Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."
-Benjamin Franklin

That's where the contention arises. Is it "essential liberty" and is the remedy "little" or "temporary."
 
Thanks. Your points have been made before and I'm not contesting them. I'm not sure how many times I can agree with a point before people accept my agreement. My ire is directed at something very different. I don't buy the sudden interest in constitutionality from the right-wing. It didn't bother them when they came up with the mandate. It didn't bother then when they tried to implement them in the 90s. Now Obama implements them and suddenly they are constitutional scholars baying that the Democrats are hell bent on trampling the constitution.

Can you get my point?

Also, this idea about being forced to do stuff. BS. Look, if it's unconstitutional and the point serves us well then fine. I don't have a problem with that. It's the faux outrage and silly arguments that drive me nuts.
They know their other arguments have fallen completely flat. The US has a disastrous health care system, and this law will help a lot of people. That's why they made up some bogus constitutional arguments which they're now trying to sell to their operatives on the supreme court.
 
I don't think that's entirely the case. Congress was concerned about the constitutionality of the legislation during its development and did consult constitutional law authorities while drafting it in an attempt to insure it would pass constitutional muster. I think they expected a constitutional challenge all along.


I think we've all heard Speaker Pelosi's response when asked about Congressional authority to enact the mandate: "Are you serious? Are you serious?"

Here are a few more reponses posted at the Volokh Conspiracy (a law professor's blog):

Rep. Conyers cited the “Good and Welfare Clause” as the source of Congress’s authority [there is no such clause].

Rep. Stark responded, “the federal government can do most anything in this country.”

Rep. Clyburn replied, “There’s nothing in the Constitution that says the federal government has anything to do with most of the stuff we do. How about [you] show me where in the Constitution it prohibits the federal government from doing this?”

Rep. Hare said “I don’t worry about the Constitution on this, to be honest [...] It doesn’t matter to me.” When asked, “Where in the Constitution does it give you the authority …?” He replied, “I don’t know.”

Sen. Akaka said he “not aware” of which Constitutional provision authorizes the healthcare bill.

Sen. Leahy added, “We have plenty of authority. Are you saying there’s no authority?”


Sen. Landriew is also on their list for not knowing where in the Constitution the authority came from but, in fairness, since she is reported to have said "I'll leave that up to the constitutional lawyers" I'm going to give her half credit.


http://volokh.com/2012/03/28/democr...tors-on-constitutional-authority-for-the-aca/
 
Well, certainly if you have a government of thugs then constitutionality does not matter. But it happens we have the matter currently before an entity called "The Supreme Court". So whether internet posters like or don't like it, that's where we are.

Some would certainly prefer the government of thugs, because of the wonderful dreams they were promised. But those would never have come to pass. They were marketing promises made to get power by politicians. The same politicians whose other marketing promises resulted in our now spending 40% more than we have in revenue.

Clearly an untenable situation (spending far in excess of revenue) will come to an end, and if at that time some kind of universal health care is in place in the US, no one who relies on the promises of health care will get much of anything out of it.
 
I think this is a very fair Supreme Court. The Chief Justice has stated he wasn't interested in practicing judicial activism but rather interpreting the constitutionality of cases brought before him.

People always accuse the court of bias when things don't go the way they want them to.
 
I think this is a very fair Supreme Court. The Chief Justice has stated he wasn't interested in practicing judicial activism but rather interpreting the constitutionality of cases brought before him.

People always accuse the court of bias when things don't go the way they want them to.

Peephole wasn't alleging bias or unfairness. He was alleging actual external control. And he can't actually defend it. The closest he comes is an attempt at sarcasm which unintentionally hits closer to the truth than his own beliefs.
 
I think this is a very fair Supreme Court. The Chief Justice has stated he wasn't interested in practicing judicial activism but rather interpreting the constitutionality of cases brought before him.

People always accuse the court of bias when things don't go the way they want them to.
So, the fact that the Chief Justice's votes favor Conservatives when the vote is split 5-4 simply coincidental?

Now, granted, it cuts both ways. And granted, many if not most decision are unanimous or close to unanimous. I think they are fair. However, it would strike me as naive to think ideology doesn't play some role here and that fact, even if it is an unconscious bias, isn't fair.
 
So, the fact that the Chief Justice's votes favor Conservatives when the vote is split 5-4 simply coincidental?

Now, granted, it cuts both ways. And granted, many if not most decision are unanimous or close to unanimous. I think they are fair. However, it would strike me as naive to think ideology doesn't play some role here and that fact, even if it is an unconscious bias, isn't fair.
BTW: Scalia is a very odd duck. Very intelligent and knowledgeable sure, but his views at times border on absurdity. Thomas arrogantly ignores calls for recusal on grounds of conflict of interest. He thinks nothing of violating the appearance of impropriety. Those two give me pause. Thomas more than Scalia.
 
BTW: Scalia is a very odd duck. Very intelligent and knowledgeable sure, but his views at times border on absurdity. Thomas arrogantly ignores calls for recusal on grounds of conflict of interest. He thinks nothing of violating the appearance of impropriety. Those two give me pause. Thomas more than Scalia.

What about Kagan? If anyone should have been recused it was her! Yet you didn't mention that

See, I hate partisan crap....... everyone ignores their own sides issues and just jumps on the other side....
If this gets shot down, the left won't blame their own side for writing a dumb law, they will blame the court for bein biased..... this is why we can't get anything done anymore. ridiculous blame game nonsense.
 
What about Kagan? If anyone should have been recused it was her! Yet you didn't mention that
No, I didn't I'm sorry. I wasn't trying to prove the left less biased. I was trying to show reasons why I have some problems with your premise. But I do think it something a false equivalency. Kagan's sin was expressing support for the law. I think she should recuse herself for that. The problems of Thomas are a more serious than that. But I will concede that both sides have biases and reasons why they might not be objective.

See, I hate partisan crap....... everyone ignores their own sides issues and just jumps on the other side....
Hang on, I said "it cuts both ways", right?

If this gets shot down, the left won't blame their own side for writing a dumb law, they will blame the court for bein biased..... this is why we can't get anything done anymore. ridiculous blame game nonsense.
You have me confused for someone else.
 
Last edited:
The end wasn't aimed at you directly man!!!

I have just become frustrated with the present age of extreme partisanship. It doesn't seem like people can hardly even be friends anymore if they have differeing politics. That's stupid and symbolic of how we much about "winning" we have become rather than "compromise" and "discussion"
 
The end wasn't aimed at you directly man!!!

I have just become frustrated with the present age of extreme partisanship. It doesn't seem like people can hardly even be friends anymore if they have differeing politics. That's stupid and symbolic of how we much about "winning" we have become rather than "compromise" and "discussion"
Fair enough.
 
I think this is a very fair Supreme Court.
As do I. They do of course look at the law through their own ideological perspectives, which seem to reflect the perspectives of the US, that being that most people identify themselves as conservative rather than liberal.
 
Plus Roberts seems to be much less of an ideologue than say Scalia. Heck he announced that he was not interested in overturning Rove V Wade or any other precedent setting cases. But was more interested in looking forward with analysis of present legislation and situation that need to be addressed by the court. This is why I don't worry about all those anti-abortion bills states are trying to pass, (or have passed) they will all make it to the court and will all get shot down.
 
Plus Roberts seems to be much less of an ideologue than say Scalia. Heck he announced that he was not interested in overturning Rove V Wade or any other precedent setting cases. But was more interested in looking forward with analysis of present legislation and situation that need to be addressed by the court. This is why I don't worry about all those anti-abortion bills states are trying to pass, (or have passed) they will all make it to the court and will all get shot down.

I would agree that it's a good court. I have confidence they will make a decision which is constitutional, and for the overall benefit of the country.
 
The central question before the court is whether or not Congress has the power to enact a law that requires someone to purchase private health insurance. When I first heard about the mandate and the penalty I assumed the media was simplifying the bill and that technically it would be a tax (either an increase to an existing tax such as income tax, or a new tax) with tax credits and/or exemptions for people who had private health insurance. When the bill was passed, I took a look at it and was surprised that it was actually presented as a penalty. The Supreme Court seems to regard it has a penalty, not a tax. So we go on to the Commerce Clause.

The initial question is the slippery slope broccoli argument. If Congress has the power to impose a non-criminal penalty for not purchasing health insurance, then where is the boundary drawn? Can it impose a penalty for not purchasing broccoli? Or not performing 3 hours of government approved exercise per week? Or not going to church? Or not publicly weeping over the death of a political leader? Or not saying the Pledge of Allegiance each morning? Or not thinking the right things? What is to prevent a doubleplussungood crimethinnk penalty?

The argument to this is that health care is different from these because it falls under the Commerce Clause and is unique because there are laws that require that health care providers (doctors, hospitals, etc.) provide essential health care even if a person can’t (demonstrate that they can) pay for it. The health care providers take a loss in cases where people can’t pay their health care bills, and those losses result in higher health care costs for people who pay out of pocket or for health insurance companies, which in turn raises costs for people who purchase health insurance.

Because the law insures that a person without the ability to pay and without insurance must be provided health care, the government “insures” everyone a minimum standard of health care. Because some uninsured people can’t or don’t pay for health care costs incurred by health care providers because of these laws, people who purchase private health insurance pay higher premiums to cover the health care “insurance” already mandated by the government. Therefore, the government, which established constitutional laws to “insure” minimum health care, which directly affects health insurance commerce, has the power to regulate that commerce, and those that directly affect it, by enacting a penalty on those who do not have private health insurance.

OK. Everything seems defensible up to this point. In practice, it seems constitutional. But there are exceptions.

What about those people who can and do pay for health care out of pocket?

Let’s say I’m extremely healthy, wealthy, and wise. Insurance is essentially a socialist or communist scheme. Everybody puts some money in a bucket. People who need it can take some money out of the bucket. With private insurance, the insurance company scrapes a bit out of the bucket as profit. Some people take out much more than they put in. And so, obviously, many people put in much more than they take out.

Since I’m extremely healthy, wealthy, and wise; I don’t have health insurance. If I were to buy health insurance, chances are I would be one of the people who put more in than I take out. Not a wise decision. If the odds go against me and I suddenly have huge health care bills, I can and will pay for them out of pocket.

So how would this mandate be fair to me? I am extremely healthy and not likely to incur large health care costs. If were to but health insurance to comply with the mandate it would be the cheapest available with a high deductible (or some other coverage where I wouldn’t get a better return). So the insurance company will end up paying little or none of my health care costs, but use my money to cover other people and make a profit to boot.

I would just be throwing money down the drain. And if I don’t do that, then I have to pay a penalty, which is just throwing money down the drain.

Because I can and will pay all of my health care costs out of pocket, I have no affect on health insurance commerce. So how can Congress have the authority to “regulate” commerce that affects someone not at all involved in or influencing that commerce in a manner that result in me just throwing money down the drain?

(In case you have forgotten, I am just playing DevilsAdvocate. I am not actually healthy or wealthy. Wise is up for debate. And I support Universal Health Care. And I think ACA and the mandate is a step in the right direction and would be an improvement, but I’m not sure if it is constitutional, or what we would want to be within the power of Congress.)
 
Devils,

It is not fair to you in your hypothetical, but I don't see why "fair to me" is even an issue when it comes to federal law. Certainly there are hundreds of laws that "aren't fair to me."

If the idea is the greatest good for the greatest number-- that has legs.

There are really two arguments on offer. The first is whether we should have some form of UHC and the second is how it can be done constitutionally (legally).

Right now, there doesn't seem to be enough political will to push through a constitutional amendment and just declare healthcare a right for all citizens, but that would clean up a lot of legal issues. And then create new ones.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom