Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

Oh and BTW, I'm an atheist, I don't think Vaccines cause autism, I just defended evolution against some jesus loony in a bar the other day (you should've heard him when i countered hi claims that I had no morality by asking him what his Baptist preacher would think of him being in a bar!!! Lunatic almost took a swing at me) So don't try and paint me some anti-intellectual Jesus freak. I DO however, find that much of what the social academics tell us is unrealistic and wrong. People and their behavior is far too complex to be treated as mathematics.
 
Last edited:
You didn't even gather the point, you attacked a word..... that's not an argument... C'mon you are better than that.
I disdain anti-intellectualism and that is beneath you. If you don't mean to be anti-scientific then don't attack intellectuals wholesale as you have. BTW: Since you are fond of pointing out the excesses of Communism, both Stalin and Mao were anti-intellectual as were most if not all fascistic regimes of the last century.

as far as the vacuum thing is concerned, the concept that having a good relationship with your Dr is akin to "the priesthood" is not a very realitic view of how human beings behave. I would mark such a statement as viewing humans in a vacuum.

It's similar to the sociologists who claim that children are damaged by having their feelings hurt by losing. When learning how to handle losing, failure and other problems is about as important a life lesson as children can get. I also think that's vacuum thinking.
This happens to be my area of interest. I studied social science and psychology at the University of Utah. Since then I have read scores of books on the subjects including behaviorism and mind sciences in general. I don't care to get bogged down in a debate with you. Let me just say I find your pop-psychology analysis underwhelming to say the least. It's more than a decade old and typical of the rhetoric of those who have no idea what the science even is. If you are going to make these kinds of statement could you bother to get your information from actual sources and not the rhetoric of pundits and politicians?
 
Last edited:
Oh and BTW, I'm an atheist, I don't think Vaccines cause autism, I just defended evolution against some jesus loony in a bar the other day (you should've heard him when i countered hi claims that I had no morality by asking him what his Baptist preacher would think of him being in a bar!!! Lunatic almost took a swing at me) So don't try and paint me some anti-intellectual Jesus freak. I DO however, find that much of what the social academics tell us is unrealistic and wrong. People and their behavior is far too complex to be treated as mathematics.
Tell me the last book you read on the social sciences?
 
Ahhhh well of course you will be protectionistic about your own little happy zone there. I took a few classes in sociology, juvenile delinquency and a few others. I found much of the root curriculum very valuable.I found most of the "programs for improvement" type of ideas unrealistic and silly. like they were written by people who had never had children, nor been around children. (an old GF who is a Child Psychologist agrees with me on this ) of course this isn't "evidence" but that doesn't mean I'm incorrect either.

I got my information from personal experience. When i was living with a GF in the Chicago suburbs her son's little league team didn't keep score. Because losing would be too damaging to their little feelings. ( This was league wide and after asking a few friends who live around the country it wasn't an isolated case) I doubt this was rooted in just a parent somewhere making a suggestion.

Why do you just assume pundits and politicians? Man that irritates me..... I don't watch TV news,I can barely tolerate either party anymore. I live life. i observe people. I have ideas and conceptualizations of solutions and avoiding problems. In other words, I try and think for myself.

The fact that I was blessed with a high IQ for problem solving helps. The other fact that I tend to loathe most people doesn't.


shrug
 
Ahhhh well of course you will be protectionistic about your own little happy zone there.
Like I get protectionistic when theists and anti-vaxers attack scientists. It's not a happy zone. It's a field that is governed by rules for study and reporting. Social science must go through peer review just as much as any other science. It's not exact but it's not guessing in the dark either.

I took a few classes in sociology, juvenile delinquency and a few others. I found much of the root curriculum very valuable.I found most of the "programs for improvement" type of ideas unrealistic and silly. like they were written by people who had never had children, nor been around children. (an old GF who is a Child Psychologist agrees with me on this ) of course this isn't "evidence" but that doesn't mean I'm incorrect either.
First off, social science isn't monolithic. You are making sweeping assertions based on rudimentary education anecdotal observation.

I got my information from personal experience. When i was living with a GF in the Chicago suburbs her son's little league team didn't keep score. Because losing would be too damaging to their little feelings. ( This was league wide and after asking a few friends who live around the country it wasn't an isolated case) I doubt this was rooted in just a parent somewhere making a suggestion.
Granting your anecdote, it doesn't speak to the entire field of child psychology past or current. Not every child psychologist subscribed to any single idea. You are being dismissive an entire group of people based on the tenuous of data. If an idea is bad it will get rooted out.

Why do you just assume pundits and politicians?
I don't live in a vacuum. I was a conservative until a few years ago. I was a long time fan of Rush Limbaugh and conservative commentators. I heard this kind of rhetoric frequently.

In any event, I don't want to debate. I should have left alone. You an have the last word on that subject.
 
Last edited:
meh, what's the point....... none of this really makes any difference anyway. Politicians are going to do what they do and there isn't much you nor I can do about it.
 
meh, what's the point....... none of this really makes any difference anyway. Politicians are going to do what they do and there isn't much you nor I can do about it.
I'm not so cynical but that's cool.
 
I still don't think we can afford UHC. Not unless we do some serious budget cutting. Privatize social security, eliminate all other entitlements. Basically go back to the Fed does the state dept, defense dept, the EPA and the Treasury.... Cuz UHC could cost $4 trillion a year. At least for the first decade or so.
Where do people get this crazy train of thought?

Every country with universal healthcare does it cheaper than the US.
 
Where do people get this crazy train of thought?

Every country with universal healthcare does it cheaper than the US.



Crazy train of thought? So you think that the first decade of Universal health care will magically become cheaper? with our aging population? I expect over time to see a significant drop, but not at first. Not with a population the size of ours!!

if the top earning 10% do not participate due to paying for private care, that will still leave 300 million people. The Govt spends $800 billion right now for 50 million people on Medicare and Medicaid. Multiply that times 6, that's $4.8 trillion dollars per year. Let's get conservative and say they really have a handle on things and knock the costs down by one third. That's still $3.2 trillion dollars per year.

Federal Revenue for 2011 $2.5 trillion federal expenditures $3.8 trillion

Plus, one must consider the possibility that people will use UHC more often than they used health services prior to it being free for all.

Can we afford to double our annual budget? Can we get 300+ million people to agree to such a tax increase?
 
A doctor patient relationship cannot be dismissed as being "like a priesthood" it's important for your Dr to know what your history is, what he's done for you in the past and how you responded. it's good for him to know what your lifestyle is like, perhaps even what your family members history is like.

This would indeed be nice. What do you suppose it would cost?

You can say that any Dr can look at a patient record and gather all that info, but will they? Will they have the time for that?

They do it now. When you see a specialist or go to the hospital, that's exactly what they do, they rely on observation, conversation and your medical records. Even your own doctor, if he is smart, reviews your records before he sees you. Unless you are envisioning some sort of Michael Jackson level of attention, it has to be that way.

Not to mention that as the patient shouldn't you have a choice what Dr you visit?

Not necessarily. Rather than demand patients evaluate doctors, let's just evaluate doctors ahead of time.


Who get's your business? I guess you think a bunch of sociologists and medical "experts" kno better than patients and Doctors?

I find that ridiculous.....

Well, one path to efficiency is to reduce customization. The more you can standardize care, the cheaper it becomes. Take the way we handle flu shots now -- cheap as dirt at any pharmacy.

My question is how is it that there are so many bad doctors out there that we demand the choice? All you are doing is shifting the less able doctors onto a part of the population that doesn't have any choices. If we can't get past the notion of Cadillac care for everyone, we'll never get anywhere at all.
 
Last edited:
Ahhh but you are making the assumption that people choose their Dr solely on their high level of ability. I would suggest that people choose their Doctor based on several different criteria like : "Treated my family since i was young" or "I saw him once and liked his demeanor" or "seems to be straight up with me" or "direct and to the point".

I would guess that generally the level of competence among Doctors is decent. (though not perfect of course) But people want to see a Doctor (a GP is what I am referring to btw) that they feel jives with their personality.


BTW, I feel that this pertains to UHC or not. If care is Universal (and said Dr chooses to participate in this system and not as a private only care giver) then why shouldn't people have a choice?
 
Last edited:
It is not fair to you in your hypothetical, but I don't see why "fair to me" is even an issue when it comes to federal law. Certainly there are hundreds of laws that "aren't fair to me."
The word “fair” probably isn’t the best here. You are confusing the law in question with the question of the power Congress. The question before the court boils down to whether or not to allow Congress to require everybody to do something as a means of regulating commerce. The argument is that Congress should have that power in the case of health insurance, but not in the broccoli case, because health care providers are required to provide service to everybody, and therefore it is “fair” or “just” or “permissible” to apply that type of “regulation” to everybody in this case because everybody participates in or (could) affect the health care commerce market.

My argument is that although everybody could conceivably participate in or affect the health CARE market, not everybody participates in or affects the health INSURANCE market. There is a set of people who can and will pay for health care out of pocket and have no influence on the health insurance market. So the argument that it is “fair” or “just” or “permissible” to make an exception for health insurance on the basis that everybody affects that commerce is false.

This situation has been addressed by some requirements for car insurance. In some states, for a car to be driven on public roads, it must be insured against liability, or the owner must have money in escrow to cover potential costs of liability. The difference is that laws already exist for the exception for escrow coverage, and I would guess that driving an uninsured car on a public road would be considered a criminal offense, with a criminal fine, and an opportunity for dispute the offense in court.

If the idea is the greatest good for the greatest number-- that has legs.
This is very, very wrong. This is how oppressive, totalitarian dictatorships get started. The courts, especially the appellate courts and mostly the supreme court, exist, perhaps primarily, as a means of ensuring justice against the greatest number and the “greatest good”. It is up to Congress to decide what might be “good”. The Supreme Court must decide whether that is “fair” or “just”.

There are really two arguments on offer. The first is whether we should have some form of UHC and the second is how it can be done constitutionally (legally).
That is not a decision for the Supreme Court case, which is what this thread is about. There are other threads about how the President and Congress might address health care in the US.
 
If so, then government made it unique. What's to stop government from making other markets unique by similar intervention? In fact, government already intervenes heavily in a number of markets (including food and housing) where everyone participates. If government intervention is itself a justification for the expansion of government powers, then what limit remains?

Potential future commerce should not be treated as actual commerce. We should not be able to regulate what doesn't exist, and potential future commerce doesn't exist until (and if) it becomes actual present commerce. If we start treating potential future commerce as something which can be regulated, then there is likewise no limit to what falls under the commerce clause.
It looks like Kennedy was going down those lines. I think a case can be made that health care is unique in that everybody has and requires health. And the question isn’t whether government intervention is allowed in markets where everyone participates—it clearly is under the Commerce Clause. And can intervene or influence such markets through other means such as taxation and provisions, or tariffs. I think the vicious snake is broken unless you want to go downstairs to the argument that Congress has no authority to require health care providers to provide necessary care when proof of ability to pay is not provided, and I doubt anybody wants to go there.
 
I have another question. If the power of Congress to require (or otherwise penalize) the purchase of health insurance is deemed permissible (where it would not be in other markets) exclusively because laws exists that require health care providers to provide necessary health care, what would happen if the mandate was in place but the law requiring require health care providers to provide necessary health care was later eliminated by Congress?

The court can’t stop Congress from changing such a law. Someone would have to bring a case, probably to the Supreme Court, to rule that the new law is invalid, not because it the law itself violates the Constitution or the Commerce Clause, but because the change in the law would change the law on which the Supreme Court had used as a basis to determine that the mandate is legal.

It seems like hanging the limits of the power of Congress on other laws passed by Congress could become difficult for the court to address.
 
yeah, we got sidetracked.....my bad
Thanks. I'd really like to hear what people think about the legal issue at hand. It is a very interesting legal question.

Vorticity said:
None of this matters. Not the arguments. Not the questions during arguments. Not even whether the ACA mandate is in fact unconstitutional or not. For cases of such political magnitude, the SCOTUS is a purely political institution.

The breakdown will be along "party lines"

I disagree that on very political matters that the SCOTUS is a purely political institution. However, in a case like this, there are legitimate arguments both for and against the mandate. It could, legitimately, go either way. In those cases, political bias splits the fence. So, I agree that it will probably be 5-4 along party lines.
 
I’m in favor of Universal Health Care. Expand Medicare/Medicaid. Or a new program. Get rid of private health insurance. Or at least a public option. Beyond that, a mandate seems like the best option for improvement.

But if I were a Supreme Court Justice, I think I would have to shoot the mandate down. Expanding the power of Congress under the Commerce Clause is very dangerous and should not be taken lightly. And the expansion of “regulation” to include “everybody is required to purchase” is a huge expansion. Introducing penalties that could apply to anybody, and for inactivity, and that are not criminal and subject to rights to arrest, trial, etc. is also very dangerous.

Arguments that health insurance should be an exclusive exception because it applies to everybody does not, to me, outweigh the dangers of this expansion of power. Although costs of health care applies to everybody under current laws requiring that necessary health care be provided, the commerce market of health insurance does not apply to all (those who can and do pay out of pocket) and there is no provision (that I am aware of) that excludes this set from the penalty.

Consider how this decision may affect decisions on other laws, not only toady, but 10 years, 25 years, 100 years, 200 years from now. The argument for an exception because the commerce applies to everybody falls flat because there is a set (people who pay out of pocket) that do not influence the commerce. The fact that almost all people currently are in that market, or that other laws require that most (or even all) people be in that market (when those laws can change), or that this is “what is best” for the country right now does not overweigh the dangerous possibilities of this expanded government control.

If that messes up health care, which it would, then Congress has to find a way to fix it in a way that doesn’t overreach the legal boundaries of the power of Congress.
 
This situation has been addressed by some requirements for car insurance. In some states, for a car to be driven on public roads, it must be insured against liability, or the owner must have money in escrow to cover potential costs of liability. The difference is that laws already exist for the exception for escrow coverage, and I would guess that driving an uninsured car on a public road would be considered a criminal offense, with a criminal fine, and an opportunity for dispute the offense in court.

This caught my eye because in my state (Michigan) a car has to be licensed even if it remains on private property (unless it is under active repair or restoration). I think the basis is that you "could" drive on public roads if you wanted to and hence the car must be licensed. Of course, to be licensed, it also has to be insured.

I don't know if that affects your argument or not, and it's on the state level anyhow.
 
Arguments that health insurance should be an exclusive exception because it applies to everybody does not, to me, outweigh the dangers of this expansion of power. Although costs of health care applies to everybody under current laws requiring that necessary health care be provided, the commerce market of health insurance does not apply to all (those who can and do pay out of pocket) and there is no provision (that I am aware of) that excludes this set from the penalty.

Consider how this decision may affect decisions on other laws, not only toady, but 10 years, 25 years, 100 years, 200 years from now. The argument for an exception because the commerce applies to everybody falls flat because there is a set (people who pay out of pocket) that do not influence the commerce. The fact that almost all people currently are in that market, or that other laws require that most (or even all) people be in that market (when those laws can change), or that this is “what is best” for the country right now does not overweigh the dangerous possibilities of this expanded government control.
But that's not accurate. The insurance market is affected by those who choose not to buy insurance - whether it be because they can't afford it or because they can. It changes the demographic. Additionally, everyone is affected by those who don't have insurance when it comes to the cost of care - even those who pay their own way must pay for those who don't have insurance to be covered, the same as the rest of us do (through our insurance carriers).

While I do agree that extending the Commerce clause should not be done lightly, I don't believe that this is a light matter, nor is it being treated as one by either side of the aisle. Should the extension be allowed by the SCOTUS, I expect it will come with very very specific limits - i.e. that it applies to health care only, and even then with restrictions on what's allowed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom