I think you have a picture where a doctor is a kind of ultimate authority and benevolent dictator. I don't think it works like that in practice. You have the AMA, insurance companies, hospital boards, the state and local government -- all with input into who gets an MRI and why. You already mentioned the role that litigation plays in it.
How can you simultaneously recognize doctors are subject to lawsuits that may motivate their behavior but then ignore a profit motive? Isn't avoiding a lawsuit the same as saving money?
By the way, I know of a person who was in a carwreck, exhibited some symptoms of possible problems in the ER, was told she was being moved right then to get the MRI, and who refused and walked out of the hospital.
She simply did not want the waste of the resource and in her own judgement thought it was not warranted.
Good enough. I believe patients should have the right to refuse treatment. I do not think they should have the right to insist on any treatment whatsoever.
What we have now is partly free market based. Even to the level that you can travel to another country if you can't buy a procedure in your home nation. Money and resources already limit what is available. I don't see how recognizing that fact changes anything. I think we differ only on what the limits should be, not that there are no limits.
We also differ on where the authority to make decisions should lie. It is now in the hands of patients, doctors and third party payers. This actually doesn't change much in current UHC models. I'd prefer it did.
It wouldn't take much either. All you need to do is come up with clear standards of practice and then allow lawyers to enforce them when doctors go beyond the boundaries. It's actually very close to what we have now.