop in the quality of their care too.
Well, they would have been nicely lied to as and if that turned out to be the case. And fiscal realities indicate that'd be inevitable, as the government spends 40% more than it takes in now, and as we extrapolate that forward, we see a correction being necessary.

Such a "correction" takes away stuff like "government provided health care" while leaving in place the taxes for it.
 
I'd like to force you to buy guns and bibles. But don't worry, no one is forcing you to do anything. You can just pay the penalty instead.

Sure. Because unconstitutional political decisions are.....

what is the penalty for not following the mandate?
 
Apart from the death panels, of course.
If that's sarcasm, it's misplaced. Everybody dies. If you survive the accident, suicide, and homicide risks of the ages between 13 and 45, you are likely to die of a lingering illness. At some point, somebody or some body will decide it's time to pull the plug on Grandma and you. Nationalizing these decisions does not reduce costs; it increases them.
 
If that's sarcasm, it's misplaced. Everybody dies. If you survive the accident, suicide, and homicide risks of the ages between 13 and 45, you are likely to die of a lingering illness. At some point, somebody or some body will decide it's time to pull the plug on Grandma and you. Nationalizing these decisions does not reduce costs; it increases them.

presumptive nonsense,
 
Last edited:
what is the penalty for not following the mandate?
A fine in the amount of $985, initially, once per transgression, stepping up to once per day of any given transgression to, and limited by the reportable income of the disobediant citizen in the year in question.
 
If that's sarcasm, it's misplaced. Everybody dies. If you survive the accident, suicide, and homicide risks of the ages between 13 and 45, you are likely to die of a lingering illness. At some point, somebody or some body will decide it's time to pull the plug on Grandma and you. Nationalizing these decisions does not reduce costs; it increases them.
I understand how such decisions might be made on Grandma, but "and you" is a bit of a problem. Who is the "you"? For example, is it the person standing closest to Grandma when the plug is yanked? Is it the local Democratic precinct chair?
 
Guess who wants all or part of the law overturned by the court?

Strikingly, the same poll found that while 39% of Democrats wanted the law upheld, 38% wanted the mandate struck down and another 12% wanted the whole thing thrown out. In other words, 50% want part or all of the law tossed. Even taking into account that some of those may be liberals who dislike ObamaCare because it isn’t more expansive, it’s a striking rejection of the president’s main accomplishment by his own party.

Among independents, the numbers are even worse for the president: 40% want the whole law repealed, 33% want the mandate overturned and only 18% want the whole thing upheld. Unsurprisingly, Republicans hate it even more: 66% want the whole thing thrown out, 19% want just the mandate gone and only 10% want it all upheld. That’s based on a poll of 906 people, conducted from March 30 to April 5.


I tend to be intrigued by what's left out of posts as much as by what's in them. In this case, I was curious why you didn't mention the source of the poll. It would seem like an obvious piece of information to include.

I hope it was simply an oversight on your part that you neglected to tell us the source. But it was a rather serious oversight, since the poll turns out to be a privately-commissioned partisan poll.

The article you quoted is from Investors.Com, which is run by Investor's Business Daily (IBD). And in the article it says:

Investors.Com said:
For example, a poll just conducted for IBD by TechnoMetrica Market Intelligence found...


TechnoMetrica Market Intelligence? Never heard of them, so I have no idea how reputable they are. But it's odd IBD had to commission and run their own poll, from this firm, rather than use polling results from one of the established firms such as Gallup. It's not as if no reputable firm has been doing polling on this question.

So Investors.Com is not simply the source of the article detailing the results of the poll. They're also the source of the poll. Hmmm.

Judging by the titles of the items listed on the side of the site as "Most Popular", and a quick glance at their editorial opinion section, this looks like a right-wing opinion site rather than a neutral news site.

For example:

IRS Might Have Stalinist Powers Under New Law​
... There remain few things more prized than American citizenship. Yet now our ever-expanding leviathan of a government is forcing Americans abroad out, and it might soon build its own Berlin Wall...


That kind of over-blown rhetoric does not fill me with confidence that this is a reliable or unbiased source of poll results.

Question: If someone posted a poll on a contentious political issue that had been commissioned by ThinkProgress, would you accept that as reliable and authoritative? Or would you want to check it against results from independent polls, to see if reputable polling turned up the same results as the contracted polling did?

This isn't hard to check. I Googled Gallup "Affordable Care Act" and quickly got this, from February 27:

Gallup said:
Americans Divided on Repeal of 2010 Healthcare Law​

Americans divide evenly when asked if they favor (47%) or oppose (44%) a Republican president's repealing the 2010 healthcare law if elected this November. Republicans overwhelmingly favor repeal (87%) and Democrats overwhelmingly oppose it (77%)...


The Kaiser Tracking Poll came up with similar results in a poll published March 15:

Kaiser said:
Regular readers of the Kaiser Health Tracking poll know by now that public opinion on the Affordable Care Act (ACA) has been at a steady cruising altitude since it was signed into law on March 23, 2010, with a little over four in ten viewing the law favorably and a similar share unfavorably...


And from a Kaiser summary of polling results since the law was passed:

Kaiser said:
As the two-year anniversary of the law approaches, the public remains chronically divided. The public is almost perfectly split: 41 percent of Americans hold a favorable view of the law this month, while 40 percent hold an unfavorable one -- not terribly different from the 46 percent who favored it and 40 percent who did not in April 2010. Opinions divide sharply along partisan lines, with Republicans disliking the law (75% have an unfavorable view of it this month), Democrats favoring it (66% favorable) and independents more divided (40% favorable vs. 42% unfavorable).


I'm inclined to give significantly more weight to polling done by Gallup and Kaiser on this question than to polling privately commissioned by a group which favors one side of a political question. I hope, now that you've seen the contrasting poll results, that you will be too -- and will, perhaps, be a bit more cautious about trusting Investors.Com in the future.
 
I tend to be intrigued....

I was curious....

I hope....

I'm inclined to give significantly more weight...

I hope.....

.
Now is that the best you can do to defend the Baaamster's pile of legislative dog turds?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom