Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

Why does the constitutionality hinge on the affordability of the fine? How is that determination made, and who gets the power to make it? What standards are we to adopt to make such a determination? And if the government institutes other mandates for other things, each of which it is individually "viable" to pay the penalty for, but not in total, what then?
Essentially this is the "free stuff" argument, that if the government gives something for free or nearly so, then that cannot be unconstitutional because you are not damaged by benefiting.

That's what Kagan said.

I thought it was rather weird, since we all pay for that "free stuff".
 
You mean except for those who don't have to pay for it, or who refuse to pay for it, or who are exempted from the fine, or exempted from the ACA, or whose 1200+ companies are exempted from the ACA, or who simply are "not in the system", like a large percentage of the 30M illegals?

Is that what you mean by saying "people would have to pay for it?"

What's your point? None of those people who wouldn't pay for it under the ACA pay for it now. If you want to minimize free stuff, you should be in favor of the ACA.

-Bri
 
One argument against the ACA is that it contains a mandate -- forcing people to purchase something. A pro-ACA argument is that there's no problem with a strict mandate since everyone already participates in health care.

That is simply false. Not everyone participates in the health care market. And even among people who participate in health care, not everyone participates in insurance. I knew someone who just paid their health care expenses out of pocket, including chemotherapy. He did NOT participate in the market for health insurance, but nobody else had to pay for him.

Furthermore, the argument you're making hinges upon the requirement that people who need emergency treatment but can't pay will still get treated. But this is itself the result of government intervention. So you're basically arguing that because government intervened in the market, that grants it MORE power to do things that it would otherwise not be able to do. That creates perverse incentives for government to interfere in order to justify its own expansion, with no limiting principle.

Another pro-ACA argument is that even if making you buy health insurance is deemed unconstitutional, giving you a choice between buying health insurance and paying a tax may not be unconstitutional. One counter-argument is that if the tax is too high, you don't really have a choice. A counter-counter-argument is that there are strict limits set on the tax that would prevent it from being so high as to not be a true choice.

You are confusing limits that Congress chooses to put into the legislation with limits on what Congress can do. And there are no such limits right now, let alone strict limits.
 
That is simply false. Not everyone participates in the health care market. And even among people who participate in health care, not everyone participates in insurance. I knew someone who just paid their health care expenses out of pocket, including chemotherapy. He did NOT participate in the market for health insurance, but nobody else had to pay for him......

And intermediate shades, like I'm on a high deductible insurance plan, coupled with a Health Savings Account.

Which is actually one of the saner options.
 
That is simply false. Not everyone participates in the health care market.

Of course they do. If anyone needs emergency care, they get it whether or not they can pay.

And even among people who participate in health care, not everyone participates in insurance. I knew someone who just paid their health care expenses out of pocket, including chemotherapy. He did NOT participate in the market for health insurance, but nobody else had to pay for him.

And if he lost all his money tomorrow, he would still be treated at an emergency room.

Furthermore, the argument you're making hinges upon the requirement that people who need emergency treatment but can't pay will still get treated. But this is itself the result of government intervention.

It's government intervention only in the fact that as a society we don't allow people to die if they can't afford treatment. It's not like the government intervened specifically to force people to buy health insurance.

So you're basically arguing that because government intervened in the market, that grants it MORE power to do things that it would otherwise not be able to do. That creates perverse incentives for government to interfere in order to justify its own expansion, with no limiting principle.

What do you mean no limiting principle? We had this discussion earlier in the thread, and I asked you to come up with some example of the slippery slope you're claiming here. The health care issue is a very specific one, and I don't think it's impossible to draw a line such that the government wouldn't be able to force everyone to participate in other markets in order to force people to buy things they don't want to buy.

You are confusing limits that Congress chooses to put into the legislation with limits on what Congress can do. And there are no such limits right now, let alone strict limits.

That's not necessarily the case. If the Supreme Court were to rule that a reasonable choice is necessary for it to be constitutional, then indeed it would be a limit on what Congress can do.

-Bri
 
Of course they do. If anyone needs emergency care, they get it whether or not they can pay.

And if they don't need it, they're not participating. Nor does payment make a difference in this respect, since some people who don't participate COULD pay. You have redefined "participation" to include potential future participation, but that is nonsense. Under such a definition, almost everyone participates in almost every market.

And if he lost all his money tomorrow, he would still be treated at an emergency room.

And if a frog had wings, it wouldn't bump its ass when it hopped.

He didn't lose all his money. He didn't participate in the health insurance market. And nobody else had to pay for him.

It's government intervention only in the fact that as a society we don't allow people to die if they can't afford treatment.

The justification for that intervention isn't the problem here. The problem is your contention that the intervention itself expands government powers. And that is a dangerous assertion.

It's not like the government intervened specifically to force people to buy health insurance.

That's not why it did in the past, but if your justification for the mandate stands, why would you expect that they wouldn't do so in the future?

What do you mean no limiting principle?

Some principle which says "this far, but no further".

We had this discussion earlier in the thread, and I asked you to come up with some example of the slippery slope you're claiming here. The health care issue is a very specific one, and I don't think it's impossible to draw a line such that the government wouldn't be able to force everyone to participate in other markets in order to force people to buy things they don't want to buy.

You think it's possible to draw this line, but you can't actually say how to do it. That doesn't inspire confidence in your position.

That's not necessarily the case. If the Supreme Court were to rule that a reasonable choice is necessary for it to be constitutional, then indeed it would be a limit on what Congress can do.

Which would necessarily get the courts into the business of micromanaging legislation to test (by methods still unknown) whether or not some particular fine was too steep. Which they aren't supposed to be doing, that's not the role of the courts. Plus, of course, it leads to the problem I mentioned before: if you have a whole set of mandates, each individual one might indeed be backed by a fine which is tolerable, but which would be intolerable collectively. What then? Has not choice still been deprived? Of course it has.
 
You pay for it whether you like it or not.

  • Everyone who pays taxes picks up the tab for those who go to an emergency room and cannot pay.
  • Everyone who works must pay into medicare.
 
Rich people have no problem paying for health care.

Who would have thought?
 
We live in a society.

Societies with high economic freedom and/or high HDI provide public health care. America stands alone in our intransigence yet we pay the most and get the least.

Ensuring that citizens are healthy is good for society. What is it that people do not get about that?
 
  • Forcing people to pay for Medicare is not an infringement on personal liberty.
  • Forcing people to buy medical insurance or pay a fine is an infringement on personal liberty.
?

FTFY.

Personally, I'd like to be in a position where I don't have to use Medicare. I'd rather figure out a way to be less of a burden on society, and voluntarily help others. (Voluntarily as in I donate capital to provide for the needs of others, rather than having the government confiscate it from me through taxation.)

This would be the ideal, but I don't see anyone making a serious effort to make that happen. The first step would be a serious re-examination of how we pay for medical care in this nation. (Much of this has already taken place.) I would further ask why employers who can afford to provide health care are not being held accountable.

True story: When I worked for a heavy haul outfit, the owner kept promising he'd set us up with health coverage. We were always just one driver short of being required by the State of California to get health coverage, (cut-off, as I recall, is 25 employees, and we were full up on office staff.)

One of the reasons I left is I found myself watching as a couple of brand new half-million dollar motor homes were delivered to our office. The Road Boss nudged me, and with a Marine's sense of contempt for such stupidity, declared, "There's your health coverage."

We'd been promised for two years that we'd have coverage. What we got, eventually, was a PPO which took about fifty bucks a month from our pay and set it aside for medical needs. If we didn't use the whole shootin' match by the next calender year per fifty, it all was given to our employer.

In other words, if you got sick, your fifty per month would supposedly cover your needs. If I started in April paying my fifty, that fifty would be given to the boss next April if I hadn't used it. I'd have a whopping $600 available to cover any medical needs I had, but nothing else, unless the County of Sacramento helped out.

Care to guess how often that happens?

I'm not even hiring anyone yet, and I'm already looking for Health Insurance Coverage for the drivers I'm going to hire in a couple of years. Why couldn't other employers do that?

The punch line? My former dispatcher needed open heart surgery. Once he got out of the hospital, the boss fired him.

Dirtbag.
 
Personally, I'd like to be in a position where I don't have to use Medicare. I'd rather figure out a way to be less of a burden on society, and voluntarily help others. (Voluntarily as in I donate capital to provide for the needs of others, rather than having the government confiscate it from me through taxation.)
I'm not wedded to any system. However, having moved from anti-UHC/Public health care to pro because of the pragmatic facts. Other nations provided UHC/Public health care and though they are not perfect do far better than we do for much less.

Just come up with a proposal we can all live with and implement it. If you want to get rid of medicare and you have something to replace it with and it has been shown to work then I'm fine with that.
 
FTFY.

Personally, I'd like to be in a position where I don't have to use Medicare. I'd rather figure out a way to be less of a burden on society, and voluntarily help others. (Voluntarily as in I donate capital to provide for the needs of others, rather than having the government confiscate it from me through taxation.)

This would be the ideal, but I don't see anyone making a serious effort to make that happen. The first step would be a serious re-examination of how we pay for medical care in this nation. (Much of this has already taken place.) I would further ask why employers who can afford to provide health care are not being held accountable.

The problem with this, RT, is that you could already make that contribution. Literally millions of people could, but don't. Because that's just not realistic framework for ensuring everyone has timely, affordable healthcare (and by affordable, I don't mean "well, some people can afford it", I mean affordable to everyone).

So, in the meantime, something else has to be implemented.
 
....In other words, if you got sick, your fifty per month would supposedly cover your needs. If I started in April paying my fifty, that fifty would be given to the boss next April if I hadn't used it. I'd have a whopping $600 available to cover any medical needs I had, but nothing else, unless the County of Sacramento helped out.

Care to guess how often that happens?....Dirtbag.

Happens all the time. Scams and cons are not limited to health care, of course.

Want to know how I would have done it? You pay for a high deductible plan, deducted from paycheck, and employer matches your payment into a Health Savings account. That's your money, not employers - but he's contributing.

If you leave the company, you keep it. 100%. Could easily add up to 20-30K after a couple years if you didn't get sick often.

(note A LOT of employees wouldn't like this, because they want essentially a free ride, everything paid for, etc - or the appearances thereof).
 
Last edited:
Happens all the time. Scams and cons are not limited to health care, of course.

Want to know how I would have done it? You pay for a high deductible plan, deducted from paycheck, and employer matches your payment into a Health Savings account. That's your money, not employers - but he's contributing.

If you leave the company, you keep it. 100%. Could easily add up to 20-30K after a couple years if you didn't get sick often.

(note A LOT of employees wouldn't like this, because they want essentially a free ride, everything paid for, etc - or the appearances thereof).

Normally, I wouldn't agree with you, but this almost sounds workable. I understand people would like their employer to cover the whole shooting match, not out of being deadbeats, but simply due to the cost, but something like this might be a start.
 
Normally, I wouldn't agree with you, but this almost sounds workable. I understand people would like their employer to cover the whole shooting match, not out of being deadbeats, but simply due to the cost, but something like this might be a start.

I would prefer my healthcare not at all tied to my employment, to be honest.

While this is workable, I shouldn't have to be employed to obtain a reasonable measure of healthcare coverage in the first place (what happens when someone has serious healthcare issues their first year on the job?)
 
  • Everyone who pays taxes picks up the tab for those who go to an emergency room and cannot pay.
  • Everyone who works must pay into medicare.
Really? I wasn't aware that the federal government reimbursed private hospitals for all their unpaid emergency room bills. Cite?

Ensuring that citizens are healthy is good for society. What is it that people do not get about that?
There's this little thing call the constitution. You might have heard of it. It's what this thread is about.
 
The problem with this, RT, is that you could already make that contribution. Literally millions of people could, but don't.
Many don't because they aren't sufficiently responsible to do so. So they gamble. Often times, when they lose everyone pays. The carrot and stick approach just doesn't work because A.) There is a wide gulf of cause and effect. B.) They can always go to the emergency room.

In the end society picks up the tab. Why not get more for our money?

Kaiser said:
source

The issue is particularly acute in the United States, which not only spends much more per capita on health care, but also has had one of the highest spending growth rates.
 
Want to know how I would have done it? You pay for a high deductible plan, deducted from paycheck, and employer matches your payment into a Health Savings account. That's your money, not employers - but he's contributing.

.

Ummmmm, not all companies have this type of coverage - are you aware of that?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom