Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

The argument to this is that health care is different from these because it falls under the Commerce Clause and is unique because there are laws that require that health care providers (doctors, hospitals, etc.) provide essential health care even if a person can’t (demonstrate that they can) pay for it.

If so, then government made it unique. What's to stop government from making other markets unique by similar intervention? In fact, government already intervenes heavily in a number of markets (including food and housing) where everyone participates. If government intervention is itself a justification for the expansion of government powers, then what limit remains?

Therefore, the government, which established constitutional laws to “insure” minimum health care, which directly affects health insurance commerce, has the power to regulate that commerce, and those that directly affect it, by enacting a penalty on those who do not have private health insurance.

Potential future commerce should not be treated as actual commerce. We should not be able to regulate what doesn't exist, and potential future commerce doesn't exist until (and if) it becomes actual present commerce. If we start treating potential future commerce as something which can be regulated, then there is likewise no limit to what falls under the commerce clause.
 
The Biggest issue is how to pay for it.. I have still not heard any reasonable manner in which to pay for UHC. It would double the Federal Budget, well at least for the first 10 years or so. I know that eventually costs would go down as everything stabilized, but with our aging population, let's not fool ourselves into thinking it won't be an enormous cost. When we spend 500 billion bucks to cover 50 million people in Medicare in 2010 (from the medicare budget site)and another $300 billion in Medicaid how are we going to afford the same type of expenditures for 6 times the people ? You institute UHC there goes private insurance as companies will have no reason to offer it to their employees? You can't force them to do it.

So let's say that 10% of the population will use private Dr's out of pocket. That leaves 300 million people. Many of them nearing their senior years. Can we afford to spend $3.5 trillion dollars just on UHC? If we tax the wealthy too much they will hide their money or move. (see 1970's England). How can we pay for it?

It's not like Norway. There's 5 million of them, most of them are Norwegian and most of them are middle class. That's a country less than a 60th the population of the USA. Not to mention that they have been dealing with a higher taxation policy for 60+ years. You try and spring those kinds of tax increases on Americans..... it ain't gonna fly.


I think that's where some of the misunderstanding between logical Republicans (like myself, I'm not talking the Jesus freaks, I'm talking the Republicans in favor of fiscal responsibility) and Democrats happen. No reasonable person is against UHC because they are saying "to hell with the poor" that's a cheap shot emotional reaction that has no bearing on the subject at hand.

The problem is HOW TO PAY FOR IT. What are you going to cut the defense budget? That won't even make a dent in it. (not to mention that a country of our population and vast area requires a large defense budget. there's just no way around it). Doubling our budget means doubling the taxation. That's a hard pill to swallow and I can't see the middle class going for it as they are the most likely to see an increase in their cost and the biggest drop in the quality of their care. The poor will pay nothing and see a vast improvement in their care, the rich...well, they will see private Dr's. The middle class will now be overtaxed and wait in line like everyone else waiting to see a Dr who is probably overworked, underpaid and stressed.

IMO, it's a system designed to help one sort of person (the poor) at the expense of another kind of person (everyone else)
 
Devils,

It is not fair to you in your hypothetical, but I don't see why "fair to me" is even an issue when it comes to federal law. Certainly there are hundreds of laws that "aren't fair to me."

If the idea is the greatest good for the greatest number-- that has legs. .....
No, it doesn't.

The idea of the "greatest good for the greatest number" is neither one of the enumerated powers in the Constitution, or an extensible interpretation of the Commerce Clause. Lots of "good things" may not be Constitutional. However, if you want to consider the Greater Good, the success of our US Constitution may be due to the limits it places on legislators and executives in implementing their particular theories. In turn this would mean that the limits of the Constitution, were themselves actually the "Greater Good". That is my view and that of strict constructionists in general.

An anecdote.

I have by sheer chance right now the following.

  • A relative who went into the hospital yesterday with a minor stroke, who got an MRI.
  • A relative of a friend who lives in a prosperous Western country with socialized medicine, Canada, was diagnosed with a severe problem that will result in death if not quickly treated, and may anyway. The diagnosis was two weeks ago. She is still waiting for a CAT scan.

...Potential future commerce should not be treated as actual commerce. We should not be able to regulate what doesn't exist, and potential future commerce doesn't exist until (and if) it becomes actual present commerce. If we start treating potential future commerce as something which can be regulated, then there is likewise no limit to what falls under the commerce clause.
This is obviously going to be a landmark case, that sets what limits there may be for the Commerce Clause for future legislation. The SC has not uncommonly issued an opinion of limited scope for particular issues.

Don't think that will be the case this time.
 
Last edited:
Therefore, the government, which established constitutional laws to “insure” minimum health care, which directly affects health insurance commerce, has the power to regulate that commerce, and those that directly affect it, by enacting a penalty on those who do not have private health insurance.
This says nothing about the limits to that regulation of commerce. As an example, unless everyone buys a minimum amount of broccoli each month, the interstate commerce market in broccoli will be significantly impacted, therefore the government should mandate the purchase of broccoli by the public each month.
 
The Biggest issue is how to pay for it.....
Well, not quite. Entitlements are understood to already be the problem in the budget and it's future projections. They are unsustainable. So rather than ask "how will we pay for extension XYZ of entitlements"....

The right question is something like how will we come to grips with the very difficult reality that entitlements will shrink, and that will happen either nicely, or rather unpleasantly.

I think it will be the latter, frankly.
 
This says nothing about the limits to that regulation of commerce. As an example, unless everyone buys a minimum amount of broccoli each month, the interstate commerce market in broccoli will be significantly impacted, therefore the government should mandate the purchase of broccoli by the public each month.
Causing an argument from altruism, at the onset by progressives and socialists (in favor of universal health care) to become an argument for government having the right to favor political cronies in the capitalistic system.

Rather unsatisfactory to those of all persuasions, one would think.
 
An anecdote.

I have by sheer chance right now the following.

  • A relative who went into the hospital yesterday with a minor stroke, who got an MRI.
  • A relative of a friend who lives in a prosperous Western country with socialized medicine, Canada, was diagnosed with a severe problem that will result in death if not quickly treated, and may anyway. The diagnosis was two weeks ago. She is still waiting for a CAT scan.

I like this because it brings up a great point. How can we do better and what limitations on care are we willing to accept?

I think there is one critical mistake in the equation. We allow patients to determine what level of care they need. Those that have great insurance use it, sometimes to excess. Those that have none are left deciding if it's even worthwhile to seek treatment (I'm in this latter class and generally do not seek treatment -- but I'd do that anyway because I'm an idiot). I would prefer that professionals determine what constitutes "enough" care.

When patients make the decisions, they have a dog in the hunt and I don't expect them to be as cold-heartedly rational as economics might demand. Is there any way to get past the infinite value of human life? That evaluation messes up the equations and swamps all the calculations.

I would be willing to accept less than the best healthcare if it were available to all without crippling our economy. I do not know if this can be done or just what "good enough" would entail. Still, if you think about it, we already have a line where we accept that nothing further can be done. We turn off the machines or shrug our shoulders when no heart for transplant is available, or we cut off funding for addiction treatment... and on and on.

It isn't like we don't have limits now, the argument is about where that line should be drawn. And that decision I am not qualified to make. It's one for the medical ethicists, economists, and the doctors. But it needs to be done.

Right out of the gate, I'd like to see doctors draw a hard line on treatment options (including that MRI you mentioned) based on outcomes instead of "seems like a good idea." If, for example, an MRI only improved outcomes in a very small percentage of stroke cases (I don't know this, I'm just making a hypothetical) then maybe an MRI isn't a good idea. Where should the line be?

And why is it all or none? I am perfectly happy with a two tiered system with a certain level of care at public expense and a higher level at private.
 
Sure it is, we let the system collapse due to over inflated pricing and rebuild it cheaper.
 
Sure it is, we let the system collapse due to over inflated pricing and rebuild it cheaper.
That isn't doing nothing. And what pray tell are the consequences of a collapse of 1/6th of the economy?
 
It serves them right . We allowed this to happen and we deserve to have it fall apart. We let medicare approve ridiculous pricing which then insurance companies followed suit with paying and before you knew it it was out of control. The only way to fix it is to let it go critical. I'm not saying it would collapse per se, what it will do is be forced to lower pricing so as to lure people back again. People will stop going if it get's too expensive, and iMO, it's pretty darn close to that point now.
 
It serves them right . We allowed this to happen and we deserve to have it fall apart. We let medicare approve ridiculous pricing which then insurance companies followed suit with paying and before you knew it it was out of control. The only way to fix it is to let it go critical. I'm not saying it would collapse per se, what it will do is be forced to lower pricing so as to lure people back again. People will stop going if it get's too expensive, and iMO, it's pretty darn close to that point now.
Cynical. But that's your prerogative.

I blame myself and other conservatives. When I was a conservative I fought the change that would have prevented this. The trend was easy to figure out and the cause easily identifiable. Expensive technology and the ability to keep people alive longer and thus accrue ever more expensive diagnostics and treatments resulted in this mess. But we didn't want social experimentation so we fought hard to keep the status quo.

We could have had what other nations have but no, so, here we are.... serves us right.
 
I still don't think we can afford UHC. Not unless we do some serious budget cutting. Privatize social security, eliminate all other entitlements. Basically go back to the Fed does the state dept, defense dept, the EPA and the Treasury.... Cuz UHC could cost $4 trillion a year. At least for the first decade or so.
 
I still don't think we can afford UHC. Not unless we do some serious budget cutting. Privatize social security, eliminate all other entitlements. Basically go back to the Fed does the state dept, defense dept, the EPA and the Treasury.... Cuz UHC could cost $4 trillion a year. At least for the first decade or so.
I still don't think we can't afford not to have UHC (see chart above).
 
I still don't think we can afford UHC. Not unless we do some serious budget cutting. Privatize social security, eliminate all other entitlements. Basically go back to the Fed does the state dept, defense dept, the EPA and the Treasury.... Cuz UHC could cost $4 trillion a year. At least for the first decade or so.
Well, there isn't any doubt about this. There's no reason to duck and dodge the "give them bread and circuses", eg "free health care" political moves here. They are what they are. That actually distracts from the budget problem. Unfortunately at the cost of deluding a sector of the population which is exactly for whom it will be most tragic later. Then it's the "blame the other party/guy game".

But this is not constructive building of prosperity, quite the reverse. It's catering to political whims while accepting decline.
 
I like this because it brings up a great point. How can we do better and what limitations on care are we willing to accept?

I think there is one critical mistake in the equation. We allow patients to determine what level of care they need. Those that have great insurance use it, sometimes to excess. Those that have none are left deciding if it's even worthwhile to seek treatment (I'm in this latter class and generally do not seek treatment -- but I'd do that anyway because I'm an idiot). I would prefer that professionals determine what constitutes "enough" care.

When patients make the decisions, they have a dog in the hunt and I don't expect them to be as cold-heartedly rational as economics might demand. Is there any way to get past the infinite value of human life? That evaluation messes up the equations and swamps all the calculations......

Not really. You are arguing for exactly what I've said was happening. The elderly person who needs the scan under the universal plan doesn't get it, or doesn't get it promptly as needed for diagnosis of a critical condition.

You've seemingly presumed that "experts" somewhere could interject better decision making into the doctor-patient relationship than the doctor and the patient. The result of this is interjecting bureaucratic stupidity into the doctor patient relationship. The simple stated outcome of your statement would be a massively thick manual specifying what doctors could do for each age group for each group of symptoms presented, including cost limits, coupled with delays for procedures based on resource scarcity.

So quality of care necessarily declines as the cost of attempting to use medical care as a card on the table of the poker game of politics.
 
You've seemingly presumed that "experts" somewhere could interject better decision making into the doctor-patient relationship than the doctor and the patient.

Yes, precisely. It's done already, but more needs to be done. There is no particular reason why the doctor-patient relationship should be sacrosanct. If you see doctor A on Monday and doctor B on Thursday, you should get the same high quality treatment. It's time to treat medicine like science instead of a priesthood.

The result of this is interjecting bureaucratic stupidity into the doctor patient relationship. The simple stated outcome of your statement would be a massively thick manual specifying what doctors could do for each age group for each group of symptoms presented, including cost limits, coupled with delays for procedures based on resource scarcity.

Not necessarily. There's already a manual with diagnostic codes. There are already standards of practice, mostly from the medical community itself. But the alternative seems to be a kind of limitless laissez faire.

What is it about doctors/medicine that should make them immune to regulation, oversight and budget constraints? Once again, if you think each individual has infinite value, then of course we can't make judgements based on cost. I think there is a limit and we must make such judgements. I do not think we need to abandon everything to do so.

So quality of care necessarily declines as the cost of attempting to use medical care as a card on the table of the poker game of politics.

There may be a saving grace. We notice. It's pretty tough to slip shoddy outcomes through the back door or hide them. I expect reform would be a constant theme for politicians wanting to get re-elected.

And, just to make things plain, there are already limits, bureaucracies and things unpaid for in private health plans. Why would a public health plan be any different? You could even have a copay element if you like.

While we are on the subject, I'd like to see a cadre of PA's introduced as cheaper, gatekeepers -- publicly funded training and reasonable salaries.
 
No No No...... You are making the typical screw up of many "intellectuals" that think that human being exists in a vacuum , we don't!

A doctor patient relationship cannot be dismissed as being "like a priesthood" it's important for your Dr to know what your history is, what he's done for you in the past and how you responded. it's good for him to know what your lifestyle is like, perhaps even what your family members history is like. You can say that any Dr can look at a patient record and gather all that info, but will they? Will they have the time for that?
Not to mention that as the patient shouldn't you have a choice what Dr you visit? Who get's your business? I guess you think a bunch of sociologists and medical "experts" kno better than patients and Doctors?

I find that ridiculous.....
 
No No No...... You are making the typical screw up of many "intellectuals" that think that human being exists in a vacuum , we don't!
Damn intelectuals with their vaccines and evolution. Yeah, like formal logic and the scientific method could result in social progress. That will be the day.

BTW: Who thinks human beings exist in a vacuum?
 
You didn't even gather the point, you attacked a word..... that's not an argument... C'mon you are better than that.

as far as the vacuum thing is concerned, the concept that having a good relationship with your Dr is akin to "the priesthood" is not a very realitic view of how human beings behave. I would mark such a statement as viewing humans in a vacuum.

It's similar to the sociologists who claim that children are damaged by having their feelings hurt by losing. When learning how to handle losing, failure and other problems is about as important a life lesson as children can get. I also think that's vacuum thinking.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom