Abortion effectively outlawed in S.Dakota

How about "before they have any brain function" or "after they no longer have any brain function"?

When they are brain dead or are so brain dead that a feeding tube is necessary to keep them alive.
Brain dead = dead dead, so saying killing someone who is brain dead doesn't even make sense. Persistent vegetative state is entirely different as is a coma. Again, how far below "fully functioning" is it permissible to kill someone? A quadriplegic isn't fully functioning. Someone in a coma isn't fully functioning nor is someone mentally retarded.
 
Brain dead = dead dead, so saying killing someone who is brain dead doesn't even make sense. Persistent vegetative state is entirely different as is a coma. Again, how far below "fully functioning" is it permissible to kill someone? A quadriplegic isn't fully functioning. Someone in a coma isn't fully functioning nor is someone mentally retarded.

Humans become human some time after they are born alive and take their first breath. Since we can't say just when this happens, we should err on the side of accepting live birth as the earliest point where a person could be said to exist.

Note that not all human cultures accept first breath; infanticide has been used to control human population for millions of years, as proven by the fossil and archeological record. But I think first breath is an acceptable standard.
 
Humans become human some time after they are born alive and take their first breath. Since we can't say just when this happens, we should err on the side of accepting live birth as the earliest point where a person could be said to exist.
So aborting a baby one hour before expected delivery is ethically acceptable to you?
 
So aborting a baby one hour before expected delivery is ethically acceptable to you?

i find that men discussing the ethics of abortion is a waste of time.
the decision has nothing to do with a man, unless he happens to be the sire of the fetus.
and even then, the final decision lies with the woman.
men will never be pregnant.
men will never have to give birth.
men have no stake in the matter.

why does this seem so hard to understand?
 
Last edited:
i find that men discussing the ethics of abortion is a waste of time.
the decision has nothing to do with a man, unless he happens to be the sire of the fetus.
and even then, the final decision lies with the woman.
men will never be pregnant.
men will never have to give birth.
men have no stake in the matter.

why does this seem so hard to understand?
Since the ethics still elude you and you keep pushing, please answer:
If a woman gets raped, it's between her and the rapist.
If a woman beats her child to death, it's between her the child, and the father, if present.
You, the government, the legal system, the police, society, have no stake in the above matters. Agreed?
 
Since the ethics still elude you and you keep pushing, please answer:
If a woman gets raped, it's between her and the rapist.
If a woman beats her child to death, it's between her the child, and the father, if present.
You, the government, the legal system, the police, society, have no stake in the above matters. Agreed?


you know, neally....this is not that difficult.
it is you that don't seem to get it.
if a woman is raped, it is a matter for the police.
if it makes her pregnant, the abortion is entirely her choice.
if a woman beats her child to death, it's murder....simple.

so, no....i don't agree.

the ethics of abortion are entirely the woman's domain.
you, myself and any other human, other than the mother, do not enter into that picture.
 
you know, neally....this is not that difficult.
it is you that don't seem to get it.
if a woman is raped, it is a matter for the police.
if it makes her pregnant, the abortion is entirely her choice.
if a woman beats her child to death, it's murder....simple.

so, no....i don't agree.

the ethics of abortion are entirely the woman's domain.
you, myself and any other human, other than the mother, do not enter into that picture.
Why is the killing of a one hour old infant murder and the killing of an infant one hour before birth, a "choice"? Please explain the ethical differences beyond, "it's her choice" and it's "entirely the woman's domain".
 
Apparently the similarities elude you. I'll make it easy. Arguing that if you don't like abortion, then don't do it ignores the ethics involved. Laws by design prevent people from doing certain things. Even though you don't abuse children or advocate others to do so, doesn't mean society should allow others to do so. That's why we make laws. That's why the pro-abortion argument that "it has nothing to do with men, so they should shut up", or "if you are against it, don't do it" is sophomoric.

Exactly.
 
Why is the killing of a one hour old infant murder and the killing of an infant one hour before birth, a "choice"? Please explain the ethical differences beyond, "it's her choice" and it's "entirely the woman's domain".

actually, under canadian law, if a mother kills her infant, it is not murder, but 'infanticide', which carries a much lighter penalty.
it is acknowledged that a mother who does this is under stress, and not in her right mind.
it is very obvious, in these cases, that an abortion was the much better option.
 
Why is the killing of a one hour old infant murder and the killing of an infant one hour before birth, a "choice"? Please explain the ethical differences beyond, "it's her choice" and it's "entirely the woman's domain".

Why do you have the right to come between me and my doctor when it comes to a medical procedure? Or the right to decide for everyone when life begins?

It's my body--it's my life--and I should be able to decide what surgical procedure I want done, as long as it's legal, and the doctor is abiding by his/her own ethics/legal limits.

Why don't you answer the previously posted question about what should happen to a women who has an abortion, if it's illegal?
 
Why is the killing of a one hour old infant murder and the killing of an infant one hour before birth, a "choice"? Please explain the ethical differences beyond, "it's her choice" and it's "entirely the woman's domain".
This is a pretty awesome strawman. How many fetuses have been killed intentionally (as in, consentual induced abortion) an hour before birth? A day before? A week before?
 
Yes how do you punish those naughty aborting women?
 
Yes how do you punish those naughty aborting women?

1. I don't know.
2. Just pray for them.
3. It's between her and her god.
4. Treat them with love.
5. I've never really thought about it.
6. Counseling.
7. I'm not a lawyer.
 
It's my body--it's my life--and I should be able to decide what surgical procedure I want done, as long as it's legal, and the doctor is abiding by his/her own ethics/legal limits.
Who determines what is legal in terms of abortion or anything else? Why shouldn't you be able to decide if you want to drown your 2 year old, after all, it's your child and your life?

actually, under canadian law, if a mother kills her infant, it is not murder, but 'infanticide', which carries a much lighter penalty.
it is acknowledged that a mother who does this is under stress, and not in her right mind.
it is very obvious, in these cases, that an abortion was the much better option.
As I suspected. Avoidance noted.

This is a pretty awesome strawman. How many fetuses have been killed intentionally (as in, consentual induced abortion) an hour before birth? A day before? A week before?
Do keep up with the discussion if you are going to chime in. The scenario wasn't meant as a real life situation, but an attempt to draw attention to the ethical issues involved.
 
Who determines what is legal in terms of abortion or anything else? Why shouldn't you be able to decide if you want to drown your 2 year old, after all, it's your child and your life?

As usual you only opted to address only one line of my post (in bold):

Why do you have the right to come between me and my doctor when it comes to a medical procedure? Or the right to decide for everyone when life begins?

It's my body--it's my life--and I should be able to decide what surgical procedure I want done, as long as it's legal, and the doctor is abiding by his/her own ethics/legal limits.

Why don't you answer the previously posted question about what should happen to a women who has an abortion, if it's illegal?

I'll answer your questions, but won't hold my breath waiting for you to address the rest of my post.

Who determines what is legal in terms of abortion or anything else?

Those who enact the laws of a country. BTW, abortion is legal in the US.

Why shouldn't you be able to decide if you want to drown your 2 year old, after all, it's your child and your life?

Because it's illegal. And it's not my life. It's the life of a child. The law is clear: murder of a 2 year old is illegal; abortion is legal.
 
Do keep up with the discussion if you are going to chime in. The scenario wasn't meant as a real life situation, but an attempt to draw attention to the ethical issues involved.

So you concede that what you posited is not a real life situation. That's good. Now, do you consider spontaneous abortion as abhorrent as induced abortion?
 
Why do you have the right to come between me and my doctor when it comes to a medical procedure?

This is the only thing that really matters. The Right is constantly trying to insert themselves into these decisions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom