Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

1. Cheaper per operation is a fact? As I wrote, that implies that there's "money on the table". I expect the "fact" to which you refer is the claim that countries with single payer plans and/or State-operated medical services have lower aggregate costs and greater age-adjusted life expectancy. These "facts", even if true, involve numerous dubious assumptions about what is counted.
2. "Ideological" is an uncomplimentary way to say "systematic" or "principled" and I try to be systematic. Antonyms include "scatter-brained" and "unscrupulous".

In fact there is much commerce in all directions: We have people going to Mexico for dentistry, mainland China for full set of teeth replacement, Thailand for cosmetic surgery. People come from all over the world to MD Anderson in Houston. Many in the US buy prescription drugs from Canada. That's the free market at work. Offhand I don't know what this nets out to, that'd be an interesting number.

In order to blur all the realities, the Left creates a nice packaged hypothetical called "health care".

You called them on this.

That means you get ad hominem attacks.

Pretty simple, really.
 
In Colorado hospitals bill uninsured patients at 800 percent above cost per a Colorado state senator; the Colorado Hospital Association acknowledges that a 500 percent markup is standard. Just what you need when recovering from a stroke.

Since the uninsured can expect at least a 500 percent markup, is it any wonder that people believe a health emergency will wipe them out? If it weren't for bogus billing maybe more people would choose to self-insure. But it's impossible to even cost out procedures. Hospitals make up the numbers and wink that they're willing to bargain.

Hospitals want to scare people into getting insurance, but there's a good chance that whatever the patient was treated for will in turn make him or her uninsurable. Hospitals are also probably trying to make a point about unfunded mandates, which have nothing to do with that individual. This is just how they vent.

Expecting people to effectively negotiate during a heart attack is unrealistic. Attempted extortion after the fact doesn't seem fair either. Without being a member of a collective-bargaining pool an individual has no access to economies of scale. Without that access they are billed at fake rates.

And how do we escape another obvious free-market obstruction? The state owns the means of credentialing surgeons. Why? There are people barred from practice who could probably do a reasonable job for discounted rates. Maybe they should be allowed to operate on the willing to risk it. Any advocates for that position here?
 
Last edited:
In Colorado hospitals bill uninsured patients at 800 percent above cost per a Colorado state senator; the Colorado Hospital Association acknowledges that a 500 percent markup is standard. Just what you need when recovering from a stroke.

Since the uninsured can expect at least a 500 percent markup, is it any wonder that people believe a health emergency will wipe them out? If it weren't for bogus billing maybe more people would choose to self-insure. But it's impossible to even cost out procedures. Hospitals make up the numbers and wink that they're willing to bargain.

Hospitals want to scare people into getting insurance, but there's a good chance that whatever the patient was treated for will in turn make him or her uninsurable. Hospitals are also probably trying to make a point about unfunded mandates, which have nothing to do with that individual. This is just how they vent.

Expecting people to effectively negotiate during a heart attack is unrealistic. Attempted extortion after the fact doesn't seem fair either. Without being a member of a collective-bargaining pool an individual has no access to economies of scale. Without that access they are billed at fake rates.

And how do we escape another obvious free-market obstruction? The state owns the means of credentialing surgeons. Why? There are people barred from practice who could probably do a reasonable job for discounted rates. Maybe they should be allowed to operate on the willing to risk it. Any advocates for that position here?

SO WHAT?

I'm not disagreeing with your facts at all. Do this. Think like a regulator or a person devising regulations. Take off the fantasy hat of "Universal medical care is the cure all". Why? Because it also needs effective regulations to work, otherwise, it also, is broke.

(Side note: In a sense that's a proof that it cannot work well here, the quality of our regulation would be no better).

Now, can you think of practical regulations to fix these problems without equally bad or worse side effects?

I certainly can.
 
If it weren't for bogus billing maybe more people would choose to self-insure.

Which, come to think of it, is not an option for lots of people. I couldn't opt out of my employer's plan. This is a made-up problem? Really? It seems like there are myriad levels of coercion already. Single-payer UHC types can at least point to what they want. I'm not sure the right wing has a response other than "everybody dies." That's not public policy, it's a statement about the futility of public policy. Any public policy. My favored Alzheimer's-care policy relies on paying illegal immigrants a pittance under the table in exchange for free board. Keeps people out of nursing homes, generates remittances, preserves capital, probably generates an acceptable quality of life for both parties. This isn't OK with the left or the right. Artificial economic constraints don't come from just one end of the spectrum.
 
Now, can you think of practical regulations to fix these problems without equally bad or worse side effects?

I certainly can.

I see, you just choose not to share them.

It's like, someone asked for an example of a modern, industrialized country - I forget the exact specs - that lets 35-year-olds with treatable cancer die. You say you can name LOTS and then point to ... Nazi Germany. (Ignoring modern Germany, which is collectivist and apparently solvent.) Amusing for you, unresponsive overall. Like playing tennis with a black hole. But if you get off on being cryptic, whatever.
 
I'd like to force you to buy guns and bibles.

I've already pointed out the flaw in this argument. You're just offering an absurd hypothetical (Congress will never pass a law mandating individuals buy guns and bibles) and observing that it is absurd. It has nothing to do with the actual constitutional issue.

That is, "absurd" is not the same as "unconstitutional".
 
(Side note: In a sense that's a proof that it cannot work well here, the quality of our regulation would be no better).

"Our" regulation won't work ...

Now, can you think of practical regulations to fix these problems without equally bad or worse side effects?

I certainly can.

Your regulations will.

Everyone's got an opinion. I'm just tickled pink when I have an informed one.
 
I see, you just choose not to share them.

It's like, someone asked for an example of a modern, industrialized country - I forget the exact specs - that lets 35-year-olds with treatable cancer die. You say you can name LOTS and then point to ... Nazi Germany. (Ignoring modern Germany, which is collectivist and apparently solvent.) Amusing for you, unresponsive overall. Like playing tennis with a black hole. But if you get off on being cryptic, whatever.

Yes, you did forget. It was PRE NAZI Germany. And I showed the method by which you or anyone could find dozens of similar situations. That's the exact opposite of being cryptic.

As for what I "choose to share", I asked something of YOU.
 
Last edited:
There are no perfect systems. Medical tourism is simply more cherry picking.1 Nations with lower costs of living will have lower costs for medical care.2 That demonstrates nothing.3BTW: Spain has UHC.4
1. This use of "cherry picking" in no sense parallels the customary use in this discussion. In argument, "cherry picking" is lying, by deliberate selection of unrepresentative data or statistics. Here, "cherry picking" means catering to a subset of the market. Specialization, in other words. This generally improves services and lowers costs.
2. Other factors beyond "cost of living" determine the cost of care.
3. Medical tourism demonstrates that private, for-profit medicine can compete even against "free" State-operated care.
4. Spain also has private clinics that treat foreign patients.
 
1. This use of "cherry picking" in no sense parallels the customary use in this discussion. In argument, "cherry picking" is lying, by deliberate selection of unrepresentative data or statistics. Here, "cherry picking" means catering to a subset of the market. Specialization, in other words. This generally improves services and lowers costs.
2. Other factors beyond "cost of living" determine the cost of care.
3. Medical tourism demonstrates that private, for-profit medicine can compete even against "free" State-operated care.
4. Spain also has private clinics that treat foreign patients.
And Spain is broke. Wondrous socialized bs put into place by fascist Franco.

http://countrystudies.us/spain/51.htm

....years from 1951 to 1956 were marked by substantial economic progress, but the reforms of the period were only spasmodically implemented, and they were poorly coordinated. One large obstacle to the reform process was the corrupt, inefficient, and bloated bureaucracy. A former correspondent of London's Financial Times, Robert Graham, described the Franco era as "the triumph of paleocapitalism--primitive market skills operating in a jungle of bureaucratic regulations, protectionism, and peddled influence." By the mid-1950s, the inflationary spiral had resumed its upward climb, and foreign currency reserves that had stood at US$58 million in 1958 plummeted to US$6 million by mid-1959. The standard of living remained one of the lowest in Western Europe, and the backwardness of agriculture and of the land-tenure system, despite lip service to agrarian reform, kept farm productivity low. The growing demands of the emerging middle class--and of the ever greater number of tourists--for the amenities of life, particularly for higher nutritional standards, placed heavy demands on imported foodstuffs and luxury items. At the same time, exports lagged, largely because of high domestic demand and institutional restraints on foreign trade. The peseta fell to an all-time low on the black market, and Spain's foreign currency obligations grew to almost US$60 million.
 
Last edited:
...is there anything we can do to improve health care delivery? Should we bother trying? Free-market systematic thinkers have lots of highly defensible ideas about how to proceed if you're starting from scratch, but not much to say about how to improve what actually exists.
"Is there anything we can do to improve health care delivery?"
Lots of things. Take care of yourself. That's a generous act, since it frees other people of the burden of carrying you and makes their labor available to others. Pull over when you see an ambulance in the rear view mirror. Take a First Aid class and render aid when you encounter someone who could use your help. Donate to a medical charity with a good reputation for efficient use of its resources (that's not the government, I hope you'll agree. Consider GSA). What public policies could improve health care? This gets complicated and depends, in part, on the meaning of "could". Political realism intrudes. Disinterested but realistic legislators will acknowledge interest group politics and ideologically-motivated opposition to any proposal. "Can" "we" make pre-college education more effective, so that an MD degree could take four years (undergraduate) rather than eight? "Can" "we" break the AMA cartel and expand the range of services that nurses or EMTs may legally provide? "Can" "we" require that government agencies compensate all of their employees in cash only (no retirement plans or other benefits), repeal corporate income taxes (reducing the financial incentive to connect health insurance to employment)? Dunno. That's a long-term project which involves changing the minds of people who imagine that the sun shines out of the government's ... rectum.

Can we convert the next Jehovah's Witness who comes to the door to materialism? Probably not.
 
Last edited:
"Is there anything we can do to improve health care delivery?"
Lots of things. Take care of yourself. That's a generous act, since it frees other people of the burden of carrying you and makes their labor available to others. Pull over when you see an ambulance in the rear view mirror. Take a First Aid class and render aid when you encounter someone who could use your help. Donate to a medical charity with a good reputation for efficient use of its resources (that's not the government, I hope you'll agree. Consider GSA). What public policies could improve health care? This gets complicated and depends, in part, on the meaning of "could". Political realism intrudes. Disinterested but realistic legislators will acknowledge interest group politics and ideologically-motivated opposition to any proposal. "Can" "we" make pre-college education more effective, so that an MD degree could take four years (undergraduate) rather than eight? "Can" "we" break the AMA cartel and expand the range of services that nurses or EMTs may legally provide? "Can" "we" require that government agencies compensate all of their employees in cash only (no retirement plans or other benefits), repeal corporate income taxes (reducing the financial incentive to connect health insurance to employment)? Dunno. That's a long-term project which involves changing the minds of people who imagine that the sun shines out of the government's ... rectum.

Can we convert the next Jehovah's Witness who comes to the door to materialism? Probably not.
Only one comment: 4 years from high school to an MD degree? Not possible. Could be done in 6 years, but you'd still be faced with picking candidates at a rather young age for the profession.

This is made worse by the "everyone graduates" theory of high school, the result is you'd have high dropout rates in medical school, which would be a real waste of resources and affect the graduation rates, and the total number of doctors produced. Anyway, you'd only be increasing the number of doctors practicing after decades, as a result of hopefully increasing the years each will practice.

To what end? Now many are planning to quietly quit practice if Obamacare remains law. That's the opposite effect.
 
Only one comment: 4 years from high school to an MD degree? Not possible.
Depends. School is a huge waste of time.
Here.
UNDEGRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION Basic medical education requires six years training that usually starts at age 17. Training of doctors and pharmacists in Russian is provided in 48 higher medical and pharmaceutical institutions.
So that means an MD at 23. We could probably shave a few years off that. A homeschooler whom I tutored took the GRE (Math) at 17 and earned his MS (Math) at 19. Why suppose that this is impossible with the MCAT and 4 year MD program? A few years ago, papers reported a homeschooling mother who studied for the MCAT, passed, and got accepted to medical school. Her daughter studied with her, also passed, and got accepted, at age 12. If she progressed normally after that she got her MD at 16.

In any case, credit-by-exam for all non-lab courses required for certification (K-PhD or K-MD), at the cost of grading exams, would lower costs of school and therefore increase the supply of MDs, lowering the cost of MD services.

"Can" "we" do this? Against opposition from well-paid, articulate, politically adept K-PHD industry insiders, probably not.
 
"Is there anything we can do to improve health care delivery?"

Thanks for the specifics. I agree with some of the suggestions.

Dunno. That's a long-term project which involves changing the minds of people who imagine that the sun shines out of the government's ... rectum.

I don't worship government or the market. I do accept the premise of government and find it reasonable to look for best practices. UHC advocates offer up data and you say maybe we're not comparing apples to apples. OK, let's be careful to do that. The fact remains: UHC advocates offer data. Market advocates offer theory.

To what end? Now many are planning to quietly quit practice if Obamacare remains law. That's the opposite effect.

Do you have quantitative evidence? Sorry if it's been presented. And on the earlier issue: You were speaking of pre-Nazi Germany, but the request was for a modern example. The "I could tell you but I won't" replies baffle me.
 
Depends. School is a huge waste of time.
Here.So that means an MD at 23. We could probably shave a few years off that. A homeschooler whom I tutored took the GRE (Math) at 17 and earned his MS (Math) at 19. Why suppose that this is impossible with the MCAT and 4 year MD program? A few years ago, papers reported a homeschooling mother who studied for the MCAT, passed, and got accepted to medical school. Her daughter studied with her, also passed, and got accepted, at age 12. If she progressed normally after that she got her MD at 16.

In any case, credit-by-exam for all non-lab courses required for certification (K-PhD or K-MD), at the cost of grading exams, would lower costs of school and therefore increase the supply of MDs, lowering the cost of MD services.

"Can" "we" do this? Against opposition from well-paid, articulate, politically adept K-PHD industry insiders, probably not.

I did mention that an MD in 6 years was possible. I used 2 years undergraduate plus 4 years medical. But what that does is free up classroom space in the undergraduate classrooms, not the medical schools. The number of slots and the number of docs produced per year remains the same. If the 6 years was spent entirely at any of our current medical school facilities the number of doctors produced goes down.

As for credit by exam, it is true that there are specific courses in medical school or areas of understanding that people who already have knowledge of - say a Phd in that field - would find a snap. But this isn't the case for the high school graduate entering a 6 year program.
 
Thanks for the specifics. I agree with some of the suggestions.



I don't worship government or the market. I do accept the premise of government and find it reasonable to look for best practices. UHC advocates offer up data and you say maybe we're not comparing apples to apples. OK, let's be careful to do that. The fact remains: UHC advocates offer data. Market advocates offer theory.



Do you have quantitative evidence? Sorry if it's been presented. And on the earlier issue: You were speaking of pre-Nazi Germany, but the request was for a modern example. The "I could tell you but I won't" replies baffle me.
And then Spain was suggested, and I explained why we can all laugh at that. Look at what I said - whenever a government spends all the money and then some, just printing it out of thin air, none of it's promises are any good. Including those for medical care. Then I said that it's easy to find lists of these countries. Just look up "hyperinflation" in Wikipedia. There is a PARTIAL list (some countries who have had this type of economic crisis did not have hyperinflation, and some others had a collapse of socialized medicine without experiencing hyperinflation) of countries who reneged on health care promises.

This isn't rocket science.
 
Last edited:
America spends far more on health care than other nations that provide UHC or more comprehensive public health care. And our costs are rising faster than all other nations.

Yeah, cherry picking is one way to make a case but in the end we spend more and get less (see link). Defending the status quo for statistical outliers doesn't make a lot of sense.

If you have a heart problem, you want the best care. That's in the US.


Everything else is secondary. Everything else is cherry picking. Everything.
 
Last edited:
If you have a heart problem, you want the best care. That's in the US.

Everything else is secondary. Everything else is cherry picking. Everything.

What's the difference between the best care and the second best care? If our standard is going to "best" then we can use it to choose doctors and hospitals as well as the system overall. With this idea in mind, no one would want to see the second best doctor or go to the second best hospital.

It brings up the problem with individual choice as a driver. Of course I want the best, and of course I do not want to pay for it. We have a problem making rational, cold hearted decisions when our own healthcare is at stake. That's why I shouldn't be making the decision.

This also explains why I will listen to experts on most issues but won't when it comes to healthcare.
 
If you have a heart problem, you want the best care. That's in the US.
You are suggesting everything takes a back seat to heart problems? The fact that our costs are rising faster than all other systems, that so many American's don't have health care, you would give up everything for a single data point, isn't that special pleading?

Everything else is secondary. Everything else is cherry picking. Everything.
But aren't you ignoring everything else for this? Isn't that cherry picking? Or do you have some special pleading to justify your cherry picking?
 
If you have a heart problem, you want the best care. That's in the US.


Everything else is secondary. Everything else is cherry picking. Everything.
Or cancer treatment - you go to MD Anderson in Houston. From all over the world. Then there's the Mayo Clinic.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom