GENERAL VERRILLI: "This is a regulation of existing commerce."
JUSTICE GINSBURG: "Can we go back to --Justice Breyer asked a question, and it kind of interrupted your answer to my question. And tell me if I'm wrong about this, but I thought a major, major point of your argument was that the people who don't participate in this market are making it much more expensive for the people who do; that is, they will get -- a goodly number of them will get services that they can't afford at the point when they need them, and the result is that everybody else's premiums get raised. So, you're not -- it's not your free choice just to do something for yourself. What you do is going to affect others, affect them in a major way."
GENERAL VERRILLI: "That -- that absolutely is a justification for Congress's action here. That is existing economic activity that Congress is regulating by means of this rule."
JUSTICE SCALIA: "Mr. Verrilli, you could say that about buying a car. If people don't buy cars, the price that those who do buy cars pay will have to be higher. So, you could say in order to bring the price down, you're hurting these other people by not buying a car."
GENERAL VERRILLI: "That is not what we're saying, Justice Scalia."
JUSTICE SCALIA: "That's not -- that's not what you're saying."
GENERAL VERRILLI: "That's not -- not --"
JUSTICE SCALIA: "I thought it was. I thought you're saying other people are going to have to pay more for insurance because you're not buying it."
GENERAL VERRILLI: "No. It's because you're going -- in the health care market, you're going into the market without the ability to pay for what you get, getting the health care service anyway as a result of the social norms that allow -- that -- to which we've obligated ourselves so that people get health care."
JUSTICE SCALIA: "Well, don't obligate yourself to that. Why -- you know?"
GENERAL VERRILLI: "Well, I can't imagine that that -- that the Commerce Clause would -- would forbid Congress from taking into account this deeply embedded social norm."
JUSTICE SCALIA: "You could do it. But does that expand your ability to issue mandates to -- to the people?"
GENERAL VERRILLI: "I -- this is not a purchase mandate. This is a -- this is a law that regulates the method of paying for a service that the class of people to whom it applies are either
consuming --"
JUSTICE SOTOMAYOR: "General --"
GENERAL VERRILLI: "-- or inevitably will consume."