Abortion effectively outlawed in S.Dakota

This is the only thing that really matters. The Right is constantly trying to insert themselves into these decisions.

The Right wants the State to let people alone except for;

Who they can sleep with.
Whether they may marry.
What medical decisions they make.
What they may learn in school.
What drugs they may take.
Whether they may have a safe workplace.
Whether they may drink clean water and breathe clean air.
Who they may vote for.

So, other than that, they are pro-freedom.


Other than that, what's left?
 
Last edited:
Humans become human some time after they are born alive and take their first breath. Since we can't say just when this happens, we should err on the side of accepting live birth as the earliest point where a person could be said to exist.

Note that not all human cultures accept first breath; infanticide has been used to control human population for millions of years, as proven by the fossil and archeological record. But I think first breath is an acceptable standard.

Either a fetus is a human or it is not. If it is not, then abortion is a fairly simple medical procedure, and the choice to have one should be left entirely up to the female. If a fetus is a human, then abortion for convenience is murder.

I'm guardedly pro-choice. I am confused about a few apparant contradictions in law, however.

1. If an unborn is not yet human, why are persons charged with crimes that carry significant penalties when they take actions that result in the death of an unborn child. I can't think of any logic that would make it a crime to kill an unborn child that should not also make it a crime for the female to choose to do the same thing.

2. If a woman is to choose whether or not to carry a child to term, and the father is to have no say, why must the father be financially responsible for the mother's choice after the birth?
 
Either a fetus is a human or it is not. If it is not, then abortion is a fairly simple medical procedure, and the choice to have one should be left entirely up to the female. If a fetus is a human, then abortion for convenience is murder.

I'm guardedly pro-choice. I am confused about a few apparant contradictions in law, however.

1. If an unborn is not yet human, why are persons charged with crimes that carry significant penalties when they take actions that result in the death of an unborn child. I can't think of any logic that would make it a crime to kill an unborn child that should not also make it a crime for the female to choose to do the same thing.

Two reasons:

1 - Because it is a crime against the mother who desires a child.
2 - Laws deliberately created to require treating an unborn child as a person. Regardless of the merits of that point of view, a law written to enforce a proposition cannot be used to justify it. That's circular.

2. If a woman is to choose whether or not to carry a child to term, and the father is to have no say, why must the father be financially responsible for the mother's choice after the birth?
Because the alternative is for the father to be able to require the mother to have an abortion regardless of her feelings on the matter, or else choose for the child to lack support from both parents. Do you think the taxpayer should pick up the slack for someone who refuses support to their own child? Choice certainly came into it at some point.
 
Either a fetus is a human or it is not. If it is not, then abortion is a fairly simple medical procedure, and the choice to have one should be left entirely up to the female. If a fetus is a human, then abortion for convenience is murder.

I'm guardedly pro-choice. I am confused about a few apparant contradictions in law, however.

1. If an unborn is not yet human, why are persons charged with crimes that carry significant penalties when they take actions that result in the death of an unborn child. I can't think of any logic that would make it a crime to kill an unborn child that should not also make it a crime for the female to choose to do the same thing.

Well, we have significant penalties above assault for maiming a person (grievous bodily injury, mayhem.) It recognizes that a pregnancy is a significant thing to human beings who want to reproduce. It recognizes that a pregnant woman is often a special target because she IS pregnant. Also it is the thin point of the wedge for attempting to control a woman's womb with laws.

They can get away with it because Roe v. Wade was not determined on when a fetus becomes a human being, but upon privacy.

2. If a woman is to choose whether or not to carry a child to term, and the father is to have no say, why must the father be financially responsible for the mother's choice after the birth?


Because before birth the woman's privacy Rights are foremost in law. After the birth, we have a human being coming into existence which has two parents.
 
Because it's illegal. And it's not my life. It's the life of a child. The law is clear: murder of a 2 year old is illegal; abortion is legal.
Back to your first post, which you avoided answering--why is the killing of a one hour old infant murder and the killing of an infant one hour before birth, a "choice"? Please explain the ethical differences beyond, "it's my body" and it's "entirely the woman's domain".

mortimer said:
Now, do you consider spontaneous abortion as abhorrent as induced abortion?
Do you consider someone dropping dead of natural causes the same as someone being murdered? You really haven't given much thought to the ethics before posting have you ?
 
Back to your first post, which you avoided answering--why is the killing of a one hour old infant murder and the killing of an infant one hour before birth, a "choice"? Please explain the ethical differences beyond, "it's my body" and it's "entirely the woman's domain".

Neither should be murder, because without a doubt human infants do not become human until some considerable time after birth, but we have to draw the line somewhere.

Do you consider someone dropping dead of natural causes the same as someone being murdered? You really haven't given much thought to the ethics before posting have you ?

You made no sense here whatsoever.
 
Two reasons:

1 - Because it is a crime against the mother who desires a child.

Not true - at least not under law. The punishment is specifically for killing an unborn child, not for depriving the woman of a child. According to the law, the child is a person and the child is the victim.

If it is a crime to intentionally kill an unborn child, and the punishment for the crime is similar to that for killing living humans, then it does not make sense to me that a woman would be free to do exactly the same thing without penalty.

If the punishment for causing a miscarrage (or killing the fetus outright) were for the harm done to the mother, then cool - but that isn't what's happening. If it were simply a property crime against the mother, that would make more sense than the current circumstance.

2 - Laws deliberately created to require treating an unborn child as a person. Regardless of the merits of that point of view, a law written to enforce a proposition cannot be used to justify it. That's circular.

Your explanation does nothing to remove the conflict between the two circumstances.

Because the alternative is for the father to be able to require the mother to have an abortion regardless of her feelings on the matter, or else choose for the child to lack support from both parents. Do you think the taxpayer should pick up the slack for someone who refuses support to their own child? Choice certainly came into it at some point.

If the father is to be denied any choice in the matter, then I am completely comfortable in relieving the father of any responsiblity for the matter. Either the father gets a say in whether or not the child is carried to term, or the father has no compeled responsibility for the child.
 
Back to your first post, which you avoided answering--why is the killing of a one hour old infant murder and the killing of an infant one hour before birth, a "choice"? Please explain the ethical differences beyond, "it's my body" and it's "entirely the woman's domain".

You keep asking questions and refusing to answer what is posed back at you. You continue to answer questions with further questions. That is your choice, of course.

I'm not going to go back through this entire thread, but a quick search reveals many (including me) have answered some of your questions specifically. I don't see any evidence that you have answered any questions at all.
 
So you concede that what you posited is not a real life situation. That's good. Now, do you consider spontaneous abortion as abhorrent as induced abortion?

To me it is not as abhorrant but to the person it happens to it is probably sadder because the child was wanted.
 
If the father is to be denied any choice in the matter, then I am completely comfortable in relieving the father of any responsiblity for the matter. Either the father gets a say in whether or not the child is carried to term, or the father has no compeled responsibility for the child.

His choice in the matter was at the start of the entire cycle. If he's man enough to make the baby, he's man enough to take care of the child if the woman gives birth to it.

Now I believe that women should choose to give some sort of weight to the wishes of the father, but that's her choice. His was to have sex with her.
 
Neither should be murder, because without a doubt human infants do not become human until some considerable time after birth, but we have to draw the line somewhere.
Few people share your opinion that a child isn't human until some considerable time after birth. Our laws certainly don't reflect that, so I'm curious as to exactly what determines when a child is human, and therefore the intentional death be considered murder?

You made no sense here whatsoever.
Very simple. Someone dying of natural causes is not considered murder. Spontaneous abortion is the death of an infant by natural causes -- the same thing.
 
Do you consider someone dropping dead of natural causes the same as someone being murdered?
Spontaneous abortions are not all attributable to natural causes. Should we do something to prevent spontaneous abortions that are not due to natural causes, much as we do for born people who become sick?
 
Not true - at least not under law. The punishment is specifically for killing an unborn child, not for depriving the woman of a child. According to the law, the child is a person and the child is the victim.

If it is a crime to intentionally kill an unborn child, and the punishment for the crime is similar to that for killing living humans, then it does not make sense to me that a woman would be free to do exactly the same thing without penalty.

If the punishment for causing a miscarrage (or killing the fetus outright) were for the harm done to the mother, then cool - but that isn't what's happening. If it were simply a property crime against the mother, that would make more sense than the current circumstance.

My first response was answering philosophically how there could be a consistency between making deliberate fetal damage a crime, but abortion legal. The question of how the laws are phrased ties more into my second point--they are that way because the legislatures wanted to define the unborn as persons under law. That has no bearing on whether that designation is reasonable.

An analogy: Let's say there was a law outlawing chocolate ice cream. The matter has come up for debate, could I say "if there's nothing wrong with chocolate ice cream, why is there a law against it?" and expect to be taken seriously?

If the father is to be denied any choice in the matter, then I am completely comfortable in relieving the father of any responsiblity for the matter. Either the father gets a say in whether or not the child is carried to term, or the father has no compeled responsibility for the child.
Great! Where do I sign, I'll go father a bunch of welfare babies and tell the mom to either suck it up or get an abortion. If the taxpayers have an issue with it, that's their problem. They can gripe at the mother.
 
Last edited:
Spontaneous abortions are not all attributable to natural causes. Should we do something to prevent spontaneous abortions that are not due to natural causes, much as we do for born people who become sick?
Please provide an example of the types of spontaneous abortions that are not due to natural causes that you are referring to.

Ability to use language and form memories.
How and why does that make them human or not? You know that animals have language and memories, and severe autism may include no language ability?
 
Please provide an example of the types of spontaneous abortions that are not due to natural causes that you are referring to.

Tobacco use by the mother, cocaine use by the mother, antidepressant use by the mother, gestational diabetes, to name a very few.
 
Spontaneous abortions are not all attributable to natural causes. Should we do something to prevent spontaneous abortions that are not due to natural causes, much as we do for born people who become sick?

There may be cases where we shouldn't, depending upon the cause.

Yes in general we should do something, We already do at least one thing,it is called education. My daughter just had her baby taken early 2 months early because she was not repsonding the correct ways to tests. That might be considered prevention.
Did she just become a human being deserving life after they cut my daughter open and took her out? I don't believe so.
Of course I am aware that many are against abortion in the last trimester
 
Tobacco use by the mother, cocaine use by the mother, antidepressant use by the mother, gestational diabetes, to name a very few.
As eeyore1954 mentioned education is one thing. Illegal drug use is already illegal regardless of pregnancy. Prescription antidepressant drugs should be monitored by the physician. From what I know about gestational diabetes, it is due to natural causes. Legal drugs like alcohol and nicotine have warnings and since the actual harmful impact is limited and not always occurring, the warnings are probably all we as a society want to do for now.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom