Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

This is something the States can do, but not the Federal government, because the federal government is a government of limited powers. Everything Congress enacts has to be authorized by something in Article I of (or an Amendment to) the Constitution. The government argues this act is authorized by Congress power to regulate interstate commerce. So the question becomes whether a law that regulates people not buying health insurance implicates interstate commerce. If inaction implicates interstate commerce, what doesn't implicate interstate commerce?


This is a good summary of the Commerce Clause issue.

People often forget the nature of the federal system and the fact that the federal government is a government of limited powers.
 
This is a good summary of the Commerce Clause issue.

People often forget the nature of the federal system and the fact that the federal government is a government of limited powers.
Not so limited that federal govt can't force you to pay a trillion dollars for a Jet fighter.

It's a half dozen of one and 6 of the other. I suppose a perception of freedom is a lot like freedom.

BTW: I actually understand the issues and do want the govt limited as you suggest. I just think it's silly to stand on some moral principle that is only perceptual.
 
  • Everyone who pays taxes picks up the tab for those who go to an emergency room and cannot pay.
  • Everyone who works must pay into medicare.
The power of congress to tax is clearly constitutional.

Had the tax code been jiggered to impose an (added) tax, to be offset by a credit if insurance was purchased, that would also imo have been clearly constitutional.
 
Not so limited that federal govt can't force you to pay a trillion dollars for a Jet fighter.

It's a half dozen of one and 6 of the other. I suppose a perception of freedom is a lot like freedom.

BTW: I actually understand the issues and do want the govt limited as you suggest. I just think it's silly to stand on some moral principle that is only perceptual.


We may not like what the Dept. of Defense spends our tax money on, but there is no question the federal government has the power to tax and spend and to provide for the common defense (U.S. Const. Art. I, Sec. 8).

Limited government means more than just not wanting the government to spend like a bunch of drunken sailors. It means that the federal government only has the authority granted under the Constitution. If you understand the issues as you say, then you should understand that requiring the government to remain within these bounds is more than "perceptual."

As I noted in the parallel health care thread, I think an expanded version of medicare would likely be constitutional. But it seems to me that Congress tried to get clever with the private insurance fix, never concerned that it might actually have to show its constitutional authority to compel individuals to buy a private product.
 
The power of congress to tax is clearly constitutional.

Had the tax code been jiggered to impose an (added) tax, to be offset by a credit if insurance was purchased, that would also imo have been clearly constitutional.
I'm not arguing otherwise. I'm arguing that the net effect is the same and all of this "the government can't force me" is faux outrage as the govt damn well does force you. I've conceded the technical point for purposes of this discussion.
 
Not so limited that federal govt can't force you to pay a trillion dollars for a Jet fighter.

That power doesn't derive from the commerce clause, so it's got nothing to do with the extent of the commerce clause.

It's a half dozen of one and 6 of the other. I suppose a perception of freedom is a lot like freedom.

This isn't about "freedom". It's about the scope of powers of the federal government.

BTW: I actually understand the issues and do want the govt limited as you suggest.

Really? Because nothing else you've said indicates that to be the case.

I just think it's silly to stand on some moral principle that is only perceptual.

This isn't about a moral principle, it's about a constitutional principle. And on that front, the distinction is hardly "only perceptual."

I'm reminded of the whole Solomon amendment case. Law schools argued that the threat to cut their funding if they didn't allow military recruiters was a violation of their free speech rights, and that Congress had no authority to use funding to coerce them to accept recruiters. The SC ruled against them unanimously, pointing out that Congress actually had the authority to impose the requirement regardless of funding, because raising an army is an enumerated power. So too is the example you have given. It's separate from the commerce clause. The scope of the commerce clause has nothing to do with Congress's ability to tax you to pay for military spending.
 
We may not like what the Dept. of Defense spends our tax money on, but there is no question the federal government has the power to tax and spend and to provide for the common defense (U.S. Const. Art. I, Sec. 8).
You have me confused for some other body.

Limited government means more than just not wanting the government to spend like a bunch of drunken sailors. It means that the federal government only has the authority granted under the Constitution. If you understand the issues as you say, then you should understand that requiring the government to remain within these bounds is more than "perceptual."
Yes, but in this instance it is just perceptual. I already conceded the point and admitted that there was a technical point that has substantive value. I just don't buy into all of this nonsense about the govt not being able to force you to buy something. That have and they do. The money for the military doesn't grow on trees.

As I noted in the parallel health care thread, I think an expanded version of medicare would likely be constitutional. But it seems to me that Congress tried to get clever with the private insurance fix, never concerned that it might actually have to show its constitutional authority to compel individuals to buy a private product.
Thanks, doesn't address my point. And I don't really buy the "get cute". It was originally thought up by a Conservative think tank and twice was introduced by GOP lawmakers and it was the basis for the Massachusetts plan. It might not be constitutional but it wasn't because someone was trying to "get cute". It was an attempt to give Republicans a plan they came up with. No one figured that the GOP would be so outraged that their plan was adopted. So outraged they would start screaming about freedom and trampling on rights.

Give me a break.
 
I just don't buy into all of this nonsense about the govt not being able to force you to buy something. [They] have and they do. The money for the military doesn't grow on trees.


The money raised by the federal government for the common defense comes from a specific power granted under the Constitution (U.S. Const. Art. I Sec. 8).

To my knowledge, the Supreme Court has never held that Congress has the authority under the Constitution to compel private individuals to buy a specific product.
 
The money raised by the federal government for the common defense comes from a specific power granted under the Constitution (U.S. Const. Art. I Sec. 8).

To my knowledge, the Supreme Court has never held that Congress has the authority under the Constitution to compel private individuals to buy a specific product.
I'm not sure where you got the idea I thought otherwise. I'm not sure how many times I can say I agree with you. Taking my money to buy things is still forcing me to buy things. No matter how hard you try I'm going to agree with you. But you keep saying the same thing and I will keep agreeing. Fair enough?
 
Normally, I wouldn't agree with you, but this almost sounds workable. I understand people would like their employer to cover the whole shooting match, not out of being deadbeats, but simply due to the cost, but something like this might be a start.
Yeah, one comes to you and says "Can we get one that handles dental", and another makes a pitch about how important optical is, and another wants to be sure those copays are low. Damn zoo.

I never like imposing my values on other people, but this is one situation where it wouldn't bother me a bit. A lot of people live paycheck to paycheck, so they are really concerned about something like that copay being low, and not having to shell out cash for a doc visit. The plan I laid out, the high deductible scheme doesn't cover any of that (unless someone goes over that deductible in one year, which is unlikely unless they get a serious problem). Then they have a debit card for the HSA account, and guess what?

Every single time they think about going to the doc or buying new glasses or filling a prescription, they think - that's MY MONEY, from MY ACCOUNT - do I really need this? Maybe I can do without it or think of a smarter way. Do I want this prescription for $140? Maybe I should look into ordering prescrips from Canada. Etc, etc.
 
Not so limited that federal govt can't force you to pay a trillion dollars for a Jet fighter.

It's a half dozen of one and 6 of the other. I suppose a perception of freedom is a lot like freedom.

BTW: I actually understand the issues and do want the govt limited as you suggest. I just think it's silly to stand on some moral principle that is only perceptual.

To be fair, the power to tax and the power to spend money on national defense are explicitly granted to Congress. And regarding the trillion dollar jets, the Constitution does not prohibit unwise policy.

Also, most of the expansion of federal law over the last 70 years has relied on the commerce power, so it is reasonable for those who favor keeping limits on federal power to try to arrest that trend, since that appears to be the source of an emerging federal plenary police power. And that is what proponents of limited government want to prevent. From the beginning, it was an explicit aim of the Constitution to prevent that.

So while one can point to things that are arguably equally coercive that are justified under other clauses of Art. I Sec. 8 (and some that are inarguably equally coercive), that isn't the point, in my view. Those other powers are given to Congress for different reasons, and none of the other powers have been used to expand the reach of federal power the way the commerce clause has. They are more circumscribed because of the purposes for which they are granted. So, respectfully, I can't agree that it is silly, and I also don't agree that the principle is mere perception. (I also don't think that it is a moral principle, but rather a practical one).
 
Last edited:
To be fair, the power to tax and the power to spend money on national defense are explicitly granted to Congress. And the Constitution does not prohibit unwise policy.

Also, most of the expansion of federal law over the last 70 years has relied on the commerce power, so it is reasonable for those who favor keeping limits on federal power to try to arrest that trend, since that appears to be the source of an emerging federal plenary police power. And that is what proponents of limited government want to prevent. From the beginning, it was an explicit aim of the Constitution to prevent that.

So while one can point to things that are arguably equally coercive that are justified under other clauses of Art. I Sec. 8 (and some that are inarguably equally coercive), that isn't the point, in my view. None of those other powers have been used to expand the reach of federal power the way the commerce clause has, because they are more circumscribed. So, respectfully, I can't agree that it is silly, and I also don't agree that the principle is mere perception. (I also don't think that it is a moral principle, but rather a practical one).
What I mean by silly is all the outrage over a technical issue. These people don't care about the reach of federal power. The came up with mandates and tried at least twice to get them passed in congress.

So, my point was never about constitutionality. It's about the bogus standing on principle. I don't buy it.
 


I think the site you linked to is being rather dishonest. First, Scalia never said the words they posted at the top of their article. Second, it appears they chopped the quote to make Scalia sound bad. If you read the transcript, the Court is questioning the Solicitor General on the consitutional basis for the government to mandate purchase of private insurance. I've posted the relevant section below. I could be wrong, but as I read the bolded section, Scalia seems to be saying that "yes, the government could take those social norms into consideration under the Interstate Commerce Clause but, even so, the government's justification is still suspect."

GENERAL VERRILLI: "This is a regulation of existing commerce."

JUSTICE GINSBURG: "Can we go back to --Justice Breyer asked a question, and it kind of interrupted your answer to my question. And tell me if I'm wrong about this, but I thought a major, major point of your argument was that the people who don't participate in this market are making it much more expensive for the people who do; that is, they will get -- a goodly number of them will get services that they can't afford at the point when they need them, and the result is that everybody else's premiums get raised. So, you're not -- it's not your free choice just to do something for yourself. What you do is going to affect others, affect them in a major way."

GENERAL VERRILLI: "That -- that absolutely is a justification for Congress's action here. That is existing economic activity that Congress is regulating by means of this rule."

JUSTICE SCALIA: "Mr. Verrilli, you could say that about buying a car. If people don't buy cars, the price that those who do buy cars pay will have to be higher. So, you could say in order to bring the price down, you're hurting these other people by not buying a car."

GENERAL VERRILLI: "That is not what we're saying, Justice Scalia."

JUSTICE SCALIA: "That's not -- that's not what you're saying."

GENERAL VERRILLI: "That's not -- not --"

JUSTICE SCALIA: "I thought it was. I thought you're saying other people are going to have to pay more for insurance because you're not buying it."

GENERAL VERRILLI: "No. It's because you're going -- in the health care market, you're going into the market without the ability to pay for what you get, getting the health care service anyway as a result of the social norms that allow -- that -- to which we've obligated ourselves so that people get health care."

JUSTICE SCALIA: "Well, don't obligate yourself to that. Why -- you know?"

GENERAL VERRILLI: "Well, I can't imagine that that -- that the Commerce Clause would -- would forbid Congress from taking into account this deeply embedded social norm."

JUSTICE SCALIA: "You could do it. But does that expand your ability to issue mandates to -- to the people?"

GENERAL VERRILLI: "I -- this is not a purchase mandate. This is a -- this is a law that regulates the method of paying for a service that the class of people to whom it applies are either
consuming --"

JUSTICE SOTOMAYOR: "General --"

GENERAL VERRILLI: "-- or inevitably will consume."


http://www.supremecourt.gov/oral_arguments/argument_transcripts/11-398-Tuesday.pdf
 
Last edited:
What I mean by silly is all the outrage over a technical issue. These people don't care about the reach of federal power. The came up with mandates and tried at least twice to get them passed in congress.

So, my point was never about constitutionality. It's about the bogus standing on principle. I don't buy it.
Or govt power in general. Collectively this group has been working tirelessly to restrict women's reproductive rights.

abortionrestrictions.jpg
 
To be fair, the power to tax and the power to spend money on national defense are explicitly granted to Congress. And regarding the trillion dollar jets, the Constitution does not prohibit unwise policy.

Also, most of the expansion of federal law over the last 70 years has relied on the commerce power, so it is reasonable for those who favor keeping limits on federal power to try to arrest that trend, since that appears to be the source of an emerging federal plenary police power. And that is what proponents of limited government want to prevent. From the beginning, it was an explicit aim of the Constitution to prevent that.

So while one can point to things that are arguably equally coercive that are justified under other clauses of Art. I Sec. 8 (and some that are inarguably equally coercive), that isn't the point, in my view. Those other powers are given to Congress for different reasons, and none of the other powers have been used to expand the reach of federal power the way the commerce clause has. They are more circumscribed because of the purposes for which they are granted. So, respectfully, I can't agree that it is silly, and I also don't agree that the principle is mere perception. (I also don't think that it is a moral principle, but rather a practical one).
All of which just goes to show that the progressive liberal view is NOT one of concern with constitutionality, but rather, with whatever narrative the progressives are focusing on at the moment, and whatever gains or losses in terms of agendas are therein. To this, the Constitution is usually just a hindrance.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom