Ziggurat
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jun 19, 2003
- Messages
- 64,419
The argument to this is that health care is different from these because it falls under the Commerce Clause and is unique because there are laws that require that health care providers (doctors, hospitals, etc.) provide essential health care even if a person can’t (demonstrate that they can) pay for it.
If so, then government made it unique. What's to stop government from making other markets unique by similar intervention? In fact, government already intervenes heavily in a number of markets (including food and housing) where everyone participates. If government intervention is itself a justification for the expansion of government powers, then what limit remains?
Therefore, the government, which established constitutional laws to “insure” minimum health care, which directly affects health insurance commerce, has the power to regulate that commerce, and those that directly affect it, by enacting a penalty on those who do not have private health insurance.
Potential future commerce should not be treated as actual commerce. We should not be able to regulate what doesn't exist, and potential future commerce doesn't exist until (and if) it becomes actual present commerce. If we start treating potential future commerce as something which can be regulated, then there is likewise no limit to what falls under the commerce clause.
