Abortion effectively outlawed in S.Dakota

If the father is to be denied any choice in the matter, then I am completely comfortable in relieving the father of any responsiblity for the matter. Either the father gets a say in whether or not the child is carried to term, or the father has no compeled responsibility for the child.

So merely having sex with a women gives a man the right to dictate her medical decisions and trumps her right to privacy?
 
So merely having sex with a women gives a man the right to dictate her medical decisions and trumps her right to privacy?

Not at all, what sarge proposes is more to popularize the second option, letting dads off the hook for child support, basically on demand.
 
Last edited:
My first response was answering philosophically how there could be a consistency between making deliberate fetal damage a crime, but abortion legal. The question of how the laws are phrased ties more into my second point--they are that way because the legislatures wanted to define the unborn as persons under law. That has no bearing on whether that designation is reasonable.

We are talking about the law - there can be no "philosophical" answer about how the legislature may make an action a capitol crime if one class of citizens does it, and not even a crime if another class of citizens does it. Your justification might make sense if the mother is the victim rather than the unborn child - or if we make fetal damage a property crime. So long as the unborn child is the victim, however, there is no rationale that I can see to criminalizing the intentional killing by some people and not by others.

An analogy: Let's say there was a law outlawing chocolate ice cream. The matter has come up for debate, could I say "if there's nothing wrong with chocolate ice cream, why is there a law against it?" and expect to be taken seriously?

Fataly flawed analogy.

If it is illegal to steal, it is illegal to steal, and that observation doesn't depend on circular logic. I am not saying that it is illegal to kill a fetus becasue the law says so. I am asking ahy is it murder to unitentionally kill a child if one person does it, but not murder if another does it intentionally.

Great! Where do I sign, I'll go father a bunch of welfare babies and tell the mom to either suck it up or get an abortion. If the taxpayers have an issue with it, that's their problem. They can gripe at the mother.

Or the converse. Great, I'll fool the man into getting me pregnant, even though he has expressed a clear desire not to father children, because I can then extort large sums of money for almost a quarter-century.

Fair is usually fair. I have no problem with all the choices resting with the female, so long as all the responsibilites come with it.
 
We are talking about the law - there can be no "philosophical" answer about how the legislature may make an action a capitol crime if one class of citizens does it, and not even a crime if another class of citizens does it. Your justification might make sense if the mother is the victim rather than the unborn child - or if we make fetal damage a property crime. So long as the unborn child is the victim, however, there is no rationale that I can see to criminalizing the intentional killing by some people and not by others.



Fataly flawed analogy.

If it is illegal to steal, it is illegal to steal, and that observation doesn't depend on circular logic. I am not saying that it is illegal to kill a fetus becasue the law says so. I am asking ahy is it murder to unitentionally kill a child if one person does it, but not murder if another does it intentionally.



Or the converse. Great, I'll fool the man into getting me pregnant, even though he has expressed a clear desire not to father children, because I can then extort large sums of money for almost a quarter-century.

Fair is usually fair. I have no problem with all the choices resting with the female, so long as all the responsibilites come with it.

The man has a choice, he can choose which woman to have sex with. If he exercises poor judgement in sexual partners and becomes a parent, it is unfair to expect society to carry the burden of his mistake.
 
There is already a way for a man to opt-out of responsibility for children.

It's called a vasectomy.

He ought to be using a condom as well, in this day and age.

Men do have a choice, it's just that theirs is much earlier, much cheaper, and much less emotionally traumatizing than the women's choice. If they can't be bothered to reap the vast benefits of this biological quirk they deserve to be saddled with child support for twenty years.
 
We are talking about the law - there can be no "philosophical" answer about how the legislature may make an action a capitol crime if one class of citizens does it, and not even a crime if another class of citizens does it. Your justification might make sense if the mother is the victim rather than the unborn child - or if we make fetal damage a property crime. So long as the unborn child is the victim, however, there is no rationale that I can see to criminalizing the intentional killing by some people and not by others.

But whether the unborn child is defined as the victim, or the mother, is a consequence of how the law is written, which comes into the second point.

Fataly flawed analogy.

If it is illegal to steal, it is illegal to steal, and that observation doesn't depend on circular logic. I am not saying that it is illegal to kill a fetus becasue the law says so. I am asking ahy is it murder to unitentionally kill a child if one person does it, but not murder if another does it intentionally.

The circularity is that you propose to define it as murder and point to the law as justification, when the entire question is whether it should be considered murder under the law. Your argument is basically "because it already is" but that's not an answer regarding the wisdom of that aspect.

Or the converse. Great, I'll fool the man into getting me pregnant, even though he has expressed a clear desire not to father children, because I can then extort large sums of money for almost a quarter-century.

Fair is usually fair. I have no problem with all the choices resting with the female, so long as all the responsibilities come with it.

How about a more generalized rule that if the child is born, it is entitled support from both parents, regardless of whether one or the other would prefer to back out?
 
There is already a way for a man to opt-out of responsibility for children.

It's called a vasectomy.

Exactly. There are many way to avoid becoming a parent. The option to use birth control or to abstain is available to both sexes. Sterilization is also an option but men have the option of reversing it if they change their mind. Abortion is an option for women. Different reproductive organs offer different ways to avoid unwanted parenthood.
 
As eeyore1954 mentioned education is one thing. Illegal drug use is already illegal regardless of pregnancy. Prescription antidepressant drugs should be monitored by the physician. From what I know about gestational diabetes, it is due to natural causes. Legal drugs like alcohol and nicotine have warnings and since the actual harmful impact is limited and not always occurring, the warnings are probably all we as a society want to do for now.
The problem with having your doctor "monitor" use of prescription drugs is that, often, the miscarriage happens before anyone knows of the pregnancy. Shouldn't more be done to save these lives?

Gestational diabetes is a condition the mother gets, not the fetus. The fetus may be perfectly healthy when such a miscarriage occurs. Shouldn't we require monitoring and treatment for gestational diabetes? Not just as a good idea, but require it, to help ensure a miscarriage doesn't occur?
 
So merely having sex with a women gives a man the right to dictate her medical decisions and trumps her right to privacy?

That isn't even close to what I said.

Merely having sex with a woman shouldn't afford a man the right to dictate anything to a woman. However, merely having sex with a woman also should not obligate a man to anything either.

If a man and a woman mutually agree to bear a child, then both the man and the woman should bear the responsibility for the child. So long as 100% of the choice rests with the woman, then 100% of the obligation (including the responsibility to see that pregnancy does not occur) should rest with the woman.
 
The requirement that a woman seeking an abortion must obtain a permission slip from a professional pro-life advocate who is under no obligation to provide one is effectively impossible.
That's not how the law is written.

The woman must provide the doctor with an written statement detailing when and who she saw for counseling, but the counselor is not required to provide permission.

Annoying, yes, but not as problematic as the waiting period.

I'm thinking of the vulnerable populations; young women, perhaps still living at home; isolated. A one-day trip across state can be justified (shopping, perhaps). But two in a week?

Of course, that may be exactly what the opponents want - legal-age teens can't be sneaking out and getting abortions, willy-nilly, can they?
 
But whether the unborn child is defined as the victim, or the mother, is a consequence of how the law is written, which comes into the second point.

No.

The law defines murder. The law defines it differently in this case, depending on who does the killing. That is an inherently illogical proposition. Either an unborn child is a human or it is not. if it is, then killing it is usually wrong. if it is not, then whether or not to abort is a decision best left soley to the bearer - and anyone else causeing its death should bear a punishment appropriate for a property crime.



The circularity is that you propose to define it as murder and point to the law as justification, when the entire question is whether it should be considered murder under the law. Your argument is basically "because it already is" but that's not an answer regarding the wisdom of that aspect.

That isn't circular logic. That is you attempting to answer a legal question with philosophy.

The law defines murder - and in this case defines it differently depending on who is doing the killing. That is a double standard. I'd prefer to remove the double standard. If it isn't murder when the mom does it, it shouldn't be murder when someone else does it.



How about a more generalized rule that if the child is born, it is entitled support from both parents, regardless of whether one or the other would prefer to back out?

Sure - so long as the mother does not get to terminate the pregnancy without the consent of the father. Heck, I'll even go so far as to allow the mother to carry to term, then not have to provide support for the child she didn't want.


No, the more logical circumstance would for the mother to retain complete control over whether or not she has the child, then bear the responsibility if the father swore off parental rights before the child is born.
 
That isn't even close to what I said.

Merely having sex with a woman shouldn't afford a man the right to dictate anything to a woman. However, merely having sex with a woman also should not obligate a man to anything either.

If a man and a woman mutually agree to bear a child, then both the man and the woman should bear the responsibility for the child. So long as 100% of the choice rests with the woman, then 100% of the obligation (including the responsibility to see that pregnancy does not occur) should rest with the woman.

So a man can have all the sex he wants with as many women as he wants using no birth control at all and then pay no child support because 100% of the final choice for family planning rests with the woman.

This whole thing is like some schoolyard idea of fair. You are defending the man's right to abdicate responsibility for his actions simply because women have an alternative option for birth control. If abortion did not exist, more men would be forced to pay child-support for children they did not want. Abortion does exist and while it incidentally benefits irresponsible men, it is a woman's option because it is a medical procedure performed on a woman's body.

For you, abortion exists for men. If they don't have the power to choose when it is used, then they will pout, take their ball(s) and go home.
 
I can think of only one situation where I could agree with giving the man the right to vacate financial responsibility, and that is when the man is raped.

But it's such a fringe case, that it doesn't really matter to me.
 
Instead of calling it abortion, let's just call it "enhanced pregnancy termination." If we do that, then the Right won't have a problem with it.
 
So a man can have all the sex he wants with as many women as he wants using no birth control at all and then pay no child support because 100% of the final choice for family planning rests with the woman.

So women can have all the sex they want, and take none of the responsibility for protection, because they can choose whether or not a man will be trapped into paying for the product of her activity?

This whole thing is like some schoolyard idea of fair. You are defending the man's right to abdicate responsibility for his actions simply because women have an alternative option for birth control.

That is a complete mischaracterization of my position.

Accurately, you advocate for women to have the option to force a man to provide for a child he did not desire, simply because she did desire it. You would force him to subsidize her choices.

If abortion did not exist, more men would be forced to pay child-support for children they did not want.

Did you miss that I am pro-choice?

Abortion does exist and while it incidentally benefits irresponsible men, it is a woman's option because it is a medical procedure performed on a woman's body.

Abortion exists, it incidentally benefits men, it directly benefits irresponsible women, and it should remain a womans option - and the man should not be held hostage to her whims.

For you, abortion exists for men. If they don't have the power to choose when it is used, then they will pout, take their ball(s) and go home.

So - you are fine with a clear double standard so long as it is the woman that benefits from it?

Bull crap. For me, abortion exists (properly) for women, and I would have it so that women take responsibility for their own choices. You would have it as it is - women get 100% of the choice, but only 50% of the responsibility.

If men and women share equally in the responsibility to prevent unwanted pregnancies, and men and women share equally in the responsibility to care for wanted children, and women have 100% of the authority to choose whether or not to carry a pregnancy to term, in spite of the man's desires, then women should bear 100% of the responsibility for raising such a child.
 
The law defines murder - and in this case defines it differently depending on who is doing the killing. That is a double standard. I'd prefer to remove the double standard. If it isn't murder when the mom does it, it shouldn't be murder when someone else does it.

This I agree with--I think that introducing laws that define an unborn fetus as a person ARE a double-standard and that it shouldn't be considered murder. I think it should still be a crime, however, as a violent act on the mother.

Sure - so long as the mother does not get to terminate the pregnancy without the consent of the father. Heck, I'll even go so far as to allow the mother to carry to term, then not have to provide support for the child she didn't want.

No, the more logical circumstance would for the mother to retain complete control over whether or not she has the child, then bear the responsibility if the father swore off parental rights before the child is born.
Even if taxpayers have to pick up the slack?

You are presenting a dilemma--something where all the outcomes are in some way undesirable or unfair. I can give a reason why my flawed remedy is better than your flawed remedy: It doesn't result in passing a burden to people that had nothing to do with the child's birth-- that can be invoked by any father-to-be just by declaring it.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom