Malcolm Kirkpatrick
Banned
- Joined
- Jan 20, 2006
- Messages
- 4,046
Engrish, prease?Observing that it's not perfect as part of your argent is fallacy.
Engrish, prease?Observing that it's not perfect as part of your argent is fallacy.
I notice a conspicuous ABSENCE of answers to my question bolded above.....
If that dog of a bill passes SC review, that opens the door to any and all crony capitalist's lobbyists to move to force any and every product or service they gain from down on people in this country.
Seems like all sides politically should be a bit concerned about that.
Why couldn't the religious right, if they were owed a favor by the politicians in power, have an earmark attached to a bill that forced everyone to buy a bible? (please don't answer this with an argument about the "establishment clause", as I assure you I can nimbly dance around it as surely as Obamacare advocates drunkenly stumble and careen around the Commerce clause).
![]()
Strikingly, the same poll found that while 39% of Democrats wanted the law upheld, 38% wanted the mandate struck down and another 12% wanted the whole thing thrown out. In other words, 50% want part or all of the law tossed. Even taking into account that some of those may be liberals who dislike ObamaCare because it isn’t more expansive, it’s a striking rejection of the president’s main accomplishment by his own party.
Among independents, the numbers are even worse for the president: 40% want the whole law repealed, 33% want the mandate overturned and only 18% want the whole thing upheld. Unsurprisingly, Republicans hate it even more: 66% want the whole thing thrown out, 19% want just the mandate gone and only 10% want it all upheld. That’s based on a poll of 906 people, conducted from March 30 to April 5.
Right, but those of us who get out and around and talk to ordinary people already know this.Guess who wants all or part of the law overturned by the court?
Yeah, politics isn't easy. Adopting a Republican plan in the hopes that you can get past the stalemate might be shrewd politically but it's going to come with a cost. I don't find this at all surprising. Obama was trying solve a problem. I guess he could be faulted for putting pragmatic solutions ahead of politics. That's pretty cynical.Guess who wants all or part of the law overturned by the court?Strikingly, the same poll found that while 39% of Democrats wanted the law upheld, 38% wanted the mandate struck down and another 12% wanted the whole thing thrown out. In other words, 50% want part or all of the law tossed. Even taking into account that some of those may be liberals who dislike ObamaCare because it isn’t more expansive, it’s a striking rejection of the president’s main accomplishment by his own party.
Among independents, the numbers are even worse for the president: 40% want the whole law repealed, 33% want the mandate overturned and only 18% want the whole thing upheld. Unsurprisingly, Republicans hate it even more: 66% want the whole thing thrown out, 19% want just the mandate gone and only 10% want it all upheld. That’s based on a poll of 906 people, conducted from March 30 to April 5.
I see little pragmatism in a 2700 p. bill passed without republican votes, and in face of public outcry against it. ymmv.Yeah, politics isn't easy. Adopting a Republican plan in the hopes that you can get past the stalemate might be shrewd politically but it's going to come with a cost. I don't find this at all surprising. Obama was trying solve a problem. I guess he could be faulted for putting pragmatic solutions ahead of politics. That's pretty cynical.
I call BS on the public outcry. It was pragmatic to appeal to the GOP. However, given Clinton's triangulation it's apparent that any of their ideas that the Dems adopt will be roundly rejected for political purposes.I see little pragmatism in a 2700 p. bill passed without republican votes, and in face of public outcry against it. ymmv.
Public outcry existed when the "process -- jam it through a democrat house & senate" was underway. Pragmatic? I still think not.I call BS on the public outcry. It was pragmatic to appeal to the GOP. However, given Clinton's triangulation it's apparent that any of their ideas that the Dems adopt will be roundly rejected for political purposes.
Yes, it was pragmatic. It passed.
Yeah, like I said, BS. There are always people who "outcry". Much of what Bush did was followed by an "outcry" by some segment of the population. That some people get their panties in a bunch doesn't constitute a public outcry and your arguing the point ad nauseam isn't going to change that. It passed because it was pragmatic. The GOP dreamed it up by looking for a market solution. Pragmatic? Damn straight. That some people don't like something doesn't demonstrate that it isn't pragmatic. Your argument is silly.Public outcry existed when the "process -- jam it through a democrat house & senate" was underway.
How is passing a law after decades of debate with a 60 seat majority in the Senate, "jamming" something through?
There wasn't decades of debate on the bill that was passed. Pelosi and crew didn't even read the damn thing. Perhaps you've forgotten her famous line, "We have to pass the bill so you can find out what is in it".How is passing a law after decades of debate with a 60 seat majority in the Senate, "jamming" something through?
Engrish, prease?
Public outcry existed when the "process -- jam it through a democrat house & senate" was underway. Pragmatic? I still think not.
There wasn't decades of debate on the bill that was passed. Pelosi and crew didn't even read the damn thing. Perhaps you've forgotten her famous line, "We have to pass the bill so you can find out what is in it".
Sounds like a quote taken quite out of context. Perhaps the GOP should have read the bill to reason out why they were against it.
You mean the bill that was passed through waiving some of the rules and using reconciliation process in the Senate?How is passing a law after decades of debate with a 60 seat majority in the Senate, "jamming" something through?
Denial of care rebuts the "everyone gets care" argument that advocates of nationalized health care make. That's the "fallacy" (i.e., lie). I also dispute that "UHC" is "better than all other systems". First, there is no single "UHC". Second, if "UHC" reduces costs on a per-operation basis, why do not countries with "UHC" offer the service for a fee above their marginal cost but lower than the non-UHC per-operation cost to citizens of non-UHC countries? There's "money on the table", as the economists say, if "UHC" really is cheaper. I suspect that someone's cooking the books.As part of your argument, you stated that UHC still fails some people. Thus, the "perfect system" fallacy. There is no such thing as a perfect health care system, yet you refuse to see that UHC is better than ALL other systems that have existed and exist in the world.
Look, buddy, you jest don't get it so lemme help you out'a'bit.Denial of care rebuts the "everyone gets care" argument that advocates of nationalized health care make. That's the "fallacy" (i.e., lie). I also dispute that "UHC" is "better than all other systems". First, there is no single "UHC". Second, if "UHC" reduces costs on a per-operation basis, why do not countries with "UHC" offer the service for a fee above their marginal cost but lower than the non-UHC per-operation cost to citizens of non-UHC countries? There's "money on the table", as the economists say, if "UHC" really is cheaper. I suspect that someone's cooking the books.
As part of your argument, you stated that UHC still fails some people. Thus, the "perfect system" fallacy. There is no such thing as a perfect health care system, yet you refuse to see that UHC is better than ALL other systems that have existed and exist in the world.
I'm not sure you are asking an empirical question that can overcome significant conflicts. Not all costs and benefits are deemed equal by conservatives and liberals alike. What is the criteria for "best system"? At best individuals can advance what they think are their criteria and then argue how it accomplishes those goals. All one need do is disagree with the criteria. In which case, like most political solutions, we will need to compromise.No it isn't. Let's see some evidence that UHC would be the best system for the USA. Including how it's paid for and how it's implemented and ho the level of care won't drop in quality.
This is a skeptic forum, back up your claims