Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

What I mean by silly is all the outrage over a technical issue. These people don't care about the reach of federal power. The came up with mandates and tried at least twice to get them passed in congress.

So, my point was never about constitutionality. It's about the bogus standing on principle. I don't buy it.

Fair enough. I can't deny that what you say applies to some, but I think you are painting with too broad a brush. I doubt even a majority of those who oppose the mandate were in favor of it in the early nineties. After all, it didn't go anywhere even in the House of Hypocrites. The existence of a few prominent examples of hypocrisy does not mean that all, or even most, of the current opposition is unprincipled. Speaking only for myself, I have no problem if states want to impose insurance mandates. I'm not sure it's good policy, but if proponents can get enough support to pass it, so be it.

There is no limit to the hypocrisy finger pointing game, as it's hardly a secret that our political class is extraordinarily opportunistic and venal. As a fan of limits, I prefer to avoid it. :)
 
Last edited:
Not a problem. Thanks for posting the entire dialog. I've not made up my mind. Of course I knee jerk accepted it.


I may be interpreting it wrong but I think there is a difference between "You could do it" and "You could do it. But ..."
 
And if they don't need it, they're not participating. Nor does payment make a difference in this respect, since some people who don't participate COULD pay. You have redefined "participation" to include potential future participation, but that is nonsense. Under such a definition, almost everyone participates in almost every market.

I've had an exchange with you in the past on this. We know that everyone will will require medical care at some point. 96% of all Americans have visited a doctor in the last 3 years. It's beyond safe to assume you and everyone else will participate in this market. Further, we dont know who will need this care, when they will need care, or what kind of care we will need. We also know that unlike, say th market for broccoli and cell phones, the timing of the purchase to buy health insurance makes a huge difference in the price you will spend when you need that care.


Unlike most every other market i can think of, the timing of purchasing insurance can swing the price you pay by literally hundreds of thousands of dollars. This disruptive effect of adverse selection means that your future entry into the market can bankrupt you, which makes your last sentence not comparable.

And if a frog had wings, it wouldn't bump its ass when it hopped.

He didn't lose all his money. He didn't participate in the health insurance market. And nobody else had to pay for him.

So what? It's an anecdotal outlier not representative of the population. But hey, my aunt has struggled with her cancer for 5+ years and even though she and her husband are millionaires, they would've been bankrupted, save their health insurance. What do either of these prove? We know that many cannot afford their medical bills, and their non payment has increased care for everyone.

The justification for that intervention isn't the problem here. The problem is your contention that the intervention itself expands government powers. And that is a dangerous assertion.

It's a tradition (providing care to those in need, regardless of ability to pay) that is far older than our country - i.e. government did not force hospitals to treat people because they saw it as a way to expand its powers. The intent was to match laws with our conventional values on illness and suffering. The reality is that there is no free lunch, so having this burden necessarily costs the system money (several billions per year IIRC).

Even before the government stepped in, those who couldn't afford to pay still cost the system money.
 
What I mean by silly is all the outrage over a technical issue. These people don't care about the reach of federal power. The came up with mandates and tried at least twice to get them passed in congress.

So in other words, you don't care about the merits of this case. As usual, you're just interested in bitching and moaning about those evil republicans who betrayed you.
 
By the way, RandFan, just to let you know, I posted on "The People's View" site pointing out that part of Scalia's statement was missing. My posted was deleted and I was banned within the hour.
That was wrong. I have nothing to do with the site. I found it on a link from facebook.
 
That was wrong. I have nothing to do with the site. I found it on a link from facebook.


I didn't think you had any relationship to the site. Just letting you know that there is apparently only one acceptable narrative allowed there.
 
By the way, RandFan, just to let you know, I posted on "The People's View" site pointing out that part of Scalia's statement was missing. My post was deleted and I was banned within the hour.

No surprise there; it's well established that liberals tend to be less tolerant of dissenting viewpoints.

Liberals are the most likely to have taken each of these steps to block, unfriend, or hide. In all, 28% of liberals have blocked, unfriended, or hidden someone on SNS because of one of these reasons, compared with 16% of conservatives and 14% of moderates.
 
No surprise there; it's well established that liberals tend to be less tolerant of dissenting viewpoints.


I've also found that to be the case. Not so much on this site, but on other sites I've posted on and among ex-pats here in Japan, I've found much less tolerance for differing political viewpoints from those who claim to be on the left. Not so long ago I had a guy who seemed ready to throw down because I disagreed with him that "Reagan was the very worst president in U.S. history." If there's anything that's pushed me further to the right in recent years, it's crap like that.
 
Last edited:
At the end of the day America can force everyone to pay for health insurance. It's an empirical fact as we have been doing it for some time now.
Yes, but the means by which we do it is important from a Constitutional perspective. Medicare is funded to the States from income taxes, which are authorized by the 16th amendment. The 16th amendment was necessary because the Constitution has strict limits on how the federal goverment can raise revenue. If the Health Care Act were funded by income taxes, there'd be no Constitutional issue.

But the Health Care Act doesn't do that. So, since this isn't an income tax, but rather a direct tax, fine, penalty, or some other category, the question is whether the Constitution authorizes it.

I know people like to pretend that the only really important limitation on power are the Bill of Rights, but it isn't true. The Constitution really has many limitations on the exercise of federal power. There are many ways Congress has to work around those limitations. The question is whether they did.

So let's not try to oversimplify this to a "Medicare exists so the Health Care Act is constitutional". That really diminishes the serious Constitutional implications of an expansion of federal power. And I say this as someone who thinks the Health Care Act is likely constitutional.
 
Overall, what has disturbed me most is how quickly people -- who cry bloody murder when their opponents do it -- will dismiss Constitutional limits on federal power when it suits them. When Democrats decried the diminishment of habeas corpus rights, Republicans dismissed these concerns on the grounds of security. When Republicans complain about the encroachment of federal power into citizen's lives, Democrats dismiss those concerns on the grounds of health care.

"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."
-Benjamin Franklin

This applies to economic security as well as physical security. While I think the Act constitutional, I don't malign those on the right who disagree. I am glad there are people who are concerned about expansion of federal power, from the left and the right. I just wish they wouldn't be so quick to tear down the protections they currently find inconvenient, because tomorrow they might find it the only thing between them and tyranny.
 
And if they don't need it, they're not participating. Nor does payment make a difference in this respect, since some people who don't participate COULD pay. You have redefined "participation" to include potential future participation, but that is nonsense. Under such a definition, almost everyone participates in almost every market.

Your friend is participating in the market because he can get medical services at any time he might need them. If your friend is hit by a car today and is brought in unconscious and couldn't prove that he is able to pay, he would still be treated. If your friend suffers an injury so devastating that the costs would wipe him out monetarily, he would still be treated. If your friend lost all his savings this morning, he would still be treated.

The justification for that intervention isn't the problem here. The problem is your contention that the intervention itself expands government powers. And that is a dangerous assertion.

The government intervention itself doesn't expand government powers. The fact that we as a society don't allow people to die if they can't prove that they can pay means that everyone participates, which expands government powers, and does so in a very specific way. I don't see a slippery slope.

That's not why it did in the past, but if your justification for the mandate stands, why would you expect that they wouldn't do so in the future?

Can you give a hypothetical example where you could see this happening? I think it would be pretty easy to draw a line as health care is a pretty specific situation where everyone participates. I can't think of any other example where the government could require everyone to participate in a market in order to avoid a situation where they are allowed to die, and then force everyone to buy a particular product.

The government could potentially do it via taxes now though for almost any reason (collect taxes and then buy a particular product that it deems will be of general benefit).

You think it's possible to draw this line, but you can't actually say how to do it. That doesn't inspire confidence in your position.

It's easy to draw a line: it only applies to health insurance. There, pretty easy.

If you need specific justification, how about the fact that health care is a must-have item for everyone, hospitals are required to provide health care even to customers who can't pay for it because the alternative is to let people die, and allowing people to purchase health insurance only after realizing they need it would produce catastrophic economic losses.

Which would necessarily get the courts into the business of micromanaging legislation to test (by methods still unknown) whether or not some particular fine was too steep. Which they aren't supposed to be doing, that's not the role of the courts.

The courts do this sort of thing all the time. For example, whenever someone sues the government because they feel that a particular law imposes a burden on their free exercise of religion, doesn't meet a compelling government interest, or doesn't do so by the least restrictive means.

The court could also give some guidelines such as the tax would have to be less than the average cost of insurance in order to offer a reasonable alternative to purchasing insurance.

Plus, of course, it leads to the problem I mentioned before: if you have a whole set of mandates, each individual one might indeed be backed by a fine which is tolerable, but which would be intolerable collectively. What then? Has not choice still been deprived? Of course it has.

You may need to provide an example. It seems to me that it's up to Congress to determine whether they are over-burdening anyone, and that goes for taxes too. As long as a reasonable alternative is provided for each mandate, nobody is being forced to buy anything.

-Bri
 
Yes, but the means by which we do it is important from a Constitutional perspective. Medicare is funded to the States from income taxes, which are authorized by the 16th amendment. The 16th amendment was necessary because the Constitution has strict limits on how the federal goverment can raise revenue. If the Health Care Act were funded by income taxes, there'd be no Constitutional issue.

But the Health Care Act doesn't do that. So, since this isn't an income tax, but rather a direct tax, fine, penalty, or some other category, the question is whether the Constitution authorizes it.

I know people like to pretend that the only really important limitation on power are the Bill of Rights, but it isn't true. The Constitution really has many limitations on the exercise of federal power. There are many ways Congress has to work around those limitations. The question is whether they did.

So let's not try to oversimplify this to a "Medicare exists so the Health Care Act is constitutional". That really diminishes the serious Constitutional implications of an expansion of federal power. And I say this as someone who thinks the Health Care Act is likely constitutional.
Thanks. Your points have been made before and I'm not contesting them. I'm not sure how many times I can agree with a point before people accept my agreement. My ire is directed at something very different. I don't buy the sudden interest in constitutionality from the right-wing. It didn't bother them when they came up with the mandate. It didn't bother then when they tried to implement them in the 90s. Now Obama implements them and suddenly they are constitutional scholars baying that the Democrats are hell bent on trampling the constitution.

Can you get my point?

Also, this idea about being forced to do stuff. BS. Look, if it's unconstitutional and the point serves us well then fine. I don't have a problem with that. It's the faux outrage and silly arguments that drive me nuts.
 
Last edited:
Thanks. Your points have been made before and I'm not contesting them.
Sorry. I responded before reading th rest of the thread.

I don't buy the sudden interest in constitutionality from the right-wing.
Will you buy the sudden interest in constitutionality from the left-wing the next time the left-wing starts complaining about civil liberties being violated?

Also, this idea about being forced to do stuff. BS. Look, if it's unconstitutional and the point serves us well then fine. I don't have a problem with that. It's the faux outrage and silly arguments that drive me nuts.
Then don't contribute to it with hyperbole and ill-thought complaints.

Oh my God! They're being totally hysterical. Gahhh!!!!!
 
Then don't contribute to it with hyperbole and ill-thought complaints.
Thanks. I'm happy with my responses. I can't imagine I would change anything. I don't think I'm contributing to anything other than the discussion. I respect your opinion but I disagree. But I'll take it under advisement.

As for the left, by all means. My ire with the GOP might cloud my objectivity a bit. If I miss it then you let me know and I'll try to be consistent.
 
But it seems to me that Congress tried to get clever with the private insurance fix, never concerned that it might actually have to show its constitutional authority to compel individuals to buy a private product.

I don't think that's entirely the case. Congress was concerned about the constitutionality of the legislation during its development and did consult constitutional law authorities while drafting it in an attempt to insure it would pass constitutional muster. I think they expected a constitutional challenge all along.
 
Your friend is participating in the market because he can get medical services at any time he might need them.

Again, you are defining "participation" to mean possible future participation. I do not accept that definition. I have no reason to accept that definition. Using that definition, there is no such thing as not participating, in ANY market.

The government intervention itself doesn't expand government powers.

You have predicated your notion of "participation" not only on future participation, but also on the obligation of health care providers to provide services even without payment. But that situation exists because of government intervention. Take a look at your own argument: what happens to it if health care providers can turn away people who can't pay? You very much are predicating the expansion of government powers (the mandate) on prior government intervention (the obligation to provide services without payment).

The fact that we as a society don't allow people to die if they can't prove that they can pay means that everyone participates, which expands government powers, and does so in a very specific way.

This is very reminiscent of the arguments at the SC. The government tried to argue that health care was special. But it couldn't really explain why. And I believe it was Kennedy (not that it matters) pointed out that next time the government is in front of the court, it will be arguing that some other market is special. Well, every market is special in some way, and every piece of legislation acts in some specific way. That's not good enough. Either there is some principle that limits government power, or there is not. I think the principle that the government can't regulate the lack of commerce should be such a principle. You don't. Fine. But what then is your limiting principle? Because so far, you have failed to provide any. Your response to this challenge is essentially just that the government wouldn't keep expanding its power. But that's not a limiting principle.

Can you give a hypothetical example where you could see this happening? I think it would be pretty easy to draw a line as health care is a pretty specific situation where everyone participates.

Everyone participates in the food market too. And everyone participates in the transportation market. And everyone participates in the housing market. And everyone participates in the clothing market. There are lots of markets where everyone participates, and much more fully, than health care.

I can't think of any other example where the government could require everyone to participate in a market in order to avoid a situation where they are allowed to die, and then force everyone to buy a particular product.

Food. In fact, the government already intervenes in the market for food. So your argument would allow them to take the next step and require our purchase of specific foods.

The government could potentially do it via taxes now though for almost any reason (collect taxes and then buy a particular product that it deems will be of general benefit).

Process matters. And the process you suggest is not the same. This idea that if two methods achieve the same ends (for your purposes), and one is constitutional, the other should be held so doesn't withstand basic scrutiny. If the next president is inaugurated on Jan. 19 instead of Jan. 20, well, the ends are pretty identical. But one is constitutional and one is not.

It's easy to draw a line: it only applies to health insurance. There, pretty easy.

That line has absolutely no basis in the constitution. As such, it cannot and will not survive. People complain when they think the courts are taking on the role of the legislator and creating rules which act like legislation. But you're proposing a far greater overreach: you're proposing that the courts basically amend the constitution itself to include this new arbitrary rule of yours.

If you need specific justification, how about the fact that health care is a must-have item for everyone

How are you defining "must have"? Because plenty of people go for years without using health care services. And some people who use health care services have no need of health insurance.

hospitals are required to provide health care even to customers who can't pay for it because the alternative is to let people die

The severity of the alternatives might serve to justify the original government intervention, but that doesn't mean that this intervention should itself justify a further expansion of government powers.

and allowing people to purchase health insurance only after realizing they need it would produce catastrophic economic losses.

Allowing people to purchase insurance? No, there's no "allowing" here. You mean forcing insurers to provide coverage. And yes, this requirement won't work without a mandate. But again, this requirement is government-imposed. We can't use the dire consequences of one government intervention to justify another intervention that the government does not have the constitutional authority to engage in. If the government doesn't want those dire consequences, it should avoid that policy rather than expand beyond its constitutional limits.

The courts do this sort of thing all the time. For example, whenever someone sues the government because they feel that a particular law imposes a burden on their free exercise of religion, doesn't meet a compelling government interest, or doesn't do so by the least restrictive means.

The courts try to limit the tests they need to impose as much as they can. But it's telling that none of your examples involve trying to figure out a dollar amount, especially in a situation where the dollar amount would actually vary from case to case.

The court could also give some guidelines such as the tax would have to be less than the average cost of insurance in order to offer a reasonable alternative to purchasing insurance.

How much less? $1 less? Because once you get even close, well, the consumer really doesn't have a choice anymore, do they?

You may need to provide an example. It seems to me that it's up to Congress to determine whether they are over-burdening anyone, and that goes for taxes too.

Taxation has a specific constitutional authorization (an authorization which doesn't require that taxation isn't overburdensome either). Mandates don't. And you just got done telling me that the courts would ensure that the burden isn't too great, and that this would ensure constitutionality by maintaining choice. But now you're going to leave it in the hands of Congress, and that entire line of reasoning is now abandoned.

As long as a reasonable alternative is provided for each mandate, nobody is being forced to buy anything.

Again, who determines this? First it was the courts, now it's Congress. And that doesn't answer my question about multiple mandates: each mandate individually might be avoidable, but not collectively. How are we to handle that? Your response leaves that completely unanswered. It is, I believe, unanswerable. There is no criteria which will work that has any constitutional basis. And you can't just invent new constitutional clauses (as you wanted to above by saying health care is unique) in order to justify legislation that has already been enacted.
 
Yawn, here and there.

http://townhall.com/columnists/paulgreenberg/2012/03/29/a_little_perspective_please

you'd think not just a landmark Supreme Court case was upon us, but a jurisprudential Armageddon. The moment of truth has arrived, the die is about to be cast, the Rubicon crossed ... pick your own favorite cliche. There are so many out there.
Charles Krauthammer, one of my favorites in the columnizing/calumniating trade, sees the fate of the Republic swaying in the balance in the current hearings on Obamacare. As he writes in the Washington Post:

"If the law is upheld, it fundamentally changes the social contract. It means the effective end of a government of enumerated powers -- finite, delineated powers beyond which the government may not go, beyond which lies the free realm of the people and their voluntary institutions. The new dispensation is a central government of unlimited power from which citizen and civil society struggle to carve out spheres of autonomy."

On the opposite but equally fervid end of the political spectrum, Linda Greenhouse waves off such fears. And any disagreement, too. Her undiluted contempt for any who might have a different opinion is palpable. Those challenging the new health-care law, she explains, haven't got a precedent to stand on. Their learned disquisitions amount to, well, nothing. She writes, you won't be surprised to hear, for the New York Times.

It may be a journalistic convention to present both sides of a legal controversy in neutral fashion, she concedes, "without the writer's thumb on the scale." But, "free of convention, and fresh from reading the main briefs in the case," Ms. Greenhouse is here to tell us that the constitutional argument against the health-care law is "so weak that it dissolves on close inspection. There's just no there there."

If the court strikes down this Signature Achievement of the Obama administration, all reason is lost.

Now that Justices Krauthammer and Greenhouse have weighed in on the law, it's a wonder the country needs a Supreme Court at all. Just choose your ideological side, his or hers, and save yourself the trouble of thought. Then declare your opinion settled law. And close the book.

The great precedents of the past may prove not so great after all. Dred Scott was going to solve the slavery question once and for all in 1857. At last the Supreme Court of the United States would render a final, decisive, comprehensive decision. No longer would this little matter trouble the peace and growth of the Union. Any misgivings about the Peculiar Institution could now be brushed aside. Scott v. Sandford was now settled law.

Except that it wasn't. The next year, a gawky ex-congressman, ex-Whig and -- who would've predicted it? -- future president of the United States chose to take on the most powerful senator and celebrated orator of his day, The Little Giant himself, Stephen A. Douglas, in a series of whistle-stop debates out on the prairies of Illinois. And what had been settled no longer was.

History had intervened. Soon enough the fateful lightning of His terrible swift sword would be loosed. And another decision was reached.

On the judicial activism progressive worries ...

http://townhall.com/columnists/magg...he_longawaited_coming_of_a_conservative_court

The shocked look on CNN legal analyst Jeffrey Toobin's face as he emerged from the Supreme Court's oral arguments over Obamacare was priceless:

"This was a train wreck for the Obama administration," Toobin said Tuesday. "This law looks like it's going to be struck down. I'm telling you, all of the predictions, including mine, that the justices would not have a problem with this law, were wrong."

By Wednesday, Toobin had upped the ante: "This still looks like a train wreck for the Obama administration, and it may also be a plane wreck. This entire law is now in serious trouble. It also seems that the individual mandate is doomed."

Toobin's dawning recognition that the Supreme Court may actually strike down a law passed by Congress and that liberals like prompted pushback from leading Democrats in Congress.

Democrats are having a hard time believing it. They aren't used to what conservatives like me have faced repeatedly. Go through the hard slog of getting a law passed (like, say, Proposition 8 in California) only to have progressives go to court and get it struck down on the grounds it offends some radical new norm no author of our Constitution would recognize.

Since at least 1973, when Roe v. Wade struck down anti-abortion laws in all 50 states, progressive elites have looked on the Supreme Court as their wholly owned subsidiary -- a trump card only they get to play.

The Supreme Court's job, in their view, is to strike down popular laws supporting traditional moral norms -- especially sexual norms -- that progressives would have trouble winning at the ballot box. The discovery and invention of new rights, from abortion to gay marriage, was their turf, their "Get Out of Democracy Free Card."

Or so they thought.

That shocked look on Jeffrey Toobin's face was a stand-in for thousands of elite progressives' dawning realization that they might be on the receiving end of "judicial activism" -- and see how little they like it.

The American people are not constitutional lawyers, but they know what they don't like: a government mandate on ordinary people to buy something they don't want.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom