Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

But that's not accurate. The insurance market is affected by those who choose not to buy insurance - whether it be because they can't afford it or because they can. It changes the demographic. Additionally, everyone is affected by those who don't have insurance when it comes to the cost of care - even those who pay their own way must pay for those who don't have insurance to be covered, the same as the rest of us do (through our insurance carriers).

While I do agree that extending the Commerce clause should not be done lightly, I don't believe that this is a light matter, nor is it being treated as one by either side of the aisle. Should the extension be allowed by the SCOTUS, I expect it will come with very very specific limits - i.e. that it applies to health care only, and even then with restrictions on what's allowed.
Not accurate. The SC is incapable of saying "we'll extend this rule but only for health care". They have to establish extensions of general principles.
 
Oh and BTW, I'm an atheist, I don't think Vaccines cause autism, I just defended evolution....
Do not fall for that. People on JREF are generally well meaning (although there are some haters) but when they start to be on the losing side of an argument the ad hominem attacks begin, and often it is done by aligning your views with religious creationism or some other logical fallacy.

That's just the way it is.
 
Not accurate. The SC is incapable of saying "we'll extend this rule but only for health care". They have to establish extensions of general principles.

No, mhaze, the SCOTUS can say that their ruling only applies to this specific legislation. Similar rulings have been done before (remember the decision regarding Gore?). It's not simply the all-or-nothing-slippery-slope so many detractors of the AHA would prefer to present this situation as.
 
No No No...... You are making the typical screw up of many "intellectuals" that think that human being exists in a vacuum , we don't!

A doctor patient relationship cannot be dismissed as being "like a priesthood" it's important for your Dr to know what your history is, what he's done for you in the past and how you responded. it's good for him to know what your lifestyle is like, perhaps even what your family members history is like. You can say that any Dr can look at a patient record and gather all that info, but will they? Will they have the time for that?
Not to mention that as the patient shouldn't you have a choice what Dr you visit? Who get's your business? I guess you think a bunch of sociologists and medical "experts" kno better than patients and Doctors?

I find that ridiculous.....
You'll be surprised then when Death Panels become an operating reality?
 
No, mhaze, the SCOTUS can say that their ruling only applies to this specific legislation. Similar rulings have been done before (remember the decision regarding Gore?). It's not simply the all-or-nothing-slippery-slope so many detractors of the AHA would prefer to present this situation as.
Nope.

The fact that it is the supreme court of the land does not mean they can't take cases other than cases on constitutionality.

But the issue of constitutionality is key to the plaintiff's argument.

It's a slippery slope within the domain of health care, based on a slippery slope outside the domain of health care, and threatening a much steeper slipper slope in all areas.

Cheers!

You'll be surprised then when Death Panels become an operating reality?
You know, inefficiency itself could prevent their becoming an operating reality. Suppose all those cases for expensive treatment just got lost....

Dead people don't complain.
 
Last edited:
You'll be surprised then when Death Panels become an operating reality?

Aren't they already? In the form of, "Sorry, your HMO doesn't cover that."

And I'll throw this in -- When patients make their own healthcare choices, some buy silver salts or homeopathic remedies.
 
Aren't they already? In the form of, "Sorry, your HMO doesn't cover that."

And I'll throw this in -- When patients make their own healthcare choices, some buy silver salts or homeopathic remedies.

Wrong question. *If it's cheap treatment, it's good treatment. *Under national health care programs.




http://wmbriggs.com/blog/?s=homeopathy&submit=Go


Taxpayers pay about £4million a year for homeopathy on the NHS.
How about England? Here’s a headline from the Daily Mail: “More homeopathy on NHS as health cash is squeezed.” The story continues:

Health Secretary Andrew Lansley yesterday rejected calls from MPs on the Commons science committee to ban funding of the unproven treatment.

He effectively gave the green light for spending on homeopathy to go up, because of his plans for patients to be able to ‘shop around’ until they find a GP willing to prescribe complementary therapies.

This means more patients will have access to such treatments. There will be no restrictions on the advertising of homeopathic treatments, he added.



Nobody argues homeopathy “works” in the sense of being biological active (it certainly has a placebo effect). Which is why England’s “Department of Health said that efficacy was not the only important factor when deciding whether scarce NHS resources should be spent on a treatment – patient choice was essential too.”​
 
Nope.

The fact that it is the supreme court of the land does not mean they can't take cases other than cases on constitutionality.

But the issue of constitutionality is key to the plaintiff's argument.

It's a slippery slope within the domain of health care, based on a slippery slope outside the domain of health care, and threatening a much steeper slipper slope in all areas.
Yes, yes I know that mhaze. And you're being obtuse, whether deliberately or not I don't know and don't care.

Yes, the SCOTUS only deals with matters of constitutionality. But, the SCOTUS can easily decide that this use of the commerce clause is acceptable but only in the terms that this particular law is written and for the effect this law has on the healthcare industry - which means it only applies to the AHA and your slippery slope doesn't exist.
 
Yes, yes I know that mhaze. And you're being obtuse, whether deliberately or not I don't know and don't care.

Yes, the SCOTUS only deals with matters of constitutionality. But, the SCOTUS can easily decide that this use of the commerce clause is acceptable but only in the terms that this particular law is written and for the effect this law has on the healthcare industry - which means it only applies to the AHA and your slippery slope doesn't exist.

If they try to make such a constrained ruling now, then the basic constitutional question may arise again in the future. And they will either have to continue to make case-by-case rulings (which is both burdensome to the courts and disruptive to the rest of the country), or they will have to make a general ruling. And unless they decide to overturn whatever decision they make in this case, then that general ruling must accord with the specifics of this case. So why would the courts postpone doing what they might have to do eventually anyways? I mean, it's one thing if you want to carve out a tiny exception to an existing general principle without overturning that general principle. But we're in uncharted waters here, and I don't think the court will (or should) pass up the opportunity to lay out some ground rules for this new territory.
 
He effectively gave the green light for spending on homeopathy to go up, because of his plans for patients to be able to ‘shop around’ until they find a GP willing to prescribe complementary therapies.

This was exactly my point about patients making their own healthcare choices. On the other hand, I'll grant you that politicians sometimes pander to those same people. Medicare does a fairly good job of keeping politics out of the mix, but I'm all for even higher standards of science based medicine.

Would you agree that an inappropriate MRI, done because an insurance company will pay for it instead of medical necessity, would also be a misuse of the current system and just as vile as homeopathy? After all, unproven is unproven, regardless of how "sciency" the equipment.
 
Last edited:
If they try to make such a constrained ruling now, then the basic constitutional question may arise again in the future. And they will either have to continue to make case-by-case rulings (which is both burdensome to the courts and disruptive to the rest of the country), or they will have to make a general ruling. And unless they decide to overturn whatever decision they make in this case, then that general ruling must accord with the specifics of this case. So why would the courts postpone doing what they might have to do eventually anyways? I mean, it's one thing if you want to carve out a tiny exception to an existing general principle without overturning that general principle. But we're in uncharted waters here, and I don't think the court will (or should) pass up the opportunity to lay out some ground rules for this new territory.
Well, that's mighty convenient for your Slippery Slope arguments... :D


I fail to see how this needs to be a general ruling. There's nothing wrong with the SCOTUS limiting it's ruling to holding specifically that the insurance mandate is a constitutional reach of the commerce and general welfare clauses.
 
I fail to see how this needs to be a general ruling. There's nothing wrong with the SCOTUS limiting it's ruling to holding specifically that the insurance mandate is a constitutional reach of the commerce and general welfare clauses.

"needs" isn't quite the right word. But their ruling should be general. The role of the Supreme Court isn't really to decide individual cases, but to decide principles. Most cases should be, and are, handled by lower courts. But if the SC refuses to provide a general ruling in this case (something I agree that it has the power to do), then it will have provided the lower courts with no clear guidance. Lower courts have arrived at contradictory rulings on this law based on their interpretations of general constitutional principles. To issue a specific ruling without any applicability beyond this one case would still leave the conflict between lower court constitutional interpretations unresolved, and that isn't a good thing.
 
"needs" isn't quite the right word. But their ruling should be general. The role of the Supreme Court isn't really to decide individual cases, but to decide principles. Most cases should be, and are, handled by lower courts. But if the SC refuses to provide a general ruling in this case (something I agree that it has the power to do), then it will have provided the lower courts with no clear guidance. Lower courts have arrived at contradictory rulings on this law based on their interpretations of general constitutional principles. To issue a specific ruling without any applicability beyond this one case would still leave the conflict between lower court constitutional interpretations unresolved, and that isn't a good thing.

Whatever the ruling, whether general or not, the SCOTUS will have given direction to the lower courts:

1) Mandate is not constitutional
2) Mandate is constitutional in general
3) Mandate is constitutional in this specific case because of the reach of the health care/insurance market

Those all give lower courts guidance on how to interpret the commerce clause. I just don't see your argument having legs. Again, I think you'd prefer it to because then the slippery slope broccoli argument is "validated"...but that's simply wishful thinking and affirming the consequent, not really looking at this fairly.
 
This was exactly my point about patients making their own healthcare choices. On the other hand, I'll grant you that politicians sometimes pander to those same people. Medicare does a fairly good job of keeping politics out of the mix, but I'm all for even higher standards of science based medicine.

Would you agree that an inappropriate MRI, done because an insurance company will pay for it instead of medical necessity, would also be a misuse of the current system and just as vile as homeopathy? After all, unproven is unproven, regardless of how "sciency" the equipment.
Wrong parsing. Complete, 100% wrong. Here's why.

A) A doc decides on MRI in an environment of much litigation.
B) A doc decides on MRI in an environment without much litigation.
C) An outside party decides what constitutes "medical necessity".

C is virtually impossible because the MRI is a diagnostic tool. The medical necessity, such as doing a surgery, is the result of diagnostic tools followed by biopsies of located suspect areas. Here we use the MRI as an example only, but you get the idea - CAT scan etc, is also diagnostic.

C is basically the sort of top down liberal progressive authoritarian controller thinking that creates unmitigated disasters. Your question seems to imply that doctors would order an MRI just to jack the bill up and increase profits. I have to say that I know of no doctors who would do such a thing. None. But I know many who do order what they view as excessive diagnostics because of an established climate of fear of litigation.

By the way, I know of a person who was in a carwreck, exhibited some symptoms of possible problems in the ER, was told she was being moved right then to get the MRI, and who refused and walked out of the hospital.

She simply did not want the waste of the resource and in her own judgement thought it was not warranted.
 
Last edited:
Whatever the ruling, whether general or not, the SCOTUS will have given direction to the lower courts:

1) Mandate is not constitutional
2) Mandate is constitutional in general
3) Mandate is constitutional in this specific case because of the reach of the health care/insurance market

Those all give lower courts guidance on how to interpret the commerce clause. I just don't see your argument having legs. Again, I think you'd prefer it to because then the slippery slope broccoli argument is "validated"...but that's simply wishful thinking and affirming the consequent, not really looking at this fairly.

I think the only fair way to look at is simply to say "Okay, how far do we let the Commerce Clause stretch to, and on what constitutional grounds?"

That's more or less the concerns voiced by the judges in the oral arguments. Why? Because of the plaintiff's arguments. The plaintiff's arguments must be one by one, answered.
 
Last edited:
Whatever the ruling, whether general or not, the SCOTUS will have given direction to the lower courts:

1) Mandate is not constitutional
2) Mandate is constitutional in general
3) Mandate is constitutional in this specific case because of the reach of the health care/insurance market

Those all give lower courts guidance on how to interpret the commerce clause.

#3 does NOT give guidance to the lower court unless they describe what the relevant standard is for the "reach" (or whatever) of a market that would make a mandate constitutional or unconstitutional. But that's still a general ruling in the sense in which I meant it: it would address mandates in general (and not simply this one mandate), even if it didn't make them all constitutional or unconstitutional.

I just don't see your argument having legs.

I suspect that's because you misunderstood what I meant by a "general" ruling.

Yes, the court in principle could rule that this mandate is constitutional but still establish a standard by which other mandates would not be. But given the lack of any coherent argument presented thus far for what such a standard would be, I do not find that possibility to be likely, though it's not a priori impossible.
 
Whatever the ruling,.... I think you'd prefer it to because then the slippery slope broccoli argument is "validated"...but that's simply wishful thinking and affirming the consequent, not really looking at this fairly.
SO I REALLY NEED TO KNOW:

Do I invest in broccoli futures?
 
Wrong parsing. Complete, 100% wrong. Here's why.

A) A doc decides on MRI in an environment of much litigation.
B) A doc decides on MRI in an environment without much litigation.
C) An outside party decides what constitutes "medical necessity".

C is virtually impossible because the MRI is a diagnostic tool. The medical necessity, such as doing a surgery, is the result of diagnostic tools followed by biopsies of located suspect areas. Here we use the MRI as an example only, but you get the idea - CAT scan etc, is also diagnostic.

C is basically the sort of top down liberal progressive authoritarian controller thinking that creates unmitigated disasters. Your question seems to imply that doctors would order an MRI just to jack the bill up and increase profits. I have to say that I know of no doctors who would do such a thing. None. But I know many who do order what they view as excessive diagnostics because of an established climate of fear of litigation.
I think you have a picture where a doctor is a kind of ultimate authority and benevolent dictator. I don't think it works like that in practice. You have the AMA, insurance companies, hospital boards, the state and local government -- all with input into who gets an MRI and why. You already mentioned the role that litigation plays in it.

How can you simultaneously recognize doctors are subject to lawsuits that may motivate their behavior but then ignore a profit motive? Isn't avoiding a lawsuit the same as saving money?

By the way, I know of a person who was in a carwreck, exhibited some symptoms of possible problems in the ER, was told she was being moved right then to get the MRI, and who refused and walked out of the hospital.

She simply did not want the waste of the resource and in her own judgement thought it was not warranted.

Good enough. I believe patients should have the right to refuse treatment. I do not think they should have the right to insist on any treatment whatsoever.

What we have now is partly free market based. Even to the level that you can travel to another country if you can't buy a procedure in your home nation. Money and resources already limit what is available. I don't see how recognizing that fact changes anything. I think we differ only on what the limits should be, not that there are no limits.

We also differ on where the authority to make decisions should lie. It is now in the hands of patients, doctors and third party payers. This actually doesn't change much in current UHC models. I'd prefer it did.

It wouldn't take much either. All you need to do is come up with clear standards of practice and then allow lawyers to enforce them when doctors go beyond the boundaries. It's actually very close to what we have now.
 
I mentioned this earlier and it got passed over:

Under UHC would Doctors still maintain liability for malpractice? or would lawsuits be directed at the Federal Govt?
 
How can you simultaneously recognize doctors are subject to lawsuits that may motivate their behavior but then ignore a profit motive? Isn't avoiding a lawsuit the same as saving money?
A climate of fear in complex decision making is likely not conducive to good patient care. A logical consequence of that climate is the making routine of defensive diagnosis procedures. Why? Because the lack of a diagnostic test having been made can be brought into court as a "fault of the doctor". Because That is true whether in his judgement the test was needed or not, the decision as to whether to make the test or not is effectively removed from his decision-making process. Once it is removed (and that's the point we are at now) the question simply no longer exists as to whether to order tests A, or A, B, C and D. You might think of it as the creation of a culture and cultural standards, based on fear in origin, but now standing separate from that original cause.

We also differ on where the authority to make decisions should lie. It is now in the hands of patients, doctors and third party payers. This actually doesn't change much in current UHC models. I'd prefer it did.

It wouldn't take much either. All you need to do is come up with clear standards of practice and then allow lawyers to enforce them when doctors go beyond the boundaries. It's actually very close to what we have now.
No, that does not work. This can best be expressed mathematically but let me try to put it in words. There is high individual variance in symptoms displayed and similar variance in actual illness based on those symptoms displayed. Therefore, the entire concept of a "general rule" does not work, excepting insofar as the general rule allows the physician to do what he thinks is best. This is a danger to the welfare of the patient whether it is a third party payer or some slugs in washington. But it would be far worse with the slugs, than the average insurance company.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom