Abortion effectively outlawed in S.Dakota

Ok, you're pretty worked up, so how big a problem is this? Specifically, what percentage of child support is actually paid to a woman who became pregnant specifically to force a man to support her?

Yes, and please compare that to the amount of child support mothers need to properly clothe and feed their children, but are denied because the deadbeat fathers lie about their incomes to avoid paying.

As a lawyer with a significant amount of divorce/custody experience, I have never encountered a woman who got pregnant for the child support. I have, however, spent a great deal of time hunting down deadbeat dads, digging through their finances to identify their income streams, and garnishing their income to make them pay for their kids.

Unless the father is making $100,000k+, the cost of having a child will be a net loss given any state's child support calculation.
 
Ok, you're pretty worked up, so how big a problem is this? Specifically, what percentage of child support is actually paid to a woman who became pregnant specifically to force a man to support her?

I'm comfortable betting that of the two of us, you are more "worked up" over this than I am. After all, I have yewt to completely and intentionally mischaracterize your argument while also resorting to name calling.

It matters not a bit how often this occurs. That the law allows a woman all of the decision making authority and only half the responsibility is a problem. Rationalize it all you want, neither you nor the others on your side of the debate have managed to provide a single logical reason to perpetuate a clear legal double standard.
 
I'm comfortable betting that of the two of us, you are more "worked up" over this than I am. After all, I have yewt to completely and intentionally mischaracterize your argument while also resorting to name calling.

It matters not a bit how often this occurs. That the law allows a woman all of the decision making authority and only half the responsibility is a problem. Rationalize it all you want, neither you nor the others on your side of the debate have managed to provide a single logical reason to perpetuate a clear legal double standard.

If this isn't happening or if it is extremely rare, this entire conversation is nothing more than an intellectual exercise. If that's the case, there is no legal double standard.
 
That the law allows a woman all of the decision making authority and only half the responsibility is a problem.

What law does this? Do you have statutes or case law in mind?

Or are you talking about the laws of nature?

Is there an alternative to the status quo that doesn't actually take away choices from women? Men and women are not biologically equivalent when it comes to reproduction, and I don't believe it is a good idea for us to create law that would attempt to make it so. (I'm thinking of the Vonnegut short story with the Handicapper General whose job it was to make people equal.)

The fact is, there have been (human) laws that singled out women and removed their freedom of choice wrt to reproductive decision making. There have never been laws that did that to males.
 
We shall fight for Loretta to have the RIGHT to have babies, even if he can't.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom